|
Tax Vista Your weekly tax recap Edn. 298 - 16th November 2026 Dr. G. Gokul Kishore |
|
Statutory authority cannot have intent to evade - High Court quashes SCN
The jurisprudence on invocation of provisions like Section 74 of CGST Act involving allegation of suppression and evasion is evolving in GST. In a significant addition, Rajasthan High Court has in a recent judgment analysed invocation of Section 74 of CGST Act in greater detail. According to it, the prejudice is real as a notice under Section 74 is not the same as Section 73 with a different label because of extended period and penalty equal to tax. The observation that misstatement and suppression can coexist in a case is interesting. They often overlap and a misstatement itself may amount to suppression. The order gives an example - "Take an assessee who is asked whether he has supplied a certain service. He answers no when the truthful answer is yes. That is a misstatement. It is also a suppression, because it hides the true fact and misleads the authority....A wrong declaration in a return is a misstatement. It also amounts to non-declaration of the true facts. Both labels may thus fit the same conduct."
The order further says that "to evade tax" govern fraud, wilful misstatement and suppression and these are the means while evasion is the end and both must exist together. An SCN which evidences the means but not the end does not satisfy Section 74. The definition of suppression does not do away with the requirement of suppression intended to serve evasion. The order further goes on to explain intent to evade - "Intent is a state of mind. A body corporate has no mind of its own. Its intent is found in the minds of those who direct its affairs. In a private company, those persons may stand to gain from evasion. Their gain may come through higher profits, dividends or the value of their holdings." This has been highlighted to hold that the petitioner in this case is a statutory body of the State headed by an IAS officer and the officers cannot be said to gain anything by evading tax. Attribution of intent to such officers has been rejected by the Court.
GST department in 9 out of 10 SCNs allege that failure to pay tax means intent to evade by suppressing liability. This order holds that Section 73 will be redundant if failure to pay itself is sufficient to invoke Section 74 as every short payment would then become evasion. The Court uses "disagreement on law" to refer to the interpretation and divergence of views involved which it terms as not evidence of evasion.
The High Court further compares intent to evade with criminal prosecution under Section 132 to point out the incongruent scenario of one officer of government prosecuting another officer when the petitioner is a statutory authority. Before quashing the SCN in this case, it hastens add in case of deliberate falsification, such officers can be prosecuted but the case before it obviously does not belong to this category.
In the Central Excise regime, inter-ministerial High Powered Committee (HPC) commonly known as Committee on Disputes (COC) used to grant permission to continue litigation when it involved PSUs. The High Court has referred to such mechanism and has called the government to explore the same in GST regime as well. When tax department fights with PSU, outcome does not change ownership of the money as it stays with the exchequer. This order of the High Court will be helpful to governmental authorities, government entities and PSUs while defending suppression cases. Litigation involving such bodies / PSUs is entirely futile as the tax revenue goes from one arm of the government to another and the exercise is in a way revenue-neutral [2026-VIL-1258-RAJ].
VIL has reported an order of GSTAT, Hyderabad wherein it has been held that detection of discrepancy by the department is not an evidence of suppression and use of "appears" indicates suspicion and not a foundational fact. It noted how the SCN was defective as it did not mention the information required to be disclosed by the taxpayer, information sought but not furnished, etc. Responding to the Appellate Authority's charge that evidence was not produced, the Tribunal states - "the failure to produce evidence in defence of a notice cannot supply, after the notice, the ingredient of suppression that the notice itself did not disclose." GSTAT has been providing the much-needed relief to the taxpayers who have bearing the brunt of blunt orders of adjudicating and appellate authorities [2026-VIL-320-GSTAT-HYD].
Taxpayer can adjust excess tax paid towards ITC liable to be reversed
A taxpayer is charged with availing input tax credit (ITC) which is not due. He notices excess payment of tax on outward supply and adjusts the same against such ITC to be reversed. The GST department is of the view that by such self-adjustment, the excess tax paid has bypassed the scrutiny of a refund claim for unjust enrichment. There is a case of non-reporting of debit note as well. But the Appellate Authority true his ordained role, dismissed the appeal with one line finding. GSTAT Ernakulam Bench was very much disappointed to see such "cavalier approach" resulting in non-speaking order due to non-application of mind.
The Tribunal has adopted a very progressive approach in this dispute. It has held that the appellant ought to have been allowed set-off of excess paid tax to make good for ITC to the extent not due. According to the Tribunal, such a course does not violate any statutory provision. The order states - "Expecting the appellant to pay up the shortfall demanded and then file a claim for refund of the excess amount paid would be an exercise in futility. As such we find that when the excess of output tax paid is more than the input credit denied, there is no short payment of tax warranting invocation of proceedings under section 73 of the KGST / CGST Act." The Tribunal also said the unjust enrichment is not applicable in this case.
The order is taxpayer friendly but the case law relied seems to be not exactly applicable. Further suo-motu adjustment by taxpayer without claiming refund separately was a litigated matter in the pre-GST regime. This is likely to again emerge as a flashpoint and GST Council may take note to provide for an appropriate mechanism. Though Service Tax provisions had adjustment facility, it was confined to excess payment in one tax period and adjustment in the next period. Cross adjustment between excess paid tax and credit liable to be reversed is something GST law has to either provide for or restrict so that law is made clear [2026-VIL-328-GSTAT-ERN].
Appellate Authority under GST cannot dismiss appeal for non-prosecution
Three opportunities were given to the taxpayer by the Appellate Authority but they did not attend and did not seek any adjournment. The Appellate Authority dismissed the appeal for non-prosecution. The Bengaluru Bench of GSTAT posed this question first - whether appeal can be dismissed on the ground of non-prosecution without any speaking order on the issue involved.
Taking note of Section 107(12) of CGST Act, it held that the order of such authority should state the points for determination, decision and reasons. Therefore, even if the taxpayer / appellant failed to appear, the Appellate Authority ought to have given findings on the grounds of appeal and should have passed a speaking order. It distinguished precedents by pointing out that in the present case the appellant had filed detailed appeal and documents and the Appellate Authority was required to examine the same. The order holds - "The appellate authority must exercise statutory appellate jurisdiction, not merely dispose of the appeal for absence. If it finds the evidence insufficient, it may reject the grounds on evidence and reasons; it cannot avoid deciding the pleaded issues altogether."
The quasi-judicial authorities can take a lesson or two from the GSTAT. Most of the orders discuss the case law relied on by the parties. In this case also, the Tribunal has dealt with each of the cases with reasons as to why the same is not applicable or why it is distinguished. The order impugned before it was held as non-speaking.
When the impugned order is non-speaking, it is rather difficult to avoid the temptation of remanding the matter back. However, the Tribunal in this case proceeded to pass order on merits after stating that the entire records were before it. It reiterated that difference between ITC in GSTR-2A and GSTR-3B alone cannot be a ground to deny ITC and based on the period involved, lack of statutory basis for denying ITC based on GSTR-2A and other grounds, denial of credit was held as not sustainable. After exhaustively going through the figures and reconciliation data, on another issue also, it has held in taxpayer's favour after cross-verifying with the Departmental Representative. A very rare one-off order of its kind where Tribunal functions true to the settled "last fact-finding authority" dictum [2026-VIL-333-GSTAT-BLR].
Interest on refund after appellate order - Date of original claim relevant
Refund related disputes generally give birth to two children - another SCN proposing rejection of refund on the ground of unjust enrichment and second, interest on refund claimed whenever favourable order is passed. The issue before GSTAT is re-enactment of excise litigation. Interest should be paid after expiry of the prescribed period computed from the date of initial order disposing refund claim or it should run only from such period after claims are filed based on appellate order.
GSTAT Vijayawada Bench after taking note of precedent judgments and meticulously analysing them has held that appellant is entitled to interest of 6% on the refund amounts, commencing immediately after expiry of 60 days from receipt of the original refund applications and continuing until actual disbursement. It held that date of order granting refund cannot be automatically substituted for date of the original application when the statute expressly links interest to the application and the appellate order established the appellant's entitlement to refund, but do not, by themselves, justify postponing the commencement of ordinary interest under Section 56 of CGST Act. The proviso providing for 9% interest has been held as applicable if consequential refund is not granted after prescribed period even after appellate order.
It is very likely that the department, despite the misadventure in Central Excise regime, will take such matters to High Court in GST regime again and litigate. Based on such clear orders, GST Council Secretariat may also consider recommending issuance of circulars so that at least a few of the authorities may not venture in such purposeless exercise [2026-VIL-335-GSTAT-VJY].
[Read previous edition dated 09.11.2026]
[The author is an Advocate. The views expressed are strictly personal.]