More Judgements

2026-VIL-109-SC  | Supreme Court SGST

GST – Supply and installation of Solar Power Generating Systems (SPG systems) - Works Contract, Composite supply - Section 2(119) read with Section 2(30) of the CGST Act, 2017 - The Appellant-assessee supplied and installed SPG systems on a turnkey basis under EPC contracts, which included certain components of civil works - Respondent treated the supply as a composite supply amounting to a works contract on the premise that a solar power plant is immovable property - Whether supply and installation of SPG systems under an EPC contract is a works contract under Section 2(119) of the CGST Act, 2017 - HELD - Every composit... [Read more]

GST – Supply and installation of Solar Power Generating Systems (SPG systems) - Works Contract, Composite supply - Section 2(119) read with Section 2(30) of the CGST Act, 2017 - The Appellant-assessee supplied and installed SPG systems on a turnkey basis under EPC contracts, which included certain components of civil works - Respondent treated the supply as a composite supply amounting to a works contract on the premise that a solar power plant is immovable property - Whether supply and installation of SPG systems under an EPC contract is a works contract under Section 2(119) of the CGST Act, 2017 - HELD - Every composite supply under Section 2(30) does not qualify as a works contract under Section 2(119). To do so, the contract must relate to some activity pertaining to immovable property as an end product. The inclusion of civil works components in the EPC contract does not automatically make the transaction a works contract - An SPG system is fixed on a civil foundation only for stability and to ensure proper functioning, which does not by itself convert it into immovable property. Affixation to something embedded in the earth does not per se qualify the object so affixed as immovable property. It is not in dispute that the SPG systems can be detached from the civil foundation and used elsewhere. They are not affixed so as to result in the beneficial enjoyment of the foundation, which merely ensures that the system remains firm and stable for its better utilisation - The mere fact that the EPC contract executed by the appellant for supply and installation of the SPG systems included certain components of civil works also did not automatically mean that the transaction would be a ‘works contract’ as defined by Section 2(119) of the CGST Act - The SPG system is not immovable property, the transaction is not a works contract - The contention of the Respondent-Revenue is rejected. The impugned order and consequential Summary Order are set aside and the appeal is allowedrnrn rnrnIssue 2: Applicable rate of tax on entire SPG system - Applicability of 70:30 ratio for supplies prior to 01.01.2019 - Prior to the 70:30 ratio regime, the Appellant paid tax at the rate applicable to the entire SPG system under Serial No. 234 of Notification No. 1/2017-Central Tax (Rate). Notification No. 24/2018 introduced the deemed valuation of 70% for goods and 30% for services with effect from 01.01.2019. A subsequent Circular clarified that tax on such projects can be paid in the 70:30 ratio for the period 01.07.2017 to 31.12.2018 - The SCN and the impugned order applied the 70:30 ratio to the Appellant for the earlier period - Whether the 70:30 ratio is mandatorily applicable to supplies made prior to 01.01.2019 - HELD - The Notification came into force on 01.01.2019 and had no retrospective operation. The Circular stated that tax can be paid in the 70:30 ratio for the earlier period, which shows that only an option was given to assessees who wanted to take recourse to the new scheme. There was no mandate in the Notification or the Circular that the ratio had to be compulsorily applied to past transactions - The notion of the authorities that the option should be mandatorily applied across the board, even to assessees who did not choose it, is patently erroneous and wholly unsustainable. Serial No. 234 treated the entire SPG system as a unit. Its later substitution by an entry covering only the solar power generator cannot be applied retrospectively to earlier transactions - The demand raised by applying the 70:30 ratio for the period prior to 01.01.2019 is unsustainable.rnrn rnrnIssue 3: Extended period of limitation - Section 74 of the CGST Act, 2017 - The Respondent invoked Section 74 and imposed penalty under Section 122(2)(b) on the allegation that the Appellant wilfully misstated and suppressed facts and misclassified its supply to minimise tax liability. Whether the extended period of limitation under Section 74 was validly invoked - HELD - As the 70:30 ratio regime came into existence only from 01.01.2019, the question of imputing fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression of facts to the Appellant for applying that ratio to the prior period does not arise. The foundational facts which lead to the inference of fraud, wilful misrepresentation or suppression should be evident from the notice itself - Mere employment of such words does not indicate application of mind, upon which alone the satisfaction can be arrived at - Invocation of extended limitation is completely unsustainable on facts and in law - The order of the Joint Commissioner and the consequential Summary Order are set aside.rnrn rnrnIssue 4: Maintainability of writ petition - Alternate remedy of appeal - The Appellant challenged an order of the Joint Commissioner and the consequential Summary Order, which demanded GST with penalty on supply and installation of Solar Power Generating systems (SPG systems) under EPC contracts for the period 01.07.2017 to 31.12.2018. The Appellant approached the High Court directly. The High Court dismissed the writ petition on the ground of an efficacious alternate remedy and left the Appellant to comply with the pre-deposit. Whether the High Court was justified in relegating the Appellant to the appellate remedy - HELD - The cursory dismissal of the writ petition was not justified, as arguable points were raised which warranted consideration by the High Court. Availability of an alternate remedy is not a straitjacketed formula to be applied without exception. Each case has to turn upon its own individual and peculiar facts - As the matter was argued at length and the issue had already been adjudicated by the Andhra Pradesh High Court, the Court found it appropriate to deal with the matter on merits instead of remitting it. [Read less]

2026-VIL-1264-GUJ-CE  | High Court CENTRAL EXCISE

Central Excise - Option to pay amount on exempted goods - Rule 6(3) of the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004 - The Appellant used common inputs for dutiable and exempted goods and paid a flat percentage of the value of exempted goods. The Appellant continued the same payment from April to June 2008 after the amendment to Rule 6(3), and by letter dated 01.07.2008 exercised the option under clause (ii) read with sub-rule (3A) to reverse proportionate credit - Respondent denied the option under Explanation 1 on the view that the Appellant had already availed the option under clause (i) on 01.04.2008, and confirmed demand with interes... [Read more]

Central Excise - Option to pay amount on exempted goods - Rule 6(3) of the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004 - The Appellant used common inputs for dutiable and exempted goods and paid a flat percentage of the value of exempted goods. The Appellant continued the same payment from April to June 2008 after the amendment to Rule 6(3), and by letter dated 01.07.2008 exercised the option under clause (ii) read with sub-rule (3A) to reverse proportionate credit - Respondent denied the option under Explanation 1 on the view that the Appellant had already availed the option under clause (i) on 01.04.2008, and confirmed demand with interest and penalty, which the CESTAT upheld - Whether the Appellant, having continued to pay the flat percentage from 01.04.2008, was precluded by Explanation 1 from exercising the option under clause (ii) during the financial year - HELD - On a conjoint reading of sub-rule (3) and sub-rule (3A), the assessee can exercise the option at any time during the financial year, and once exercised under clause (i) or clause (ii), it cannot be withdrawn for the remaining part of that financial year. There is no prescription under Rule 6(3) that the option must be exercised on 1st April of each financial year. Sub-rule (3A) requires written intimation to the Superintendent of the date from which the option is exercised or proposed to be exercised. Treating the Appellant as having deemed to avail the option under clause (i) on 01.04.2008 is contrary to the legislative intention of the amendment. Once the option under clause (ii) is exercised, it cannot be withdrawn during the rest of the financial year, but the assessee may revert to clause (i) in the succeeding financial year - The CESTAT was not right in holding that the appellant had exercised the option to pay equivalent to 10% of the value of the exempted goods under Rule 6(3) of the Rules and therefore could not have availed such option upon amendment of Rules with effect from 1.4.2008 during the financial year 2008-09 - The orders of the CESTAT, the adjudicating authority and the Commissioner (Appeals) are set aside and the appeal is allowed [Read less]

2026-VIL-1899-CESTAT-MUM-CU  | CESTAT CUSTOMS

Customs - Classification of milk based coffee beverage - Tariff Items 2202 99 30 and 2202 99 90 - The Appellant imported a ready to drink milk based coffee beverage, which was classified under the entry for beverages containing milk. The goods were assessed to IGST under Serial No. 12A as caffeinated beverages classifiable under the residuary tariff item. The Commissioner (Appeals) upheld the assessment on the ground that the ingredient list showed caffeine content - Whether the goods are classifiable as beverages containing milk under Tariff Item 2202 99 30 or as caffeinated beverages under Tariff Item 2202 99 90 - HELD -... [Read more]

Customs - Classification of milk based coffee beverage - Tariff Items 2202 99 30 and 2202 99 90 - The Appellant imported a ready to drink milk based coffee beverage, which was classified under the entry for beverages containing milk. The goods were assessed to IGST under Serial No. 12A as caffeinated beverages classifiable under the residuary tariff item. The Commissioner (Appeals) upheld the assessment on the ground that the ingredient list showed caffeine content - Whether the goods are classifiable as beverages containing milk under Tariff Item 2202 99 30 or as caffeinated beverages under Tariff Item 2202 99 90 - HELD - The packaging and labelling show that the imported goods are milk based beverages, whereas goods declared as caffeinated beverages are water based. The impugned order reproduced the tariff headings and HSN Explanatory Notes but ignored them while determining classification, and it did not discuss the product description, specification and label. The goods are undisputedly milk based and are therefore beverages containing milk, which is a more specific description than the residuary entry. Where a commodity reasonably falls within a specific enumerated entry, recourse to the residuary entry is impermissible. Under the FSSAI standards, the characterising base of the goods is milk or dairy components and not water. The caffeine present is naturally inherent to the coffee extract, with no added caffeine. The goods are not required to carry the labels prescribed for caffeinated beverages under Regulation 2.10.6(2). The goods are therefore outside the purview of Serial No. 12A - The goods are classifiable under Tariff Item 2202 99 30 and the impugned order is set aside and the appeal is allowed [Read less]

2026-VIL-336-GSTAT-TVP  | Tribunal SGST

GST - Penalty for non-generation of e-invoice - Section 129(1) of CGST Act, 2017 - Appellant transported goods by way of stock transfer under a tax invoice and a valid e-way bill. The vehicle was intercepted and the goods were detained as the supplier had not generated e-invoice under Rule 48(4) of the CGST Rules, 2017 - Penalty equal to the tax was imposed on the Appellant under Section 129(1), which the FAA upheld - Whether penalty under Section 129(1) can be levied on the recipient of goods in an inter-state supply, on interception of the vehicle, when the transporter is carrying proper tax invoice and valid e-way bill ... [Read more]

GST - Penalty for non-generation of e-invoice - Section 129(1) of CGST Act, 2017 - Appellant transported goods by way of stock transfer under a tax invoice and a valid e-way bill. The vehicle was intercepted and the goods were detained as the supplier had not generated e-invoice under Rule 48(4) of the CGST Rules, 2017 - Penalty equal to the tax was imposed on the Appellant under Section 129(1), which the FAA upheld - Whether penalty under Section 129(1) can be levied on the recipient of goods in an inter-state supply, on interception of the vehicle, when the transporter is carrying proper tax invoice and valid e-way bill but the supplier has not prepared an e-invoice - HELD - Supply between two distinct registered persons in different States is an inter-state supply even though both share a common PAN, and IGST is payable. There was no discrepancy as regards quantity and description of goods and the e-way bill was valid at the time of interception. The obligation of the recipient is limited to carrying the proper tax invoice and valid e-way bill and showing the same to the officer during checking. Section 31 of the Act and Rule 46 of the Rules apply only to the registered supplier and do not implicate the recipient for any omission to prepare e-invoice. The entire burden of issuing an e-invoice under Rule 48(4) is only on the supplier. Non-issuance of e-invoice cannot be a ground for detention of the vehicle and imposing penalties, as the Appellant has not contravened any Section or Rule so as to attract Section 129(1). Any omission under Rule 48 is to be monitored by the jurisdictional officer during scrutiny, assessment or audit of the supplier - The order of the FAA is set aside and the appeal is allowed [Read less]

2026-VIL-1903-CESTAT-KOL-ST  | CESTAT SERVICE TAX

Service Tax - Taxability of road transportation of goods - Section 66D(p)(i)(A) of Finance Act, 1994 - The Appellant was a truck owner and operator transporting coal and iron for principal transporters under work orders, without registration or filing of returns. The demand was raised on the gross receipts shown in the Income Tax Return, treating the entire amount as consideration for taxable services - Whether transportation of goods by road without issuing consignment notes is taxable as Goods Transport Agency service - HELD - Services by way of transportation of goods by road are in the Negative List unless provided by ... [Read more]

Service Tax - Taxability of road transportation of goods - Section 66D(p)(i)(A) of Finance Act, 1994 - The Appellant was a truck owner and operator transporting coal and iron for principal transporters under work orders, without registration or filing of returns. The demand was raised on the gross receipts shown in the Income Tax Return, treating the entire amount as consideration for taxable services - Whether transportation of goods by road without issuing consignment notes is taxable as Goods Transport Agency service - HELD - Services by way of transportation of goods by road are in the Negative List unless provided by a Goods Transport Agency, and issuance of a consignment note is an indispensable prerequisite for qualifying as a Goods Transport Agency under Section 65B(26) read with Rule 4B. The work orders, transport challans, vehicle records and ledgers show that the Appellant acted solely as a hired truck owner, and the challans were issued by the principal transporters. The Revenue failed to adduce any evidence of issuance of consignment notes. The plea on consignment notes is a legal question touching exigibility and can be raised at any stage. Even otherwise, liability on freight paid by specified recipients such as bodies corporate and partnership firms rested on the recipients under the Reverse Charge Mechanism, which was not examined. The initial burden lies on the Revenue to establish that a transaction is taxable before proof of exemption is demanded - The services are exempt under the Negative List and the demand is set aside - Demand based on Income Tax data - Section 66B of Finance Act, 1994 - The demand was raised by adopting gross turnover reflected in the Income Tax Return and CBDT data, without any independent investigation - Whether Service Tax can be demanded merely on the basis of Income Tax Return and Form 26AS data - HELD - Service Tax is leviable only on the provision of a specific service that is neither in the Negative List nor exempted, and the burden rests on the Revenue to identify the service and determine the taxable consideration. Gross receipts cannot be borrowed from Income Tax records and treated as taxable service income by default. Form 26AS is maintained on cash basis for tax deducted at source and is not a statutory document for determining taxable turnover, whereas Service Tax is chargeable on accrual basis. In the absence of independent corroborative evidence of any taxable service, the demand cannot be sustained - The demand and interest are set aside - Extended period of limitation - Section 73(1) of Finance Act, 1994 - The SCN invoked the extended period alleging suppression for non-registration and non-filing of returns, and mens rea was inferred from the Appellant's inability to produce old records during the pandemic - Whether the extended period under the proviso to Section 73(1) can be invoked - HELD - The demand rested on receipts transparently declared in the Appellant's own Income Tax Return and audited books, and the Appellant promptly disclosed the nature of its business during the inquiry. Extended period requires proof of fraud, collusion, wilful misstatement or suppression with intent to evade tax. Mere omission to obtain registration or file returns, driven by a bona fide understanding of non-taxability, is not suppression. Inability to produce records during a pandemic inquiry cannot establish fraudulent intent for an earlier year. The normal period had lapsed before the pandemic, so the general extension of limitation does not revive the demand - The invocation of the extended period fails and the demand is barred by limitation - Penalties - Sections 77 and 78 of Finance Act, 1994 - Penalties were imposed under Section 77(1)(c)(ii), Section 77(2) and Section 78 - Whether the penalties are sustainable - HELD - Penalty under Section 78 requires fraud, collusion, wilful misstatement or suppression of facts with intent to evade tax, which are absent as the Appellant acted under a bona fide belief of non-taxability. Penalty under Section 77(1)(c)(ii) is not warranted, since the Appellant furnished its Income Tax Return acknowledgement and audited Balance Sheet, and inability to produce granular historical records during the pandemic is not wilful default. The general procedural penalty under Section 77(2) is not interfered with - The penalties under Section 78 and Section 77(1)(c)(ii) are set aside and the penalty under Section 77(2) is upheld. [Read less]

2026-VIL-340-GSTAT-ERN  | Tribunal SGST

GST - Jurisdiction of State officer over registered person of another State - Section 129 of CGST Act, 2017 - Appellant, registered in Tamil Nadu, supplied goods to a buyer in Kerala. The vehicle was intercepted in Kerala, and the Assistant State Tax Officer issued the notice and the order imposing penalty to the Appellant without generating a TEMP ID. The TEMP ID was generated about four months later at the stage of uploading the summary of the order on the portal - Whether the State Tax Officer of Kerala has jurisdiction to issue the notice and order to a registered person in Tamil Nadu and impose penalty under Section 1... [Read more]

GST - Jurisdiction of State officer over registered person of another State - Section 129 of CGST Act, 2017 - Appellant, registered in Tamil Nadu, supplied goods to a buyer in Kerala. The vehicle was intercepted in Kerala, and the Assistant State Tax Officer issued the notice and the order imposing penalty to the Appellant without generating a TEMP ID. The TEMP ID was generated about four months later at the stage of uploading the summary of the order on the portal - Whether the State Tax Officer of Kerala has jurisdiction to issue the notice and order to a registered person in Tamil Nadu and impose penalty under Section 129(1) without issuing a TEMP ID - HELD - The Assistant State Tax Officer exceeded his jurisdiction by issuing the notice and order to a registered person of another State without generating the TEMP ID. Generation of the TEMP ID subsequently, at the time of uploading the summary of the order, does not cure the defect. All notices and orders issued under Section 129(3) before that date are impermissible, without jurisdiction and illegal - The notice and order are null and void ab initio, the order of the FAA is set aside and the appeal is allowed.rnrn rnrnIssue 2: Penalty for non-generation of e-invoice - Section 129(1) of CGST Act, 2017 - The vehicle was carrying a tax invoice and a valid e-way bill, with no discrepancy in the goods. The only discrepancy was that the e-invoice was not available at the time of interception, and it was produced the next day - Whether penalty under Section 129(1) can be levied when the transporter is carrying a proper tax invoice and a valid e-way bill but the e-invoice was not prepared on the date of supply - HELD - When there is a tax invoice and e-way bill, which is sufficient for the transporter to demonstrate, the vehicle should have been let go. Non-issuance of e-invoice at the time of interception, when it was subsequently produced the next day and not disputed by the Revenue, cannot be a ground for detention of the vehicle and imposing penalties - There is no requirement of physically carrying the e-invoice, and the Act does not prescribe any time limit for issuing it. Section 31 of the Act and Rule 46 of the Rules apply only to the registered supplier. The burden of issuing an e-invoice is only on the supplier. Section 129(1) cannot be invoked for non-issuance of e-invoice under Rule 48(4) when a proper tax invoice is already issued. Any omission under Rule 48 is to be monitored by the jurisdictional officer during audit, scrutiny or assessment of the supplier - The penalty under Section 129(1) is not sustainable, the order of the FAA is set aside and the appeal is allowed. [Read less]

2026-VIL-339-GSTAT-CTT  | Tribunal SGST

GST - Denial of ITC on invoices of non-existent supplier - Section 16(2)(b) of the CGST Act, 2017 - Appellant availed ITC on purchases from a supplier which investigation found to be non-existent, as the registered proprietor disowned the business and registration and the owner of the premises denied letting it out. The rent agreement used for registration was forged, as its signatories had died long before its date - The Appellant produced invoices, e-way bills, weighment slips and bank statement but did not produce stock register, purchase and sale registers or transport challans. The demand under Section 74 was confirme... [Read more]

GST - Denial of ITC on invoices of non-existent supplier - Section 16(2)(b) of the CGST Act, 2017 - Appellant availed ITC on purchases from a supplier which investigation found to be non-existent, as the registered proprietor disowned the business and registration and the owner of the premises denied letting it out. The rent agreement used for registration was forged, as its signatories had died long before its date - The Appellant produced invoices, e-way bills, weighment slips and bank statement but did not produce stock register, purchase and sale registers or transport challans. The demand under Section 74 was confirmed by the adjudicating authority and the FAA - Whether ITC availed against invoices issued by a non-existent supplier is admissible when the supplier was registered on the date of the transaction - HELD - The essential ingredient of input tax under Section 2(62) is a transaction of supply, and a supply can happen only if both the supplier and the recipient exist and carry on business. In the absence of any business at the registered place of business, the invoices are reduced to mere paper invoices without any underlying supply of goods - Registration obtained by a forged rent agreement is void ab initio. Validity of registration on the date of transaction, filing of returns by the supplier and appearance of the invoices in GSTR-2B are irrelevant. Invoices, e-way bills, weighment slips and bank payment do not counter the allegation and cannot be taken as evidence of receipt of goods, so the condition in Section 16(2)(b) is not fulfilled - Payment by bearer cheques without proof of credit to the supplier's account weakens reliance on the bank statement. The stock register and affidavit were not admitted as additional evidence, as no formal application explaining reasonable cause was made. The principle that a purchasing dealer cannot be denied credit for the default of a genuine selling dealer does not apply where the supply transaction itself is a paper transaction - ITC is held inadmissible, the demand is confirmed and the appeal is dismissed.rnrnIssue 2: Invocation of Section 74 - Commission of fraud - The Appellant contended that Section 74 had no application as there was no fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression of facts on its part - Whether Section 74 was rightly invoked for recovery of the ITC - HELD - Once non-existence of any business at the registered place of business and obtaining of registration by fraudulent means is established, the complicity of the recipient availing ITC against invoices of such a registrant is established as a natural corollary. Commission of fraud is one of the grounds for invoking Section 74 for recovery of inadmissible ITC. Taking ITC without receipt of goods is an offence under Section 122(1)(vi), liable to penalty equivalent to the ITC so availed - The invocation of Section 74 is sustained.c [Read less]

2026-VIL-338-GSTAT-ERN  | Tribunal SGST

GST - Refund of unutilised ITC on exports under LUT - Computation of Net ITC under Rule 89(4) of CGST Rules, 2017 - Appellant claimed refund of unutilised ITC for two months and the refund was sanctioned in part. The FAA held that the Net ITC adopted was incorrect, resulting in excess refund, and allowed the Revenue's appeal - The Appellant contended that ITC reversed through GSTR-3B for February had already been deducted while determining refund for an earlier period and that a further deduction amounts to duplication - Whether the FAA correctly calculated the refund amount as per the formula prescribed in Rule 89(4) - HE... [Read more]

GST - Refund of unutilised ITC on exports under LUT - Computation of Net ITC under Rule 89(4) of CGST Rules, 2017 - Appellant claimed refund of unutilised ITC for two months and the refund was sanctioned in part. The FAA held that the Net ITC adopted was incorrect, resulting in excess refund, and allowed the Revenue's appeal - The Appellant contended that ITC reversed through GSTR-3B for February had already been deducted while determining refund for an earlier period and that a further deduction amounts to duplication - Whether the FAA correctly calculated the refund amount as per the formula prescribed in Rule 89(4) - HELD - The dispute is only regarding Net ITC, all other figures being undisputed. The Net ITC for the refund period is to be taken as per Table 4(C) of the GSTR-3B returns filed by the Appellant. The formula in Rule 89(4) is to be strictly applied. The claim of reversal of ITC in February pertaining to an earlier period is not relevant to the calculation of refund for the present period - The appellant did not furnish proof of any such reversal by way of DRC-03, DRC-03A or any other document. Reduction of ineligible ITC in the refund of an earlier period and actual debit from the electronic credit ledger in a later period are two different events, and there is no duplication - The figures in the refund claim differed from the GSTR-3B returns, and the Appellant did not correctly show the Net ITC - The order of the FAA is upheld and the appeal is rejected [Read less]

2026-VIL-1895-CESTAT-AHM-CU  | CESTAT CUSTOMS

Customs - Conditions of provisional release - Section 110A of the Customs Act, 1962 - The Appellant imported distillate marine oil declared for industrial use. The test report stated that the sample was most akin to a restricted grade of diesel but had a flash point below the prescribed minimum, and the goods were seized under Section 110. The Commissioner held that the goods could not be treated as the restricted grade at that stage and ordered provisional release under Section 110A. The release was subject to an end-use bond, maintenance of batch-wise records, a bond for the full assessable value and a bank guarantee for... [Read more]

Customs - Conditions of provisional release - Section 110A of the Customs Act, 1962 - The Appellant imported distillate marine oil declared for industrial use. The test report stated that the sample was most akin to a restricted grade of diesel but had a flash point below the prescribed minimum, and the goods were seized under Section 110. The Commissioner held that the goods could not be treated as the restricted grade at that stage and ordered provisional release under Section 110A. The release was subject to an end-use bond, maintenance of batch-wise records, a bond for the full assessable value and a bank guarantee for a percentage of the assessable value. The Appellant complied under financial hardship due to mounting terminal charges, and the goods were provisionally released. The Appellant sought modification of the conditions and discharge of the bank guarantee, relying on decisions in the cases of similarly situated importers. The Respondent justified the order - Whether the bank guarantee and the other conditions imposed for provisional release are liable to be set aside - HELD - In a recent matter concerning a similar product, the Tribunal considered the same test reports and clarifications of the laboratory. The test reports were not definitive as to whether the distillate oil was diesel or the restricted grade. Diesel fraction is a broad category including the restricted grade and other distillate oils, and cloud point cannot be the sole basis for seizure of the cargo. The condition of furnishing a bank guarantee is against the directions given in the cases of identical goods and is liable to be set aside. The end-use certificate has already been produced on record, and any remaining certificate shall be produced before the authorities - The bank guarantee shall be returned on production of the end-use certificate and execution of a bond - The appeal is allowed [Read less]

2026-VIL-333-GSTAT-BLR  | Tribunal SGST

GST - Dismissal of appeal for non-appearance - Section 107(11) and (12) of CGST Act, 2017 - Appellant's input tax credit was disallowed on the basis of the difference between Form GSTR-3B and Form GSTR-2A for FY 2018-19. The demand was confirmed in the adjudication order, and the FAA dismissed the appeal for non-prosecution since the Appellant did not appear on three dates fixed for personal hearing. The Appellant had filed a detailed appeal with its reply to the SCN, a reconciliation statement and the amendment table details. The FAA did not decide the grounds on merits - Whether the FAA is right in dismissing the appeal ... [Read more]

GST - Dismissal of appeal for non-appearance - Section 107(11) and (12) of CGST Act, 2017 - Appellant's input tax credit was disallowed on the basis of the difference between Form GSTR-3B and Form GSTR-2A for FY 2018-19. The demand was confirmed in the adjudication order, and the FAA dismissed the appeal for non-prosecution since the Appellant did not appear on three dates fixed for personal hearing. The Appellant had filed a detailed appeal with its reply to the SCN, a reconciliation statement and the amendment table details. The FAA did not decide the grounds on merits - Whether the FAA is right in dismissing the appeal for failure to utilise the opportunity of personal hearings - HELD - Section 107(11) requires the FAA to pass an order confirming, modifying or annulling the order appealed against. Section 107(12) requires the order to state the points for determination, the decision thereon and the reasons for such decision. Even where the Appellant did not appear, the FAA should have given findings on the grounds of appeal and examined the supporting documents. A general statement that the Appellant did not adduce necessary documentary evidence cannot replace an examination of the documents and grounds already filed. The decisions on non-prosecution relied upon concern their own procedural settings and do not override the statutory duty to pass a reasoned decision on merits. The inherent power to dismiss for non-prosecution cannot be used where the statute requires the appeal to be decided on merits - The FAA could proceed after the default but could not dismiss the appeal solely for default of appearance. The conduct of the Appellant in not replying to the audit observations and not attending the hearings does not relieve the FAA of its duty - The order of the FAA is a non-speaking order in breach of Section 107(12) and cannot be sustained - The appeal is allowed - Denial of Input Tax Credit on mismatch between Form GSTR-3B and Form GSTR-2A - Section 16 of CGST Act, 2017 - Demand was confirmed on a comparison of the total credit availed in Form GSTR-3B with the total credit in the auto-drafted Form GSTR-2A for FY 2018-19, without invoice-wise details or identification of any condition of Section 16 that was violated. Appellant contended that no provision during the period barred credit not reflected in Form GSTR-2A - Whether the excess credit availed in Form GSTR-3B as compared to Form GSTR-2A can be disallowed as not available under Section 16 - HELD - Section 16(2) prescribes the conditions for credit, being possession of a tax invoice, receipt of goods or services, payment of tax to the Government and filing of return. The Appellant was not put on notice about any condition violated, and the demand was based only on the mismatch of total credit. A mismatch alone does not create a liability of tax and can only provide a basis for initiating verification proceedings. Where the mismatch arises from supplier default, the defaulting suppliers must be identified and their returns verified, which was not done. During the period there was no provision for denial of credit on account of a difference between the two Forms. The scheme of matching under Sections 38, 41 and 42 was never brought into operation, and Form GSTR-2A served only as a facility on the common portal. Rule 36(4) was inserted only with effect from October 2019. Form GSTR-2A is only a facilitator for taking an informed decision while doing self-assessment. The auto-drafted data may be the source for the officer to initiate examination and identify lapses from the supplier end. The Circular directs that the proper officer first seek invoice-wise details and then ascertain fulfilment of the conditions of Section 16. The Circular binds the officers, and its procedure for certificates is to be undertaken by the Appellant only after the details of defaulting suppliers are shared, which was not done - The demand confirmed on the comparison of total credit without invoice-level mismatch cannot be sustained - The appeal is allowed - Sufficiency of records to establish no excess credit - Reconciliation with amendment table of Form GSTR-2A - Adjudicating authority rejected the reconciliation by referring only to the B2B table of Form GSTR-2A for July 2019, and ignored the entries in the B2BA amendment table for the same month. Appellant contended that credit relating to nine invoices of one supplier, which were not reflected earlier, appeared in the updated Form GSTR-2A for FY 2018-19 through amendment - Whether the documents are sufficient to establish that there was no excess credit availed in Form GSTR-3B during the year - HELD - The amended invoices did not appear in Form GSTR-2A of the year as they were not reflected in the B2B table, and appeared on amendment through the outward supplies return of July 2019. The Appellant consistently submitted that the shortage was due to non-consideration of the B2BA amendment invoices. The authorised representative of the Respondent verified the updated Form GSTR-2A and Form GSTR-3B and confirmed that the total credit availed was within the total credit available. Form GSTR-3B of July 2019 shows that the credit of these invoices was not availed a second time. Had the adjudicating authority followed the Circular and called for invoice-wise details, the amendment entries would have come to light. Had the Appellant replied to the audit observations, the litigation could have been avoided - There was no excess availment of credit, and the demand confirmed in the adjudication order and upheld by the FAA is set aside - Interest and penalty on the demand of excess credit - Section 50 and Section 73(9) of CGST Act, 2017 - Interest and penalty were confirmed along with the demand of reversal of credit, and the Appellant sought in the alternative a waiver of interest for the period when filing before the Tribunal was unavailable - Whether interest and penalty survive and whether waiver of interest arises - HELD - As the demand of reversal of credit fails, the interest under Section 50 and the penalty under Section 73(9) also fall. As the tax demand does not survive, no interest is payable and the alternative plea for waiver of interest does not arise - The appeal is allowed, the adjudication order and the order of the FAA are set aside. [Read less]

2026-VIL-341-GSTAT-CHD  | Tribunal SGST

GST - Refund of accumulated ITC on export of goods without payment of tax during the period January - March 2022 - Rule 89(4) of CGST Rules, 2017 – Respondent-assessee filed a refund claim of accumulated ITC for January to March 2022 in respect of goods exported under bond or letter of undertaking. The FAA allowed additional refund – Appellant-Department contended that one shipping bill had an EGM date after the relevant period, so it should be excluded from the zero-rated turnover and the adjusted total turnover - Whether the invoice for goods exported after the relevant period can be included in the turnover of zero-... [Read more]

GST - Refund of accumulated ITC on export of goods without payment of tax during the period January - March 2022 - Rule 89(4) of CGST Rules, 2017 – Respondent-assessee filed a refund claim of accumulated ITC for January to March 2022 in respect of goods exported under bond or letter of undertaking. The FAA allowed additional refund – Appellant-Department contended that one shipping bill had an EGM date after the relevant period, so it should be excluded from the zero-rated turnover and the adjusted total turnover - Whether the invoice for goods exported after the relevant period can be included in the turnover of zero-rated supply - HELD - Under Rule 89(4), the refund is the portion of Net ITC in the ratio of the turnover of zero-rated supply of goods to the Adjusted Total Turnover, and all three figures must relate to the same relevant period. Turnover for a period is the sum total of invoices issued for supply during that period. Under Section 12 read with Section 31 of the CGST Act, 2017, the tax invoice must be issued before or at the time of removal of the goods - The supply of export goods therefore takes place at removal and issue of the invoice, even though the goods are treated as exported only when they leave India. An invoice issued during the relevant period is included in the turnover of zero-rated supply whether or not the goods were exported in that period. Refund can be given only after the exporter establishes that the goods have actually been exported. It is undisputed that the invoice was prepared in the relevant period and that the goods were exported. The date of the shipping bill itself falls within the relevant period, so the contention of the Appellant is incongruous - The contention of the Dept is not tenable and the appeal is rejected [Read less]

2026-VIL-1886-CESTAT-CHE-CE  | CESTAT CENTRAL EXCISE

Central Excise - Eligibility to CENVAT Credit on Service Tax paid on broadcasting services - Rules 2(1), 3 and 9(2) of the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004 - The Respondent, a manufacturer, engaged an advertising agency for television advertisement of its products. The agency booked air time with broadcasting channels, which billed the agency and paid Service Tax on the broadcasting charges. The agency raised invoices on the Respondent showing the broadcasting charges and the Service Tax thereon as reimbursement, along with its own commission. The Department denied credit of the Service Tax on broadcasting charges by SCN, since t... [Read more]

Central Excise - Eligibility to CENVAT Credit on Service Tax paid on broadcasting services - Rules 2(1), 3 and 9(2) of the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004 - The Respondent, a manufacturer, engaged an advertising agency for television advertisement of its products. The agency booked air time with broadcasting channels, which billed the agency and paid Service Tax on the broadcasting charges. The agency raised invoices on the Respondent showing the broadcasting charges and the Service Tax thereon as reimbursement, along with its own commission. The Department denied credit of the Service Tax on broadcasting charges by SCN, since the channels had billed the agency and not the Respondent. The FAA allowed the credit. The Appellant (Revenue) contended that the broadcasting service was an input service of the agency and not of the Respondent under Rule 2(1). It further contended that Rule 9(2) cannot condone credit taken on invoices not issued by the service provider - Whether the Respondent is eligible to CENVAT credit of Service Tax paid on broadcasting services where the channels' invoices were addressed to the advertising agency - HELD - The appeal fails on its own record. Both members of the Committee of Commissioners agreed that the Order-in-Appeal deserved acceptance on merits, and the appeal was authorised only to keep the issue alive pending the decision in one of the cases relied upon by the FAA. That decision has since attained finality, so the foundation of the appeal no longer exists. The other decision relied upon by the FAA was never challenged and is by itself sufficient to sustain the Order-in-Appeal. On merits, the Revenue's own case is that the agency paid Service Tax only on its commission and did not take credit of the Service Tax charged by the channels. The agency therefore neither used the broadcasting service for any taxable output service of its own nor claimed it as an input service. The amount paid by an advertising agency for space and time in the electronic media, excluding its own commission, is not includible in the value of its taxable service. The only way the tax charged by the channels could reach the advertiser was as a reimbursement shown in the agency's invoice. A service on which the intermediary neither paid tax as part of its output nor took credit as an input cannot be treated as its input service merely because the channel's invoice was addressed to it. The Respondent commissioned the advertisements of its products, bore the Service Tax and used the service in relation to the manufacture of its goods. The service was therefore received by the manufacturer within the meaning of Rule 3, and advertisement falls expressly within the inclusive limb of input service under Rule 2(1). The Revenue's position is also inconsistent, since it allowed credit of the Service Tax on the agency's commission on the very same invoices. Having accepted that the Respondent received the agency service of procuring air time, the Revenue cannot contend that the Respondent did not receive the broadcast so procured. The invoices disclose the Service Tax paid by the channels, the description and value of the service and the particulars of the parties, as Rule 9(2) requires. Credit cannot be denied for a deficiency in the document when payment of tax, receipt of the service and its use are not in dispute - The appeal filed by the Revenue is dismissed and the Order-in-Appeal allowing the CENVAT credit is upheld [Read less]

2026-VIL-320-GSTAT-HYD  | Tribunal SGST

GST - Reversal of Input Tax Credit on Mismatch with Form GSTR-2A - Section 16(2)(c) of CGST Act, 2017 - The Appellant availed input tax credit in Form GSTR-3B for July 2017 to March 2018 in excess of the amount reflected in Form GSTR-2A - Show cause notice under Section 74 alleging breach of Section 16(2)(c) on the ground that the suppliers had neither reported the supplies nor paid the tax - The FAA affirmed the order after rejecting the amended B2B entries and the supplier certificates produced by the Appellant as not acceptable, without recording reasons - The Appellant contended that the orders are non-speaking, that t... [Read more]

GST - Reversal of Input Tax Credit on Mismatch with Form GSTR-2A - Section 16(2)(c) of CGST Act, 2017 - The Appellant availed input tax credit in Form GSTR-3B for July 2017 to March 2018 in excess of the amount reflected in Form GSTR-2A - Show cause notice under Section 74 alleging breach of Section 16(2)(c) on the ground that the suppliers had neither reported the supplies nor paid the tax - The FAA affirmed the order after rejecting the amended B2B entries and the supplier certificates produced by the Appellant as not acceptable, without recording reasons - The Appellant contended that the orders are non-speaking, that the Circular No. 183/15/2022-GST binds the Respondent, and that proceedings under Section 74 are without jurisdiction in the absence of suppression - Whether the order directing reversal of input tax credit can be sustained where the amended B2B entry and supplier certificates, produced as per the Circular, were rejected by the FAA without reasoned findings - HELD - The Appellant has taken a preliminary objection that the Respondent cannot justify the demand on grounds that do not figure in the SCN. Raising additional grounds at the appellate stage that are not found in the show cause notice is against the principles of natural justice. The enquiry is confined to the case made in the notice, namely the condition in Section 16(2)(c) - The Circular was issued under Section 168(1), and its paragraph 6 extends its application to Financial Year 2017-18 cases where adjudication or appeal proceedings are pending, so it applies to the Respondent - The para 4 of the Circular requires the officer to first seek the details and then ascertain fulfilment of the conditions. The Respondent did not show that the AA or the FAA undertook this exercise - The discrepancy arose from an amendment in the supplier's return and from reporting of supplies against the erstwhile registration of the Appellant, which are supplier-side corrections. The amended B2B entry forms part of Form GSTR-2A generated from the supplier's own declaration and discloses the particulars of the invoice, so it has probative value. Without contrary material, the want of a copy of the invoice cannot sustain the reversal - Where the supplier-wise difference exceeds the prescribed threshold, the Circular requires a certificate of a Chartered Accountant or Cost Accountant bearing a UDIN, and otherwise a certificate from the supplier. The Appellant produced the certificates in the prescribed form. A certificate is itself the means of verification, and the Respondent could have verified the UDIN and the supplier's Form GSTR-3B but did not do so - The Circular does not require the certificate to state the wrong registration number and provides that allowance of credit to the actual recipient does not depend on action against the holder of the registration number wrongly mentioned - Section 155 places the burden of proof on the claimant, but once the material is on record, a bare denial that it is unverified, without verification or contrary material, does not displace it. A difference between Form GSTR-2A and Form GSTR-3B may justify verification but is not conclusive proof of wrong availment - The FAA order is non-speaking. The Appellant established the conditions in Section 16(2) for the credit covered by the amended B2B entry and the certificates, and the demand to that extent is not sustainable and set aside - The appeal filed by the taxpayer is partly allowed - Residual IGST without Certificate - Whether the remaining IGST shortfall can be charged to the Appellant - HELD - The Appellant produced no certificate or other evidence that the supplier paid the tax to the Government, so the burden under Section 155 is not discharged and the condition in Section 16(2)(c) is not shown to be satisfied. Having invoked the Circular as the means of establishing eligibility, the Appellant cannot rely on its prescribed mode of proof for one set of invoices and disclaim it for another, as that would amount to approbating and reprobating, and the conditions of a beneficial instrument apply uniformly to every invoice - The credit for the residual amount is not admissible - Invocation of Section 74, Interest and Penalty - Whether the invocation of Section 74 and the consequential levy of interest and penalty can be sustained - HELD - Section 74 applies only where credit is wrongly availed by reason of fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression of facts to evade tax, and the satisfaction of the proper officer on these ingredients is a jurisdictional requirement. The foundational facts for the inference must be evident from the notice itself, and mere employment of these words does not show application of mind. The notice stated only that the discrepancy would have remained unnoticed without departmental verification and that the Appellant appears to have suppressed the facts. Detection of a discrepancy by the Department is not evidence of suppression, and the word ‘appears’ records a suspicion and not a foundational fact - Mere omission to give correct information is not suppression unless deliberate, and availment of credit without due verification does not amount to suppression, as every transgression of Section 16(2) cannot invite Section 74 without clear evidence of fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression with intent to evade tax. Failure to produce evidence in defence cannot supply, after the notice, an ingredient of suppression that the notice did not disclose. The charge is not established and the notice under Section 74(1) is not sustainable - The tax on the residual credit alone is payable under Section 73, with interest if the credit was utilised and penalty to be computed by the proper officer, the balance demand along with the proceedings under Section 74 is set aside. [Read less]

2026-VIL-1889-CESTAT-CHE-ST  | CESTAT SERVICE TAX

Service Tax - Extended period of limitation - Proviso to Section 73(1) of the Finance Act, 1994 - The Appellant operates Automalls and facilitates trading in used commercial vehicles. On departmental audit, SCN invoking the extended period proposed recovery of CENVAT credit attributable to trading under Rule 6, denial of credit on input services and recovery of credit on expenditure treated as capital goods, with interest and penalty. The adjudicating authority confirmed the demands and imposed penalty under Section 78. The FAA upheld part of the demand and remanded the rest. The Appellant contended that the proceedings ar... [Read more]

Service Tax - Extended period of limitation - Proviso to Section 73(1) of the Finance Act, 1994 - The Appellant operates Automalls and facilitates trading in used commercial vehicles. On departmental audit, SCN invoking the extended period proposed recovery of CENVAT credit attributable to trading under Rule 6, denial of credit on input services and recovery of credit on expenditure treated as capital goods, with interest and penalty. The adjudicating authority confirmed the demands and imposed penalty under Section 78. The FAA upheld part of the demand and remanded the rest. The Appellant contended that the proceedings arose from audit of its books and returns, that payments and reversals were already made and that the dispute was interpretational. The Respondent contended that the discrepancies were detected only during audit - Whether there is any justification for invoking the extended period of limitation and for sustaining interest and penalty - HELD - Limitation goes to the very recoverability of the demand and is therefore examined first. The normal period under Section 73(1) was one year from the relevant date, and the demand could survive beyond it only if the proviso was validly invoked. The trading activity, input services, credit entries and expenditure were available in the Appellant's records, from which the Department itself made the disputed computations. The Appellant had paid part of the amount with interest and claimed further reversals through ST-3 returns well before the SCN. These circumstances militate against a finding that the transactions or credit were deliberately withheld. The dispute involved interpretation of Rule 6 and of the definition of input service. The substantive question whether credit was reversible is distinct from the requirement of establishing fraud, wilful misstatement, suppression of facts or contravention with intent to evade. Under Section 73(6), the relevant date is determined with reference to the filing of the periodical return. The returns were due on dates more than one year before the SCN, and their subsequent filing cannot retrospectively extend the limitation applicable to a notice already issued. Mere detection of discrepancies during audit, where payments and reversals had already been made, cannot by itself establish the ingredients of the extended period. Since the extended period is not invocable, interest under Section 75 and penalty under Section 78 read with Rule 15 cannot survive - The entire demand is barred by limitation and the interest and penalty are set aside - Reversal of CENVAT credit attributable to trading - Rule 6 of the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004 - The demand was for short reversal of CENVAT credit attributable to trading for the years 2010-11 and 2011-12. The FAA upheld the demand for 2010-11 and remanded 2011-12 for re-determination under the applicable formula. The Appellant contended that the statutory formula had to be correctly applied from 01.04.2011 and that Rule 6(5) protected the services covered by it - Whether the demand towards reversal of CENVAT credit attributable to trading is sustainable under Rule 6 - HELD - Since the entire demand is already held to be barred by limitation, the merits are examined only briefly as an alternative. The Explanation treating trading as an exempted service became operative from 01.04.2011, and a notification modified the manner of determining the value of trading for the purposes of Rule 6. For the period from 01.04.2011, the computation therefore had to conform to the statutory formula. Rule 6(5) operates independently, notwithstanding the general restrictions under Rule 6(1) to (3). The Department has not satisfactorily demonstrated that the demand was correctly quantified after giving effect to the statutory formula, the reversals already made and the claim under Rule 6(5). A final determination on substantive liability is not necessary since the demand is barred by limitation - The demand towards trading cannot be recovered, and the demand confirmed for 2010-11 and the remand for 2011-12 do not survive - Input service credit and capital goods credit - Rules 2(l) and 2(a) of the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004 - The Department denied credit on input services such as property valuation, company-secretarial services, expenditure on the launch of an Automall and group critical-illness insurance. It also treated credit on rent, engineering, installation and communication services as capital goods credit, since the expenditure was capitalised. The Appellant had already reversed the latter amount. The Appellant contended that the services had nexus with its business and that capitalisation in the accounts cannot convert a service into capital goods - Whether the denial of input service credit and the demand relating to alleged capital goods credit are sustainable - HELD - Since the entire demand is already held to be barred by limitation, these issues are examined briefly as an alternative. The valuation services and the company-secretarial services have a discernible business nexus, and the Department has not established that they were wholly unrelated to the Appellant's business. The launch expenditure was connected with publicity and promotion of the business, and advertisement and sales promotion were specifically covered within the definition of input service applicable during the relevant period. The Appellant has not established that the group critical-illness insurance fell outside the exclusion applicable to life or health insurance used primarily for personal use or consumption of employees. The denial of this component is not disturbed on merits, but the amount is not recoverable since the extended period is unavailable. Capitalisation of expenditure in the books is only an accounting treatment and does not by itself convert a service into capital goods within the meaning of Rule 2(a). Where the invoices are for services, eligibility has to be examined with reference to the definition of input service. The Department has not established that the disputed amount represented specified goods falling within the definition of capital goods. The reversal made by the Appellant cannot determine the original admissibility of the credit - The finding treating the amount as inadmissible capital goods credit is unsustainable, the remaining components are not recoverable on limitation, and the Order-in-Appeal is set aside to the extent challenged with the appeal allowed. [Read less]

2026-VIL-335-GSTAT-VJY  | Tribunal SGST

GST – Eligibility to Interest on delayed refund under Section 56 of CGST Act, 2017 - Appellant filed refund applications of unutilised input tax credit under the inverted duty structure, which were rejected by the original authority - FAA set aside the rejection orders, and the Appellant-assessee filed consequential applications to implement the appellate orders. The refunds were sanctioned within sixty days of the consequential applications, but interest was rejected on that ground - Appellant contended that interest under the main provision of Section 56 runs from the expiry of sixty days from the original applications... [Read more]

GST – Eligibility to Interest on delayed refund under Section 56 of CGST Act, 2017 - Appellant filed refund applications of unutilised input tax credit under the inverted duty structure, which were rejected by the original authority - FAA set aside the rejection orders, and the Appellant-assessee filed consequential applications to implement the appellate orders. The refunds were sanctioned within sixty days of the consequential applications, but interest was rejected on that ground - Appellant contended that interest under the main provision of Section 56 runs from the expiry of sixty days from the original applications - Whether the Appellant whose original refund claims were rejected but later allowed by the FAA is entitled to interest under Section 56 from the expiry of sixty days from the original applications, notwithstanding that the refunds were sanctioned within sixty days of the consequential applications - HELD - The main provision, the proviso and the Explanation to Section 56 must be read together. The main provision links the commencement of ordinary interest to the original application under Section 54(1), the proviso provides for an enhanced rate where the refund arising from an order that has attained finality is not paid within sixty days of the application filed consequent to such order, and the Explanation gives the appellate order the character of an order under Section 54(5). The proviso does not replace or dilute the main provision, and it only enhances the rate for the subsequent period - The consequential application is a procedural step to implement the appellate order and it does not constitute a fresh starting point for the entire interest calculation - The Explanation to Rule 93 treats a refund as rejected only when the appeal is finally rejected, which shows that the original claim retains legal significance during the appellate process - Interest is linked to the date of the refund application and not to the date of the order granting the refund. The entitlement to interest cannot be defeated merely because the original authority passed an order that was reversed in appeal. Payment within sixty days of the consequential application does not extinguish the ordinary interest accrued under the main provision, although the enhanced rate under the proviso may not become payable in such a case - The appellant is entitled to interest at the ordinary notified rate under the main provision, from the day immediately following the expiry of sixty days from receipt of each original application until actual disbursement - The impugned orders are set aside and the appeals are allowed [Read less]

2026-VIL-334-GSTAT-BLR  | Tribunal SGST

GST - Penalty under Section 129 of CGST Act, 2017 for mismatch of vehicle number in e-way bill - The consignment accompanied by an e-way bill and a delivery challan was detained since the vehicle in which it was transported differed from the vehicle number in Part B of the e-way bill - Proper officer imposed penalty under Section 129(1)(a) on the ground that Part B was updated with a different vehicle number and valid e-way bills were not produced - Whether invoking Section 129 and levy of penalty is just and proper where the only discrepancy is the vehicle number in Part B of the e-way bill - HELD - The need to prove mens... [Read more]

GST - Penalty under Section 129 of CGST Act, 2017 for mismatch of vehicle number in e-way bill - The consignment accompanied by an e-way bill and a delivery challan was detained since the vehicle in which it was transported differed from the vehicle number in Part B of the e-way bill - Proper officer imposed penalty under Section 129(1)(a) on the ground that Part B was updated with a different vehicle number and valid e-way bills were not produced - Whether invoking Section 129 and levy of penalty is just and proper where the only discrepancy is the vehicle number in Part B of the e-way bill - HELD - The need to prove mens rea depends on the statutory provision and the nature of the contravention. The Apex Court has upheld the requirement of mens rea before invoking Section 129 and the proper officer cannot conclude an intention to evade tax without material. The reasoning of FAA that mens rea is not relevant is rejected - Section 129 is a machinery provision to check evasion of tax and a detention is justified only if there is a contravention in relation to transportation of goods - The e-way bill and the delivery challan contained all the information required under Rule 138 and Rule 55 of the CGST Rules, 2017 and the only discrepancy was the vehicle number in Part B. Furnishing correct conveyance particulars under Rule 138 is a statutory requirement and not an empty formality. However, the nature and extent of the discrepancy cannot by themselves establish an intention to evade tax, and the explanation, the documents and the circumstances must be examined cumulatively. Physical verification revealed no defects, and the authorities relied on no other material to establish an intention to evade tax - The levy of penalty under Section 129 is unwarranted. The order of the FAA is set aside and the appeal is allowed [Read less]

2026-VIL-324-GSTAT-DEL  | Tribunal SGST

GST - Maintainability of departmental appeal before the Appellate Tribunal - Monetary limit prescribed by Circular No. 207/1/2024-GST dated 26.06.2024 and its exceptions - Respondent claimed refund of accumulated Input Tax Credit under Section 54, which was rejected by the adjudicating authority solely on limitation and allowed by the appellate authority - Appellant-Department filed the appeal under Section 112(3) on the direction of the Principal Commissioner - Respondent contended that the disputed tax was below the monetary limit, that none of the exceptions applied, and that the exception for refunds was confined to in... [Read more]

GST - Maintainability of departmental appeal before the Appellate Tribunal - Monetary limit prescribed by Circular No. 207/1/2024-GST dated 26.06.2024 and its exceptions - Respondent claimed refund of accumulated Input Tax Credit under Section 54, which was rejected by the adjudicating authority solely on limitation and allowed by the appellate authority - Appellant-Department filed the appeal under Section 112(3) on the direction of the Principal Commissioner - Respondent contended that the disputed tax was below the monetary limit, that none of the exceptions applied, and that the exception for refunds was confined to interpretation of the substantive law of entitlement - Whether the appeal is liable to be dismissed in limine as not maintainable on account of the monetary limit - HELD - The right to file the appeal flows from Section 112(3) of the Act, and the review order was passed in exercise of that power. The Circular itself provides that the monetary limits do not apply where the matter relates to refunds, and the dispute being one relating to refund falls squarely within that exclusion. The contention that the exception is confined to the substantive law of entitlement finds no support in the language of the Circular, which speaks of a matter related to refunds without any qualification. The appeal also raises questions of true construction of Section 54(1), Notification No. 13/2022, the proviso to Rule 90(3) and the effect of a deficiency memo, which would govern numerous other cases. Section 120(1) permits instructions on monetary limits only to regulate the discretion of officers and does not curtail the jurisdiction of the Tribunal - The objection on maintainability is rejected and the appeal is held maintainable - Computation of limitation for refund of exporter during the COVID exclusion period - Limitation under Section 54(1) read with Notification No. 13/2022-Central Tax and the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the suo motu proceedings on extension of limitation - Respondent exported goods by sea, and the relevant date was taken as the date of Let Export Order on the shipping bills, which fell within the excluded window from 01.03.2020 to 28.02.2022. The first refund application was filed on 22.02.2024. The appellate authority excluded only the days running from the relevant date to the end of the window and left a residual delay of twelve days for the second application - Whether the first refund application was filed within the period of limitation, and whether the computation of the appellate authority is sustainable - HELD - The limitation question is a pure question of law on admitted facts, and the Tribunal is bound to reckon limitation correctly irrespective of the manner of computation adopted by the parties or the authorities below. The direction of the Hon'ble Supreme Court granting ninety days from 01.03.2022 applies only where limitation would have expired within the exclusion window. Where the relevant date itself falls within the window and the two-year period had not started running, the entire period up to 28.02.2022 stands excluded, and the balance period becomes available from 01.03.2022. The day of the relevant date is excluded under Section 9 of the General Clauses Act, 1897. The full period of two years is therefore reckoned from 01.03.2022, and the last date for filing the refund application is 29.02.2024. The first application filed on 22.02.2024 is within time on the computation of the appellate authority, on the computation of the Hon'ble High Court of Andhra Pradesh, and on the computation adopted by the Tribunal – The first refund application is held to be filed within the extended period of limitation - Effect of deficiency memo and relation back of rectified refund application - Effect of a deficiency memo on limitation - Proviso to Rule 90(3) of the CGST Rules, 2017 and paragraph 12 of Circular No. 125/44/2019-GST - Respondent filed the first refund application, which was followed by a deficiency memo stating only that supporting documents were incomplete - The Appellant-Department contended that the second application was a fresh application with a residual delay, that only the period up to the deficiency memo could be excluded, and that the Circular was binding - Whether the second refund application relates back to the first application, and what effect the deficiency memo has on limitation - HELD - A bona fide rectification of deficiencies following a deficiency memo does not give rise to a fresh cause of action or a fresh limitation period, and relates back to the original application as its continuation. The decisions of the Hon'ble High Court of Delhi, which are binding on the Tribunal within its territorial jurisdiction, hold that an application not deficient in material particulars cannot be treated as non est and that limitation stops on its filing - The doctrine of relation back operates only where the original application was itself filed within the extended period of limitation, and that condition was satisfied. The deficiency memo did not identify any missing document, no finding was recorded that the first application was deficient in any material particular, and the Appellant did not point out any such particular even before the Tribunal. A taxpayer who responds promptly to a deficiency memo cannot be penalised for diligence. The residual delay arises only if the second application is treated as fresh, and as it is a continuation of the first, no question of delay arises - The issue is answered in favour of the Respondent-assessee - Whether the two-year period under Section 54(1) is mandatory or directory - Appellate authority relied on the decisions of the Hon'ble High Court of Madras holding that the period is directory and that delay can be condoned for reasons shown - Appellant-Department contended that those decisions were not accepted and were under challenge in pending writ appeals - Whether the two-year period under Section 54(1) is mandatory or merely directory - HELD - Limitation periods under special fiscal statutes are to be strictly construed and are not ordinarily susceptible to relaxation on equitable grounds, however marginal the delay. The Hon'ble Supreme Court has held that a claim for refund must be made within the four corners of the statute, that where a special statute prescribes its own limitation without a power to condone delay, neither the authorities nor the High Court can extend it, and that a refund under GST law is a statutory concession to be claimed strictly in accordance with the prescribed conditions - No provision of the Act confers on the proper officer or the appellate authority a power to condone delay in filing a refund application, and the Hon'ble High Court of Delhi has also expressed reservation about treating the period as directory. The Tribunal declined to adopt the view of the Hon'ble High Court of Madras - The error of the appellate authority does not affect the outcome, as the refund claim was filed within time and no delay required condonation - The period is held to be mandatory and not directory, the finding does not alter the result. The appeal of the Department is dismissed [Read less]

2026-VIL-1255-PAT  | High Court VAT

Bihar Settlement of Taxation Disputes Act, 2024 - Admitted tax under Sections 2(b) and 3 of the Bihar Settlement of Taxation Disputes Act, 2024 - Petitioner disclosed output tax in its returns, claimed set-off of Entry Tax and paid the balance by cheque. The assessing authority disallowed a part of the set-off claimed on batteries supplied as free replacement, and raised an additional demand - The prescribed authority treated the amount arising from the disallowance as admitted tax, demanded it in Form-IV and rejected the applications for failure to deposit it - Whether the amount arising from the disallowance of set-off c... [Read more]

Bihar Settlement of Taxation Disputes Act, 2024 - Admitted tax under Sections 2(b) and 3 of the Bihar Settlement of Taxation Disputes Act, 2024 - Petitioner disclosed output tax in its returns, claimed set-off of Entry Tax and paid the balance by cheque. The assessing authority disallowed a part of the set-off claimed on batteries supplied as free replacement, and raised an additional demand - The prescribed authority treated the amount arising from the disallowance as admitted tax, demanded it in Form-IV and rejected the applications for failure to deposit it - Whether the amount arising from the disallowance of set-off can be treated as admitted tax - HELD - Section 2(b) defines admitted tax as the amount of tax admitted as being payable in the returns filed by the party. Sections 2(d) and 2(f) separately cover tax payable pursuant to an order of assessment as arrear in dispute and disputed amount. The Legislature has thus maintained a distinction between the tax admitted in the return and the amount determined pursuant to an assessment order. The additional demand was not separately admitted in the return. It arose upon the determination in the assessment order, which was pursued in appeal, and it falls under the disputed amount - The Scheme is not one where the entire liability reflected in the assessment order is required to be deposited. Under Explanation 1 to Section 3(1), the settlement amount does not include arrears of admitted tax, which the party shall deposit separately. Under Rule 4 of the Settlement Rules, Form-IV deals only with the disputed amount or the settlement amount and is not the source of liability towards admitted tax - On a strict interpretation of the Explanation, the Petitioner is required to pay the short payment against admitted tax that arose when the assessing authority reduced the adjustment claimed for Entry Tax paid. The correctness of the disallowance of set-off is not examined - The Petitioner shall make payment of the arrears of admitted tax, and the Respondent shall then pass a fresh order of settlement – The writ applications are disposed [Read less]

2026-VIL-323-GSTAT-HYD  | Tribunal SGST

GST - Revocation of cancellation of registration - Proviso to Rule 23(1) of the CGST Rules, 2017 - Payment of interest, late fee and penalty on returns filed for revocation – Respondent defaulted in furnishing returns for a continuous period of six months, and its registration was cancelled after an SCN - FAA revoked the cancellation, having noted that all returns were filed immediately after the SCN, and directed the proper officer to verify filing of returns and payment of tax - Appellant-Department contended that the FAA ignored the proviso to Rule 23(1) and did not ensure payment of interest, late fee and penalty - ... [Read more]

GST - Revocation of cancellation of registration - Proviso to Rule 23(1) of the CGST Rules, 2017 - Payment of interest, late fee and penalty on returns filed for revocation – Respondent defaulted in furnishing returns for a continuous period of six months, and its registration was cancelled after an SCN - FAA revoked the cancellation, having noted that all returns were filed immediately after the SCN, and directed the proper officer to verify filing of returns and payment of tax - Appellant-Department contended that the FAA ignored the proviso to Rule 23(1) and did not ensure payment of interest, late fee and penalty - Whether the FAA was within its powers to allow the appeal without ensuring that interest, late fee and penalty were paid along with the tax for the relevant period - HELD - The liability arising from the returns extends to interest, late fee and penalty, which are substantive obligations integral to the correct adjudication of the dispute. The FAA approached the matter solely on verification of tax payment and filing of returns without any consideration of the proviso to Rule 23(1), which requires such amounts to be paid before revocation, and thereby committed a jurisdictional and substantive error - The intent of the FAA, though Rule 23 was not directly referred to, appears to be that the amounts indicated in that Rule were to be collected. As the Respondent had paid only the tax and filed the returns, the Appellant was at liberty to collect interest and late fee under Sections 50 and 47 of the Act. Since the amounts are admitted, the statutory machinery of Section 79 is available for their recovery. The Respondent is further liable for penalty under Rule 23, and a penalty is accordingly imposed - The order of the FAA is modified to this extent, the appeal of the Department is allowed [Read less]

2026-VIL-321-GSTAT-LCK  | Tribunal SGST

GST - Reversal of Input Tax Credit under Section 17(2) read with Rules 42 and 43 of the CGST Rules, 2017 - Respondent, trading in taxable goods and tax-exempt food products, had exempt outward supplies declared in the annual return, on the basis of which the proper officer presumed common inputs and confirmed a demand for proportionate reversal - FAA dropped the demand entirely on the strength of separate books, purchase ledgers and stock registers - Revenue contended that no verified demarcation criteria existed and that manual books could not bypass the formula - Whether the order of the FAA dropping the demand under Sec... [Read more]

GST - Reversal of Input Tax Credit under Section 17(2) read with Rules 42 and 43 of the CGST Rules, 2017 - Respondent, trading in taxable goods and tax-exempt food products, had exempt outward supplies declared in the annual return, on the basis of which the proper officer presumed common inputs and confirmed a demand for proportionate reversal - FAA dropped the demand entirely on the strength of separate books, purchase ledgers and stock registers - Revenue contended that no verified demarcation criteria existed and that manual books could not bypass the formula - Whether the order of the FAA dropping the demand under Section 17(2) read with Rule 42 is sustainable - HELD - Section 17(2) restricts credit to the portion attributable to taxable supplies where inputs are used partly for taxable and partly for exempt supplies, and Rule 42 prescribes a formula based on the ratio of exempt turnover to total turnover - The FAA dropped a substantial demand without recording the actual values of exempt sales, taxable sales and common credit for the disputed period. The claim that no common credit was mixed was accepted at face value without any verified physical audit or examination of the separate stock registers. In a wholesale-cum-retail trading firm operating from a single principal place of business, shared overheads and common inputs ordinarily exist, and the FAA failed to verify whether credit on such shared channels was properly segregated - The order, resting on general assertions without clear numbers and calculations, is non-speaking and unquantified to the extent it drops the demand under Rule 42 - The portion of the order-in-appeal dropping the demand under Section 17(2) read with Rule 42 is set aside and the matter is remanded to the FAA for de novo adjudication – Ordered accordingly - Mismatch between ITC claimed in GSTR-3B and ITC reflected in GSTR-2A - Relief granted by the FAA under Circular No. 183/15/2022-GST - Respondent explained that a portion of the mismatch arose because the supplier had wrongly mapped valid transactions to a different GSTIN in its returns, and produced tax invoices, banking records and a supplier certificate - Whether the FAA was correct in extending the benefit of the Circular on the mismatched ITC - HELD - The Respondent fulfilled all the verification requirements under the Circular by producing valid tax invoices, banking records proving actual payment of consideration and a certificate from the supplier confirming that the tax was fully paid to the Government but inadvertently mapped to an incorrect GSTIN. The core requirements of Section 16(2)(c) of the Act being satisfied, the FAA correctly extended the benefit of the Circular. The Revenue cannot validly challenge a relaxation mechanism officially mandated by its own Board - The findings of the FAA on the GSTR-3B versus GSTR-2A mismatch and the sustained liability are upheld and the Revenue appeal is rejected - Revenue objection to ITC already disallowed by the FAA - Objection of the Revenue to ITC pertaining to purchase invoices of a particular supplier not reflected in GSTR-2A - Revenue contended that the supplier's certificate did not reconcile with its declared filings, making the credit unverified - Whether the objection of the Revenue on this ITC component is sustainable - HELD - A review of the order-in-appeal reveals that this specific credit was already disallowed and decided against the Respondent due to non-production of a reconciled transaction validation certificate. The issue having been decided in favour of the Revenue, there is nothing left for the Revenue to challenge on this point - The objection of the Revenue is without merit and is rejected. [Read less]

2026-VIL-1892-CESTAT-DEL-CU  | CESTAT CUSTOMS

Customs - Undervaluation of imported goods - Evidentiary value of statements under Section 108 of the Customs Act, 1962 - On intelligence of evasion of Customs duty by undervaluation and fabrication of documents, investigation was conducted against the importer of hop products, its directors and its employees. Parallel invoices were recovered from the premises, the laptop and the hard disc. SCN proposed rejection of the declared value, re-determination of value, demand of differential duty, confiscation and penalties, which the adjudicating authority confirmed. The Appellants did not make final submissions despite repeated... [Read more]

Customs - Undervaluation of imported goods - Evidentiary value of statements under Section 108 of the Customs Act, 1962 - On intelligence of evasion of Customs duty by undervaluation and fabrication of documents, investigation was conducted against the importer of hop products, its directors and its employees. Parallel invoices were recovered from the premises, the laptop and the hard disc. SCN proposed rejection of the declared value, re-determination of value, demand of differential duty, confiscation and penalties, which the adjudicating authority confirmed. The Appellants did not make final submissions despite repeated adjournments, and the appeals were decided on merits. The Appellants had retracted their statements - Whether the hop products imported by the Appellants have been undervalued and whether the statements recorded under Section 108 can be relied upon - HELD - Section 108 empowers the gazetted officer of Customs to summon any person to give evidence or produce documents. Under sub-section (3) the persons summoned are bound to state the truth, and under sub-section (4) the inquiry is deemed a judicial proceeding. Customs officers are not police officers, so statements recorded by them are admissible as substantive evidence. A retraction must be contemporaneous and made at the first available opportunity. There was nothing on record to suggest that the statements were recorded under threat, and the statements were in the nature of admissions which need no further proof. Although the procedure under Section 138B was not followed, the statements were rightly relied upon in view of the distinguishing facts. The statements stand corroborated by documentary evidence. Invoices bearing the same number carried two different values, and the invoices filed before Customs carried altered and reduced values. The overseas enquiry revealed that the invoices submitted at import clearance were forged and that the exporters denied any knowledge of them. Procedural non-compliance is insufficient to falsify the corroborated documentary evidence - The Appellants have mis-declared the value of the imported goods, and the question is decided in favour of the Revenue - Rejection and re-determination of transaction value - Section 14 of the Customs Act, 1962 and Rules 3, 4, 5 and 12 of the Customs Valuation Rules, 2007 - The Department rejected the declared value of the imported hop products and re-determined it with reference to the value of similar goods imported at about the same time. The Appellants challenged the rejection and re-determination - Whether the declared value has rightly been rejected and re-determined - HELD - Under Section 14 read with Rule 3(1), the price actually paid or payable is ordinarily to be accepted as the transaction value, subject to Rule 12. The Assessing Officer can reject the declared value only by giving reasons supported by material. The Department obtained contemporaneous import invoices of the same and similar goods from other importers, and these showed values several times higher than the declared value. The foreign suppliers denied knowledge of the invoices filed in India. The declared value has therefore been rightly rejected, and Rules 3, 4 and 5 were sequentially followed in re-determining the value. The transaction value is not acceptable when goods of the same kind are imported at a higher price about the same time and the claim of a lower price is not substantiated by documentary evidence - The value has rightly been re-determined and the question is decided in favour of the Revenue - Differential duty, confiscation and penalty - Sections 28(4), 111(m), 112, 114A and 114AA of the Customs Act, 1962 - The adjudicating authority confirmed the differential duty with interest, held the goods liable to confiscation and imposed penalties on the importer, its directors and its employees - Whether the differential duty, confiscation and penalties are sustainable - HELD - In view of the finding that the value was mis-declared by use of forged invoices, the differential duty has rightly been confirmed under Section 28(4). The goods are rightly held liable to confiscation under Section 111(m). Penalty equal to the differential duty on the importer under Section 114A is upheld. The penalties on the other Appellants under Sections 112 and 114AA are also upheld - The order under challenge is upheld and the appeals are dismissed. [Read less]

2026-VIL-1893-CESTAT-BLR-CU  | CESTAT CUSTOMS

Customs - Refund of Special Additional Duty - Time limit under Notification No. 102/2007-Cus. as amended by Notification No. 93/2008-Cus. - The Respondent imported almonds in shells and paid additional duty of customs of 4%. It filed a refund claim under the Notification more than one year after the date of payment of duty. The original authority rejected the claim as barred by limitation, but the FAA allowed the Respondent's appeal. The Appellant (Revenue) contended that the amending Notification prescribed a time limit of one year from the date of payment, so the claim was time barred. The Respondent contended that the c... [Read more]

Customs - Refund of Special Additional Duty - Time limit under Notification No. 102/2007-Cus. as amended by Notification No. 93/2008-Cus. - The Respondent imported almonds in shells and paid additional duty of customs of 4%. It filed a refund claim under the Notification more than one year after the date of payment of duty. The original authority rejected the claim as barred by limitation, but the FAA allowed the Respondent's appeal. The Appellant (Revenue) contended that the amending Notification prescribed a time limit of one year from the date of payment, so the claim was time barred. The Respondent contended that the claim was filed within the time limit counted from the last domestic sale and that all other conditions were met - Whether the refund claim of Special Additional Duty filed beyond one year from the date of payment of duty is barred by limitation under the amended Notification - HELD - With effect from 01.08.2008, the amending Notification substituted clause (c) of paragraph 2 of the original Notification and required the importer to file the refund claim before the expiry of one year from the date of payment of the additional duty. The decisions relied upon by the FAA and the Respondent concerned imports prior to 01.08.2008 and dealt only with the retrospective application of the amended Notification. They have no application to imports made after the time limit was introduced. In the present case, the Bills of Entry were filed and the duty was paid after the introduction of the one year time limit, and the refund claim was submitted well beyond one year from the date of payment. A notification has to be read as a whole, and if any condition laid down in it is not fulfilled, the party is not entitled to its benefit. The conditions of an exemption notification are to be strictly construed, and the importer cannot pick and choose the conditions that suit it - The original authority rightly rejected the refund claim as time barred, the order of the FAA is set aside and the appeal of the Revenue is allowed [Read less]

2026-VIL-1246-ORI-ST  | High Court SERVICE TAX

Service Tax - Continuation of Proceedings after Death of Service Provider - Section 73 and Section 65(7) of Finance Act, 1994 - The Respondent passed an Order-in-Original raising a demand of service tax under Sections 73, 75, 77 and 78 for Financial Year 2015-16, and later issued a notice for payment in the name of the service provider, who had died, warning of recovery action under Section 87 - The Petitioner, the wife of the deceased service provider, intimated the death with the death certificate and filed a writ petition for quashing the Order-in-Original - The Petitioner contended that the order is a nullity as it can... [Read more]

Service Tax - Continuation of Proceedings after Death of Service Provider - Section 73 and Section 65(7) of Finance Act, 1994 - The Respondent passed an Order-in-Original raising a demand of service tax under Sections 73, 75, 77 and 78 for Financial Year 2015-16, and later issued a notice for payment in the name of the service provider, who had died, warning of recovery action under Section 87 - The Petitioner, the wife of the deceased service provider, intimated the death with the death certificate and filed a writ petition for quashing the Order-in-Original - The Petitioner contended that the order is a nullity as it cannot subsist against a dead person, and that the Finance Act, 1994 has no provision to proceed against legal representatives, unlike the provision in the income tax law - Whether proceedings under Section 73 can continue, and an Order-in-Original can be passed in the name of the service provider, after his death - HELD - A taxing statute must be read strictly, and what is not explicit cannot be construed as implicit. Section 65(7) defines assessee as a person liable to pay the service tax and includes his agent. The terms person and agent are not defined in Chapter V, so they take their ordinary meaning. An agent is a person employed to do any act for another or to represent another in dealings with a third person, and it is not the Respondent's case that the deceased engaged his legal heirs as agents in his business. A legal heir therefore cannot be equated with an agent - The definition of ‘person’ in the General Clauses Act, 1897 does not include legal representatives of a deceased person. Under Section 65(121), the definitions in the Central Excise Act, 1944 apply to service tax, so the exposition on continuing assessment against a dead person applies to the present facts. Sections 69 and 73 also refer only to the person liable to pay service tax and the person chargeable with the service tax - The Petitioner's argument that no provision in Chapter V allows proceedings under Section 73 to continue against a legal heir remained uncontroverted. The service provider died of natural causes, and it was not a case where death was manoeuvred to evade tax. On the death of the service provider, in the absence of a statutory provision empowering the authority to continue, the proceeding under Section 73 abates - Respondent could not discard the death certificate, and an Order-in-Original issued in the name of a dead person is a nullity. Recovery under Section 87 therefore cannot be taken - The Order-in-Original is set aside, the direction in the letter to discharge the liability is quashed. The writ petition is allowed [Read less]

2026-VIL-1901-CESTAT-BLR-ST  | CESTAT SERVICE TAX

Service Tax - Rebate of Cenvat credit on exported services - Rule 5 of Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004 read with Notification No. 11/2005-ST - The Appellant, rendering Business Auxiliary Service, Business Support Service and Information Technology Services, filed a rebate claim for a quarter in 2012. The original authority sanctioned part of the claim and rejected the rest, on the ground that the Appellant was not eligible for credit on some of the input services. The Commissioner (Appeals) upheld the rejection on the ground that the conditions of the Notification were not complied with - Whether the rebate claim can be rejected... [Read more]

Service Tax - Rebate of Cenvat credit on exported services - Rule 5 of Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004 read with Notification No. 11/2005-ST - The Appellant, rendering Business Auxiliary Service, Business Support Service and Information Technology Services, filed a rebate claim for a quarter in 2012. The original authority sanctioned part of the claim and rejected the rest, on the ground that the Appellant was not eligible for credit on some of the input services. The Commissioner (Appeals) upheld the rejection on the ground that the conditions of the Notification were not complied with - Whether the rebate claim can be rejected on the ground of nexus of input services with output services - HELD - The original authority had recorded that the services qualified as export services, the consideration was received in convertible foreign exchange and Service Tax was paid on the exported services. It is settled law that as long as the services have been exported and the conditions of the Notification are satisfied, the rebate claim cannot be rejected on the question of nexus of input services with output services - The rebate claim on this ground is allowed - Rebate claim - Verification of documents - The original authority considered only part of the claim since category-wise details were not mentioned, and rejected the remaining part for non-production of documents. Credit on certain input invoices was also disallowed as it could not be ascertained whether tax in respect of such invoices had been discharged - Whether the amounts rejected for non-production of documents and non-ascertainment of tax payment can be sustained - HELD - The Appellant is to be given an opportunity to produce the documents before the original authority. Whether tax on the input invoices was discharged also needs to be verified - The matter is remanded to the original authority for verification and the appeal is allowed by way of remand. [Read less]

2026-VIL-1887-CESTAT-DEL-CE  | CESTAT CENTRAL EXCISE

Central Excise - Liability of a trader alleged to have goods manufactured through job workers - Rule 25 of the Central Excise Rules, 2002 - Search at the premises of the Appellant, a proprietary trading concern, revealed excess stock of electrical goods and cash. The registration which the Appellant had applied for was revoked, as verification found no power connection, plant and machinery. SCN alleged that the goods were manufactured by job workers on the Appellant's account and cleared without payment of duty. It demanded duty and proposed confiscation of the goods and cash with penalties, which the authorities below con... [Read more]

Central Excise - Liability of a trader alleged to have goods manufactured through job workers - Rule 25 of the Central Excise Rules, 2002 - Search at the premises of the Appellant, a proprietary trading concern, revealed excess stock of electrical goods and cash. The registration which the Appellant had applied for was revoked, as verification found no power connection, plant and machinery. SCN alleged that the goods were manufactured by job workers on the Appellant's account and cleared without payment of duty. It demanded duty and proposed confiscation of the goods and cash with penalties, which the authorities below confirmed. The Appellant contended that it was only a trader. The Department relied on a statement that goods were got manufactured from job workers on the Appellant's account - Whether the Appellant is a manufacturer liable to duty and whether the goods are liable to confiscation - HELD - The premises had no electricity connection, plant and machinery or other infrastructure for manufacture, so the Appellant cannot be held to be a manufacturer. No investigation was conducted with the job workers, and no job worker came forward to state that goods were manufactured on behalf of the Appellant. If goods are manufactured by a job worker, the job worker is the manufacturer and is liable to pay duty. The Appellant being only a trader, the goods cannot be seized on the premise that they were meant for clandestine removal - The seizure, confiscation, redemption fine and duty are set aside, and no penalty is imposable on the Appellant or its representatives - Confiscation of excess goods and cash found with manufacturer - Rule 25 of the Central Excise Rules, 2002 - Excess electrical goods not entered in the RG-1 register were found at the premises of the Appellant, a registered manufacturer. Cash was found at the factory and at the residences of its directors. The authorities below confiscated the goods and cash and allowed redemption of the goods on payment of fine. The Appellant contended that the goods were work in progress, as they had to be tested, repacked and affixed with MRP stickers, and were later cleared on payment of duty. It explained the cash as the cash book balance, the personal property of family members and an advance received for sale of property - Whether the excess goods and cash are liable to confiscation - HELD - No investigation was conducted to establish that the excess goods were finished goods meant for clandestine removal. It does not appear that the goods had test reports and MRP stickers affixed, so the contention that they had not reached the stage of finished goods is acceptable. The advance was entered in the cash ledger before the search and supported by an agreement, and the other amounts were explained. The cash cannot be said to be sale proceeds of clandestine clearance in the absence of evidence by the Revenue - The goods are not liable for confiscation, the redemption fine and penalty are set aside, and the cash is to be refunded - Duty on packing, repacking and affixing MRP stickers by unregistered unit - Section 2(f)(iii) of the Central Excise Act, 1944 - The Appellant, an unregistered company, was engaged in packing, repacking and affixing MRP stickers on goods. SCN demanded duty on the clearances, treating the activity as manufacture, and proposed confiscation of the goods and penalty. The Appellant contended that the goods already suffered duty at the hands of the supplier - Whether duty, confiscation and penalty are sustainable on the Appellant - HELD - The goods were MRP based, and the supplier had already paid duty on them after taking the abatement. The assessable value did not change after the MRP stickers were affixed. The Appellant being unregistered could not take CENVAT credit, and the duty payable by it would be equal to the credit available. It is a revenue neutral situation, and the non-availment of CENVAT credit amounts to payment of duty - The demand of duty, confiscation, redemption fine and penalty are set aside - Penalty on proprietor and directors - Rule 26 of the Central Excise Rules, 2002 - Penalties were imposed on the proprietor and the directors of the concerns - Whether penalty can be imposed on the proprietor and directors - HELD - The case made out by the Revenue against the concerns is not sustainable, so no penalty can be imposed on the proprietor and the directors - The penalties are set aside and the appeals are allowed. [Read less]

2026-VIL-326-GSTAT-RJK  | Tribunal SGST

GST - Classification of chuna in slurry and paste form - Whether goods obtained by mixing slaked lime with water, calcium carbonate and glycerin are excluded from heading 2522 by Note 1 to Chapter 25 - Respondent purchased slaked lime and made chuna by physical mixing with water and fillers, and classified it under tariff item 2522 20 00 at the lower rate - Appellant-Revenue issued an SCN under Section 74 proposing classification under tariff item 2106 90 99 as a food preparation at the higher rate, relying on Note 1 to Chapter 25 which excludes products obtained by mixing. The adjudicating authority confirmed the demand, ... [Read more]

GST - Classification of chuna in slurry and paste form - Whether goods obtained by mixing slaked lime with water, calcium carbonate and glycerin are excluded from heading 2522 by Note 1 to Chapter 25 - Respondent purchased slaked lime and made chuna by physical mixing with water and fillers, and classified it under tariff item 2522 20 00 at the lower rate - Appellant-Revenue issued an SCN under Section 74 proposing classification under tariff item 2106 90 99 as a food preparation at the higher rate, relying on Note 1 to Chapter 25 which excludes products obtained by mixing. The adjudicating authority confirmed the demand, but the Commissioner (Appeals) set it aside - Whether the goods are excluded from heading 2522 by Note 1 to Chapter 25 - HELD - Every limb of the exclusion in Note 1 is subject to its opening words, namely that the headings cover such products except where their context otherwise requires. The Hon'ble Supreme Court held in the case of calcined china clay that the exclusion of calcination does not apply where the context otherwise requires. The context need not arise only from express words of process in the heading, as the Revenue itself accepts that quicklime and slaked lime, products of calcination and hydration, fall in heading 2522 which contains no such words, and the Explanatory Note recognises that certain headings refer to goods which by their nature are subjected to a process not provided for by Note 1. Slaked lime itself is produced by bringing quicklime and water together, so mixing of lime and water cannot by itself attract the exclusion. The test is whether the goods as obtained remain the slaked lime named in the heading - On admitted facts the process is simple physical blending without any chemical reaction, the additions are fillers, a diluent and a soothing agent, no new article emerges, and the essential character is that of slaked lime. Non-conformity with grades of hydrated lime only shows that the goods are not purified calcium hydroxide of heading 2825. The anti-dusting proviso is merely permissive and does not cut down the opening words - The goods are not excluded from heading 2522 by Note 1 and are classifiable under tariff item 2522 20 00 – The appeals filed by the Revenue are dismissed - Classification of chuna - Whether chuna is a food preparation of heading 2106 - Appellant-Revenue relied on the food additive licence held by the Respondent, Supplementary Note 5 to Chapter 21, the Explanatory Note to heading 21.06 and Note 1(b) to Chapter 38, contending that chuna is a preparation made by combining ingredients to a fixed recipe - Whether the goods are covered by heading 2106 - HELD - Heading 2106 applies only to food preparations not elsewhere specified or included and yields to any heading that covers the goods, since goods with a reasonable claim to a specific heading cannot be consigned to a residuary entry, as held by the Hon'ble Supreme Court - Chuna is not consumed directly or after processing such as cooking or dissolving, and is applied in small quantities to betel leaf or mixed with areca nut and tobacco as an ingredient. None of its constituents is a foodstuff, and the Revenue itself treated calcium carbonate and glycerin as chemicals of other Chapters, while its contention that they are dietary ingredients was unsupported by technical evidence. Pan masala and supari have their own tariff items, and lime is named in the Supplementary Notes only as an ingredient, which does not make lime itself a preparation of heading 2106 - The headings, Supplementary Notes and Explanatory Notes describe articles which are themselves food, and chuna bears no resemblance to that class. A licence under a regulatory statute does not determine classification, and under that statute a food additive is a substance not normally consumed as food by itself and cannot be equated with food - Note 1(b) to Chapter 38 is merely an exclusionary Note and its premise of a mixture of chemicals with foodstuffs is not established. That the goods are prepared by a process does not make them food preparations - The goods are not covered under heading 2106 or tariff item 2106 90 99 - The appeals filed by the Revenue are dismissed - Application of General Rules of Interpretation and test reports - Application of Rules 2(b), 3 and 4 of the General Rules of Interpretation and relevance of test reports - Whether the goods are correctly classifiable under tariff item 2522 20 00 on application of the General Rules - HELD - The premise that Note 1 removes heading 2522 fails in view of the earlier finding. Rule 2(b) extends a heading to mixtures of the named material, so the goods are prima facie classifiable by reference to slaked lime, while heading 2106 does not refer to any material of which the goods consist - Under Rule 3(a), heading 2522 which names slaked lime is more specific than the residuary heading 2106. Under Rule 3(b), mixtures are classified by the component giving essential character, which is slaked lime, and the route adopted in the SCN therefore leads to heading 2522. Rules 3(c) and 4 are rules of last resort and would also lead to heading 2522, as it occurs last in numerical order and the goods are most akin to lime - The conclusion rests on the statutory text read with the Explanatory Notes and not on commercial parlance - The goods are classifiable under tariff item 2522 20 00 attracting the lower rate, the demand of differential tax, interest and penalty does not survive - The appeals of the Revenue are dismissed and the impugned order is upheld. [Read less]

2026-VIL-325-GSTAT-AGR  | Tribunal SGST

GST - Departmental appeal against order of the FAA reducing demand - Scrutiny of returns, Input Tax Credit under Section 17(5), capital goods and cancelled e-way bills - Respondent did not respond to the notice for discrepancies in scrutiny of returns or to the SCN under Section 73, and an ex-parte order imposed tax and penalty. The FAA partially allowed the appeal and substantially reduced the demand - The Appellant-Department contended that the FAA reduced the demand without appreciating the facts, that the discrepancies between returns, the blocked credits, the credit on capital goods and the treatment of expenses were ... [Read more]

GST - Departmental appeal against order of the FAA reducing demand - Scrutiny of returns, Input Tax Credit under Section 17(5), capital goods and cancelled e-way bills - Respondent did not respond to the notice for discrepancies in scrutiny of returns or to the SCN under Section 73, and an ex-parte order imposed tax and penalty. The FAA partially allowed the appeal and substantially reduced the demand - The Appellant-Department contended that the FAA reduced the demand without appreciating the facts, that the discrepancies between returns, the blocked credits, the credit on capital goods and the treatment of expenses were not satisfactorily explained, and that cancelled e-way bills were rightly treated as suppressed supplies - Whether the order of the FAA was passed after due scrutiny of all the relevant facts or suffers from any infirmity of law and facts requiring interference - HELD - The FAA analysed each point raised in the SCN through the books of account and documents and passed a reasoned order. Expenses on job work were verified through tax invoices reflected in the supplier-based return, with credit claimed in the return and not questioned. Repair expenses of machinery were verifiable, and for other repairs no credit was claimed. Insurance of stock is not prohibited by Section 17(5), which bars credit only for general insurance, servicing, repair and maintenance of motor vehicles, vessels or aircraft, and the credit was rightly allowed except for a small expenditure not related to furtherance of business, which was rightly disallowed - On capital goods the FAA examined the matter in detail and disallowed only the credit relating to office chairs, wire and a mobile phone as not related to furtherance of business, while other credit was allowable. The cancelled e-way bills were found to be due to typographical and clerical errors, copies were produced, and new e-way bills were issued against the same invoices immediately or within a short period less than the time required for transportation, so no likelihood of misuse was found. The Department failed to point out any factual or legal infirmity in the order - The order of the FAA is upheld and the departmental appeal is dismissed [Read less]

2026-VIL-322-GSTAT-AGR  | Tribunal SGST

GST - Denial of input tax credit on inward supply from a supplier found non-existent - Burden of proof under Section 155 of the CGST Act, 2017 and conditions under Section 16(2) - Appellant relied on tax invoices, e-way bills, lorry receipts, goods receipt note, photographs, ledger and bank statements, and contended that the authorities acted on borrowed satisfaction from the investigation letter - Whether the Appellant availed Input Tax Credit without actual inward supply of goods covered by the invoices - HELD - Section 155 places the burden of proving eligibility of Input Tax Credit on the person claiming it, and this b... [Read more]

GST - Denial of input tax credit on inward supply from a supplier found non-existent - Burden of proof under Section 155 of the CGST Act, 2017 and conditions under Section 16(2) - Appellant relied on tax invoices, e-way bills, lorry receipts, goods receipt note, photographs, ledger and bank statements, and contended that the authorities acted on borrowed satisfaction from the investigation letter - Whether the Appellant availed Input Tax Credit without actual inward supply of goods covered by the invoices - HELD - Section 155 places the burden of proving eligibility of Input Tax Credit on the person claiming it, and this burden rests strictly on the Appellant once physical verification establishes that the supplier is fake and non-existent. The e-way bills are not conclusive proof of actual movement of goods. The photographs without spatial co-ordinates or verifiable audit trails cannot override the physical inspection findings. The goods receipt note may be fabricated after receipt of notice. Paper trails of invoices, banking entries and lorry receipts can easily create an impression of authenticity and do not automatically establish physical receipt of goods, particularly as the inspection was made only three months after the transactions - The Appellant produced no independent verifiable evidence of the source of the goods, no consignment note, weighment slip or GSTR-2A, and no evidence that the supplier had deposited the tax with the Government as required under Section 16(2)(c) - The decisions of the Hon'ble Supreme Court and the Hon'ble High Court of Allahabad on the documents required to prove genuineness of purchases and on the need for deposit of tax by the supplier apply - The impugned orders are upheld and the appeal is dismissed [Read less]

2026-VIL-1896-CESTAT-AHM-CU  | CESTAT CUSTOMS

Customs - Penalty on alleged masterminds - Section 112(a) of Customs Act, 1962 - Betel nuts were found concealed behind HMS scrap in four containers imported in the name of the importer firm and were confiscated. The Appellants were alleged to be masterminds and financiers of the importer firm, and penalty was imposed on each under Section 112(a) as abettors. The case rested on statements of co-noticees recorded in a separate investigation and on the Appellants' own statements, which were retracted before the Magistrate. Cross-examination was not allowed - Whether penalty under Section 112(a) is imposable on the Appellants... [Read more]

Customs - Penalty on alleged masterminds - Section 112(a) of Customs Act, 1962 - Betel nuts were found concealed behind HMS scrap in four containers imported in the name of the importer firm and were confiscated. The Appellants were alleged to be masterminds and financiers of the importer firm, and penalty was imposed on each under Section 112(a) as abettors. The case rested on statements of co-noticees recorded in a separate investigation and on the Appellants' own statements, which were retracted before the Magistrate. Cross-examination was not allowed - Whether penalty under Section 112(a) is imposable on the Appellants on the basis of such evidence - HELD - The Department relied upon statements and documents relating to a separate investigation against another firm, without a proper connect being established. The proprietor of the importer firm, the most crucial witness, was not interrogated as he is alleged to be absconding, so the investigation remains incomplete and half baked. The co-accused were not subjected to cross-examination, which is a right of the party as per Section 138B. The Appellants have made no culpatory statement till date, as the earlier statements were retracted. The forged certificate attributed to the Appellant was not established by any forensic, handwriting or computer expert evidence. It was seized from the computer of the Customs Broker, and as per Section 138C it is presumed to be in the Customs Broker's possession. There was also no logical basis for imposing a higher penalty on the Appellants than on the importer on record. The case of the Department is far from proved, and the mens rea or the connect required to establish conspiracy is not established - The penalties under Section 112(a) are set aside and the appeals are allowed - Financing of imports - Section 2(26) of Customs Act, 1962 - The Appellants were alleged to have financed the importer firm and to be its owners and beneficiaries. The Appellants denied funding it and stated that the payment was made by a third-party firm - Whether the Appellants can be treated as importer under Section 2(26) and penalised for financing the import - HELD - At the time of import, the definition of importer under Section 2(26) did not include the expression beneficial owner. The importer could only be the owner as per documents or a person who holds himself out to be the importer. The proprietor of the importer firm held himself out as the importer, which is not disputed. The Appellants never held themselves out as the owner of the consignment, so ownership cannot be imposed upon them. The allegation of financial benefit was denied, as the payment was made by the third-party firm. Financing directly or indirectly someone cannot be an offence - The Appellants cannot be treated as importer or owner of the goods, the penalties are not sustainable and the appeals are allowed. [Read less]

2026-VIL-330-GSTAT-LCK  | Tribunal SGST

GST - Interest under Section 50(3) of the CGST Act, 2017 read with Rule 88B(3) on wrongly availed Input Tax Credit - Appellant availed Input Tax Credit in excess of the credit reflected in the supplier-based return and voluntarily reversed it through Form GST DRC-03 before the SCN was issued. The tax demand on the difference in liability was set aside entirely by the FAA, but interest on the reversed credit and a residual penalty were sustained - Whether interest is leviable under Section 50(3) when the Appellant had sufficient unutilised balance in the Electronic Credit Ledger throughout the relevant period and the disput... [Read more]

GST - Interest under Section 50(3) of the CGST Act, 2017 read with Rule 88B(3) on wrongly availed Input Tax Credit - Appellant availed Input Tax Credit in excess of the credit reflected in the supplier-based return and voluntarily reversed it through Form GST DRC-03 before the SCN was issued. The tax demand on the difference in liability was set aside entirely by the FAA, but interest on the reversed credit and a residual penalty were sustained - Whether interest is leviable under Section 50(3) when the Appellant had sufficient unutilised balance in the Electronic Credit Ledger throughout the relevant period and the disputed credit was reversed without being utilised - HELD - Section 50(3), as amended retrospectively from 01.07.2017, provides for interest where input tax credit is wrongly availed and utilised. The utilisation is an additional condition which must be satisfied before interest liability can arise - Under the Explanation to Rule 88B(3), credit is deemed to be utilised when the balance in the Electronic Credit Ledger falls below the amount of wrongly availed credit. As clarified by the Circular dated 17.07.2023, the balance under the integrated, central and state tax heads is considered collectively, and where the aggregate balance has not fallen below the wrongly availed credit, it cannot be treated as utilised. The report of the jurisdictional authority, acknowledged by the Respondent, showed that the credit balance always remained higher than the reversed amount, and no contrary material was placed on record - The disputed credit cannot be treated as utilised within the meaning of Section 50(3), the essential condition for levy of interest is not fulfilled, and the interest sustained by the FAA is set aside – The appeal is allowed - Sustainability of residual penalty after the tax demand is set aside - Penalty under Section 73 of the CGST Act, 2017 - Survival of a residual penalty sustained by the FAA when the entire substantive tax demand has been set aside - Appellant contended that no independent basis remained for the residual penalty once the tax demand was set aside and the interest was not leviable. The Respondent did not demonstrate any independent basis, and no cross appeal against the order of the FAA was filed - Whether the penalty sustained by the FAA under Section 73 can survive when the substantive tax demand has been set aside - HELD - A penalty under Section 73 cannot be sustained as a matter of course, and its imposition must have a valid statutory foundation supported by the facts of the case. The entire tax demand which formed the basis of the original proceedings no longer survives, no independent basis for the residual penalty was demonstrated by the Respondent, and the alleged utilisation of the disputed credit was also not established - The residual penalty is not sustainable, the appeal is allowed. [Read less]

2026-VIL-1890-CESTAT-DEL-ST  | CESTAT SERVICE TAX

Service Tax - Taxability of consulting engineer's service provided by body corporate - Section 65(31) and Section 65(105)(g) of the Finance Act, 1994 - The Appellant, a body corporate, provided consulting engineers services to a government authority during July 2003 to September 2005. It paid Service Tax on the gross amounts charged up to June 2003 and thereafter only on the remuneration for local professional staff and support staff. It did not pay Service Tax on the amounts received under other heads such as transportation, travel, office rent, supplies, utilities, document printing and contingencies. SCNs demanded the S... [Read more]

Service Tax - Taxability of consulting engineer's service provided by body corporate - Section 65(31) and Section 65(105)(g) of the Finance Act, 1994 - The Appellant, a body corporate, provided consulting engineers services to a government authority during July 2003 to September 2005. It paid Service Tax on the gross amounts charged up to June 2003 and thereafter only on the remuneration for local professional staff and support staff. It did not pay Service Tax on the amounts received under other heads such as transportation, travel, office rent, supplies, utilities, document printing and contingencies. SCNs demanded the Service Tax, which was confirmed by the adjudicating authority, and the FAA confirmed part of the demand in remand proceedings. The Appellant contended that bodies corporate were brought within the ambit of consulting engineers only by an amendment. The Respondent contended that the expression person included bodies corporate even before the amendment - Whether a body corporate was covered by the definition of consulting engineer before the amendment - HELD - Bodies corporate, being persons, were covered under the definition of consulting engineer even before the amendment. All contrary decisions on this question of law stand overruled - The contention of the Appellant is rejected - Valuation of taxable service - Reimbursable expenses - Section 67 of the Finance Act, 1994 and Rule 5 of the Service Tax (Determination of Value) Rules, 2006 - The dispute was only with respect to the amounts received as reimbursable expenses, and the demand related to the period before 2015. The Appellant contended that reimbursable expenses do not form part of the value of the taxable service. The Respondent supported the demand - Whether Service Tax is payable on reimbursable expenses for the period before the amendment of Section 67 - HELD - Rule 5 provided for inclusion of reimbursable expenses in the taxable value, but the Rule has been held to be ultra vires of Section 67. Section 67 was amended later to include reimbursable expenses in the taxable value. The present demand pertains to the period before the amendment and is therefore not sustainable - The impugned order is set aside and the appeal is allowed. [Read less]

2026-VIL-1900-CESTAT-KOL-CE  | CESTAT CENTRAL EXCISE

Central Excise - Whether fitting of lenses into spectacle frames amounts to manufacture - The Appellant was alleged to be manufacturing Spectacles falling under CET 9004, and a SCN was issued invoking the extended period for the period November 2012 to June 2017 demanding duty. The Appellant contended that fixing of lenses in frames would not amount to manufacture under Section 2(f) of the Central Excise Act, 1944, but the lower authorities confirmed the demand - Whether the fixing of lenses in the frames amounts to manufacture so as to attract duty under the Central Excise Act, 1944 - HELD - The issue whether fixing of le... [Read more]

Central Excise - Whether fitting of lenses into spectacle frames amounts to manufacture - The Appellant was alleged to be manufacturing Spectacles falling under CET 9004, and a SCN was issued invoking the extended period for the period November 2012 to June 2017 demanding duty. The Appellant contended that fixing of lenses in frames would not amount to manufacture under Section 2(f) of the Central Excise Act, 1944, but the lower authorities confirmed the demand - Whether the fixing of lenses in the frames amounts to manufacture so as to attract duty under the Central Excise Act, 1944 - HELD - The issue whether fixing of lenses in the frames amounts to manufacture is no more res integra. The Madras High Court, relying on the Supreme Court decision in Mehta Opticians, held that an optician who only fits lenses into a spectacle frame carries out no process of manufacture and no separate or distinct commodity emerges. Manufacture implies a change, but every change would not be manufacture, and there must be a transformation of raw materials into a new and distinct article having a distinctive name, character or use. Even though the process involves skill and sophistication, the end result is only assembly of the lens with the frame, and refining and fine-tuning that is part and parcel of assembly does not tantamount to manufacture. The Revenue could not produce any contrary decision despite being granted time - The decision of the Madras High Court is squarely applicable to the facts of the case, the impugned order is set aside, and the appeal is allowed [Read less]

2026-VIL-1263-TEL  | High Court VAT

Andhra Pradesh General Sales Tax Act, 1957 - Deferment of tax on scrap turnover - Final Eligibility Certificate under the Target 2000 Scheme - The Petitioner was granted sales tax deferment on turnover above the base turnover, which had been fixed by including turnover of paper, paperboards and scrap. The revised Final Eligibility Certificate confined deferment to paper and paperboards and excluded scrap. The assessments denied deferment on scrap sales - Petitioner contended that scrap forms part of the base turnover and is integrally connected with manufacture, so the Department adopted approbation and reprobation - Wheth... [Read more]

Andhra Pradesh General Sales Tax Act, 1957 - Deferment of tax on scrap turnover - Final Eligibility Certificate under the Target 2000 Scheme - The Petitioner was granted sales tax deferment on turnover above the base turnover, which had been fixed by including turnover of paper, paperboards and scrap. The revised Final Eligibility Certificate confined deferment to paper and paperboards and excluded scrap. The assessments denied deferment on scrap sales - Petitioner contended that scrap forms part of the base turnover and is integrally connected with manufacture, so the Department adopted approbation and reprobation - Whether the Petitioner was entitled to deferment of sales tax on scrap turnover when the base turnover included scrap but the deferment was confined to paper and paperboards - HELD - The base turnover and the eligible turnover for deferment perform distinct functions. The base turnover is only the threshold against which additional turnover is measured and does not determine the transactions on which deferment may be claimed. The certificate did not create an unqualified entitlement on every item of sale, as the incentive was conditional, quantified and period-bound - Where an incentive is granted upon stated conditions, the beneficiary must establish compliance with them, and the Court cannot expand the benefit by implication, equity or assumed intention. Deferment is a fiscal concession permitting postponement of payment subject to the terms of the scheme. Scrap may arise incidentally from the principal manufacturing activity and yet remain outside the incentive if the certificate does not include it. Inclusion of scrap in the base turnover was relevant only to the threshold, while its exclusion from deferment related to the scope of the concession. The two determinations are not contradictory, so there is no approbation and reprobation - The question of law is answered against the Petitioner and the Tax Revision Cases are dismissedrnrnIssue 2: Promissory estoppel against the State - The Petitioner contended that the Department is estopped from changing its stand after the Final Eligibility Certificate was issued with the approval of the Department. The Petitioner had not sought amendment of the certificate with the view that scrap would be allowed deferment - Whether promissory estoppel can compel the State to allow deferment on scrap turnover - HELD - Promissory estoppel cannot compel the State to grant a fiscal benefit beyond the terms of the policy or the eligibility certificate. The doctrine may prevent the State from acting inconsistently with a clear promise on which a party has acted to its detriment, but it cannot create a deferment that was never granted in clear and unambiguous terms. A taxing concession must rest upon authority of law and be traced to the applicable policy instrument. It cannot be inferred from an ambiguity, an administrative omission or the unilateral expectation of the assessee. The expectation of the Petitioner cannot alter the scope of the incentive, and the revised certificate made the position explicit by excluding scrap - The plea of promissory estoppel is rejected. [Read less]

2026-VIL-1248-MP  | High Court SGST

GST - Blocking of Electronic Credit Ledger under Rule 86A of the CGST Rules and bar on parallel proceedings under Section 6 of the MPGST Act, 2017 - Petitioner's Electronic Credit Ledger was blocked under Rule 86A for alleged availment of ITC without valid invoices or debit notes - Petitioner contended that the Central GST authorities had already conducted search, verification and concluded proceedings on the same subject matter and tax period after payment through Form GST DRC-03, that State proceedings were therefore barred by cross-empowerment under Section 6, and that no valid reasons to believe were recorded nor was a... [Read more]

GST - Blocking of Electronic Credit Ledger under Rule 86A of the CGST Rules and bar on parallel proceedings under Section 6 of the MPGST Act, 2017 - Petitioner's Electronic Credit Ledger was blocked under Rule 86A for alleged availment of ITC without valid invoices or debit notes - Petitioner contended that the Central GST authorities had already conducted search, verification and concluded proceedings on the same subject matter and tax period after payment through Form GST DRC-03, that State proceedings were therefore barred by cross-empowerment under Section 6, and that no valid reasons to believe were recorded nor was any opportunity of hearing afforded - Respondents contended that the earlier proceedings pertained to a distinct issue of clandestine removal, while the present proceedings arose from a separate investigation by the Anti-Evasion Bureau into bogus ITC passed on by certain suppliers - Whether the blocking of the Electronic Credit Ledger is sustainable in view of Section 6 and Rule 86A - HELD - Section 6 of the MPGST Act prohibits parallel proceedings only in respect of the same subject matter. The present proceedings relate to a separate transaction and a fresh cause of action, hence Section 6 is not attracted. Rule 86A empowers the proper officer to block the Electronic Credit Ledger where there are reasons to believe that the ITC has been fraudulently availed or is otherwise ineligible. The proper officer formed such belief on the basis of the investigation report received from the Joint Commissioner, State Tax, Anti-Evasion Bureau. No ground is made out for interference and the writ petition is dismissed [Read less]

2026-VIL-1252-GAU  | High Court SGST

GST - Non-issuance of Form GST ASMT-10 before proceeding under Section 73 of CGST Act, 2017 - Petitioner challenged the notice in Form GST DRC-01 and the consequential adjudication order determining tax, interest and penalty - The demand was arrived at by examining the annual return and comparing it with other returns, e-way bills and records available with the Department, but no notice in Form GST ASMT-10 was issued - Whether non-issuance of Form GST ASMT-10 before initiating proceedings under Section 73 vitiates the proceedings, where the demand is founded on discrepancies noticed upon scrutiny of returns - HELD - Sectio... [Read more]

GST - Non-issuance of Form GST ASMT-10 before proceeding under Section 73 of CGST Act, 2017 - Petitioner challenged the notice in Form GST DRC-01 and the consequential adjudication order determining tax, interest and penalty - The demand was arrived at by examining the annual return and comparing it with other returns, e-way bills and records available with the Department, but no notice in Form GST ASMT-10 was issued - Whether non-issuance of Form GST ASMT-10 before initiating proceedings under Section 73 vitiates the proceedings, where the demand is founded on discrepancies noticed upon scrutiny of returns - HELD - Section 61 of CGST Act, 2017 read with Rule 99 of the CGST Rules, 2017 contemplates an opportunity for the registered person to explain the discrepancies noticed during scrutiny of returns before further action is taken. Communicating the discrepancies in Form GST ASMT-10 is not an empty formality - Section 73 permits a proper officer to proceed on independently available information or material. However, where the demand is founded on discrepancies noticed during scrutiny of returns, the procedure under Section 61 read with Rule 99 must be followed, as the source and foundation of the proposed demand determine its applicability - The Form GST DRC-01 itself disclosed that the alleged under-declaration was arrived at upon examination of returns and related particulars and the Respondents did not show any independent investigation or material unconnected with it. The proceedings under Section 73 could not have been initiated without first following the procedure under Section 61 read with Rule 99 - The notice in Form GST DRC-01 and the consequential adjudication order are set aside. The Respondents are at liberty to proceed in accordance with law, if otherwise permissible, subject to limitation and other requirements of the Act – The writ petition is allowed [Read less]

2026-VIL-1258-RAJ  | High Court SGST

GST - Intent to evade tax - Section 74(1) of CGST Act, 2017 - The SCN rested on the allegation that the Petitioner failed to disclose and pay the tax found during audit, which amounts to suppression with intent to evade, under the guise of public functions - Whether the notice discloses the jurisdictional fact of intent to evade tax, which alone opens the door to Section 74 - HELD - Sections 73 and 74 are mutually exclusive, and Section 74 is the harsher provision with a longer period, a penalty equal to the tax and the possibility of prosecution. The conditions must therefore be strictly met, and the Revenue cannot treat ... [Read more]

GST - Intent to evade tax - Section 74(1) of CGST Act, 2017 - The SCN rested on the allegation that the Petitioner failed to disclose and pay the tax found during audit, which amounts to suppression with intent to evade, under the guise of public functions - Whether the notice discloses the jurisdictional fact of intent to evade tax, which alone opens the door to Section 74 - HELD - Sections 73 and 74 are mutually exclusive, and Section 74 is the harsher provision with a longer period, a penalty equal to the tax and the possibility of prosecution. The conditions must therefore be strictly met, and the Revenue cannot treat Section 74 as the default route. The words to evade tax govern each of fraud, wilful misstatement and suppression, since those are the means and evasion is the end, and both must exist together. Explanation 2 defines suppression but does not dispense with the requirement that it be to evade tax. Failure to pay is the starting point of both Sections 73 and 74, and if it by itself proved intent, Section 73 would have no field left. Intent is a state of mind found in those who direct the affairs of a body corporate - The Petitioner is a statutory authority run by public servants who would gain nothing from evading tax payable from public funds that would go into the public exchequer. The notice shows only a disagreement on law over whether the receipts are consideration for a supply. The receipts were found in the Petitioner's own books and records, the question admits of two plausible views, and the stand taken is arguable and openly taken. Raising a legal question in good faith is not a guise. Attributing intent to evade to officers of a State authority who gain nothing would also lead to prosecution under Section 132 of one officer by another, which the legislature could not have intended. A public authority is not barred from proceedings under Section 74 where the record shows deliberate falsification or a collateral purpose - The notice does not disclose the jurisdictional fact of intent to evade tax and the invocation of Section 74 is without jurisdiction. The SCN and all proceedings under it are quashed and the writ petition is allowed - GST - Misstatement and suppression alleged together - Section 74 and Explanation 2 of CGST Act, 2017 - Petitioner contended that the notice alleges both wilful misstatement and suppression, which cannot co-exist since misstatement is a positive act of giving wrong information and suppression is the withholding of information - Whether the notice is vitiated because it alleges both misstatement and suppression - HELD - The use of both expressions does not vitiate the notice, as the two often overlap and a misstatement may itself amount to suppression. Explanation 2 to Section 74 defines suppression as non-declaration of facts or information required to be declared in a return or document. A wrong declaration in a return is a misstatement and also amounts to non-declaration of the true facts, so both labels may fit the same conduct - GST - Writ petition against show cause notice - Petitioner is a statutory development authority against which an audit led to SCNs - Whether the Court should entertain a writ petition against a SCN when a statutory process of adjudication and appeal is available - HELD - A writ Court does not ordinarily interfere with a SCN, which is only the first step and records a tentative view. The rule is one of self restraint and not a bar on jurisdiction, as an alternative remedy is no bar where the proceedings are wholly without jurisdiction. Section 74 is a special power exercisable only on the existence of jurisdictional facts, namely fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression, coupled with intent to evade tax. If those facts cannot exist on the face of the notice, the officer assumes a jurisdiction the statute has not conferred, and the defect lies at the threshold. The prejudice is real, as a notice under Section 74 allows the Revenue to reach back for a longer period, carries a penalty equal to the tax and casts a charge of evasion. Such a challenge raises a pure question of law to be decided on the notice as it stands, without weighing evidence or deciding whether the three heads are taxable - The writ petition can be entertained. [Read less]

2026-VIL-1254-TEL  | High Court SGST

GST - Service of order through GST portal - Section 169(1)(d) of CGST Act, 2017 - Petitioner cancelled its registration and furnished an alternate address for official communications - The Order-in-Original and the consequential DRC-07 were passed in the year 2024 and uploaded on the GST portal, while the physical notice was sent to the old address - The Petitioner came to know of the order from the portal in September 2025 and filed the writ petition after considerable delay, contending that there was no proper service and a violation of natural justice - Whether the writ petition is entertainable against the order when t... [Read more]

GST - Service of order through GST portal - Section 169(1)(d) of CGST Act, 2017 - Petitioner cancelled its registration and furnished an alternate address for official communications - The Order-in-Original and the consequential DRC-07 were passed in the year 2024 and uploaded on the GST portal, while the physical notice was sent to the old address - The Petitioner came to know of the order from the portal in September 2025 and filed the writ petition after considerable delay, contending that there was no proper service and a violation of natural justice - Whether the writ petition is entertainable against the order when the order was made available on the GST portal and the Petitioner approached the Court belatedly - HELD - Section 169(1)(d) permits service of notices and orders through the web portal. When the order was made available on the GST portal as per the procedure prescribed under the Act, the Petitioner cannot contend that there was no service at all - A writ petition may be entertained where the challenge is on the ground of lack of jurisdiction or violation of natural justice. However, the availability of an alternative statutory remedy and the delay in approaching the Court are relevant considerations. Having come to know of the order in September 2025, the Petitioner ought to have challenged it without further delay, but placed no sufficient reason to justify the delay. Entertaining the petition at this belated stage, when the statutory remedy is available, is not justified - The writ petition is dismissed [Read less]

2026-VIL-1888-CESTAT-AHM-CE  | CESTAT CENTRAL EXCISE

Central Excise - Recovery of duty foregone on duty free procurement by 100% EOU - Notification Nos. 22/2003-CE and 52/2003-Cus - The Appellant, a 100% EOU, procured raw materials without payment of duty under the Notifications and executed a bond. The bulk drug manufactured from them failed the quality test and was destroyed within the factory without intimation to the department. On CERA audit observation, SCN demanded the duty foregone with interest and penalty, which the adjudicating authority confirmed and the FAA upheld. The Appellant contended that destruction within the unit is permitted and non-intimation is only a... [Read more]

Central Excise - Recovery of duty foregone on duty free procurement by 100% EOU - Notification Nos. 22/2003-CE and 52/2003-Cus - The Appellant, a 100% EOU, procured raw materials without payment of duty under the Notifications and executed a bond. The bulk drug manufactured from them failed the quality test and was destroyed within the factory without intimation to the department. On CERA audit observation, SCN demanded the duty foregone with interest and penalty, which the adjudicating authority confirmed and the FAA upheld. The Appellant contended that destruction within the unit is permitted and non-intimation is only a procedural lapse, and that duty can be demanded only on goods cleared into DTA. The Respondent contended that the conditions of the Notifications and the bond were not fulfilled - Whether the duty foregone on duty free raw materials is recoverable where the finished goods manufactured from them were destroyed - HELD - The raw materials were procured duty free on the condition that they are used for manufacture of finished goods for export. The Appellant had bound itself by the bond to pay duty with interest if the raw materials were not used for the intended purpose. There is no dispute that the raw materials were used for manufacture of the finished goods. The intended purpose of allowing duty free procurement was, however, to export the manufactured goods and earn foreign exchange, which was not satisfied. The Foreign Trade Policy provides that no duties are payable on goods destroyed with permission of Customs authorities, but the Appellant did not intimate the department regarding destruction. An exemption notification is to be construed strictly. The conditions of the Notifications not being satisfied, the Appellant is not entitled to the exemption and is liable to pay the duty foregone as per the bond - The duty demand along with interest is upheld - Limitation and demand based on audit observations - Bond executed under Notification Nos. 22/2003-CE and 52/2003-Cus - The SCN for duty foregone on procurements of 2013-14 and 2014-15 was issued in 2018 on the basis of CERA observations. The Appellant contended that the SCN was time barred, that the extended period was wrongly invoked and that the notice was issued without independent investigation - Whether the demand is barred by limitation and is sustainable on the basis of audit observations - HELD - Where a bond is executed undertaking to pay duty if the goods are not used as specified, the normal period of limitation does not apply and the demand is not hit by limitation. The conditions of the bond and the Notifications having been violated, the grounds challenging the extended period or the issue of the SCN without investigation are not sustainable - The demand is not barred by limitation - Penalty - Section 11AC of the Central Excise Act, 1944 - Penalty equal to the duty was imposed on the Appellant. The Appellant had reversed the CENVAT credit on duty paid raw materials with interest on being pointed out by the audit team. The Appellant contended that no fraud, collusion, wilful mis-statement or suppression was involved - Whether penalty under Section 11AC is imposable on the Appellant - HELD - There is no element to suggest that the Appellant had any intention to evade payment of duty, as is clear from its reversal of the CENVAT credit with interest on being pointed out by the audit team. The Notifications require the 100% EOU to pay duty and interest on the goods not used for the intended purpose but do not mandate imposition of penalty - The penalty under Section 11AC is set aside and the appeal is partly allowed. [Read less]

2026-VIL-332-GSTAT-SHM  | Tribunal SGST

GST - Non-speaking and unreasoned orders - Sections 75(6) and 107(12) of CGST Act, 2017 - Appellant is a manufacturer of PP non-woven fabric bags against whom a SCN proposed re-classification of the goods from Tariff Heading 6305 to Tariff Heading 3923. The adjudicating authority confirmed the re-classification along with differential tax, interest and penalty - Appellant contended that both orders are non-speaking and unreasoned, and that the SCN was issued with a pre-determined conclusion and without any proper inquiry - Whether the orders of the adjudicating authority and the FAA are sustainable under Sections 75(6) and... [Read more]

GST - Non-speaking and unreasoned orders - Sections 75(6) and 107(12) of CGST Act, 2017 - Appellant is a manufacturer of PP non-woven fabric bags against whom a SCN proposed re-classification of the goods from Tariff Heading 6305 to Tariff Heading 3923. The adjudicating authority confirmed the re-classification along with differential tax, interest and penalty - Appellant contended that both orders are non-speaking and unreasoned, and that the SCN was issued with a pre-determined conclusion and without any proper inquiry - Whether the orders of the adjudicating authority and the FAA are sustainable under Sections 75(6) and 107(12) or are liable to be quashed as non-speaking and unreasoned - HELD - The adjudicating authority passed a mechanical order without an independent evaluation of the facts or setting forth the grounds forming the basis of its decision. The FAA was under a mandatory obligation to pass a reasoned order setting out the points for determination, the decision thereon and the reasons for it. The FAA merely recorded a few submissions of the Appellant in one paragraph and dismissed them in the next paragraph in agreement with the original authority - The order contains no independent analysis of the contentions, no formulation of points for determination, and is silent on the technical reports and precedents cited by the Appellant. Recording reasoned findings on each contention is not a mere procedural formality but is vital in quasi-judicial orders. A mechanical affirmation reduces the statutory right of appeal to an empty formality and inflicts a fatal blow to the principles of natural justice. The concluding paragraphs of the SCN reflect a pre-judged conclusion and a closed mind. A notice whose language reads like a decision rather than a proposal amounts to a denial of natural justice and renders the subsequent adjudication bad in law - Both orders are non-speaking, unreasoned and bad in law, are quashed – The appeal is allowed - Classification of PP non-woven fabric bags - Tariff Headings 6305 and 3923 - Appellant manufactures bags by cutting and ultrasonic sealing of PP non-woven fabric, which is produced from PP granules through a spunbond extrusion process. Revenue contended that the bags are articles of plastic because the main raw material is PP granules - Appellant contended that the immediate raw material is non-woven fabric classifiable as textile under Tariff Heading 5603 - Whether PP non-woven fabric bags are classifiable as made-up textile articles under Tariff Heading 6305 or as articles of plastics under Tariff Heading 3923 - HELD - The Revenue cannot adopt a double standard by taxing one taxpayer at a higher rate while allowing a similarly placed manufacturer in the same jurisdiction to clear identical bags under a lower rate. Such hostile discrimination without any differentia violates Article 14 of the Constitution of India - The immediate and direct raw material of the bags is PP non-woven fabric, a distinct intermediate product with its own commercial identity, and not PP granules. The authorities below erred in treating the bags as manufactured directly from plastic granules - The Revenue has itself accepted the classification of the intermediate product as textile under Tariff Heading 5603. The test of character, name and marketability shows that the granules lose their original identity and emerge as a textile fabric - The CBIC Circular no 80/54/2018-GST was aimed at conventional laminated plastic bags and cannot override the Chapter Notes or enhance the rate of tax without authority of law, as a circular contrary to the statutory provisions has no legal existence. Even if both Headings were applicable, Rule 3(a) of the General Rules of Interpretation requires the specific description to be preferred over the general description - The bags are correctly classifiable under Tariff Heading 6305. The order of the FAA is set aside and the appeal is allowed [Read less]

2026-VIL-331-GSTAT-DEL-NAPA  | Tribunal SGST

GST - Anti-profiteering - Maintainability of application under Rule 31 of GSTAT (Anti-Profiteering Methodology and Procedure) Rules, 2025 - Tribunal had directed the Respondent to refund the profiteered amount along with the GST component and interest to the homebuyers for failure to pass on the benefit of ITC under Section 171 of CGST Act, 2017. The Respondent filed an application seeking correction or modification of that order - Whether the application under Rule 31 is maintainable - HELD - Jurisdiction under Rule 31 is limited to correction of a clerical, arithmetical or factual mistake apparent from the record. It doe... [Read more]

GST - Anti-profiteering - Maintainability of application under Rule 31 of GSTAT (Anti-Profiteering Methodology and Procedure) Rules, 2025 - Tribunal had directed the Respondent to refund the profiteered amount along with the GST component and interest to the homebuyers for failure to pass on the benefit of ITC under Section 171 of CGST Act, 2017. The Respondent filed an application seeking correction or modification of that order - Whether the application under Rule 31 is maintainable - HELD - Jurisdiction under Rule 31 is limited to correction of a clerical, arithmetical or factual mistake apparent from the record. It does not confer a general power of review or permit reconsideration of an order on merits merely because a party is aggrieved by the findings. A mistake apparent from the record must be obvious and patent and cannot be one that requires a long-drawn process of reasoning on points on which two views may be possible. The issues raised, including the challenge to the GST component, were considered and adjudicated in the original proceedings. The Respondent did not identify any obvious and patent error in the findings or directions. The examination of the grounds is confined to clarifying the implementation of existing directions - The application is held not maintainable under Rule 31 - Deposit in Consumer Welfare Fund - Rule 133(3)(c) of CGST Rules, 2017 - The Respondent could not obtain the bank account details of certain identified homebuyers and sought permission to deposit the corresponding amounts in the Consumer Welfare Fund instead of refunding them directly - Whether the Respondent may be permitted to deposit the amounts attributable to the homebuyers in the Consumer Welfare Fund in view of the stated inability to effect direct refunds - HELD - Rule 133(3)(c) contemplates deposit in the Fund in two distinct circumstances, namely where the eligible person does not claim return of the amount or is not identifiable - Mere identification of an eligible person coupled with non-availability of bank account particulars does not establish that such person is unidentifiable. The absence of a refund by itself does not establish that the amount is unclaimed. The principle that the law does not demand the impossible must be established on cogent material demonstrating genuine impossibility. It cannot dispense with an express statutory requirement - The Respondent remains under an obligation to refund directly wherever particulars are available. For the remaining amounts, it must demonstrate reasonable and bona fide efforts and maintain a homebuyer-wise statement with documentary evidence. The original complainant is an identified recipient, and his amount cannot be deposited in the Fund merely because his bank particulars are unavailable. The permission is confined to the facts of the case and is not a general authorisation - The Respondent is permitted to deposit in the Fund only the amounts attributable to homebuyers whose direct refunds cannot be effected, subject to the conditions of Rule 133(3)(c) - Inclusion of GST component in profiteered amount - Rule 31 of GSTAT (Anti-Profiteering Methodology and Procedure) Rules, 2025 - The Respondent sought deletion of the GST component from the amount directed to be refunded, contending that it was already deposited with the GST Department and that refund would result in double recovery - Whether the GST component included in the profiteered amount can be removed from the original order by way of rectification - HELD - The contention was considered and adjudicated in the original order, which specifically examined the computation of the profiteered amount. The profiteered amount was computed exclusive of GST whereas the Respondent had collected the total consideration from the homebuyers inclusive of GST. The amount realised therefore included the GST attributable to the additional amount collected. Payment of GST to the Government does not absolve the Respondent of its separate statutory obligation under Section 171 of CGST Act to pass on the benefit of additional ITC. The Respondent conflated its tax-payment obligation with its obligation to pass on the benefit to the homebuyers. Rule 31 does not permit a concluded issue to be reopened merely because a party seeks a different outcome - The request for deletion of the GST component is rejected - Rectification on the basis of a subsequent order in another case - Rule 31 of GSTAT (Anti-Profiteering Methodology and Procedure) Rules, 2025 - The Respondent relied on a subsequent order passed by the Tribunal in a separate matter and sought similar relief by modification of the original order - Whether the subsequent order warrants rectification or modification of the original order - HELD - The subsequent order was passed in separate proceedings on the facts of another case and was not a decision placed before the Tribunal when the original order was passed. It cannot establish that the Tribunal committed a mistake or omitted to consider material available on the record. The power of rectification is not an unrestricted power to reconsider an adjudicated issue or to modify an order merely because a party subsequently relies upon a different decision. The material consideration is whether the alleged error is a manifest mistake apparent from the record. The Respondent did not demonstrate any such mistake - The request for rectification or modification on the basis of the subsequent order is rejected. [Read less]

2026-VIL-1902-CESTAT-DEL-ST  | CESTAT SERVICE TAX

Service Tax - Renting of immovable property for use as residence - Section 66D(m) of Finance Act, 1994 - Based on information from the Income Tax Department, the Respondent demanded Service Tax on rent received by the Appellant from renting of immovable property for the post negative list period. The Appellant contended that the property was rented out for use as residence, namely a hostel - Whether the rent received from renting of immovable property is taxable - HELD - The phrase residential dwelling is not defined in the Finance Act, 1994. It means any building, structure or part thereof, other than offices or factories... [Read more]

Service Tax - Renting of immovable property for use as residence - Section 66D(m) of Finance Act, 1994 - Based on information from the Income Tax Department, the Respondent demanded Service Tax on rent received by the Appellant from renting of immovable property for the post negative list period. The Appellant contended that the property was rented out for use as residence, namely a hostel - Whether the rent received from renting of immovable property is taxable - HELD - The phrase residential dwelling is not defined in the Finance Act, 1994. It means any building, structure or part thereof, other than offices or factories, used or intended to be used as home or residence, whether permanently or temporarily. A hostel qualifies as a residential dwelling as it is a house of residence for students for a comparatively longer period than a stay in a hotel or lodge. Clause (m) of Section 66D specifically excludes services by way of renting of residential dwelling for use as residence from taxable service under Section 65B(44). The issue was already decided in the Appellant's own case for the earlier period on the same reasoning - The rent is not taxable and the demand along with interest and penalties is set aside - Credit of tax deposited under challans - Cenvat Credit Rules, 2011 - The Appellant claimed credit of the amount deposited through two challans against the demand. The Respondent denied it as the Appellant had not filed returns for the period - Whether the Appellant is eligible for the credit of the amount deposited - HELD - Cenvat credit can be availed only when the output service is taxable and only on a document as required under Rule 9(2). The assessee must maintain records under Rule 9(6). The Appellant led no evidence to establish that the conditions of the Cenvat Credit Rules are satisfied - The Appellant is not eligible for the credit and the appeal is allowed in part. [Read less]

2026-VIL-1259-KAR  | High Court SGST

GST - Cancellation of registration - Rule 21(d) read with Rule 10A of the CGST Rules, 2017 – Cancellation of registration on the ground of failure to furnish bank account details as required under Rule 10A before filing the first return - Whether the order cancelling the registration can be sustained - HELD - The Respondent accepted that the Petitioner had not been put on notice of the alleged failure to furnish the bank account details as required under Rule 10A before filing the first return. The circumstances that the Petitioner has been out of business from April 2023 and is willing to offer all taxes, pay penalty an... [Read more]

GST - Cancellation of registration - Rule 21(d) read with Rule 10A of the CGST Rules, 2017 – Cancellation of registration on the ground of failure to furnish bank account details as required under Rule 10A before filing the first return - Whether the order cancelling the registration can be sustained - HELD - The Respondent accepted that the Petitioner had not been put on notice of the alleged failure to furnish the bank account details as required under Rule 10A before filing the first return. The circumstances that the Petitioner has been out of business from April 2023 and is willing to offer all taxes, pay penalty and interest and file the necessary returns persuaded the Court to restore the proceedings with an opportunity to file a reply - The order cancelling the registration is quashed. The Petitioner is to file a response to SCN and the Respondent is to consider the response, the returns filed and the Petitioner's willingness to offer taxes and pay penalty and interest, and pass just orders. The petition is allowed [Read less]

2026-VIL-337-GSTAT-SHM  | Tribunal SGST

GST - Non-speaking order and pre-judged SCN - Sections 75(6) and 107(12) of the CGST Act, 2017 - Respondent issued an SCN proposing to reclassify PP non-woven fabric bags from Tariff Heading 6305 to Tariff Heading 3923, and the adjudicating authority confirmed the demand with interest and penalty. The FAA upheld the order - Appellant contended that both orders are non-speaking and unreasoned, and that the SCN was issued with a pre-determined conclusion without any inquiry into the manufacturing process - Whether the orders of the adjudicating authority and the FAA are sustainable - HELD - The adjudicating authority passed ... [Read more]

GST - Non-speaking order and pre-judged SCN - Sections 75(6) and 107(12) of the CGST Act, 2017 - Respondent issued an SCN proposing to reclassify PP non-woven fabric bags from Tariff Heading 6305 to Tariff Heading 3923, and the adjudicating authority confirmed the demand with interest and penalty. The FAA upheld the order - Appellant contended that both orders are non-speaking and unreasoned, and that the SCN was issued with a pre-determined conclusion without any inquiry into the manufacturing process - Whether the orders of the adjudicating authority and the FAA are sustainable - HELD - The adjudicating authority passed a mechanical order without an independent evaluation of facts or setting out the grounds of its decision, in defiance of Section 75(6). The FAA was under a mandatory obligation under Section 107(12) to set out the points for determination, the decision thereon and the reasons. The FAA merely recorded a few submissions in one paragraph and dismissed them in the next, with no independent analysis and total silence on the technical reports and precedents cited. Recording reasons is not a mere procedural formality, as it ensures transparency, prevents arbitrariness and enables the higher forum to understand the path of reasoning. A mechanical affirmation reduces the right of appeal to an empty formality and is a fatal blow to the principles of natural justice. The concluding paragraphs of the SCN reflect a pre-judged conclusion and closed mind, and a notice reading like a decision rather than a proposal denies natural justice and vitiates the subsequent adjudication - The orders of both authorities are non-speaking, unreasoned and bad in law and are quashed.rnrnIssue 2: Classification of PP non-woven fabric bags - Tariff Heading 6305 or Tariff Heading 3923 - The Appellant manufactures PP non-woven fabric from PP granules by a spunbond extrusion process and makes bags by cutting and ultrasonic sealing of that fabric. The Respondent classified the bags as articles of plastic on the ground that the primary raw material is PP granules - Whether PP non-woven fabric bags are classifiable as made-up textile articles under Tariff Heading 6305 or as articles of plastics under Tariff Heading 3923 - HELD - The Revenue cannot adopt a double standard by taxing one taxpayer at a higher rate while allowing a direct competitor in the same jurisdiction the lower rate. The immediate raw material of the bags is PP non-woven fabric, a distinct intermediate product with its own commercial identity classified under Tariff Heading 5603, which the Revenue itself accepts - The PP granules lose their original identity through the spunbond process, so classification cannot rest on the starting raw material. Note 1 and Note 2(p) to Chapter 39 exclude textiles and textile articles of Section XI, so a made-up article of such fabric cannot be dragged back into the plastic chapter. The decisions relied on by the Revenue concerned woven sacks and bags from slit plastic tapes and are distinguishable - CBIC Circular No. 80/54 dated 31.12.2018 addresses conventional laminated plastic bags, and a circular cannot override Chapter Notes or enhance the rate of tax without authority of law. Even if both headings apply, the specific description under Tariff Heading 6305 must be preferred over the general description under Tariff Heading 3923 - Non-woven fabric bags are classifiable under Tariff Heading 6305. The order of the FAA is set aside and the appeal is allowed [Read less]

2026-VIL-1253-HP  | High Court SGST

GST - Show cause notices issued under omitted Rule 96(10) - Rule 96(10) of CGST Rules, 2017 - Petitioner challenged the show cause notices issued in Form DRC-01 under Rule 96(10) of the CGST Rules, which were issued after Rule 96(10) was omitted by notification without any saving clause - Whether the show cause notices issued under Rule 96(10) after its omission without a saving clause or sunset clause are sustainable - HELD - The Apex Court has held that where a Rule is omitted, pending proceedings can continue only if there is a provision for their continuance or a legal device preserving them, and that the legislature b... [Read more]

GST - Show cause notices issued under omitted Rule 96(10) - Rule 96(10) of CGST Rules, 2017 - Petitioner challenged the show cause notices issued in Form DRC-01 under Rule 96(10) of the CGST Rules, which were issued after Rule 96(10) was omitted by notification without any saving clause - Whether the show cause notices issued under Rule 96(10) after its omission without a saving clause or sunset clause are sustainable - HELD - The Apex Court has held that where a Rule is omitted, pending proceedings can continue only if there is a provision for their continuance or a legal device preserving them, and that the legislature brought in no saving clause or sunset clause when Rule 96(10) was omitted. The recommendation that the omission be prospective is advisory and does not bind the rule making authority. The omission therefore applies to all proceedings pending on the date of omission, as also clarified by the Circular on the subject - The show cause notices were issued by the authority without any statutory backing and are non-est in the eyes of law - The show cause notices are quashed and the writ petition is allowed [Read less]

2026-VIL-1247-TEL  | High Court VAT

Andhra Pradesh VAT Act, 2005 - Taxability of service line charges and development charges collected by an electricity distribution company under Section 4(8) of the APVAT Act as transfer of the right to use goods - Petitioner, a distribution licensee under the Electricity Act, 2003, extended service lines and developed distribution infrastructure comprising electric poles, transformers and cables for applicants, and recovered the cost of the goods under the heads of service line charges and development charges - Respondent held that there was a transfer of the right to use goods and levied tax on the turnover under Section... [Read more]

Andhra Pradesh VAT Act, 2005 - Taxability of service line charges and development charges collected by an electricity distribution company under Section 4(8) of the APVAT Act as transfer of the right to use goods - Petitioner, a distribution licensee under the Electricity Act, 2003, extended service lines and developed distribution infrastructure comprising electric poles, transformers and cables for applicants, and recovered the cost of the goods under the heads of service line charges and development charges - Respondent held that there was a transfer of the right to use goods and levied tax on the turnover under Section 4(8) of the APVAT Act - Whether the recovery of service line charges and development charges from consumers amounts to a transfer of the right to use goods exigible to tax under Section 4(8) of the APVAT Act - HELD - The mere recovery of the cost of materials does not by itself establish that the right to use the goods was transferred to the consumers. The poles, transformers and cables continued to remain under the control and maintenance of the Petitioner, and the consumers were not entitled to interfere with or operate the equipment – The continued ownership and control are relevant factors, and the issue cannot be decided merely on the basis of recovery of cost or installation of the equipment. However, the entire cost of the goods used in developing the infrastructure was recovered from the respective applicants, the infrastructure was developed exclusively for their use, and such activity was ancillary to the principal business of supplying electricity. Viewed in its entirety, the nature of the transaction establishes a transfer of the right to use the goods, as transfer of ownership is not necessary and the transfer of the right to use is sufficient to attract the levy - The tax levied on the value of the goods recovered is exigible at the applicable rates under Section 4(8) of the APVAT Act – The question is answered in favour of the Respondent and the writ petition is dismissed [Read less]

2026-VIL-1894-CESTAT-CHE-CU  | CESTAT CUSTOMS

Customs - Invocation of extended period of limitation - Proviso to Section 28(1) of the Customs Act, 1962 - The Respondent imported telecom equipment. On a doubt that the goods were misdeclared by giving only the technical name and not the trade name to evade anti-dumping duty, investigation was taken up. SCN was issued under the proviso to Section 28(1) proposing demand of anti-dumping duty, confiscation and penalty. The Commissioner dropped the proceedings, and the Appellant (Revenue) challenged that order. The Respondent contended that the Bill of Entry was filed long before the SCN, which was therefore beyond the norma... [Read more]

Customs - Invocation of extended period of limitation - Proviso to Section 28(1) of the Customs Act, 1962 - The Respondent imported telecom equipment. On a doubt that the goods were misdeclared by giving only the technical name and not the trade name to evade anti-dumping duty, investigation was taken up. SCN was issued under the proviso to Section 28(1) proposing demand of anti-dumping duty, confiscation and penalty. The Commissioner dropped the proceedings, and the Appellant (Revenue) challenged that order. The Respondent contended that the Bill of Entry was filed long before the SCN, which was therefore beyond the normal period, and that it had correctly declared the description and value of the goods. It further contended that the Department had visited its premises and collected the relevant documents, so the extended period could not be invoked. The Appellant contended that the Commissioner erred in interpreting the exclusion clause of the notification - Whether the Revenue was justified in issuing the SCN by invoking the extended period of limitation - HELD - The officials of the Department visited the Respondent's premises and collected the relevant documents, and the Respondent had explained the nature and description of the goods much before the SCN. The Revenue was therefore aware of the facts but chose not to act in time. The Respondent cannot be alleged to have colluded or made any wilful misstatement or suppression of facts. A SCN which is wholly time barred challenges the jurisdiction of the adjudicating authority and must be examined at the threshold. An order passed without jurisdiction is a nullity and cannot be cured in appellate proceedings - The appeal of the Revenue is dismissed on limitation itself, and the merits are not examined [Read less]

2026-VIL-1891-CESTAT-KOL-ST  | CESTAT SERVICE TAX

Service Tax - Construction of individual residential houses under assignment agreements - Section 65(91a) and Section 65(105)(zzzh) of the Finance Act, 1994 and Entry 14(b) of Notification No. 25/2012-ST - The Appellant constructs residential complexes. Under assignment agreements, the purchasers acquired plots registered in their own names and engaged the Appellant to construct individual houses such as simplex, duplex and bungalows. SCN invoking the extended period alleged that these houses form part of a residential complex and are taxable as construction of residential complex service. The adjudicating authority confir... [Read more]

Service Tax - Construction of individual residential houses under assignment agreements - Section 65(91a) and Section 65(105)(zzzh) of the Finance Act, 1994 and Entry 14(b) of Notification No. 25/2012-ST - The Appellant constructs residential complexes. Under assignment agreements, the purchasers acquired plots registered in their own names and engaged the Appellant to construct individual houses such as simplex, duplex and bungalows. SCN invoking the extended period alleged that these houses form part of a residential complex and are taxable as construction of residential complex service. The adjudicating authority confirmed the demand with interest and penalty, relying on the planned layout, common amenities and presence of more than twelve units. The Appellant contended that individual houses built on separate plots under separate approvals are not a residential complex. The Respondent contended that the colony had common area and facilities under the builder's control - Whether construction of individual residential houses under assignment agreements is taxable as construction of residential complex - HELD - The definition of residential complex before 01.07.2012 is cumulative. It requires a building or buildings having more than twelve residential units, a common area, specified facilities and an approved layout. The mere existence of several residential structures within a larger development does not dispense with proof of these elements. The requirement of more than twelve units is not fulfilled at the level of the individual structures, as the purchasers acquired the plots in their own names and entrusted the Appellant with construction of individual houses. The existence of other independently owned houses elsewhere in the colony cannot establish taxability. From 01.07.2012, Entry 14(b) exempts construction of a single residential unit otherwise than as part of a residential complex. Where title to a demarcated plot has passed to the purchaser and the construction agreement entrusts the erection of a house, the transaction bears the characteristics of construction undertaken for the landowner. The source of the land is not decisive, and the gated nature of the colony, common boundary and facilities are not conclusive. The houses were self-contained units with separate entries and separate electricity and water connections for one family, and the Revenue failed to establish that they formed part of a residential complex - The demand, interest and penalty on construction of individual houses are set aside - Abatement on construction of residential flats - Notification Nos. 1/2006-ST, 29/2010-ST and 26/2012-ST - Under agreements for sale, the purchasers acquired identified flats together with the corresponding interest in land for a consolidated consideration. The Appellant did not dispute the taxability of construction of flats but discharged Service Tax on the abated value. The Department denied the abatement on the ground that the value of land was not included in the amount charged, and that a satisfactory break-up of corner charges and development charges was not furnished. The Respondent contended that an exemption notification is to be construed strictly - Whether the abatement can be denied on construction of residential flats - HELD - The abatement of 33% under Entry 10 of the 2006 Notification carried no condition regarding land. The condition regarding separate recovery of land cost was introduced by Entry 10(a) only from 01.07.2010. Where the purchaser agrees to acquire a flat together with the corresponding interest in the land for a consolidated consideration, the amount represents the consideration for the transaction as a whole. The absence of a separately stated allocation towards land does not signify that land was excluded or separately recovered. In the case of flats, land is never sold separately but forms the undivided portion accruing to the flat buyer, so the land cost is invariably included in the value of the flat. The denial of abatement on the premise that the value of land was not separately identified is unsustainable. The absence of a break-up of corner charges and development charges cannot by itself render the entire consideration ineligible for abatement. The same reasoning applies to the condition under Notification No. 26/2012-ST that the value of land is included in the amount charged from 01.07.2012 - The Appellant is entitled to abatement for the entire period, subject to verification of other conditions. The matter is remanded to the adjudicating authority to re-quantify the demand after allowing abatement and to adjust the Service Tax already paid. The payment claimed on preferential location or development service is remanded for verification. Penalty is set aside, the claim of refund is left open to be made separately and limitation is not examined since the merits are decided. [Read less]

2026-VIL-1897-CESTAT-MUM-CU  | CESTAT CUSTOMS

Customs - Classification of Brown Rice Protein Powder - Tariff Items 3504 0099 and 2106 1000 - The Appellant imported Brown Rice Protein Powder with protein content of approximately 80% and self-assessed it under Tariff Item 3504 0099. The Respondent re-classified the goods under Tariff Item 2106 1000, relying on the HSN Explanatory Notes, the 90% protein condition and foreign customs rulings. The Appellant relied on a technical clarification of an Institute of Technology that Glutelins and Prolamins are the major proteins in the goods - Whether the goods are classifiable under Tariff Item 3504 0099 or Tariff Item 2106 100... [Read more]

Customs - Classification of Brown Rice Protein Powder - Tariff Items 3504 0099 and 2106 1000 - The Appellant imported Brown Rice Protein Powder with protein content of approximately 80% and self-assessed it under Tariff Item 3504 0099. The Respondent re-classified the goods under Tariff Item 2106 1000, relying on the HSN Explanatory Notes, the 90% protein condition and foreign customs rulings. The Appellant relied on a technical clarification of an Institute of Technology that Glutelins and Prolamins are the major proteins in the goods - Whether the goods are classifiable under Tariff Item 3504 0099 or Tariff Item 2106 1000 - HELD - The onus of establishing classification under a different entry rests on the Revenue, which must adduce cogent evidence to displace the classification declared. As per Explanatory Note (B)(1) to heading 3504, cereal proteins, being Glutelins and Prolamins, are covered irrespective of protein content. The Respondent brushed aside the technical clarification without any inquiry, testing or counter-expert opinion, and substituted his own subjective technical perception. Explanatory Note (6) to heading 2106 refers only to textured protein substances, whereas the goods are imported in powder form. The 90% protein condition applies only to protein isolates under Explanatory Note (B)(6), and the expression generally used therein shows that it is not a sine qua non. Under Rule 3(a) of the General Rules of Interpretation, heading 3504 is the more specific description, and even under Rule 3(c) it occurs last in numerical order. Rule 4 could not be applied without ruling out Rules 1 to 3. Foreign customs rulings are at best persuasive, and being divergent they carry no persuasive value. The Revenue failed to discharge its onus - The goods are classifiable under Tariff Item 3504 0099 as declared and the re-classification is set aside - Extended period - Section 28(4) of Customs Act, 1962 - The Respondent invoked the extended period on the ground that the bills of entry were self-assessed and that mis-classification was adopted with fraudulent intention to claim a lower rate of duty - Whether the extended period under Section 28(4) can be invoked for a dispute of classification - HELD - The goods were correctly described in the bills of entry and were cleared without the classification being disputed. Assessment under a particular tariff item as per the understanding of the importer does not give rise to the extended period when the goods are correctly described. The issue is complex and based on interpretation of law, as the Respondent himself examined chapter headings, Explanatory Notes and rulings. Suppression of facts or wilful misstatement cannot be alleged - The invocation of the extended period is vitiated in law - Confiscation, redemption fine and penalty - Sections 111(m), 114A and 125 of Customs Act, 1962 - The goods were held liable to confiscation under Section 111(m) on the sole ground of mis-classification, and redemption fine and penalty under Section 114A were imposed. The goods were not available for confiscation - Whether confiscation, redemption fine and penalty can be sustained on the ground of incorrect classification - HELD - It is not the case of the Revenue that the value or description of the goods was mis-declared. A classification claimed in the bill of entry is only a self-assessment as per the importer's understanding, and an incorrect claim does not render the goods liable to confiscation under Section 111(m). Redemption fine cannot be imposed when the goods are not available for confiscation. Penalty and confiscation on the ground of mis-classification, devoid of any mala fide, are not justified - The confiscation, redemption fine and penalty are set aside and the appeal is allowed. [Read less]

2026-VIL-1260-BOM  | High Court SGST

GST - Service of SCN and Order uploaded on portal - Section 169 of the GST Act, 2017 - The SCN and the ex-parte Order-in-Original were issued only on the portal and not by any other effective communication. The Petitioner came to know of them only when the Nodal Officer contacted the Petitioner on mobile, and the appeal filed thereafter was rejected on limitation - Whether the SCN, the Order-in-Original, the Order-in-Appeal and the recovery notice are sustainable when the SCN and the Order-in-Original were only uploaded on the portal and the Petitioner was not heard - HELD - It is clear from the SCN and the Order-in-Origin... [Read more]

GST - Service of SCN and Order uploaded on portal - Section 169 of the GST Act, 2017 - The SCN and the ex-parte Order-in-Original were issued only on the portal and not by any other effective communication. The Petitioner came to know of them only when the Nodal Officer contacted the Petitioner on mobile, and the appeal filed thereafter was rejected on limitation - Whether the SCN, the Order-in-Original, the Order-in-Appeal and the recovery notice are sustainable when the SCN and the Order-in-Original were only uploaded on the portal and the Petitioner was not heard - HELD - It is clear from the SCN and the Order-in-Original that the Petitioner was not heard. No mistake can be attributed to the Petitioner for not having noticed the notice or the order on the portal, as the Petitioner had no opportunity to reply to the SCN. Portal-based service is sufficient but not necessarily effective service under Section 169, and where it is ineffective the Department must adopt alternate statutory modes such as RPAD, failing which the proceedings are unsustainable - The SCN, the Order-in-Original and the Order-in-Appeal are in gross defiance of the principles of natural justice - The recovery notice, the SCN, the Order-in-Original and the Order-in-Appeal are quashed and set aside. The petition is allowedrnrnIssue 2: Rectification of ITC wrongly recorded under CGST and SGST instead of IGST - Bona fide error - The accountant of the Petitioner had incorrectly and inadvertently recorded ITC in GSTR-3B for March 2019 under CGST and SGST instead of IGST. The Petitioner rectified the error by correctly showing the ITC under IGST in GSTR-3B for September 2019 - Whether the inadvertent error in recording ITC, rectified by the Petitioner, can be allowed to stand corrected - HELD - The Petitioner, upon realising the mistake, rectified it by correctly showing the ITC under IGST. The mistake was bona fide and there was no loss to the revenue, which justifies allowing even a time-barred correction in such circumstances - The impugned orders are quashed and the petition is allowed. [Read less]

2026-VIL-1256-KAR  | High Court SGST

GST - Ex-parte adjudication order - Petitioner challenged an adjudication order raising a demand and directing discharge of the liability within 90 days, failing which recovery action under Section 79 would follow - The order was passed ex-parte under Section 73(9) without notifying the Petitioner of the action contemplated - Whether the writ petition is maintainable against an ex-parte adjudication order despite the availability of an appellate remedy - HELD - An appeal is provided under Section 107, but the fact remains that the Petitioner was placed ex-parte. In these circumstances, the order was passed in utter violati... [Read more]

GST - Ex-parte adjudication order - Petitioner challenged an adjudication order raising a demand and directing discharge of the liability within 90 days, failing which recovery action under Section 79 would follow - The order was passed ex-parte under Section 73(9) without notifying the Petitioner of the action contemplated - Whether the writ petition is maintainable against an ex-parte adjudication order despite the availability of an appellate remedy - HELD - An appeal is provided under Section 107, but the fact remains that the Petitioner was placed ex-parte. In these circumstances, the order was passed in utter violation of the principles of natural justice. The Petitioner is entitled to the same benefit that the Coordinate Bench extended in an identical matter, where the order was set aside and the Petitioner was given an opportunity to reply - The writ petition is allowed subject to payment of costs. The Petitioner shall appear before the Original Authority, who shall provide an opportunity to submit a reply with documents and pass appropriate orders in accordance with the law – The petition is disposed of [Read less]

2026-VIL-1257-KAR  | High Court SGST

GST - Same Officer conducting GST Audit and Adjudication - Petitioner challenged the Order-in-Appeal and the Order-in-Original on the ground that the same officer who conducted the audit, issued the audit observation and report, and issued the intimation of tax ascertainment and the SCN, also passed the Order-in-Original - The Petitioner contended that the reply was not considered and that the audit officer and the adjudicating officer being one and the same is not permissible - Whether the officer who conducted the audit under Section 65 can issue the SCN and adjudicate the matter under Section 73 - HELD - The Coordinate ... [Read more]

GST - Same Officer conducting GST Audit and Adjudication - Petitioner challenged the Order-in-Appeal and the Order-in-Original on the ground that the same officer who conducted the audit, issued the audit observation and report, and issued the intimation of tax ascertainment and the SCN, also passed the Order-in-Original - The Petitioner contended that the reply was not considered and that the audit officer and the adjudicating officer being one and the same is not permissible - Whether the officer who conducted the audit under Section 65 can issue the SCN and adjudicate the matter under Section 73 - HELD - The Coordinate Bench has held that an officer who initiated the audit proceedings could not have issued the notice and adjudicated the matter. The contention that petitioner actively participated and submitted a reply makes no difference, as the contention is a point of law that can be urged in the writ petition - The matter is remanded for consideration afresh from the stage of submitting a reply to the intimation of tax ascertained under Section 73(5). The Joint Commissioner of Commercial Taxes shall assign the matter to a proper officer other than the officer who passed the Order-in-Original - The writ petition is allowed by remand [Read less]

2026-VIL-205-AAR  | Advance Ruling Authority SGST

GST – Telangana AAR - Reimbursement of Electricity and Water Charges to Lessor - Pure Agent under Rule 33 of CGST Rules, 2017 - The Applicant, engaged in operating restaurants and coffee cafes, took commercial premises on lease and was contractually required, besides rent, to bear the electricity and water charges for actual consumption determined from separate meters and recovered by the lessor on production of supporting bills - Whether the reimbursement of electricity and water charges paid to the lessor is liable to GST or is excludable from the value of taxable supply under Rule 33 of the CGST Rules, 2017 - HELD - E... [Read more]

GST – Telangana AAR - Reimbursement of Electricity and Water Charges to Lessor - Pure Agent under Rule 33 of CGST Rules, 2017 - The Applicant, engaged in operating restaurants and coffee cafes, took commercial premises on lease and was contractually required, besides rent, to bear the electricity and water charges for actual consumption determined from separate meters and recovered by the lessor on production of supporting bills - Whether the reimbursement of electricity and water charges paid to the lessor is liable to GST or is excludable from the value of taxable supply under Rule 33 of the CGST Rules, 2017 - HELD - Electrical energy and water are exempt under the exemption notification without any conditions. Rule 33 excludes from the value of supply the expenditure or costs incurred by a supplier as a pure agent of the recipient, if the supplier makes payment to a third party on authorisation by the recipient, the payment is separately indicated in the invoice, and the supplies procured are in addition to the services supplied on own account - Where electricity is supplied bundled with renting of immovable property, it forms part of a composite supply taxed at the rate of the principal supply, even if billed separately. However, where electricity is supplied by a real estate owner as a pure agent, it does not form part of the value of the owner's supply, and a person charging the same amount for electricity as charged by the electricity supplier is deemed to act as a pure agent - The Applicant is eligible to exclude the electricity charges paid to the lessor from the value of taxable supply if the lessor acts as a pure agent, indicates the charges in the invoice and collects them only on actual basis without any surplus or deficit. The same ruling applies to water charges covered in Sl.No.99 of notification No.2/2017, dated. 28.06.2017 – Ordered accordingly - Qualification of Recovery as Pure Agent Expenditure - Whether the recovery of electricity and water charges by the lessor, strictly in terms of the Lease Agreement and without any markup or profit element, qualifies as expenditure incurred by a pure agent under Rule 33 - HELD - The question raised is not under the purview of the Authority - No ruling is given on the question. [Read less]

2026-VIL-1261-BOM  | High Court SGST

GST - Denial of ITC on IGST paid on imports - Non-reflection in Electronic Credit Ledger due to technical glitch - Petitioner paid IGST on import of goods but the same was not reflected in the GST Portal owing to a failure of integration between ICEGATE and GSTN. The Petitioner furnished the Bills of Entry and reconciliation statements in response to the discrepancy notice, yet the Respondents passed the Adjudication Order and the Order-in-Appeal on the basis of system-generated data - Whether denial of ITC to the Petitioner solely on account of non-reflection of IGST on the GST Portal, caused by a technical glitch in the ... [Read more]

GST - Denial of ITC on IGST paid on imports - Non-reflection in Electronic Credit Ledger due to technical glitch - Petitioner paid IGST on import of goods but the same was not reflected in the GST Portal owing to a failure of integration between ICEGATE and GSTN. The Petitioner furnished the Bills of Entry and reconciliation statements in response to the discrepancy notice, yet the Respondents passed the Adjudication Order and the Order-in-Appeal on the basis of system-generated data - Whether denial of ITC to the Petitioner solely on account of non-reflection of IGST on the GST Portal, caused by a technical glitch in the electronic systems of the Respondents, is sustainable - HELD - The non-reflection of the IGST is prima facie a result of failure of integration between ICEGATE and GSTN, both of which are electronic systems maintained and controlled by the Respondents. The Petitioner has no role to play in such transmissions and cannot be made to suffer for technical or systemic lapses attributable to the authorities themselves - The Petitioner has produced documents supporting payment of tax, and denial of ITC mainly on the ground of a technical glitch was not proper. The impugned orders are on the face of it unsustainable as they are based solely on non-reflection of the IGST - The Adjudication Order and the Order-in-Appeal are quashed and set aside. The Respondents are directed to reconcile and give due consideration to the IGST paid on import by duly reflecting the same in the Electronic Credit Ledger, with the Petitioner at liberty to put forth all documents in support of the case - The petition is disposed of [Read less]

2026-VIL-1262-RAJ  | High Court SGST

GST - Maintainability of writ against order of confiscation - Alternative remedy of appeal - The conveyance carrying goods declared as Soyabean Refined Oil was intercepted, and physical verification found the goods to be Mustard Oil, with the driver having absconded. An SCN for confiscation was issued, and in the earlier round the Court directed release of the vehicle and goods against a bank guarantee. The Petitioner did not furnish the guarantee, and the adjudicating authority passed a final order of confiscation in FORM GST MOV-11 after considering the reply and affording a personal hearing - Whether the writ petition i... [Read more]

GST - Maintainability of writ against order of confiscation - Alternative remedy of appeal - The conveyance carrying goods declared as Soyabean Refined Oil was intercepted, and physical verification found the goods to be Mustard Oil, with the driver having absconded. An SCN for confiscation was issued, and in the earlier round the Court directed release of the vehicle and goods against a bank guarantee. The Petitioner did not furnish the guarantee, and the adjudicating authority passed a final order of confiscation in FORM GST MOV-11 after considering the reply and affording a personal hearing - Whether the writ petition is maintainable against the order of confiscation when an appeal lies under Section 107 of the Act - HELD - The Act is a self-contained, comprehensive code, and Section 107 provides an alternative and efficacious remedy of appeal against the adjudicatory order of confiscation. The writ jurisdiction under Article 226 is not meant to short-circuit or circumvent the statutory appellate hierarchy. The exceptions of absolute lack of jurisdiction, violation of fundamental rights or gross violation of natural justice are conspicuously absent, as the Petitioner was served the SCN, filed a detailed reply, was afforded a personal hearing and a reasoned order was passed dealing with every objection. - The controversy is mired in disputed questions of fact, such as the nature of the goods, the travel time and the toll and RFID mapping, which a writ court cannot re-appreciate and which the Appellate Authority is statutorily equipped to examine. The grievance regarding the bank guarantee and the quantification of fine and penalty under Section 130 must be raised in the appeal - The Petitioner is at liberty to approach the Appellate Authority, which shall decide the appeal on its own merits - The writ petition is not maintainable and is disposed of [Read less]

2026-VIL-1898-CESTAT-CHE-CU  | CESTAT CUSTOMS

Customs - Classification of unflavoured Supari - Tariff Items 2106 90 30 and 0802 80 20 - The Respondent imported goods declared as Betel Nut Product Known as Supari (Unflavoured Supari) under Tariff Item 2106 90 30. The Appellant-Revenue reclassified them as split areca nuts under Tariff Item 0802 80 20, relying on the CRCL reports that described the samples as split pieces of betel nuts without lime, katha or tobacco. The Respondent relied on FSSAI reports and NOC identifying the goods as Supari. The Commissioner (Appeals) set aside the reclassification - Whether the goods are classifiable under Tariff Item 2106 90 30 or... [Read more]

Customs - Classification of unflavoured Supari - Tariff Items 2106 90 30 and 0802 80 20 - The Respondent imported goods declared as Betel Nut Product Known as Supari (Unflavoured Supari) under Tariff Item 2106 90 30. The Appellant-Revenue reclassified them as split areca nuts under Tariff Item 0802 80 20, relying on the CRCL reports that described the samples as split pieces of betel nuts without lime, katha or tobacco. The Respondent relied on FSSAI reports and NOC identifying the goods as Supari. The Commissioner (Appeals) set aside the reclassification - Whether the goods are classifiable under Tariff Item 2106 90 30 or Tariff Item 0802 80 20 - HELD - The burden of proof in classification disputes rests on the Revenue, which must adduce cogent evidence to displace the classification declared. The FSSAI and CRCL reports operate in different fields and are not mutually destructive. The FSSAI reports record moisture below the limit for roasted nuts, identify the product as Supari and have not been shown to be erroneous. The CRCL reports raised no query on the processing undergone, the moisture content or whether the goods were known as Supari, and merely describe physical characteristics. Chapter 21 provides a specific entry for Supari, defined as any preparation containing betel nuts but not lime, katha or tobacco, whether or not containing other ingredients. No specific process is prescribed for a product to qualify as Supari, and absence of other ingredients does not take the goods out of Chapter 21. Classification ends at GRI 1 unless the Revenue establishes that the goods do not answer the description of Supari, and the specific entry prevails over the general entry. The ratio of earlier decisions cannot be mechanically extended to every product commonly known as Supari. The Revenue failed to discharge its burden - The goods are classifiable under Tariff Item 2106 90 30 as declared and the reclassification is set aside - Concessional rate of duty - Section 111(o) of Customs Act, 1962 - The Respondent claimed the benefit of the exemption notification on the strength of Certificates of Origin issued by the competent authority of the exporting country, describing the goods as Betelnut Product known as Supari under the same HS Code. The Revenue denied the benefit and proposed confiscation under Section 111(o) - Whether the benefit can be denied and the goods confiscated under Section 111(o) - HELD - The Certificates of Origin were certified by the competent authority and were neither challenged on any substantive ground nor shown to be invalidated in accordance with law. The Revenue did not follow the prescribed verification mechanism and made no investigation into suppression or dishonest intention to make a false representation. A dispute only on classification does not permit denial of the preferential rate to goods covered by a valid Certificate of Origin - The Respondent is entitled to the benefit of the exemption notification and confiscation under Section 111(o) is unsustainable - Valuation of imported goods - Section 14 of Customs Act, 1962 - The Revenue redetermined the assessable value on the basis of classification under Tariff Item 0802 80 20 - Whether the redetermination of value is sustainable - HELD - Tariff values under Section 14(2) apply to raw areca nuts, whereas no tariff value is fixed for Supari, so valuation must be under Section 14(1). The valuation proposed rested on classification under Tariff Item 0802 80 20, which has been negatived, and there was no dispute on the transaction value. The mandatory procedure under Section 14 read with the Valuation Rules was not followed - The declared transaction value is to be accepted and the valuation proposed by the Revenue is contrary to law - Confiscation, redemption fine and penalty - Sections 111(d), 111(m), 112 and 114AA of Customs Act, 1962 - Confiscation was proposed on the ground that split areca nuts below the minimum import price were imported in contravention of the import restriction and were misdeclared, and redemption fine and penalties were imposed - Whether confiscation, redemption fine and penalties are sustainable - HELD - The premise of the prohibition rested on classification under Tariff Item 0802 80 20, which does not survive, so Section 111(d) is not attracted. Confiscation under Section 111(m) is unsustainable in the absence of cogent evidence, in view of the FSSAI reports and the inconclusive CRCL reports. As the Respondent cannot be faulted for adopting classification under Tariff Item 2106 90 30, no differential duty, interest, redemption fine or penalty arises - The appeal of the Revenue is dismissed. [Read less]

2026-VIL-1249-RAJ  | High Court SGST

GST - Constitutional validity of Rule 36(4) of the CGST Rules restricting ITC on invoices or debit notes not uploaded by suppliers under Section 37(1) of the CGST Act - Rule 36(4) was inserted restricting availment of ITC in respect of invoices or debit notes not uploaded by suppliers to a prescribed limit of the eligible credit reflected in uploaded invoices, and the limit was subsequently reduced - Petitioners sought quashing of Rule 36(4) contending that it is ultra vires Section 16, contrary to Sections 37 and 42, that Section 43A was not notified, and that it penalises bona fide recipients in violation of Articles 14,... [Read more]

GST - Constitutional validity of Rule 36(4) of the CGST Rules restricting ITC on invoices or debit notes not uploaded by suppliers under Section 37(1) of the CGST Act - Rule 36(4) was inserted restricting availment of ITC in respect of invoices or debit notes not uploaded by suppliers to a prescribed limit of the eligible credit reflected in uploaded invoices, and the limit was subsequently reduced - Petitioners sought quashing of Rule 36(4) contending that it is ultra vires Section 16, contrary to Sections 37 and 42, that Section 43A was not notified, and that it penalises bona fide recipients in violation of Articles 14, 19 and 300A - Respondents contended that Rule 36(4) derives authority from Sections 16 and 164, was not introduced under Section 43A, and is a policy measure to curb fraudulent availment of ITC - Whether Rule 36(4) of the CGST Rules is ultra vires the CGST Act and unconstitutional - HELD - Three High Courts have dealt with the same issue and upheld the rule, and the matter is no longer res integra. Rule 36 and in particular sub-rule (4) derives power from Section 16 of the CGST Act as well as from the general powers conferred by the Act. Section 43A, having never been enforced, cannot be treated as the source of power of a rule. The Court is in respectful agreement with the view taken by the High Courts and sees no reason to take a contrary view - The challenge to the constitutional validity of Rule 36(4) of the CGST Rules fails and the petitions are disposed of accordingly - Maintainability of challenge to show cause notices issued for reversal of ITC on the ground of mismatch under Rule 36(4) of the CGST Rules - Respondents issued Form GST DRC-01A calling upon the Petitioner to reverse ITC on the ground of mismatch between the ITC availed and the amounts reflected in GSTR-2A, and the Petitioners assailed the notices along with the vires of Rule 36(4) - Whether the SCN are liable to be quashed at the stage of their issuance - HELD - The challenge to the show cause notices is primarily founded on the challenge to the vires of Rule 36(4), and since that challenge has failed the Court is not persuaded to quash the notices. The Hon'ble Supreme Court has held that no writ lies against the issuance of a show cause notice and such a writ petition would not be maintainable. The Petitioners are at liberty to avail the appropriate remedies by appearing before the competent authorities and placing whatever material they wish to rely upon - The Court declines to interfere with the show cause notices at this stage and the writ petitions are disposed of, with liberty to challenge any assessment orders in accordance with law. [Read less]

2026-VIL-1268-GUJ-CU  | High Court CUSTOMS

Customs - Export benefit under the DFIA Scheme - Classification of import item under SION Entry E22 or E76 - The Respondent exported liquid glucose concentrate and obtained DFIA Authorisations by declaring the import item as Maize (Corn) Starch under SION Entry E22. The Authorisations were transferred to third parties and remain valid and subsisting, as DGFT did not cancel or suspend them. The investigation found that starch slurry was directly used to manufacture liquid glucose and powdered starch was never used as an input - Appellant contended that the correct input was Maize under SION Entry E76 - SCN issued under Sect... [Read more]

Customs - Export benefit under the DFIA Scheme - Classification of import item under SION Entry E22 or E76 - The Respondent exported liquid glucose concentrate and obtained DFIA Authorisations by declaring the import item as Maize (Corn) Starch under SION Entry E22. The Authorisations were transferred to third parties and remain valid and subsisting, as DGFT did not cancel or suspend them. The investigation found that starch slurry was directly used to manufacture liquid glucose and powdered starch was never used as an input - Appellant contended that the correct input was Maize under SION Entry E76 - SCN issued under Section 28AAA with confiscation under Section 113(i) and penalty under Section 114(iii), which the CESTAT set aside - Whether the Respondent was justified in claiming import of inputs under SION Entry E22 and not SION Entry E76 - HELD - Liquid glucose is a common export item under both entries, and Entry E22 specifies glucose in both liquid concentrate and powder forms while Entry E76 covers only liquid glucose. Starch slurry, essentially starch in slurry form, was used as the immediate input in manufacturing the export item, so it cannot be said that starch was not an input. The immediate parent material for the export goods was starch falling under SION Entry E22, and denial of the benefit on the ground that maize is the original input is not sustainable. The deletion of Entry E22 by DGFT on the premise that it was being misused by exporters supports the finding that the export item remained the same under both entries - The Respondent was justified in claiming the benefit under SION Entry E22. The Revenue appeals is dismissedrnrnIssue 2: Recovery under Section 28AAA, confiscation under Section 113(i) and penalty under Section 114(iii) of the Customs Act, 1962 - The DFIA Authorisations were issued by DGFT and the Appellant invoked Section 28AAA on the ground of wilful mis-statement and suppression of facts in obtaining them - Whether the Revenue could invoke Section 28AAA and sustain confiscation and penalty when DGFT has accepted the classification of the import item - HELD - DGFT is the proper authority to determine classification of goods under the DFIA claims. The Authorisations issued by DGFT are valid and subsisting, no proceedings for cancellation or suspension have been initiated and DGFT has accepted the classification of the import item under SION Entry E22. The Appellant could not have invoked Section 28AAA in these circumstances. In view of the findings of fact that there was no wilful mis-statement or suppression of facts for obtaining the Authorisations, the Revenue authorities were not justified in invoking Section 113(i) read with Section 114(iii) - The appeal is dismissed [Read less]

2026-VIL-327-GSTAT-AGR  | Tribunal SGST

GST - Eligibility of ITC under Section 16(2) of CGST Act, 2017 where the supplier is subsequently found to be non-existent - Respondent purchased GP sheet used in manufacturing of padlock and metal items from a supplier and claimed ITC thereon - Revenue informed that the supplier was a non-existent firm only issuing fictitious invoices without actual supply of goods - FAA allowed the first appeal and set aside the demand, against which the Revenue preferred the second appeal - Whether ITC can be denied under Section 16(2) to a purchasing taxpayer who possesses valid tax invoice, e-way bills, transport records and proof of ... [Read more]

GST - Eligibility of ITC under Section 16(2) of CGST Act, 2017 where the supplier is subsequently found to be non-existent - Respondent purchased GP sheet used in manufacturing of padlock and metal items from a supplier and claimed ITC thereon - Revenue informed that the supplier was a non-existent firm only issuing fictitious invoices without actual supply of goods - FAA allowed the first appeal and set aside the demand, against which the Revenue preferred the second appeal - Whether ITC can be denied under Section 16(2) to a purchasing taxpayer who possesses valid tax invoice, e-way bills, transport records and proof of payment through banking channels, merely because the supplier was subsequently found to be non-existent - HELD - Section 16(1) and 16(2) prescribe the conditions for claiming ITC, namely possession of tax invoice, actual receipt of goods, payment of tax charged to the public exchequer and filing of return under Section 39 - Respondent produced verifiable documents, being e-way bill, consignment note and payment details, and the raw material was utilised in manufacturing of padlock goods. The department neither questioned nor disputed the manufacture or sale of the finished goods, and manufacturing of such goods without raw material is impermissible, which validates actual physical receipt of goods. Payment for the inward supply was also proved through verifiable banking channels prior to receipt of SCN. At the time of the transaction the supplier was a registered entity carrying a valid GSTIN on the common portal, and a subsequent investigation declaring the supplier non-existent or retrospective cancellation of registration cannot automatically disentitle a bonafide buyer who acted upon the registration status displayed on the official portal - Though the burden of proving eligibility of ITC lies on the person claiming it under Section 155, Respondent successfully discharged it, and the burden to rebut shifted to the department, which failed to do so. The Revenue cannot make the purchasing dealer a guarantor for the supplier's statutory compliance or post transaction records - The question is answered against the Appellant, FAA rightly set aside the reversal of ITC - The appeal is dismissed - Justification of penalty under Section 74 of CGST Act against a purchasing dealer without proof of collusion or active participation in fraud - FAA set aside the demand and penalty, and the Revenue preferred the second appeal - Whether a penalty order under Section 74 is justified against a purchasing dealer without proving collusion or active participation in the fraud - HELD - Section 74 applies only where tax is not paid, short paid or ITC is wrongly availed by reason of fraud or wilful misstatement or suppression of facts to evade tax liability. To invoke Section 74, the onus is on the department to establish deliberate fraud, misinterpretation or collusion between buyer and supplier. In the SCN, the proper officer failed to produce any direct evidence, statement or material to show that the Respondent was aware of any bogus invoice ring operated by the supplier - Respondent, having produced tax invoice, e-way bill, consignment note, bank transaction statement and evidence of raw material consumption, is a bonafide taxpayer who entered into the transaction in good faith with a registered entity and cannot be penalised for the post transaction disappearance of the supplier. The penalty is not sustainable and set aside - The order of FAA is upheld and the appeal is dismissed. [Read less]

2026-VIL-328-GSTAT-ERN  | Tribunal SGST

GST - Natural Justice - Non-speaking order of the FAA rejecting detailed submissions in one line - Appellant was issued an SCN under Section 73 for the year 2017-18 on comparison of GSTR-3B and GSTR-2A, and the demand of tax, interest and penalty was confirmed and upheld by the FAA. The Appellant made elaborate submissions on set-off of excess output tax against the disallowed ITC, validity of credit notes not reflected in GSTR-2A and non-applicability of interest on late filing, and these were recorded in the appellate order over several pages but rejected in a single line stating that there was no evidence in support of ... [Read more]

GST - Natural Justice - Non-speaking order of the FAA rejecting detailed submissions in one line - Appellant was issued an SCN under Section 73 for the year 2017-18 on comparison of GSTR-3B and GSTR-2A, and the demand of tax, interest and penalty was confirmed and upheld by the FAA. The Appellant made elaborate submissions on set-off of excess output tax against the disallowed ITC, validity of credit notes not reflected in GSTR-2A and non-applicability of interest on late filing, and these were recorded in the appellate order over several pages but rejected in a single line stating that there was no evidence in support of the disputed ITC claim - Whether the order of the FAA rejecting the submissions in one line without discussion can be sustained - HELD - The submissions recorded over five pages were brusquely rejected in one line, which is a cavalier approach resulting in an order that is non-speaking, with non-application of mind writ large on its face. The order is arbitrary and passed in complete violation of the canons of natural justice and deserves to be set aside on this ground alone - The Tribunal proceeded to decide the case on merits - Demand under Section 73 alleging short payment of tax on account of ineligible ITC offset by excess output tax paid - Appellant had paid output tax in excess of what was due as per GSTR-1, while the updated GSTR-2A showed excess input tax availed only to a lesser extent under CGST and SGST. The Respondent did not dispute these facts but contended that discharge of output liability and availment of ITC are distinct mechanisms, and that unilateral adjustment of excess output tax without following the refund process under Section 54 is impermissible - Whether a notice under Section 73 can be issued for short payment of tax when the shortfall due to ineligible ITC is offset by an excess of output tax paid - HELD - Even if the Appellant made a short payment to the extent of ITC disallowed, there is no reason why it cannot be set off against the excess tax paid, which is not in dispute, and this does not violate any statutory provision. Expecting the Appellant to pay the shortfall and then claim refund of the excess would be an exercise in futility. The Kerala High Court decision, though rendered in the context of cross utilisation of ITC, upheld the principle that the electronic credit ledger is a pool with compartments for IGST, CGST and SGST and that no short payment arises where there is no loss of revenue. This principle applies with greater force where the output tax paid was much in excess of the shortfall on account of ITC disallowed - There is no overall short payment of tax warranting proceedings under Section 73, and the demand of tax, interest and penalty is not sustainable - Refund of Excess Output Tax - Applicability of unjust enrichment - The Respondent contended that Section 54 read with Section 57 requires refund of excess tax paid to undergo scrutiny for unjust enrichment, and that automatic set-off in assessment proceedings would bypass verification of whether the burden was passed on to consumers - Whether refund of excess paid output tax is subject to the test of unjust enrichment - HELD - Section 54(8)(c) provides that the refundable amount shall be paid to the applicant instead of being credited to the Fund where it is relatable to refund of tax paid on a supply which is not provided, wholly or partially, and for which invoice has not been issued. The excess payment of output tax over and above what was due falls within this exemption and is not subject to the principles of unjust enrichment. The apprehension that the statutory mandate of verifying unjust enrichment is bypassed is misplaced as there is no such statutory mandate - The contention is not sustainable and refund of excess paid output tax is not subject to the test of unjust enrichment - Sales Return - Demand confirmed on a ground not mentioned in the SCN and non-declaration of credit and debit notes in the portal - The SCN alleged that the sales return claimed was without supporting documents, whereas the Appellant produced the debit notes and credit notes. The adjudicating authority rejected them on the ground that the supplier had not declared the debit note in its GSTR-1 or GSTR-9, and the Respondent relied on Section 34(2) requiring declaration of such notes in the return - Whether the demand on account of sales return can be confirmed on a ground not found in the SCN, and whether credit and debit notes can be invalidated for non-declaration in the portal for the year 2017-18 - HELD - The adjudicating authority travelled beyond the SCN and confirmed the demand on a ground not found in it, and the FAA upheld the order without any worthwhile finding or discussion. GSTR-2A was initially rolled out in 2017-18 as a taxpayer facility for reconciliation of ITC and became a mandatory return only from October 2019. There was no mandatory provision during the period in dispute for declaring these credit and debit notes in the portal, and the notes, if otherwise in order, cannot be invalidated on the ground that they were not uploaded - The demand of tax, interest and penalty on this account is not sustainable - Interest on Belated Filing of Returns - Vague SCN lacking specificity - Appellant contended that due dates were continuously extended on account of faults in the GST Portal and that the delay was due to the Portal. The SCN did not mention the months of default, the tax on which interest was demanded or the period of interest, and the amount of interest in the order differed from that in the SCN without any explanation of the basis of either figure - Whether the demand of interest on account of late filing can be sustained on such an SCN - HELD - The SCN is vague, lacks specificity and does not disclose the specific months of default, the quantum of tax on which interest is demanded and the period for which interest is demanded. The difference between the interest stated in the SCN and the order remains unexplained. Such an SCN is in violation of the principles of natural justice - The demand of interest is not sustainable and the appeal is allowed. [Read less]

2026-VIL-329-GSTAT-AGR  | Tribunal SGST

GST - Treatment of discounts or incentives received from supplier and disclosed as adjustment in turnover in reconciliation statement of recipient - Respondent disclosed an amount in the adjustment column of the reconciliation statement in GSTR-9C, explained as incentives and discounts received from its supplier and as already deposited through Form GST DRC-03. The adjudicating authority initiated proceedings under Section 74 alleging that the Respondent was availing the benefit of the same deposit twice - The FAA decided the appeal in favour of the Respondent - Whether the demand of output tax can be sustained on the basi... [Read more]

GST - Treatment of discounts or incentives received from supplier and disclosed as adjustment in turnover in reconciliation statement of recipient - Respondent disclosed an amount in the adjustment column of the reconciliation statement in GSTR-9C, explained as incentives and discounts received from its supplier and as already deposited through Form GST DRC-03. The adjudicating authority initiated proceedings under Section 74 alleging that the Respondent was availing the benefit of the same deposit twice - The FAA decided the appeal in favour of the Respondent - Whether the demand of output tax can be sustained on the basis of the amount disclosed in the reconciliation statement without examining the nature and tax treatment of the discounts - HELD - Section 15(3) of the CGST Act, 2017 governs the value of the taxable supply of the supplier and prescribes the conditions for excluding a discount from that value, and not from the taxable supply of the recipient. Receipt of a discount does not by itself entitle the recipient to reduce its own outward taxable turnover by the same amount. The tax treatment must be determined with reference to the nature of the transaction, the invoices and credit notes, and the treatment adopted by the supplier and the recipient in their returns - The adjudicating authority must ascertain whether the supplier issued credit notes recorded in its GSTR-1, whether the discounts were linked to invoices under an agreement entered into at or before the supply, whether the supplier reduced its taxable value, and whether the recipient is required to reverse ITC. If the supplier did not reduce its taxable value or output tax liability, reversal of ITC by the recipient is not warranted. The adjudicating authority must also verify whether the recipient actually reduced its outward taxable turnover or output tax liability in its returns, and if it did not, mere disclosure of the amount in the reconciliation statement does not justify a demand of output tax - The orders of the FAA and the adjudicating authority passed without adequate investigation are set aside, and the matter is remanded for fresh order – The appeal is allowed by remand [Read less]

2026-VIL-203-AAR  | Advance Ruling Authority SGST

GST – Karnataka AAR - Invoicing Procedure for Development Services – Maintainability of AAR application under Section 97(2) of CGST Act, 2017 - The Applicant, a developer, entered into a Joint Development Agreement with the landowners for development of a residential layout, bore the entire cost of development, and the developed plots were to be allocated between the landowners and the Applicant in the agreed proportion - Whether the question relating to the procedure of invoicing is maintainable before the Authority under Section 97(2) of the CGST Act, 2017 - HELD - Section 97(2) exhaustively specifies the questions o... [Read more]

GST – Karnataka AAR - Invoicing Procedure for Development Services – Maintainability of AAR application under Section 97(2) of CGST Act, 2017 - The Applicant, a developer, entered into a Joint Development Agreement with the landowners for development of a residential layout, bore the entire cost of development, and the developed plots were to be allocated between the landowners and the Applicant in the agreed proportion - Whether the question relating to the procedure of invoicing is maintainable before the Authority under Section 97(2) of the CGST Act, 2017 - HELD - Section 97(2) exhaustively specifies the questions on which an advance ruling can be sought. The question did not seek determination of the value of supply under Section 15 but only the manner in which invoices are to be issued, the amount to be reflected in the invoice and the extent of invoicing. The Authority is constituted to decide only the questions enumerated under Section 97(2) and is not empowered to issue advisory opinions or administrative guidance on accounting practices, documentation requirements, invoicing methodology or the mechanics of compliance. The question does not relate to classification, applicability of a notification, admissibility of input tax credit, tax liability, registration or whether an activity is a supply - The question is not maintainable and no ruling can be given on this issue – Ordered accordingly - Availment, Utilisation and Reversal of Input Tax Credit - Whether the Applicant is entitled to avail and utilise eligible input tax credit towards GST on the taxable outward supply of development services - HELD - The Applicant makes a taxable outward supply of development services to the landowners and is liable to discharge GST on such supply under the forward charge mechanism. Section 16 entitles a registered person to avail input tax credit on goods or services used or intended to be used in the course or furtherance of business, subject to the conditions and restrictions prescribed. Section 49 permits utilisation of the balance in the electronic credit ledger towards payment of output tax. Since the eligible input tax credit is available for utilisation towards output tax, the question of its reversal does not arise. Any ineligible input tax credit shall be reversed in accordance with the Act and the Rules - The Applicant is entitled to avail and utilise eligible input tax credit subject to Sections 16 and 17, and no reversal of eligible credit is required. [Read less]

2026-VIL-209-AAR  | Advance Ruling Authority SGST

GST – Karnataka AAR - Rooftop Solar Power System as ‘Plant and Machinery’ - Explanation to Section 17 of CGST Act, 2017 - The Applicant, engaged in wholesale and retail trading of grocery and general merchandise, installed a rooftop solar power system comprising solar panels, inverter and mounting structures on its shop building using bolts, screws and structural supports, capable of being dismantled and relocated, and surplus electricity is injected into the grid under a net-metering arrangement - Whether the rooftop solar power system with installation and commissioning constitutes plant and machinery used in the b... [Read more]

GST – Karnataka AAR - Rooftop Solar Power System as ‘Plant and Machinery’ - Explanation to Section 17 of CGST Act, 2017 - The Applicant, engaged in wholesale and retail trading of grocery and general merchandise, installed a rooftop solar power system comprising solar panels, inverter and mounting structures on its shop building using bolts, screws and structural supports, capable of being dismantled and relocated, and surplus electricity is injected into the grid under a net-metering arrangement - Whether the rooftop solar power system with installation and commissioning constitutes plant and machinery used in the business - HELD - The Explanation to Section 17 defines ‘plant and machinery’ as apparatus, equipment and machinery fixed to earth by foundation or structural support that are used for making outward supply of goods or services, but excludes land, building or other civil structures. A rooftop solar power system is an integrated system with an independent functional identity and utility, and its support on the rooftop by bolts, screws or other structural supports does not make it a part of the building or a civil structure. The expression ‘fixed to earth by foundation or structural support’ does not require the apparatus to be permanently embedded in the earth or incapable of removal, as the definition itself recognises structural support as a means of fixing – The occasional surplus generation injected into the grid does not alter the essential character of the system or convert it into a commercial power-generation plant established principally for making outward supplies of electricity - The rooftop solar power system, including the solar panels, inverter, mounting structures and associated components, qualifies as plant and machinery – Ordered accordingly - Input Tax Credit on Erection, Installation and Commissioning - Section 17(5)(d) and Section 16 of CGST Act, 2017 - Whether the Applicant is eligible for input tax credit on inputs, input services and capital goods used in the erection, installation and commissioning of the rooftop solar power system - HELD - Section 17(5)(d) restricts input tax credit on goods or services received for construction of an immovable property, other than plant or machinery, on own account. The inward supplies relate to the erection of a system held to be plant and machinery, which is not itself the land, building or civil structure on which it is installed, so the restriction cannot be invoked merely because the system is installed on the rooftop or uses structural supports. The inward supplies have a nexus with the business and satisfy Section 16(1), but the finding does not confer an unconditional right to credit, and the conditions of Section 16(2), the time limit for availment and the restriction under Section 16(3) on depreciation continue to apply - Surplus electricity injected under net metering does not sever the nexus with the business, and any question of apportionment or reversal under Section 17(2) and Rules 42 and 43 requires separate examination. The ruling is confined to the erection, installation and commissioning, and no finding is recorded on repair or maintenance expenditure - The Applicant is eligible to avail input tax credit on the inputs, input services and capital goods used in the erection, installation and commissioning of the system, subject to the conditions and restrictions of Section 16 and other applicable provisions – Ordered accordingly [Read less]

2026-VIL-204-AAR  | Advance Ruling Authority SGST

GST – Karnataka AAR - Classification of Kulfi - Heading 0404 or Heading 2105 of Customs Tariff - The Applicant proposed to manufacture and retail kulfi, a product prepared by heating milk until it is reduced in volume, adding sugar, flavouring agents and dry fruits, and freezing the mixture - The Applicant contended that kulfi retains the essential character of a milk product due to the predominant use of milk and merits classification under Heading 0404 - Whether kulfi prepared from milk and sugar, with or without dry fruits, is classifiable under Heading 0404 as a product consisting of natural milk constituents or unde... [Read more]

GST – Karnataka AAR - Classification of Kulfi - Heading 0404 or Heading 2105 of Customs Tariff - The Applicant proposed to manufacture and retail kulfi, a product prepared by heating milk until it is reduced in volume, adding sugar, flavouring agents and dry fruits, and freezing the mixture - The Applicant contended that kulfi retains the essential character of a milk product due to the predominant use of milk and merits classification under Heading 0404 - Whether kulfi prepared from milk and sugar, with or without dry fruits, is classifiable under Heading 0404 as a product consisting of natural milk constituents or under Heading 2105 00 00 as ice cream and other edible ice - HELD - GST classification is aligned with the HSN, and the tariff item, sub-heading, heading and Chapter carry the same meaning as in the First Schedule to the Customs Tariff Act, 1975, read with the Rules for Interpretation. Heading 0404 covers products which are essentially natural milk constituents, retaining the basic character of milk with minimal or no processing, and the expression not elsewhere specified or included restricts it to products not classifiable under a more specific heading. Kulfi is not a mere milk derivative since the process of heating, concentration, addition of ingredients and freezing results in a new and distinct product with a different character, use and identity - Classification cannot be determined solely on the predominant ingredient, because otherwise ice cream and frozen desserts, which are largely milk-based, would fall under Chapter 04 and render Heading 2105 redundant. The identity, character and use of the finished product are of greater significance than the ingredients. Applying the common parlance test, kulfi is not purchased as a milk constituent but is known, sold and consumed as a ready-to-eat frozen dessert in the same manner as ice cream - The expression other edible ice in Heading 2105 is of wide import and covers frozen edible products of a similar nature. Under Rule 3(a) of the General Rules for Interpretation, the heading providing the more specific description is to be preferred, and a specific entry prevails over a general entry - Kulfi is classifiable under Tariff Heading 2105 00 00 and not under Heading 0404 – Ordered accordingly [Read less]

2026-VIL-206-AAR  | Advance Ruling Authority SGST

GST - Karnataka AAR - Classification of Cashew Nut Shell Liquid - Heading 1302 of Customs Tariff and Notification No. 09/2025-Central Tax (Rate) - The Applicant manufactures crude Cashew Nut Shell Liquid by extraction from cashew nut shells through heating and mechanical expulsion, and supplies it for industrial applications such as resins, coatings and friction materials - Applicant classified the product under Heading 1302 and contended that the concessional rate in the amended rate notification applies to the entire heading without restriction to any sub-heading - Whether Cashew Nut Shell Liquid is classifiable under He... [Read more]

GST - Karnataka AAR - Classification of Cashew Nut Shell Liquid - Heading 1302 of Customs Tariff and Notification No. 09/2025-Central Tax (Rate) - The Applicant manufactures crude Cashew Nut Shell Liquid by extraction from cashew nut shells through heating and mechanical expulsion, and supplies it for industrial applications such as resins, coatings and friction materials - Applicant classified the product under Heading 1302 and contended that the concessional rate in the amended rate notification applies to the entire heading without restriction to any sub-heading - Whether Cashew Nut Shell Liquid is classifiable under Heading 1302 of the Customs Tariff and liable to GST at the concessional rate prescribed for that heading - HELD - The tariff item, sub-heading, heading and Chapter in the rate notification carry the same meaning as in the First Schedule to the Customs Tariff Act, 1975, and classification is determined on the nature and composition of the product, the degree of processing and the essential character - Chapter 08 covers only cashew nuts in natural or minimally processed form and does not cover a derivative extracted from the shell. Chapter 20 requires the product to be fit for human consumption, and the product is non-edible and used for industrial purposes. Chapter 15 covers edible oils, and the product contains toxic phenolic compounds and cannot be treated as edible oil. Heading 1302 specifically covers vegetable saps and extracts, and Tariff Item 1302 19 20 specifically covers Cashew Nut Shell Liquid, crude. The Explanatory Notes include cashew nutshell extract and exclude only its polymers under Heading 3911 - The product is obtained by mechanical and thermal extraction without chemical modification or polymerisation, so Heading 3911 is not applicable. Serial No. 74 of Schedule I to the rate notification refers to Heading 1302 without restricting it to any sub-heading, so it covers all goods falling under that heading, including the product - Cashew Nut Shell Liquid is classifiable under HSN 1302 19 20 and is liable to the 5% GST rate prescribed under Serial No. 74 of Schedule I to Notification No. 9/2025-Central Tax (Rate), effective from 22.09.2025 – Ordered accordingly [Read less]

2026-VIL-207-AAR  | Advance Ruling Authority SGST

GST – Karnataka AAR - Exemption to Non-Profit Entity on Membership Fee - Serial No. 77A of Notification No. 12/2017-Central Tax (Rate) - The Applicant, a non-profit entity registered under Section 12AA of the Income Tax Act, 1961 and established by the State Government, implements and administers a healthcare scheme for members of co-operative societies, providing cashless treatment through empanelled hospitals against payment of an annual membership fee, with an additional fee for additional family members - Whether the Applicant is eligible for the exemption under Serial No. 77A in respect of the annual subscription co... [Read more]

GST – Karnataka AAR - Exemption to Non-Profit Entity on Membership Fee - Serial No. 77A of Notification No. 12/2017-Central Tax (Rate) - The Applicant, a non-profit entity registered under Section 12AA of the Income Tax Act, 1961 and established by the State Government, implements and administers a healthcare scheme for members of co-operative societies, providing cashless treatment through empanelled hospitals against payment of an annual membership fee, with an additional fee for additional family members - Whether the Applicant is eligible for the exemption under Serial No. 77A in respect of the annual subscription collected from members - HELD - Serial No. 77A exempts services provided by an unincorporated body or a non-profit entity registered under any law, engaged in the specified activities, to its own members against a membership fee up to the prescribed limit per member per year. The Applicant is a non-profit entity registered under Section 12AA/12AB, so the first condition is satisfied. The expression social welfare is not defined in the Act or the notification and must be interpreted in its ordinary, natural and purposive sense - Implementation of a healthcare scheme for economically vulnerable sections is aligned with the constitutional objectives of Articles 38, 41 and 47, the Applicant is not engaged in any commercial or profit-oriented activity, and the membership fee is merely incidental to the administration of the scheme. A provision intended to promote public welfare must receive a broad and liberal construction, so the Applicant is engaged in the promotion of social welfare. The benefits are available only to persons enrolled as members upon payment of the fee, and no services are provided to non-members - The contribution collected is in the nature of a membership fee, and when apportioned among the covered members it does not exceed the prescribed limit per member per year. The Applicant satisfies all the conditions of Serial No. 77A, and the services provided to its members are exempt from GST, subject to continued fulfilment of the conditions – Ordered accordingly [Read less]

2026-VIL-208-AAR  | Advance Ruling Authority SGST

GST – Karnataka AAR - Interest on Margin Trading Facility - Entry 27(a) of Notification No. 12/2017-Central Tax (Rate) - The Applicant, a brokerage company registered with SEBI, proposed to offer a Margin Trading Facility under which a client purchases shares by paying only part of the value, the balance is funded by the broker as a loan against pledged securities, and interest is charged per day on the funded amount from the day after the transaction until the position is cleared - Whether the interest charged to clients who avail the Margin Trading Facility is liable to GST - HELD - Money and securities are excluded fr... [Read more]

GST – Karnataka AAR - Interest on Margin Trading Facility - Entry 27(a) of Notification No. 12/2017-Central Tax (Rate) - The Applicant, a brokerage company registered with SEBI, proposed to offer a Margin Trading Facility under which a client purchases shares by paying only part of the value, the balance is funded by the broker as a loan against pledged securities, and interest is charged per day on the funded amount from the day after the transaction until the position is cleared - Whether the interest charged to clients who avail the Margin Trading Facility is liable to GST - HELD - Money and securities are excluded from the definition of goods and from the definition of services. However, the definition of services includes activities relating to the use of money for which a separate consideration is charged. Under the facility, the Applicant provides funds to clients beyond the margin available and charges interest on the amount funded, so the consideration is for the use of money by the client for a specified period and the activity is a supply of service - Entry 27(a) of the exemption notification exempts services by way of extending deposits, loans or advances in so far as the consideration is represented by way of interest or discount. The Applicant funds a portion of the purchase consideration of securities, the client is required to repay the funded amount and pay interest for the period it remains outstanding, and the transaction possesses all the attributes of a loan or advance - The interest is independent of the brokerage charged for execution of trades and represents consideration for providing finance to the client. The interest charged by the Applicant for the Margin Trading Facility is exempt from GST under Entry 27(a) of Notification No. 12/2017-Central Tax (Rate) – Ordered accordingly [Read less]

2026-VIL-1265-GUJ  | High Court SGST

GST - Excess ITC carried forward in TRAN-1 - For the period up to 30.06.2017, the Assessing Officer disallowed the ITC claimed in TRAN-1 in excess of the ITC available as per the assessment order under the Gujarat VAT Act, 2003 and raised demand of tax with interest, which the FAA confirmed. The Tribunal removed the demand and interest and left it open to the Revenue to take remedial action under the GST Act - Whether the Assessing Officer can raise the demand of tax and interest under the VAT Act on the excess ITC claimed in TRAN-1 - HELD - It is not in dispute that the Respondent claimed excess ITC in TRAN-1 as against t... [Read more]

GST - Excess ITC carried forward in TRAN-1 - For the period up to 30.06.2017, the Assessing Officer disallowed the ITC claimed in TRAN-1 in excess of the ITC available as per the assessment order under the Gujarat VAT Act, 2003 and raised demand of tax with interest, which the FAA confirmed. The Tribunal removed the demand and interest and left it open to the Revenue to take remedial action under the GST Act - Whether the Assessing Officer can raise the demand of tax and interest under the VAT Act on the excess ITC claimed in TRAN-1 - HELD - It is not in dispute that the Respondent claimed excess ITC in TRAN-1 as against the ITC available as per the assessment order under the VAT Act. Rule 117 of the GST Rules provides for crediting the amount specified in TRAN-1 to the electronic credit ledger. Rule 121 provides that where credit so credited is wrongly availed, wholly or partly, the GST Department may initiate proceedings under Section 73 or Section 74 of the GST Act. The Assessing Officer ought to have informed the concerned GST Department of the excess ITC, and it is for the GST Department to take action under Rule 121 - The only remedy available to the VAT Department is to inform the concerned GST officer of the wrong availment of ITC - The Tribunal was justified under the provisions of the VAT Act that the assessee was entitled to set off of the tax payable against the available ITC. There is no infirmity in the impugned order of the Tribunal – Revenue appeal is dismissed [Read less]

2026-VIL-1266-GUJ-CE  | High Court CENTRAL EXCISE

Central Excise - CENVAT credit on furnace oil used in captive power plant - Electricity supplied to Grinding Unit and Jetty - Respondent manufactures clinker and cement through a Clinker Unit and a Grinding Unit, with a captive power plant about 14 kilometers from the Clinker Unit and a captive jetty at the Grinding Unit. Respondent availed CENVAT credit on furnace oil used for generating electricity supplied to the Clinker Unit, the Grinding Unit, the jetty and the residential colony. The adjudicating authority allowed credit for the electricity supplied to the Clinker Unit but denied it for the Grinding Unit, the jetty a... [Read more]

Central Excise - CENVAT credit on furnace oil used in captive power plant - Electricity supplied to Grinding Unit and Jetty - Respondent manufactures clinker and cement through a Clinker Unit and a Grinding Unit, with a captive power plant about 14 kilometers from the Clinker Unit and a captive jetty at the Grinding Unit. Respondent availed CENVAT credit on furnace oil used for generating electricity supplied to the Clinker Unit, the Grinding Unit, the jetty and the residential colony. The adjudicating authority allowed credit for the electricity supplied to the Clinker Unit but denied it for the Grinding Unit, the jetty and the colony, and imposed penalties under Rule 15(1). The CESTAT allowed credit for the Grinding Unit and the jetty - Revenue contended that the Grinding Unit has a separate registration, is not part of the factory and was claimed as a separate entity for area-based exemption - Whether CENVAT credit on furnace oil used as input in the power plant is available to the extent the electricity is supplied to the Grinding Unit and the jetty - HELD - The CESTAT recorded findings of fact that the Clinker Unit, the Grinding Unit and the jetty are part of the manufacture of final products of the Respondent and are treated as the same factory, as all linking roads are in the possession and control of the Respondent. In such circumstances, it makes no difference to the eligibility of credit that the power plant is 14 kilometers away or that there is a distance between the units - The electricity was wheeled out only to the Clinker Unit, the Grinding Unit and the jetty, with no sale or diversion to an outsider, unlike a case where excess electricity is sold. The only irregularity was non-compliance with the prescribed procedure applicable on the principle of a job worker, and the substantial benefit of credit cannot be denied for that reason - The Respondent is entitled to CENVAT credit on the furnace oil to the extent the electricity is supplied to the Grinding Unit and the jetty - Since the Respondent was entitled to the CENVAT credit on the furnace oil to the extent the electricity was supplied to the Grinding Unit and the jetty, the very basis of the levy of penalty does not survive - The question is answered in favour of the Respondent. The Revenue appeals are dismissed [Read less]

2026-VIL-1267-GUJ-CU  | High Court CUSTOMS

Customs - Duty on auctioned damaged goods - Re-import of exported goods - The Appellant purchased in an auction from the insurance company a consignment of rubber tyres, tubes and flaps from a grounded ship, on an as is where is basis. The consignment had been exported under the DEEC scheme, and the ship had crossed territorial waters before returning and being grounded - Appellant cleared the goods by filing a Bill of Entry, and duty was demanded treating the clearance as re-import. The Appellant contended that there was no import or re-import, that the auction purchaser of deteriorated goods is not liable and that the in... [Read more]

Customs - Duty on auctioned damaged goods - Re-import of exported goods - The Appellant purchased in an auction from the insurance company a consignment of rubber tyres, tubes and flaps from a grounded ship, on an as is where is basis. The consignment had been exported under the DEEC scheme, and the ship had crossed territorial waters before returning and being grounded - Appellant cleared the goods by filing a Bill of Entry, and duty was demanded treating the clearance as re-import. The Appellant contended that there was no import or re-import, that the auction purchaser of deteriorated goods is not liable and that the insurance company is liable - Whether customs duty is payable by the Appellant on the damaged goods cleared on the basis of the Bill of Entry when the Appellant contends that there is no import or re-import - HELD - It is clear from the findings of fact of the CESTAT that the goods were exported by the exporter after availing the benefit of the DEEC scheme, so export had taken place. It is an admitted position that the Appellant cleared the goods after filing the Bill of Entry as re-import. The contention that the B/E was filed under pressure was without any basis as nothing on record showed that the Appellant was pressurised. The damaged goods, ownership of which passed to the Appellant before customs clearance after following due process, are liable to duty - The questions are answered in favour of the Revenue and the appeal is dismissed [Read less]

Create Account



Log In



Forgot Password


Please Note: This facility is only for Subscribing Members.

Email this page



Feedback this page