GST - Intermediary services or Export of services under Section 2(6) of the IGST Act – Rendering of freight forwarding, clearing and forwarding and related services to an overseas entity under a Service Agreement. Under the agreement, the Respondent handles the routing of the overseas entity's shipments in India and the expenses paid on its behalf are charged to it. The Respondent claimed refund of unutilised Input Tax Credit on export of services without payment of tax. The refund was proposed to be rejected on the ground that the Respondent is an intermediary - The FAA held in favour of the Respondent. Revenue contende... [Read more]
GST - Intermediary services or Export of services under Section 2(6) of the IGST Act – Rendering of freight forwarding, clearing and forwarding and related services to an overseas entity under a Service Agreement. Under the agreement, the Respondent handles the routing of the overseas entity's shipments in India and the expenses paid on its behalf are charged to it. The Respondent claimed refund of unutilised Input Tax Credit on export of services without payment of tax. The refund was proposed to be rejected on the ground that the Respondent is an intermediary - The FAA held in favour of the Respondent. Revenue contended that the Respondent acted as an agent and that the place of supply is in India under Section 13(8)(b) - Whether the services rendered by the Respondent to its overseas recipient qualify as export of services under Section 2(6) of the IGST Act or fall within the definition of intermediary services under Section 2(13), and whether the Respondent is eligible for refund of unutilised ITC on account of zero-rated supplies - HELD - An intermediary merely arranges or facilitates the supply between two other parties without himself supplying the main service, and the definition expressly excludes a person who supplies on his own account. The phrase ‘on behalf of’ in the agreement does not alter the character of the transaction, as the substance, the conduct of the parties and the flow of consideration establish a principal-to-principal relationship - The Respondent is not a party to any arrangement between the overseas entity and its clients, orders and payments of the clients go to the overseas entity, the Respondent negotiates no transaction, has no authority to conclude contracts and renders services using its own resources and personnel. There are only two parties and no second supply of facilitation, so the requirements of three parties and two distinct supplies under the CBIC Circular are not satisfied - The Respondent supplies the main service on its own account and the exclusionary clause in Section 2(13) applies. The place of supply is outside India under Section 13(2) and all conditions of Section 2(6) are satisfied, so the services qualify as export of services and the Respondent is entitled to the refund - The findings of the FAA are upheld and the refund is to be granted with applicable interest under Section 56 - The appeals of the Revenue are dismissed [Read less]
GST - Maintainability of departmental appeal - Monetary limit under Circular issued under Section 120 - Appellant filed an appeal under Section 112(3) against the order of the FAA which set aside a demand of tax under RCM on OIDAR services alleged to have been received from a foreign entity on the basis of an intelligence alert - Respondent contended that the disputed tax was below the monetary limit prescribed by the Circular. Appellant contended that the appeal fell within the exclusion in paragraph 4 relating to place of supply and recurring issues involving interpretation - Whether the appeal filed by the Revenue is no... [Read more]
GST - Maintainability of departmental appeal - Monetary limit under Circular issued under Section 120 - Appellant filed an appeal under Section 112(3) against the order of the FAA which set aside a demand of tax under RCM on OIDAR services alleged to have been received from a foreign entity on the basis of an intelligence alert - Respondent contended that the disputed tax was below the monetary limit prescribed by the Circular. Appellant contended that the appeal fell within the exclusion in paragraph 4 relating to place of supply and recurring issues involving interpretation - Whether the appeal filed by the Revenue is not maintainable in view of the monetary limits prescribed under the Circular - HELD - The scheme of Section 120 is regulatory and the Circular issued under it binds the departmental authorities, who cannot selectively apply its provisions. The power under Section 112(3) must be exercised in conformity with the Circular. Where the dispute pertains to demand of tax, only the aggregate disputed tax is considered for the monetary limit. Clause 4(iv)(e) cannot be read in isolation. All matters in clause 4(iv), namely valuation, classification, refunds, place of supply or any other issue, stand on the same footing and must be recurring in nature or involve interpretation. Mere statement that SCNs were issued for other years, without placing any document on record, does not establish that the issue is recurring. No interpretation of a notification is involved, as the issue is limited to the factual question whether the Respondent actually received the services. The review order ignored the Circular and failed to disclose how the case was covered by any exclusion, which wasted judicial resources. As the disputed tax is significantly below the prescribed threshold, the appeal is barred by the monetary limit. The merits of liability under RCM were not examined - The appeal is dismissed as not maintainable. [Read less]
GST - Refund of unutilised Input Tax Credit on exports under LUT - Proviso to Section 54(3)(i) of the CGST Act, 2017 - The Appellant filed refund claims of unutilised Input Tax Credit on exports made under LUT for three months. The claims were rejected on the ground that the Appellant had availed higher drawback and, as per the proviso to Section 54(3)(i), no refund is allowed if drawback in respect of Central Tax is availed - Appellant had initially believed that it claimed only the lower rate of drawback pertaining solely to Customs, but later realised that it had claimed the higher rate and paid back the entire excess d... [Read more]
GST - Refund of unutilised Input Tax Credit on exports under LUT - Proviso to Section 54(3)(i) of the CGST Act, 2017 - The Appellant filed refund claims of unutilised Input Tax Credit on exports made under LUT for three months. The claims were rejected on the ground that the Appellant had availed higher drawback and, as per the proviso to Section 54(3)(i), no refund is allowed if drawback in respect of Central Tax is availed - Appellant had initially believed that it claimed only the lower rate of drawback pertaining solely to Customs, but later realised that it had claimed the higher rate and paid back the entire excess drawback with interest - Whether the Appellant is entitled to refund of accumulated credit on account of exports under LUT when it had initially availed the higher rate of drawback instead of the lower rate and subsequently paid back the excess drawback along with interest - HELD - The declaration to be made on the shipping bill at the time of claiming drawback is that the exporter shall not claim IGST refund, but it does not stipulate that the IGST refund cannot be granted when drawback is claimed. Since the excess drawback was repaid with interest, which is not disputed, it is as good as drawback not availed as on date and there is no other reason for denying the refund – The Circular No.37/2018-Customs dated 9-10-2018 explaining the provisions of drawback has nothing to do with the IGST refund and cannot run contrary to the statutory Rule 96, under which the claim for refund can be withheld only in the two circumstances specified. Circulars cannot prevail over the statute. The plea to keep the appeals pending was not accepted as the review petition relied upon by the Respondent stood disposed of - The order in appeal is set aside and the appeals are allowed [Read less]
GST - Jurisdiction of State officers over inter-State movement of goods - Proceedings under Section 130 of the CGST Act, 2017 - Appellant is registered only in Andhra Pradesh and is engaged in manufacture and sale of gold jewellery. Its sales representatives carrying sample gold ornaments were intercepted by the Mobile Squad in Kerala. The SCN under Section 130 alleged that the goods were transported without prescribed documents and with intent to evade tax, and confiscation was confirmed - FAA dismissed the appeal holding that, in the absence of statutory documents, the officer ascertained the transaction to be intra-Stat... [Read more]
GST - Jurisdiction of State officers over inter-State movement of goods - Proceedings under Section 130 of the CGST Act, 2017 - Appellant is registered only in Andhra Pradesh and is engaged in manufacture and sale of gold jewellery. Its sales representatives carrying sample gold ornaments were intercepted by the Mobile Squad in Kerala. The SCN under Section 130 alleged that the goods were transported without prescribed documents and with intent to evade tax, and confiscation was confirmed - FAA dismissed the appeal holding that, in the absence of statutory documents, the officer ascertained the transaction to be intra-State - Appellant contended that the transaction was an inter-State supply under Section 10(1)(a) of the IGST Act and the State officers lacked jurisdiction - Whether State officers of one State can exercise jurisdiction over an assessee registered in a different State in respect of transactions undertaken in their State without issuing a temporary identification number - HELD - Where the goods originated from Andhra Pradesh and the allegation is of attempted sale in Kerala, the transaction is inter-State and is governed by the IGST Act and not the CGST or SGST Act. The officer had no clue about the nature of the transaction and by default assumed it to be intra-State without any legal basis - The SCN, the order and the order in appeal were all issued to a person registered in another State over whom the State officers had no jurisdiction, and the temporary registration was issued only later to enable filing of the appeal. No credible explanation was offered by the Respondent for the authority under which the proceedings were conducted. The Tribunal may decide an appeal on grounds not set forth in the form of appeal, provided the affected party has had a sufficient opportunity of being heard, which was given. The case is hit by the principle of coram non judice - The entire proceedings are quashed and declared non est and void ab initio - The appeal is allowedrnrnIssue 2: Section 130(1) - Failure to specify the clause in the SCN - The SCN invoked Section 130(1) without specifying the clause alleged to be contravened. Respondent contended that the notice tracks clauses (i), (ii) and (iv), that failure to cite the sub-clause does not vitiate the exercise of power and that no prejudice was alleged. Whether proceedings under Section 130(1) can be launched against a person without specifying the particular clause alleged to be contravened - HELD - Section 130(1) deals with five distinct offences which cannot be clubbed together, and natural justice demands that the taxpayer is put to notice of the specific offence charged. Failure to cite the source of power does not vitiate its exercise only where there is no ambiguity about the source of power and the purpose for which it is exercised - Where multiple interpretations are possible, the authority cannot avoid citing the provision which clarifies the scope of action. The tracking of clauses without citing them is not based on any legal principle. The Appellant addressing intent to evade in its reply or framing a ground on an assumption does not amount to waiver of its right to be informed of the specific charge. An SCN must stand on its own and cannot be improved by submissions made by the Respondent at the second appellate stage. In the absence of specific charges, the proceedings violate the principles of natural justice and are void ab initio - The appeal is allowed. [Read less]
GST - Jurisdiction of State officers over a person registered in another State - Proceedings under Section 129 - The Enforcement Squad of the State intercepted a vehicle carrying gold jewellery from Maharashtra to Kerala. Forms MOV-01 to MOV-07 and the order in Form MOV-09 under Section 129(3) were issued to the Appellant, who is registered in Maharashtra, and a temporary identification number was issued to the Appellant only later - Whether State officers could exercise jurisdiction over the Appellant before the issue of the temporary identification number - HELD - The State officers could exercise jurisdiction over the A... [Read more]
GST - Jurisdiction of State officers over a person registered in another State - Proceedings under Section 129 - The Enforcement Squad of the State intercepted a vehicle carrying gold jewellery from Maharashtra to Kerala. Forms MOV-01 to MOV-07 and the order in Form MOV-09 under Section 129(3) were issued to the Appellant, who is registered in Maharashtra, and a temporary identification number was issued to the Appellant only later - Whether State officers could exercise jurisdiction over the Appellant before the issue of the temporary identification number - HELD - The State officers could exercise jurisdiction over the Appellant only from the date of issue of the temporary identification number and all proceedings from the date of detention up to that date are non est and void ab initio. On the territorial jurisdiction issue alone, the case is hit by the principle of coram non judice. A defect of jurisdiction goes to the root of the matter and an order passed by an authority having no jurisdiction is a nullity - The entire proceedings are quashed and declared non est and void ab initio.rnrnIssue 2: Time limit for passing order for payment of penalty under Section 129(3) - Goods were detained but the order in Form MOV-09 was not issued within the period prescribed. The Appellant contended that the notice and the order were required to be issued within the timelines in Section 129(3) - Respondent contended that the timelines are directory and not mandatory - Whether an order for payment of penalty passed beyond the timelines in Section 129(3) is valid - HELD - Section 129(3) requires the proper officer to issue the notice within seven days of detention and to pass the order within seven days from the date of service of the notice. The use of the expression shall signifies that adherence to the timeline is mandatory and the Act, being a fiscal statute, is to be construed strictly - Once Constitutional courts have held a provision to be mandatory, the Tribunal cannot read it down as directory. The contents of the order, which refer to a reply filed by the recipient several months after detention, show that it was not passed within the stipulated time. The Respondent produced no record of the dates. Violation of the timeline vitiates the entire proceedings - The order is void ab initio and a nullity in law and is set aside.rnrnIssue 3: Invocation of Section 129 - Tax invoice under Section 31 read with Rule 46 - The consignment was accompanied by a delivery note describing the goods as gold jewellery for job work, while the goods were finished ornaments, and no tax invoice accompanied them - Respondent alleged absence of nexus between the goods and the documents. The Appellant contended that the description was a clerical error for gold jewellery after job work and that the goods were returned after job work - Whether Section 129 could be invoked against the Appellant for absence of a tax invoice - HELD - Section 31 applies only to supply of goods and the onus is on the Respondent to prove that the transaction is a supply. The SCN proceeded on the premise of supply without any basis and no argument was articulated that the transaction is a supply. Once it is not established to be a supply, Section 31 and Rule 46 have no application. The fact that the goods are finished ornaments does not automatically require a tax invoice. The fact that the recipient does not do job work is irrelevant as the Appellant contended that it provided job work to the recipient. The particulars in the delivery note were not refuted and the only discrepancy was in the description. Invocation of Section 129 requires contravention of the provisions of the Act or Rules to be established, which is not done here - The invocation of Section 129 is not sustainable and the case fails on merits.rnrnIssue 4: Reliance on Rule 45(1) at the appellate stage - Contravention not alleged in SCN or order - The FAA and the Respondent relied on Rule 45(1) to support the case against the Appellant. Whether contravention of Rule 45(1) can be invoked at the appellate stage - HELD - The allegation of contravention of Rule 45(1) was neither part of the SCN nor of the order-in-original. The requirements to make a notice or order valid must be contained in such notice or order and cannot be supplanted later. The attempt to invoke the Rule at the appellate stage is not sustainable - The appeal is allowed and the order in appeal is set aside. [Read less]
GST - Maintainability of Departmental appeals - Monetary limit under Circular No. 207/1/2024-GST dated 26.06.2024 issued under Section 120 - Two appeals filed by the Appellant-State arose from a composite order of the Appellate Authority disposing of two appeals relating to two financial years. The Respondent contended that the demand for each financial year was below the monetary limit prescribed by the Circular and the appeals were therefore barred. Whether the appeals are maintainable in view of the Circular - HELD - Paragraph 3(viii) of the Circular provides that in a composite order which disposes more than one appeal... [Read more]
GST - Maintainability of Departmental appeals - Monetary limit under Circular No. 207/1/2024-GST dated 26.06.2024 issued under Section 120 - Two appeals filed by the Appellant-State arose from a composite order of the Appellate Authority disposing of two appeals relating to two financial years. The Respondent contended that the demand for each financial year was below the monetary limit prescribed by the Circular and the appeals were therefore barred. Whether the appeals are maintainable in view of the Circular - HELD - Paragraph 3(viii) of the Circular provides that in a composite order which disposes more than one appeal or demand notice, the monetary limit shall be applicable on the total amount and not on the amount involved in an individual appeal or demand notice. The impugned order is a composite order disposing of two separate appeals arising from two orders pertaining to two financial years, so the aggregate tax demand in the composite order is the relevant consideration. The contention that the demand for each period falls below the limit is not sustainable in view of the express language of the clause - The appeals are held to be maintainable.rnrnIssue 2: Short payment of tax - Section 73 or Section 74 - Wilful suppression - The Respondent was engaged in composite supply of works contract services. An enquiry initiated on information from WAMIS detected short payment of tax for two financial years and the SCN proposed recovery under Section 74 read with Section 50. The Respondent did not participate before the Adjudicating Authority -e Appellate Authority re-computed the tax liability and held that there was no intention to evade tax or wilful suppression, so that penalty was leviable under Section 73 - Appellant-State contended that the failure to disclose the correct taxable turnover indicated deliberate suppression within Explanation 2 to Section 74. Whether the Appellate Authority was justified in concluding that the dispute does not fall within Section 74 in the absence of fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression of facts with intent to evade payment of tax - HELD - Section 73 applies where the default is without fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression of facts, whereas Section 74 applies where it is due to such conduct with intent to evade tax. Department must establish by clear and cogent evidence that the omission was deliberate, as mere non-payment or short payment does not by itself show intent to evade tax. In the absence of direct evidence, wilfulness has to be inferred from the surrounding facts and the conduct of the person - Respondent failed to respond to the communications and the SCN and did not appear before the Adjudicating Authority. It offered no cogent explanation even before the Tribunal - Being engaged in works contract services, it was expected to understand its statutory obligations, yet it did not correctly disclose its taxable transactions in Form GSTR-1 and its taxable turnover and tax liability in Form GSTR-3B for two financial years - Respondent deliberately and persistently misstated and suppressed its actual taxable turnover, which would have remained undetected but for the intervention of the Department. The finding of the Appellate Authority that the case should be dealt with under Section 73 is not tenable - The order of the Appellate Authority holding the invocation of Section 74 illegal is set aside, the invocation of Section 74 is restored. Tax liability determined by the Appellate Authority is sustained and the penalty and interest are to be recomputed. [Read less]
GST - Penalty on undeclared goods in transit, Documents produced after interception - Mobile Squad Officer intercepted a vehicle and the driver produced some bilties, the corresponding invoices and one e-way bill - On physical verification, a substantial quantity of hosiery, readymade apparels and other goods was found for which no invoice, bilty or e-way bill was produced - Penalty was imposed and the FAA upheld it. Appellant contended that the driver inadvertently produced only one of two bundles of documents - Whether the additional invoices and bilties produced long after interception were sufficient to establish the g... [Read more]
GST - Penalty on undeclared goods in transit, Documents produced after interception - Mobile Squad Officer intercepted a vehicle and the driver produced some bilties, the corresponding invoices and one e-way bill - On physical verification, a substantial quantity of hosiery, readymade apparels and other goods was found for which no invoice, bilty or e-way bill was produced - Penalty was imposed and the FAA upheld it. Appellant contended that the driver inadvertently produced only one of two bundles of documents - Whether the additional invoices and bilties produced long after interception were sufficient to establish the genuineness of transportation - HELD - The mere assertion that documents were available in a separate bundle does not establish that the goods found were covered by them. The driver had stated at the time of verification that he possessed no other document. The additional documents were produced much after initiation of the proceedings - The absence of buyers and sellers by itself may not invariably be sufficient to reject a transaction. However, when it is considered together with non-production of documents at interception, delayed submission, failure to establish identity and business credentials of the parties and absence of any person claiming ownership, the circumstances cast serious doubt on the explanation - Three trucks of the same transporter were intercepted on the same date and the same explanation was given in each, which does not appear natural and suggests that the goods were transported without declaration with intent to evade tax and that the documents were created as an afterthought. The Appellant failed to establish a reliable documentary link between the additional documents and the undeclared goods - The appeal is dismissed and the order of the FAA affirming the penalty is affirmedrnrnIssue 2: Jurisdiction of transit State Mobile Squad Officer - Appellant contended that mere passage of the vehicle through Uttar Pradesh did not confer jurisdiction on the Mobile Squad Officer to detain or seize the goods moving from Delhi to Madhya Pradesh - Whether the legal principles laid down by the High Court in the decision relied upon by the Appellant are applicable to the facts of the present case - HELD - Where the origin State and destination State are different and goods are moved from a third State, the officers of the transit State are empowered only to intercept and verify and to intimate the concerned authorities. The applicability of a judicial precedent must be determined by examining its material facts and comparing them with the facts of the case under consideration - In the precedent, the documents of buyers and sellers were produced contemporaneously, the parties were registered and genuine dealers, the transactions were acknowledged and reflected in their books and the destination was identifiable outside the State. In the present case, the goods were totally undeclared and transportation of undeclared goods via a transit State might cause a tax effect in the transit State. The Appellant failed to establish that the goods were genuinely destined for a place outside Uttar Pradesh, so the factual foundation for invoking the decision is not established - The decision is distinguishable and does not assist the Appellant. The appeal is dismissed [Read less]
GST - Appeal against FAA order dismissing time barred first appeal under amnesty scheme - Pre-deposit through electronic credit ledger - Appellant filed the first appeal under the amnesty scheme against an order of the proper officer. The FAA registered the appeal as defective and dismissed it as barred by limitation - Appellant had paid the pre-deposit by debit of the electronic credit ledger as the GST portal did not allow deposit of the requisite percentage through the electronic cash ledger - Respondent contended that the conditions of the scheme were not complied with - Whether the rejection of the first appeal as tim... [Read more]
GST - Appeal against FAA order dismissing time barred first appeal under amnesty scheme - Pre-deposit through electronic credit ledger - Appellant filed the first appeal under the amnesty scheme against an order of the proper officer. The FAA registered the appeal as defective and dismissed it as barred by limitation - Appellant had paid the pre-deposit by debit of the electronic credit ledger as the GST portal did not allow deposit of the requisite percentage through the electronic cash ledger - Respondent contended that the conditions of the scheme were not complied with - Whether the rejection of the first appeal as time barred under the amnesty scheme under notification no. 53/2023 solely due to the debit of pre-deposit from the electronic credit ledger instead of the electronic cash ledger is legally sustainable - HELD - Under the scheme, a time barred first appeal was admissible subject to deposit of the prescribed percentage of the disputed tax, partly through the electronic cash ledger and partly through the electronic credit ledger. Where the pre-deposit is paid through the electronic credit ledger instead of the electronic cash ledger, the appellate authority should not reject the appeal outright on hyper technical grounds - A shortfall or misallocation in the cash component of the pre-deposit is a curable defect. The FAA erred in summarily dismissing the appeal as time barred without giving the Appellant a reasonable opportunity of being heard on merit and to make good the differential cash payment or rebalance the ledger debits. The rejection solely due to the debit from the electronic credit ledger is not legally sustainable - The Appellant is granted time to pay the shortfall cash component through the electronic cash ledger and the corresponding excess in the electronic credit ledger shall be recredited. The FAA is directed to admit the first appeal and decide it afresh after hearing both sides - The appeal is allowed and the order of the FAA is set aside.rnrnIssue 2: Technical glitches on GST portal - Prejudice to statutory remedy of appeal - The Appellant could not deposit the requisite percentage of pre-deposit through the electronic cash ledger on account of a technical problem on the GST portal and debited the entire amount through the electronic credit ledger. Whether technical glitches on the GST portal impeding a taxpayer from complying strictly with ledger selection can prejudice the statutory remedy of appeal - HELD - It is a well settled principle of law that a taxpayer cannot be made to suffer due to technical glitches or system error on the official portal. Technical glitches on the GST common portal impeding a taxpayer from complying strictly with ledger selection cannot prejudice the statutory remedy of appeal - The appeal is allowed and the matter is remanded to the FAA for deciding afresh. [Read less]
GST – Sanction of Refund of IGST on exports - Section 54(3) of CGST Act, 2017 read with Rule 96 - Respondent exported goods on payment of IGST and claimed refund. It was identified as a risky exporter, and verification of its supply chain found that its suppliers were non-existent or had their registrations cancelled - Adjudicating authority rejected the refund claims under Section 16(2)(a) and (c). The FAA set aside the orders and allowed the refunds. Separately, an SCN under Section 74 was pending for denial and recovery of the same ITC - Whether the refund can be sanctioned or rejected while the Section 74 proceeding... [Read more]
GST – Sanction of Refund of IGST on exports - Section 54(3) of CGST Act, 2017 read with Rule 96 - Respondent exported goods on payment of IGST and claimed refund. It was identified as a risky exporter, and verification of its supply chain found that its suppliers were non-existent or had their registrations cancelled - Adjudicating authority rejected the refund claims under Section 16(2)(a) and (c). The FAA set aside the orders and allowed the refunds. Separately, an SCN under Section 74 was pending for denial and recovery of the same ITC - Whether the refund can be sanctioned or rejected while the Section 74 proceedings on the underlying ITC are pending - HELD - A refund of IGST on zero-rated supplies is predicated on the lawful and valid availment of the ITC used to pay the IGST, governed by Section 16(2). A refund cannot be granted when the foundational ITC is disputed and is the subject of a pending demand proceeding for fraud or collusion. Sanctioning the refund while the Section 74 proceedings are underway is premature and jeopardises the interest of the Revenue - FAA erred in allowing the refund on preliminary clearance reports. The orders rejecting the refund without waiting for the outcome of the Section 74 SCN were also procedurally flawed. The refund claims cannot be adjudicated in a vacuum and must be decided afresh on the final outcome of the Section 74 proceedings - The impugned orders are set aside and the matters are remanded with all issues open. The refund applications are to be kept in abeyance or consolidated with the Section 74 adjudication - The appeal of the Revenue is allowed by way of remand [Read less]
Service Tax - Reversal of Cenvat Credit - Notification No. 39/2009-ST - The Appellant provided job-work service for alcoholic beverages and availed exemption under the notification, which requires that no Cenvat credit is taken - Demand was confirmed on the ground that the Appellant had taken Cenvat credit, and a lump sum amount based on a percentage of the value of exempted services was demanded. During the appeal, the Appellant reversed the entire credit taken on capital goods along with interest - Whether reversal of Cenvat credit with interest after the SCN, even at the Tribunal stage, satisfies the condition of the ex... [Read more]
Service Tax - Reversal of Cenvat Credit - Notification No. 39/2009-ST - The Appellant provided job-work service for alcoholic beverages and availed exemption under the notification, which requires that no Cenvat credit is taken - Demand was confirmed on the ground that the Appellant had taken Cenvat credit, and a lump sum amount based on a percentage of the value of exempted services was demanded. During the appeal, the Appellant reversed the entire credit taken on capital goods along with interest - Whether reversal of Cenvat credit with interest after the SCN, even at the Tribunal stage, satisfies the condition of the exemption notification - HELD - The notification requires that no Cenvat credit is taken, even in respect of capital goods. Reversal of the credit with interest amounts to non-availment of credit at the initial stage. The Appellant is therefore eligible for the exemption even where the reversal is made after clearance, including at the Tribunal stage – Further, a demand at a percentage of the value of exempted services cannot be sustained even if the assessee failed to opt for proportionate reversal. Rule 6(3AA) of the Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004 is a beneficial provision and has retrospective effect. The Appellant has reversed the entire credit with interest, as evidenced by challans, and no other liability arises. The impugned order is set aside and the appeal is allowed on merits - The Revenue brought no evidence that the Appellant suppressed facts with intent to evade service tax. The quantification of demand is highly disproportionate to the actual credit taken. Reversal of the entire credit with interest shows the bona fides of the Appellant. The demand for the extended period is not sustainable. The demand is also set aside as time-barred – The appeal is allowed [Read less]
GST – Branded or Unbranded product – Denial of claim of exemption on flour put up in unit container - Notification No. 1/2017-Central Tax (Rate) read with Notification Nos. 2/2017-Central Tax (Rate) and 27/2017-Central Tax (Rate) - Petitioner manufactured atta, maida and sooji sold in 50 kg bags and declared its outward supplies for 2018-19 as exempt in its returns. After audit, the proper officer issued an SCN and passed an order raising demand of tax, interest and penalty on the ground that the Petitioner sold branded products in unit containers – Petitioners contend that its goods were unbranded, that its name was... [Read more]
GST – Branded or Unbranded product – Denial of claim of exemption on flour put up in unit container - Notification No. 1/2017-Central Tax (Rate) read with Notification Nos. 2/2017-Central Tax (Rate) and 27/2017-Central Tax (Rate) - Petitioner manufactured atta, maida and sooji sold in 50 kg bags and declared its outward supplies for 2018-19 as exempt in its returns. After audit, the proper officer issued an SCN and passed an order raising demand of tax, interest and penalty on the ground that the Petitioner sold branded products in unit containers – Petitioners contend that its goods were unbranded, that its name was printed on the packages under the Legal Metrology law, and that no affidavit was required before the Commissioner of State Tax - Whether the Petitioner is entitled to exemption under Notification No. 2/2017-Central Tax (Rate) read with Notification No. 27/2017 - HELD -The petitioner is manufacturer/seller of atta, maida and sooji, put up in unit container (50 kg bag) which as per Notification No. 01/2017-Central Tax (Rate) dated 28.06.2017, is covered by Sl. No. 54, Tariff item 1101 Schedule I and attracts rate 5% GST - The exemption entry excludes flour put up in a unit container bearing a registered brand name. Notification No. 27/2017 extended the entry to goods bearing a brand name on which an actionable claim or enforceable right is available. The exception applies only where such right is voluntarily foregone by filing an affidavit with the jurisdictional Commissioner and printing a declaration on each unit container in indelible ink - The matching State notification specifically requires the affidavit to be filed with the jurisdictional Commissioner of State Tax, so the contention that no such affidavit was required fails - The name of the Petitioner as manufacturer was printed three times on the bag, which falls within the definition of brand name - Printing the name and address under Rule 6 of the Legal Metrology (Packaged Commodities) Rules, 2011 further strengthens the case of the Revenue. The brand was known locally for decades, and transfer of the company between owners does not end the brand – Further, no affidavit was filed and the Petitioner has not challenged Notification No. 27/2017 - The petitioner is liable to pay tax at 5% and is not entitled to exemption - The order is not interfered with and the writ application is dismissedrnrnIssue 2: Audit under Section 65 and proceedings under Section 73 of CGST Act, 2017 - The audit authority had recommended only proceedings under Section 47 for non-filing of GSTR-9C. The Petitioner contended that the notice was issued in contravention of Section 65(7) - Whether proceedings under Section 73 could be initiated on the basis of the audit - HELD - The Petitioner has misunderstood Sections 65 and 73. Section 73 is a standalone provision which can be invoked separately when it appears to the proper officer that there is escapement of tax, erroneous refund or wrongful claim of ITC. An audit under Section 65 is conducted by the Commissioner or an officer authorised by him. Where the audit detects non-payment or short payment of tax, the proper officer may initiate proceedings under Section 73 or 74. The recommendation of the audit may or may not bind the proper officer. The proper officer initiated the proceedings under Section 73 after taking cue from the audit report. The contention is rejected. [Read less]
An adjudication order passed by the Proper Officer under Section 73 is a quasi-judicial determination of liability and cannot be converted into or treated as a show cause notice, which initiates the adjudicatory process.\r\n\r\nSection 75(7) bars the Proper Officer from confirming tax, interest and penalty in the adjudication order in excess of the amount specified in the SCN or on grounds other than those specified in the notice.
Central Excise - CENVAT credit on service tax paid on compensation for short off-take of gas - Rule 2(l) of the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004 - Appellant procured natural gas, used as an input in the manufacture of motor vehicles, under an agreement requiring minimum monthly off-take failing which a penalty was payable. The Appellant defaulted for several years and paid compensation for short off-take as per mutual understanding with the supplier, which paid service tax on it as a declared service of tolerating an act or situation - The Appellant took credit of the service tax, which the Revenue denied it alleging that no inpu... [Read more]
Central Excise - CENVAT credit on service tax paid on compensation for short off-take of gas - Rule 2(l) of the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004 - Appellant procured natural gas, used as an input in the manufacture of motor vehicles, under an agreement requiring minimum monthly off-take failing which a penalty was payable. The Appellant defaulted for several years and paid compensation for short off-take as per mutual understanding with the supplier, which paid service tax on it as a declared service of tolerating an act or situation - The Appellant took credit of the service tax, which the Revenue denied it alleging that no input service was availed - Whether the Appellant is eligible for CENVAT credit of service tax paid on compensation for short off-take of gas - HELD - The Revenue sought to deny credit solely on the ground that the declared service does not qualify as an input service. The definition of input service under Rule 2(l) comprises the means part and the inclusive part, and the inclusive part permits credit on services used in relation to procurement of inputs. The penal amount paid is undoubtedly in relation to the procurement of goods. If the Appellant did not procure natural gas there would have been no occasion to pay the penal amount and the service tax on it. The penalty was therefore paid in the course of services availed for procurement of inputs - The Revenue has not disputed payment of service tax by the supplier, and having accepted that the supplier rendered the service, it cannot say that the Appellant has not received any service. Denial of credit at the recipient's end cannot be justified when payment of service tax at the service provider's end is not disputed - The impugned order is set aside and the appeal is allowed [Read less]
GST - Denial of Input Tax Credit - Section 16(2)(c) of CGST Act, 2017 - Appellant claimed ITC on inward supplies from a supplier who did not file GSTR-3B for any period of the year - The adjudicating authority denied the ITC and FAA confirmed the demand and enhanced the interest - Appellant contended that a bonafide recipient should not be denied ITC for the supplier's failure to deposit tax - Whether ITC is available to a bonafide recipient where the supplier has not deposited the tax - HELD - The entitlement to ITC operates on the statutory assumption that the tax collected by the supplier has been remitted to the Govern... [Read more]
GST - Denial of Input Tax Credit - Section 16(2)(c) of CGST Act, 2017 - Appellant claimed ITC on inward supplies from a supplier who did not file GSTR-3B for any period of the year - The adjudicating authority denied the ITC and FAA confirmed the demand and enhanced the interest - Appellant contended that a bonafide recipient should not be denied ITC for the supplier's failure to deposit tax - Whether ITC is available to a bonafide recipient where the supplier has not deposited the tax - HELD - The entitlement to ITC operates on the statutory assumption that the tax collected by the supplier has been remitted to the Government. Credit is reflected in the electronic credit ledger only upon such payment. Unless the tax is deposited, the recipient cannot claim ITC as a matter of right - The decisions relied on by the Appellant relate to the Delhi VAT Act, under which credit was confined within the originating State. The GST regime is destination based and requires strict compliance, as the tax paid on inter-State supplies is transferred to the destination State under Section 53. The recipient is not without recourse, as it may pursue remedies against the supplier and the Government may recover the unpaid tax from the defaulting supplier - The principle of double taxation is not attracted. The plea regarding Rule 37A is not acceptable. The registration of the supplier was cancelled and no revocation was sought, so the case falls within the exceptions where recovery from the supplier is not possible - The appeal has no merit and the demand is upheld – However, the Adjudicating Authority did not follow Rule 88B(3) of the WBGST/CGST Rules, 2017 in calculating interest. The Proper Officer is directed to calculate the interest afresh in terms of Rule 88B(3) - The appeal is disposed of [Read less]
GST - Penalty for expiry of E-way Bill - Section 129 of CGST Act, 2017 read with Rule 138 - A vehicle carrying goods was intercepted about 13 hours after the validity of the E-way Bill had expired, and the E-way Bill was not extended. The goods were seized and penalty was imposed under Section 129. The FAA set aside the penalty – Respondent-assessee submitted that the delay was due to a vehicle breakdown caused by road blockage from election rallies and that there was no intention to evade tax - Whether non-renewal of the E-way Bill within the prescribed time attracts penalty under Section 129 even where there is no inte... [Read more]
GST - Penalty for expiry of E-way Bill - Section 129 of CGST Act, 2017 read with Rule 138 - A vehicle carrying goods was intercepted about 13 hours after the validity of the E-way Bill had expired, and the E-way Bill was not extended. The goods were seized and penalty was imposed under Section 129. The FAA set aside the penalty – Respondent-assessee submitted that the delay was due to a vehicle breakdown caused by road blockage from election rallies and that there was no intention to evade tax - Whether non-renewal of the E-way Bill within the prescribed time attracts penalty under Section 129 even where there is no intention to evade tax - HELD - The mere expiration of an E-way Bill does not automatically imply an intention to evade tax when the transit delay is caused by road blockages beyond the control of the taxpayer. Election canvassing was at its peak in the region, so a breakdown of the vehicle cannot be ruled out - A delay of about 13 hours appears to have occurred naturally. Nothing on record shows any attempt or intention to evade tax, and the Revenue failed to establish such intention. Technical lapses without financial implication do not justify penal action. The order of the FAA setting aside the penalty is justified. The appeal of the Revenue is dismissedrnrnIssue 2: Assessee Appel - Power of First Appellate Authority to impose penalty - Section 107(11) of CGST Act, 2017 - While setting aside the penalty, the FAA imposed a fresh penalty on the Appellant under Section 122(1)(xiv) read with Section 20 of the IGST Act. The Appellant contended that the FAA lacked the power to do so - Whether the FAA could impose such penalty without notice - HELD - Section 107(11) empowers the Appellate Authority to confirm, modify or annul the order appealed against. An order enhancing a penalty cannot be passed unless the appellant has been given a reasonable opportunity of showing cause. No such opportunity was given to the Appellant. The law does not authorise the FAA to impose penalty arbitrarily without a hearing. The imposition is not justified due to non-compliance with Section 107(11). The penalty is set aside and the appeal of the assessee is allowed [Read less]
GST - Composition scheme - Cum-tax value of supplies - Section 15 of CGST Act, 2017 read with Rule 35 - The Appellant registered under the composition scheme, continued to pay tax at the composition rate in FY 2019-20 although its turnover in the preceding year exceeded the threshold limit - SCN under Section 73 demanded tax at the normal rate on the declared turnover. The FAA re-determined the liability by treating the invoice value as inclusive of tax under Rule 35 - The Revenue filed a cross-objection against the re-determination - Whether re-determination of tax liability by treating the value as cum-tax is legally per... [Read more]
GST - Composition scheme - Cum-tax value of supplies - Section 15 of CGST Act, 2017 read with Rule 35 - The Appellant registered under the composition scheme, continued to pay tax at the composition rate in FY 2019-20 although its turnover in the preceding year exceeded the threshold limit - SCN under Section 73 demanded tax at the normal rate on the declared turnover. The FAA re-determined the liability by treating the invoice value as inclusive of tax under Rule 35 - The Revenue filed a cross-objection against the re-determination - Whether re-determination of tax liability by treating the value as cum-tax is legally permissible - HELD - Under Section 10, eligibility for the Composition scheme depends on the aggregate turnover of the preceding financial year. As the turnover of the preceding year exceeded the threshold limit, the Appellant became a regular taxpayer from 01.04.2019. Applying the normal rate directly on the declared turnover is flawed because a composition dealer is prohibited under Section 10(4) from collecting tax from customers - The gross consideration received must therefore be treated as inclusive of tax, and the cum-tax benefit is available under Section 15(1) read with Rule 35. Where the status of a composition dealer is retrospectively changed, the values of supplies already realised cannot be altered to add tax on top - The FAA correctly applied the formula under Rule 35 and deducted the tax already paid under the composition scheme. There is no fallacy in this approach and the cross-objection of the Revenue is dismissedrnrnIssue 2: Input Tax Credit on inward supplies - Section 16(4) and Section 16(5) of CGST Act, 2017 - The Appellant claimed ITC on inward supplies received in FY 2019-20 in its reply to the SCN, as it had become a regular taxpayer retrospectively - Both authorities rejected the claim - Whether the Appellant can claim ITC on inward supplies of FY 2019-20 - HELD - A regular taxpayer cannot claim ITC after the due date for filing the return for September of the succeeding financial year. The time limit under Section 16(4) is not merely procedural or directory, and late fee or a delayed GSTR-3B does not cure the time bar. Section 16(5) protects ITC for FY 2017-18 to FY 2020-21 only if the return in Form GSTR-3B was furnished by 30.11.2021 - The Appellant filed only composition returns and no such return claiming the credit up to that date. It cannot register a fresh claim through its reply to the SCN. The law does not revive a lapsed timeline for claiming ITC upon retrospective conversion to a regular taxpayer. The Appellant did not plead that it was impossible to claim ITC, so its request to adjust the ITC against the liability as a computational relief cannot be accepted. The denial of ITC is upheld.rnrnIssue 3: Input Tax Credit on stock - Section 18(1)(c) and Section 18(2) of CGST Act, 2017 - The Appellant claimed ITC on stock held on 31.03.2019 on becoming a regular taxpayer - Whether ITC on stock held can be claimed - HELD - Section 18(1)(c) entitles a person who ceases to pay tax under the composition scheme to take credit of input tax on inputs held in stock on the day immediately preceding the date of becoming liable to pay normal tax. As the switch over date shifts retrospectively to 01.04.2019, the Appellant was eligible on stock held on 31.03.2019. However, Section 18(2) bars ITC after the expiry of one year from the date of issue of the tax invoice - The invoices for stock held on 31.03.2019 would be dated March 2019 or earlier, so the one-year window closed by March 2020. The issue of the SCN in 2024 cannot serve to claim ITC after the window had closed. The denial of ITC on stock is upheld.rnrnIssue 4: Interest on delayed payment - Section 50 of CGST Act, 2017 - The Appellant pleaded bona fide belief that the composition scheme applied and sought to avoid interest - Whether interest is payable - HELD - Interest under Section 50 is inevitably payable on account of delayed payment to the exchequer. The plea of bona fide belief does not waive the interest. The department has correctly worked out the interest on the revised net differential tax. The order of the FAA is affirmed to this extent.rnrnIssue 5: Penalty - Section 73 and Section 125 of CGST Act, 2017 - Penalty under Section 73 and a general penalty under Section 125 were imposed. The Appellant pleaded that the mistake was bona fide and inadvertent - Whether the penalties are sustainable - HELD - The Appellant was aware that its turnover of the preceding year had exceeded the threshold limit. It continued as a composition dealer in disregard of law and did not disclose its true status. It is therefore liable to be penalised, and the penalty under Section 73 was rightly imposed by the FAA. A general penalty under Section 125 is not warranted in view of Section 125 itself and Section 75(13), and it is set aside. The order of the FAA is upheld with this modification and the appeal of the Appellant is dismissed. [Read less]
Customs - Continuation of suspension of Customs Broker licence - Regulation 16 of CBLR, 2018 - DRI Offence Report alleged that the credentials of the Customs Broker were made available to unauthorised persons, resulting in filing of a Bill of Entry for a consignment containing restricted goods concealed against the declared goods - Principal Commissioner suspended the licence with immediate effect under Regulation 16(1) and continued the suspension under Regulation 16(2) pending inquiry under Regulation 17 - Appellant contended that the suspension was contrary to the timeline in Circular No. 9/2010-Cus dated 08.04.2010, wh... [Read more]
Customs - Continuation of suspension of Customs Broker licence - Regulation 16 of CBLR, 2018 - DRI Offence Report alleged that the credentials of the Customs Broker were made available to unauthorised persons, resulting in filing of a Bill of Entry for a consignment containing restricted goods concealed against the declared goods - Principal Commissioner suspended the licence with immediate effect under Regulation 16(1) and continued the suspension under Regulation 16(2) pending inquiry under Regulation 17 - Appellant contended that the suspension was contrary to the timeline in Circular No. 9/2010-Cus dated 08.04.2010, which is mandatorily binding on the department - Whether the suspension order issued beyond the time limit prescribed in the Circular is valid and whether continuation of the suspension can be sustained - HELD - Under Regulation 16(1), the suspension order with immediate effect is to be passed within fifteen days from the date of receipt of the Offence Report. The timeline prescribed in Circular No. 9/2010-Cus is mandatory in nature, and a suspension order issued in violation of the timeline is bad in law. The Offence Report was received on 27.07.2026, so the suspension order should have been issued on or before 11.08.2026, whereas it was issued only on 20.08.2026. The order of suspension having been issued beyond the time limit is void ab initio, and the subsequent order continuing the suspension under Regulation 16(2) is also not sustainable. The order is set aside only on account of the procedural infraction and no opinion is expressed on the merits of the case or the evidence available to implicate the Appellant - The order continuing the suspension is set aside and the appeal is allowed [Read less]
Service Tax - Advertising Agency Service - Section 65(105)(e) of Finance Act, 1994 - Appellant canvassed advertisements for print and visual media on behalf of clients, paid the balance to the media after retaining a commission and discharged service tax on that commission - Respondent held that the activities were classifiable as Advertising Agency Service since the Appellant was an accredited advertising agency and the financial records showed printing and creative work charges - Whether the services of canvassing advertisements for print and visual media on commission basis are classifiable under Advertising Agency Serv... [Read more]
Service Tax - Advertising Agency Service - Section 65(105)(e) of Finance Act, 1994 - Appellant canvassed advertisements for print and visual media on behalf of clients, paid the balance to the media after retaining a commission and discharged service tax on that commission - Respondent held that the activities were classifiable as Advertising Agency Service since the Appellant was an accredited advertising agency and the financial records showed printing and creative work charges - Whether the services of canvassing advertisements for print and visual media on commission basis are classifiable under Advertising Agency Service - HELD - Circular dated 23.08.2007 clarifies that merely canvassing advertisements for publishing on commission basis is not classifiable under Section 65(105)(e). The Appellant undertook services of procuring the sale of space for advertisement in print and visual media and acted as a mediator between clients and the broadcaster for a commission. Other activities undertaken by the Appellant were not placed on record except for the statement that the financial records show amounts under printing and creative work charges. The media are not clients of the advertising agency, and the discount given by the media has nothing to do with the amount received from the clients. The Appellant cannot be considered an Advertising Agency as clarified by the Board - The demand on Advertising Agency Service is set aside.rnrnIssue 2: Eligibility to Cenvat Credit - Rule 14 of Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004 - Credit availed on invoices relating to advertisement charges was disallowed for non-production of documents, on the ground that a service of larger value cannot be an input service for a service of smaller value - Whether the Appellant is eligible to cenvat credit on advertisement charges paid to the media - HELD - The breakup of the total cenvat credit availed is not available on record to find out whether it includes advertisement charges paid to the publisher. Invoices issued by the Appellant to the advertisers on the amount received from them make the Appellant eligible for cenvat credit. Where the invoices are issued in the name of the Appellant by the broadcaster, the Appellant is not eligible for cenvat credit - The matter is remanded to find out whether ineligible credit was claimed on invoices issued by the broadcaster or print media addressed to the Appellant as an agent of the advertiser. Demand is to be confirmed only on such amount and only for the normal period.rnrn rnrnIssue 3: Extended Period of Limitation and Penalty - Section 78 of Finance Act, 1994 and Rule 15 of Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004 - Demand and penalty on disallowance of cenvat credit were confirmed by invoking the extended period - Whether the demand and penalty on disallowance of cenvat credit are sustainable by invoking the extended period - HELD - The SCN proposed penalty under Rule 15A of Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004. There was clear absence of invocation of Rule 15(3) of Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004 and Section 78 of Finance Act, 1994 alleging fraud, collusion, wilful mis-statement or suppression of facts or contravention of the Rules or the Act. Demand confirmed and penalty imposed on disallowance of cenvat credit by invoking the extended period is unsustainable - The demand and penalty by invoking the extended period are set aside [Read less]
GST - Condonation of delay - Section 107(4) of the CGST Act, 2017 - Respondent defaulted in furnishing returns for a continuous period of six months, and its registration was cancelled with retrospective effect under Section 29(2)(c) without any application for revocation being filed - Respondent filed an appeal before the FAA after the period prescribed by Section 107(1) and beyond the further period condonable under Section 107(4). The FAA condoned the delay on condition of payment of all outstanding tax, interest, penalties and late fees – Revenue-Appellant contended that the FAA had no jurisdiction to condone delay b... [Read more]
GST - Condonation of delay - Section 107(4) of the CGST Act, 2017 - Respondent defaulted in furnishing returns for a continuous period of six months, and its registration was cancelled with retrospective effect under Section 29(2)(c) without any application for revocation being filed - Respondent filed an appeal before the FAA after the period prescribed by Section 107(1) and beyond the further period condonable under Section 107(4). The FAA condoned the delay on condition of payment of all outstanding tax, interest, penalties and late fees – Revenue-Appellant contended that the FAA had no jurisdiction to condone delay beyond the maximum period prescribed - Whether the FAA was justified in condoning the delay in preferring the appeal beyond the maximum condonable period prescribed under Section 107(4) - HELD - The FAA is a creature of the statute and must act within the four corners of the enactment, and the limits prescribed under Section 107 are mandatory in nature. The judgments of the High Court were rendered in exercise of Constitutional jurisdiction under Article 226 on the facts peculiar to those proceedings, and cannot be construed as laying down any general proposition enlarging the jurisdiction of the FAA under Section 107(4) - Equity follows the law and cannot be invoked by a statutory authority to override an express legislative prescription, so the delay cannot be extended on considerations of hardship, equity or substantial justice - The FAA exceeded the bounds of its statutory jurisdiction and exercised a power ultra vires Section 107 - The FAA was not justified in condoning the delay beyond the period permissible under Section 107(4) - However, the Department, by giving effect to the impugned order and facilitating the restoration of the respondent’s GST registration, has itself acted on the relief it now seeks to challenge - No effective relief can be granted to the Department even if its objections on limitation are accepted in principle - The appeal has become infructuous and is disposed of as not maintainablernrnIssue 2: Maintainability of Department's appeal - Implementation of impugned order of the FAA - The Department had acted upon the order of the FAA by restoring the registration of the Respondent, who has since continued to carry on business and file returns. The Department challenged the same order on the ground of limitation - Whether the appeal preferred by the Department is maintainable when it has already acted upon and implemented the impugned order by revoking the cancellation of registration - HELD - Having implemented the order and altered the legal and commercial position of the Respondent, the Department cannot seek to invalidate the same order without addressing the consequences of its own action - Allowing the appeal would make the restored registration liable to cancellation again, including with retrospective effect, and imperil the genuine transactions undertaken by the Respondent in the intervening period. Allowing the Department to attack an order it implemented would be unfair and run counter to established principles of estoppel and orderly administration. No effective relief can be granted to the Department even if its objections on limitation are accepted in principle - The appeal has become infructuous and is disposed of as not maintainable. [Read less]
GST - Condonation of delay - Section 107(4) of the CGST Act, 2017 - Respondent defaulted in furnishing returns for a continuous period of six months, and its registration was cancelled with retrospective effect under Section 29(2)(c) without any application for revocation being filed - Respondent filed an appeal before the FAA after the period prescribed by Section 107(1) and beyond the further period condonable under Section 107(4). The FAA condoned the delay on condition of payment of all outstanding tax, interest, penalties and late fees – Revenue-Appellant contended that the FAA had no jurisdiction to condone delay b... [Read more]
GST - Condonation of delay - Section 107(4) of the CGST Act, 2017 - Respondent defaulted in furnishing returns for a continuous period of six months, and its registration was cancelled with retrospective effect under Section 29(2)(c) without any application for revocation being filed - Respondent filed an appeal before the FAA after the period prescribed by Section 107(1) and beyond the further period condonable under Section 107(4). The FAA condoned the delay on condition of payment of all outstanding tax, interest, penalties and late fees – Revenue-Appellant contended that the FAA had no jurisdiction to condone delay beyond the maximum period prescribed - Whether the FAA was justified in condoning the delay in preferring the appeal beyond the maximum condonable period prescribed under Section 107(4) - HELD - The FAA is a creature of the statute and must act within the four corners of the enactment, and the limits prescribed under Section 107 are mandatory in nature. The judgments of the High Court were rendered in exercise of Constitutional jurisdiction under Article 226 on the facts peculiar to those proceedings, and cannot be construed as laying down any general proposition enlarging the jurisdiction of the FAA under Section 107(4) - Equity follows the law and cannot be invoked by a statutory authority to override an express legislative prescription, so the delay cannot be extended on considerations of hardship, equity or substantial justice - The FAA exceeded the bounds of its statutory jurisdiction and exercised a power ultra vires Section 107 - The FAA was not justified in condoning the delay beyond the period permissible under Section 107(4) - However, the Department, by giving effect to the impugned order and facilitating the restoration of the respondent’s GST registration, has itself acted on the relief it now seeks to challenge - No effective relief can be granted to the Department even if its objections on limitation are accepted in principle - The appeal has become infructuous and is disposed of as not maintainablernrnIssue 2: Maintainability of Department's appeal - Implementation of impugned order of the FAA - The Department had acted upon the order of the FAA by restoring the registration of the Respondent, who has since continued to carry on business and file returns. The Department challenged the same order on the ground of limitation - Whether the appeal preferred by the Department is maintainable when it has already acted upon and implemented the impugned order by revoking the cancellation of registration - HELD - Having implemented the order and altered the legal and commercial position of the Respondent, the Department cannot seek to invalidate the same order without addressing the consequences of its own action - Allowing the appeal would make the restored registration liable to cancellation again, including with retrospective effect, and imperil the genuine transactions undertaken by the Respondent in the intervening period. Allowing the Department to attack an order it implemented would be unfair and run counter to established principles of estoppel and orderly administration. No effective relief can be granted to the Department even if its objections on limitation are accepted in principle - The appeal has become infructuous and is disposed of as not maintainable. [Read less]
GST – Odisha Advance Ruling - Admission of repeat application under first proviso to Section 98(2) of CGST Act, 2017 - Applicant, a sub-contractor of an overseas platform provider, supplied user licenses to access online content to a State skill development authority. The Authority had earlier ruled on the classification and taxability of this supply and held it to be classifiable under SAC 997331. The Applicant filed a fresh application raising the same questions in respect of a later work order. Whether an application raising questions already decided in the earlier advance ruling in the Applicant's own case can be adm... [Read more]
GST – Odisha Advance Ruling - Admission of repeat application under first proviso to Section 98(2) of CGST Act, 2017 - Applicant, a sub-contractor of an overseas platform provider, supplied user licenses to access online content to a State skill development authority. The Authority had earlier ruled on the classification and taxability of this supply and held it to be classifiable under SAC 997331. The Applicant filed a fresh application raising the same questions in respect of a later work order. Whether an application raising questions already decided in the earlier advance ruling in the Applicant's own case can be admitted under the first proviso to Section 98(2) - HELD - The Authority shall not admit an application where the question raised is already pending or decided in any proceedings in the case of the Applicant. The earlier ruling was issued on the facts of the case and the contractual agreements between the parties, so the plea that it was work order specific is not sustainable. The Applicant did not establish any material change in the facts, the contractual arrangement or the applicable law. The mere filing of another application raising the same questions does not furnish a basis for reopening a determination already made. Any challenge to the correctness of the earlier ruling must be pursued through the statutory remedies available under the Act - The application is not admitted and is rejected at the admission stage. [Read less]
GST - Revocation of cancellation of registration under Rule 23(1) of the CGST Rules, 2017 - The Respondent defaulted in furnishing GSTR-3B returns for a continuous period of six months, and its registration was cancelled after SCN - FAA allowed the appeal as the Respondent had filed all returns immediately on issue of SCN and directed the proper officer to verify the filing of returns and payment of taxes – Revenue-appellant contended that the FAA did not consider the proviso to Rule 23(1) and ought to have ensured payment of interest, late fee and penalty - Whether the FAA was within his powers to allow the appeal witho... [Read more]
GST - Revocation of cancellation of registration under Rule 23(1) of the CGST Rules, 2017 - The Respondent defaulted in furnishing GSTR-3B returns for a continuous period of six months, and its registration was cancelled after SCN - FAA allowed the appeal as the Respondent had filed all returns immediately on issue of SCN and directed the proper officer to verify the filing of returns and payment of taxes – Revenue-appellant contended that the FAA did not consider the proviso to Rule 23(1) and ought to have ensured payment of interest, late fee and penalty - Whether the FAA was within his powers to allow the appeal without ensuring or causing verification that interest, late fee and penalty are paid along with the taxes for the relevant period - HELD - The liability arising from the returns is not confined to the principal tax but extends to interest, late fee and penalty, which are substantive obligations integral to the adjudication. The FAA approached the appeal solely on verification of tax payment and filing of returns, without considering the proviso to Rule 23(1), which bars an application for revocation of cancellation for failure to furnish returns unless the returns are furnished and tax is paid along with interest, penalty and late fee. This omission goes to the root of the substantive liability, and the FAA exceeded its jurisdiction. The intent of the FAA's order appears to be that the amounts indicated in Rule 23 are to be collected. As the Respondent had paid tax alone and filed the returns, the Appellant was at liberty to collect interest and late fee under Section 50 and Section 47 respectively. The Respondent is also liable for penalty under Rule 23 - The order of the FAA is modified to that extent and penalty is imposed under Rule 23 - The appeal filed by the Department is modified [Read less]
GST - Revocation of cancellation of registration under Rule 23(1) of the CGST Rules, 2017 - The Respondent defaulted in furnishing GSTR-3B returns for a continuous period of six months, and its registration was cancelled after SCN - FAA allowed the appeal as the Respondent had filed all returns immediately on issue of SCN and directed the proper officer to verify the filing of returns and payment of taxes – Revenue-appellant contended that the FAA did not consider the proviso to Rule 23(1) and ought to have ensured payment of interest, late fee and penalty - Whether the FAA was within his powers to allow the appeal witho... [Read more]
GST - Revocation of cancellation of registration under Rule 23(1) of the CGST Rules, 2017 - The Respondent defaulted in furnishing GSTR-3B returns for a continuous period of six months, and its registration was cancelled after SCN - FAA allowed the appeal as the Respondent had filed all returns immediately on issue of SCN and directed the proper officer to verify the filing of returns and payment of taxes – Revenue-appellant contended that the FAA did not consider the proviso to Rule 23(1) and ought to have ensured payment of interest, late fee and penalty - Whether the FAA was within his powers to allow the appeal without ensuring or causing verification that interest, late fee and penalty are paid along with the taxes for the relevant period - HELD - The liability arising from the returns is not confined to the principal tax but extends to interest, late fee and penalty, which are substantive obligations integral to the adjudication. The FAA approached the appeal solely on verification of tax payment and filing of returns, without considering the proviso to Rule 23(1), which bars an application for revocation of cancellation for failure to furnish returns unless the returns are furnished and tax is paid along with interest, penalty and late fee. This omission goes to the root of the substantive liability, and the FAA exceeded its jurisdiction. The intent of the FAA's order appears to be that the amounts indicated in Rule 23 are to be collected. As the Respondent had paid tax alone and filed the returns, the Appellant was at liberty to collect interest and late fee under Section 50 and Section 47 respectively. The Respondent is also liable for penalty under Rule 23 - The order of the FAA is modified to that extent and penalty is imposed under Rule 23 - The appeal filed by the Department is modified [Read less]
GST - Time limit for availment of Input Tax Credit - Section 16(4) of CGST Act, 2017 - Respondent filed GSTR-3B returns for July 2018 to March 2019 after a delay of about 1,200 days - Adjudicating authority denied the ITC as time-barred under Section 16(4). The FAA set aside that order, holding the ITC genuine and admissible - Whether ITC claimed through belated GSTR-3B returns can be denied under Section 16(4) - HELD - Section 16(4) has to be strictly construed , which restricts the time limit for claiming ITC until 30th November following the end of the financial year (or the furnishing of the annual return), whichever i... [Read more]
GST - Time limit for availment of Input Tax Credit - Section 16(4) of CGST Act, 2017 - Respondent filed GSTR-3B returns for July 2018 to March 2019 after a delay of about 1,200 days - Adjudicating authority denied the ITC as time-barred under Section 16(4). The FAA set aside that order, holding the ITC genuine and admissible - Whether ITC claimed through belated GSTR-3B returns can be denied under Section 16(4) - HELD - Section 16(4) has to be strictly construed , which restricts the time limit for claiming ITC until 30th November following the end of the financial year (or the furnishing of the annual return), whichever is earlier, has to be strictly construed as the legislature used the word "shall". ITC is a statutory concession and not an unconditional vested right. The time limit is not elastic and cannot be treated as directory. Filing a delayed return with late fee does not extend the time limit. A delay of almost four years cannot be viewed as an oversight or administrative error - Section 16(5), inserted by the Finance Act, 2024, gives relief only where GSTR-3B was furnished by 30.11.2021. The return was filed on 23.02.2023, so the Respondent does not qualify and the ITC remains time-barred. DRC-07 is a confirmation of tax liability and not an approval of an irregular credit. The FAA's observation that the order was based on procedural grounds without documentary evidence is unreasonable - The order of FAA is set aside, the Order-in-Original is restored, the denial of ITC and the penalty are upheld - The appeal of the Revenue is allowedrnrnIssue 2: Interest on wrongly availed ITC - Section 50(3) of CGST Act, 2017 read with Rule 88B - The ITC was held to be wrongly availed and interest was demanded under Section 50 - Whether interest is payable on ineligible ITC and how it is to be computed - HELD - Section 50(3) provides for interest at 18% per annum only where the ITC is both wrongly availed and utilised in terms of Rule 88B(3) - ITC is utilised when the balance in the electronic credit ledger falls below the amount of the wrongly availed ITC. A mere reflection of ineligible ITC in the ledger without utilisation does not attract interest. Interest is computed on the combined balance across IGST, CGST and SGST/UTGST heads (excluding Cess). It is payable for the period the aggregate balance fell short, up to the date of reversal of the credit or payment of tax. It is not payable from the date the credit was entered in the ledger. Interest already paid is to be adjusted against the interest still payable. Interest is payable as per these observations. [Read less]
GST - Revocation of cancellation of registration under Rule 23(1) of the CGST Rules, 2017 - The Respondent defaulted in furnishing GSTR-3B returns for a continuous period of six months, and its registration was cancelled after SCN - FAA allowed the appeal as the Respondent had filed all returns immediately on issue of SCN – Revenue-appellant contended that the FAA did not consider the proviso to Rule 23(1) and ought to have ensured payment of interest, late fee and penalty - Whether the FAA was within his powers to allow the appeal without ensuring or causing verification that interest, late fee and penalty are paid alon... [Read more]
GST - Revocation of cancellation of registration under Rule 23(1) of the CGST Rules, 2017 - The Respondent defaulted in furnishing GSTR-3B returns for a continuous period of six months, and its registration was cancelled after SCN - FAA allowed the appeal as the Respondent had filed all returns immediately on issue of SCN – Revenue-appellant contended that the FAA did not consider the proviso to Rule 23(1) and ought to have ensured payment of interest, late fee and penalty - Whether the FAA was within his powers to allow the appeal without ensuring or causing verification that interest, late fee and penalty are paid along with the taxes for the relevant period - HELD - The liability arising from the returns is not confined to the principal tax but extends to interest, late fee and penalty, which are substantive obligations integral to the adjudication. The FAA approached the appeal solely on verification of tax payment and filing of returns, without considering the proviso to Rule 23(1), which bars an application for revocation of cancellation for failure to furnish returns unless the returns are furnished and tax is paid along with interest, penalty and late fee. This omission goes to the root of the substantive liability, and the FAA exceeded its jurisdiction - The intent of the FAA's order appears to be that the amounts indicated in Rule 23 are to be collected. As the Respondent had paid tax alone and filed the returns, the Appellant was at liberty to collect interest and late fee under Section 50 and Section 47 respectively. The Respondent is also liable for penalty under Rule 23 - The order of the FAA is modified to that extent and penalty is imposed under Rule 23 - The appeal filed by the Department is modified [Read less]
GST - Invocation of extended period under Section 74 of the CGST Act, 2017 for non-payment of IGST on the secondment of employees arrangement – Adjudicating authority confirmed demand of tax under Section 74(1) with interest and equal penalty, treating the secondment as import of manpower supply services from a related person taxable on reverse charge for July 2017 to March 2023 - Revenue view that it amounted to wilful misstatement and suppression, and that the tax was payable since the advent of GST. The same arrangement had earlier been examined in audit under the Finance Act, 1994, and by an adjudication order the ex... [Read more]
GST - Invocation of extended period under Section 74 of the CGST Act, 2017 for non-payment of IGST on the secondment of employees arrangement – Adjudicating authority confirmed demand of tax under Section 74(1) with interest and equal penalty, treating the secondment as import of manpower supply services from a related person taxable on reverse charge for July 2017 to March 2023 - Revenue view that it amounted to wilful misstatement and suppression, and that the tax was payable since the advent of GST. The same arrangement had earlier been examined in audit under the Finance Act, 1994, and by an adjudication order the expatriates were held to be employees of the Petitioner - Whether the proceedings could validly be initiated and concluded under Section 74 - HELD - Section 74 is an exception, with a longer limitation and penalty equal to the tax, and is available only where its distinct pre-conditions exist. The words to evade tax in Section 74(1) govern all three expressions of fraud, wilful misstatement and suppression - The foundational facts leading to the inference of fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression must emerge from the notice itself, the words cannot be mechanically recited and what the notice lacks cannot be supplied by an affidavit - Section 74(1) cannot be invoked merely on account of non-payment of tax without a specific element of fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression to evade tax. The SCN equated non-payment of tax in the return with wilful misstatement and suppression and treated the declaratory nature of judgment of Northern Operating Systems as showing intent to evade tax, which says nothing about the intent of an assessee who did not pay - The arrangement was within the knowledge of the Department, which had adjudicated the same agreements and held that no service was received. Suppression presupposes that something was kept back, and here nothing was. An assessee who bona fide believes that a transaction is not a supply and does not report it as one is not making a suppression to evade tax, since otherwise every case of non-payment would fall under Section 74 and Section 73 would be rendered otiose - The pre-conditions for Section 74 did not exist. The SCN did not disclose the foundational facts, and the confirmation of demand and penalty under that provision cannot be sustained - The Order-in-Original, the summaries in Form GST DRC-07 and the SCN with its summary in Form GST DRC-01 are quashed. The writ petition is allowedrnrn rnrnIssue 2: Valuation of import of service from related person, Binding nature of Board Circular - Second proviso to Rule 28(1) of the CGST Rules, 2017 read with Section 168(1) of the CGST Act - The Petitioner and the foreign parent company are related persons, and the Petitioner is eligible for full input tax credit. The Petitioner issued no invoice for the alleged import of service. The Petitioner relied on the Board's Circular No. 210/4/2024-GST clarifying that in such a case the value of services may be deemed to be Nil. The adjudicating authority held the Circular inapplicable on the ground that consideration was involved - Whether the demand could have been confirmed notwithstanding the Circular - HELD - Section 168(1) obliges all officers to observe and follow the orders, instructions or directions of the Board and it is not open to them to contend that a Circular beneficial to the assessee is not to be followed - The clarification applies where the recipient is eligible for full input tax credit and no invoice is issued by it for the service, and both conditions were satisfied, as the failure to issue invoices was itself the Respondents' case and the eligibility was not disputed - The Circular does not make the absence of consideration a condition, since its operative paragraphs apply in all cases of supply between related persons where full input tax credit is available. The second proviso to Rule 28(1) likewise draws no distinction between supplies made with and without consideration, and an officer bound by a Circular cannot read into its operative part a limitation which the Board has not placed there - The reasoning of the adjudicating authority defeats itself, as it held that the value is to be determined under Rule 28 and extracted the second proviso, but then fixed the value at the remuneration paid without applying the proviso. Even on the assumption that the arrangement is an import of service from the foreign parent company, the value of the supply is Nil and no tax is payable. Interest, which is compensatory and levied on tax not paid, and penalty, which is computed with reference to the tax evaded, fall with the demand - The demand of tax, interest and penalty is contrary to Section 168(1) and cannot be sustained for any part of the period from July 2017 to March 2023.rnrn rnrnIssue 3: Reasoned order - Section 75(6) of the CGST Act, 2017 - The Petitioner filed a detailed reply and additional submissions relying clause by clause on the dispatch agreement and employment contracts, the earlier adjudication order on the same agreements and the Board's instruction on secondment. The order reproduced the SCN as findings - Whether the impugned order satisfies the requirement of a reasoned order - HELD - Section 75(6) requires the proper officer to set out in the order the relevant facts and the basis of the decision. Recording of reasons is an indispensable component of the decision-making process, and a pretence of reasons or rubber-stamp reasons is not equivalent to a valid decision-making process. The order reproduced the SCN with its tentative language and made no reference to the clauses of the agreements relied upon by the Petitioner. Its observations on the agreements could not be reconciled with the documents on record, as features of another case were attributed to the Petitioner without examining whether its documents bore them out. The order did not deal with the earlier adjudication order of a senior officer of the same Department on the same agreements, which had been pressed by the Petitioner and was a relevant consideration, nor with the instruction on secondment. It also did not correctly state the period for which the liability was fastened in its operative part. Remand for a fresh order is not warranted, since on the findings on the earlier issues no demand can lawfully result from the SCN - The order does not satisfy Section 75(6) and is passed in breach of principles of natural justice.rnrn rnrnIssue 4: Writ jurisdiction - Whether the petition ought not to be entertained on account of the remedy of appeal under Section 107 - HELD - The alternative remedy does not operate as a bar where there is a violation of principles of natural justice, where the order is wholly without jurisdiction, or where the challenge turns on a pure question of law on admitted facts. The challenge to invocation of Section 74 goes to the very foundation of the proceedings. The refusal of a statutory authority to follow a Circular issued by the Board under Section 168(1) is a pure question of law on undisputed facts - The grievance that the order does not deal with the Petitioner's defence is one of breach of natural justice. No disputed question of fact requires to be resolved, the petition had been pending since April 2025 and the pleadings were complete, so relegating the Petitioner to appeal would serve no purpose - The preliminary objection of Revenue is overruled. [Read less]
GST - Exemption for distillery licence fee, Scope of expression "alcoholic liquor" under Notification No. 25/2019-Central Tax (Rate) - Notification No. 25/2019-Central Tax (Rate) - Respondent, a manufacturer of Extra Neutral Alcohol and impure spirit, paid fees to various departments of the State Government. Department alleged non-payment of tax on these fees, a show cause notice was issued under Section 74 - Adjudicating Authority confirmed the demand with interest and penalty under Section 122(2)(b) - The FAA set aside the demand except for royalty, which it converted to a demand under Section 73 - Whether the benefit of... [Read more]
GST - Exemption for distillery licence fee, Scope of expression "alcoholic liquor" under Notification No. 25/2019-Central Tax (Rate) - Notification No. 25/2019-Central Tax (Rate) - Respondent, a manufacturer of Extra Neutral Alcohol and impure spirit, paid fees to various departments of the State Government. Department alleged non-payment of tax on these fees, a show cause notice was issued under Section 74 - Adjudicating Authority confirmed the demand with interest and penalty under Section 122(2)(b) - The FAA set aside the demand except for royalty, which it converted to a demand under Section 73 - Whether the benefit of the Notification extends to the licence fee paid for renewal of the licence for manufacture of Extra Neutral Alcohol and rectified spirit, which the Department contended are not alcoholic liquor for human consumption - HELD - The entry covers service by way of grant of alcoholic liquor licence against consideration in the form of licence fee or application fee or by whatever name it is called. The entry does not contain the words for human consumption, and a limitation cannot be supplied by implication when the language is clear. The minutes of the GST Council meeting cannot be preferred to the text of the Notification. The notification is the instrument that operates in law, and, the text of the entry being free from ambiguity, no occasion arises to resort to the minutes for the purpose of construing it - The expression ‘liquor’ under the State Excise Act includes rectified spirits and denatured spirits, and the Extra Neutral Alcohol and rectified spirit are liquor. There is no reason to hold that the notifying authority intended the expression "alcoholic liquor" to bear a narrower meaning than the expression "liquor" bears under the State enactment under which the Licence is granted - The decisions relied upon by the Department relate to the levy on supply or sale of such alcohol and not to the fee paid for the licence. The expression ‘by whatever name it is called’ takes within its fold the renewal fee - The licence fee is covered by the Notification - The ground of the Department is rejected.rnrn rnrnIssue 2: Exemption for licence fees - Entry No. 47 of Notification No. 12/2017-Central Tax (Rate) - Whether boiler, factory, pollution control board and explosive licence fees paid for renewal are covered by the entry - HELD - A licence or permission granted for a period ceases to authorise the activity on expiry, and renewal is the means by which the Government authorises the continuance of the activity for a further period. In substance, renewal is the grant of a licence or permission for that further period. The entry draws no distinction between a fee for first-time grant and a fee for renewal, and a distinction not found in the text cannot be introduced by construction. The periodic inspection and certification required under the Factories Act reinforces this view - All fees paid for renewal or first-time obtaining of the licence, certificate or registration are covered by the exemption, and the ground of the Department is rejected.rnrn rnrnIssue 3: Exemption for Water Charges - Entry No. 99 of Notification No. 02/2017-Central Tax (Rate) - Whether the water charges paid to the Irrigation Department are in the nature of licence fee outside the entry - HELD - The amount payable varies with and is computed on the quantity of water actually drawn as measured by meters, and a charge fixed by reference to volume is in substance the price of the water supplied irrespective of its nomenclature. The supply of water by the Government against consideration computed per unit is a sale of water. The entry does not make generation of an invoice or bill a condition of exemption, and the water drawn is raw natural water which is not branded - The water charges are consideration for sale of raw, unbranded water and the supply is exempt, and the ground of the Department is rejected.rnrn rnrnIssue 4: Demand on royalty and contribution to District Mineral Foundation - Sections 73, 74 and 75(2) of CGST Act, 2017 - Whether the First Appellate Authority was correct in directing re-computation of the demand under Section 73 instead of Section 74 - HELD - Section 74(1) may be invoked only where non-payment of tax is by reason of fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression of facts to evade tax, and mere non-payment is not sufficient. The Department did not identify any fact required to be declared which was not declared, and the payments were reflected in the books of account of the Respondent - The liability of royalty to tax was highly interpretative with divergent views, so intent to evade tax cannot be attributed. There is no field in the return format to disclose such supplies, and treating the absence of disclosure as suppression would be contrary to fair notice. Section 75(2) empowers the Appellate Authority to determine tax as if the notice were issued under Section 73(1) where the charges are not established - Section 74 is unsustainable, the First Appellate Authority rightly directed re-computation under Section 73 and the ground of the Department is rejected.rnrn rnrnIssue 5: Penalty under Section 122(2)(b) of CGST Act, 2017 - Whether the penalty imposed under Section 122(2)(b) is sustainable - HELD - Section 122(2)(b) is attracted only where tax has not been paid by reason of fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression of facts to evade tax, the same elements as Section 74(1). As these elements are not established, the condition for the penalty is not satisfied. Section 75(8) provides that where the Appellate Authority or Tribunal modifies the tax, the interest and penalty shall stand modified accordingly. Section 122(2) contemplates penalty both where mens rea is found and where it is not - The penalty under Section 122(2)(b) is converted and reworked under Section 122(2)(a) in accordance with the revised computation of tax and the appeal is disposed of. [Read less]
GST - Show cause notice under Section 74 of CGST Act, 2017 - Petitioner challenged the SCN issued under Section 74(1) on the ground that the ingredients of Section 74 were not borne out from the notice. The Respondents contended that the writ petition against an SCN is not maintainable as the grounds can be raised in a reply - Whether an SCN under Section 74 can be sustained where it does not allege fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression of facts to evade tax - HELD - The condition precedent for invoking Section 74 is that the officer is satisfied that tax has not been paid or short paid, or ITC has been wrongly availed... [Read more]
GST - Show cause notice under Section 74 of CGST Act, 2017 - Petitioner challenged the SCN issued under Section 74(1) on the ground that the ingredients of Section 74 were not borne out from the notice. The Respondents contended that the writ petition against an SCN is not maintainable as the grounds can be raised in a reply - Whether an SCN under Section 74 can be sustained where it does not allege fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression of facts to evade tax - HELD - The condition precedent for invoking Section 74 is that the officer is satisfied that tax has not been paid or short paid, or ITC has been wrongly availed or utilised, by reason of fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression of facts to evade tax. The requirement has to be correlated with the allegations in the notice - Mere mention of allegations followed by a bald assertion that they amount to fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression does not satisfy Section 74. The foundational facts leading to that inference should be evident from the notice itself, and the words of Section 74 cannot be mechanically recited. The SCN neither alleged nor established that the act of the Petitioner was due to fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression of facts. The SCN is quashed and set aside – The petition is disposed of [Read less]
GST - Demand basis difference between GSTR-1 and GSTR-3B - Adjudicating Authority confirmed demand towards tax short paid on outward supply on comparison between GSTR-1 and GSTR-3B - The First Appellate Authority disposed of the appeal ex parte as none appeared on the dates fixed - Appellant contended that GSTR-1 contained inadvertent mistakes including multiple entry of the same invoice and entry of the same invoice against different customers, causing additional tax liability in comparison to the sales register and audited profit and loss account, and uploaded documents in support - Whether the demand arising from the di... [Read more]
GST - Demand basis difference between GSTR-1 and GSTR-3B - Adjudicating Authority confirmed demand towards tax short paid on outward supply on comparison between GSTR-1 and GSTR-3B - The First Appellate Authority disposed of the appeal ex parte as none appeared on the dates fixed - Appellant contended that GSTR-1 contained inadvertent mistakes including multiple entry of the same invoice and entry of the same invoice against different customers, causing additional tax liability in comparison to the sales register and audited profit and loss account, and uploaded documents in support - Whether the demand arising from the difference in outward tax liability declared in GSTR-1 and GSTR-3B is sustainable in the light of the explanation of the Appellant - HELD - The documents and records furnished by the Appellant need to be examined by the Adjudicating Authority to ascertain the veracity of the claim of the Appellant - The order of the FAA is set aside and the matter is remanded to the Adjudicating Authority to hear the matter afresh. The Appellant may produce and rely on the documents available in its possession - The appeal is disposed of [Read less]
GST - Denial of input tax credit on the ground that supplier firm was found to be fictitious and the appellant-assessee failed to establish the actual supply of goods - Sections 16(2)(b), 16(2)(c) and 74 of CGST Act, 2017 - Appellant availed and utilised input tax credit on purchases from a supplier, which was later found to be non-existent during inspection conducted years after the transactions and after cancellation of its registration - Appellant produced invoices, e-way bills and bank payment details before the authorities, and filed Goods Receipts and weighment slips for the first time before the Tribunal - Whether t... [Read more]
GST - Denial of input tax credit on the ground that supplier firm was found to be fictitious and the appellant-assessee failed to establish the actual supply of goods - Sections 16(2)(b), 16(2)(c) and 74 of CGST Act, 2017 - Appellant availed and utilised input tax credit on purchases from a supplier, which was later found to be non-existent during inspection conducted years after the transactions and after cancellation of its registration - Appellant produced invoices, e-way bills and bank payment details before the authorities, and filed Goods Receipts and weighment slips for the first time before the Tribunal - Whether the transactions are real and genuine, under which the goods were actually transported and received by the Appellant - HELD - The supplier had filed its returns and the transactions were auto-populated and disclosed by the Appellant. However, the authorities below found that the Appellant failed to furnish evidence of actual movement and delivery of goods. The Goods Receipts filed at the appellate stage were found to contain glaring discrepancies, including alterations of digits, erased entries, missing truck number and wrong copy of the receipt, and were held to be fabricated through erasure and interpolation. The weighment slips lose evidentiary value when the movement of goods is under suspicion. The remaining documentation is merely showpiece paperwork intended to claim false input tax credit, and payment of tax by a few fake suppliers in a chain carries no weight - The judgments relied upon by the Appellant are distinguishable on facts as they did not involve failure to establish actual movement of goods and collusion with the supplier - The transactions are neither real nor genuine. The entire documentation prepared by the parties in respect of these transactions was merely showpiece paperwork, intended to enable the appellant to claim and avail false ITC - The Appellant is not entitled to input tax credit. The appeal is dismissedrnrnIssue 2: Invocation of Section 74 of CGST Act, 2017 - Whether the authorities were justified in invoking Section 74 against the Appellant and whether the notice and order complied with its ingredients - HELD - Section 74 applies where input tax credit is wrongly availed by reason of fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression of facts to evade tax. Though the expression was not used in the notice in Form DRC-01 and the order, both specifically mentioned that the supplier was non-existent and bogus and that the Appellant availed input tax credit on showpiece invoices in collusion with the supplier with the intention of evading tax - The facts and conclusions recorded, in their pith and substance, satisfy the ingredients of Section 74. Under Section 160, no notice or adjudication is invalid merely by reason of a mistake, defect or omission if it is in substance and effect in conformity with the requirements of the Act - The notice, the order and the appellate order comply with the ingredients of Section 74, and the appeal is dismissed. [Read less]
GST - Show cause notice and summary in Form DRC-01 - Section 73(1) of CGST Act, 2017 - Petitioner assailed the summary of show cause notice in Form DRC-01, the assessment order under Section 73 confirming demand with interest and penalty contending no statutory show cause notice was served prior to the summary - Whether the proceedings are vitiated for want of a statutory show cause notice and breach of natural justice - HELD - The Petitioner was aware of the notice under Section 73(1), the demand figures were identical to those in the intimation in Form ASMT-10 to which the Petitioner had filed a reply, and the date of h... [Read more]
GST - Show cause notice and summary in Form DRC-01 - Section 73(1) of CGST Act, 2017 - Petitioner assailed the summary of show cause notice in Form DRC-01, the assessment order under Section 73 confirming demand with interest and penalty contending no statutory show cause notice was served prior to the summary - Whether the proceedings are vitiated for want of a statutory show cause notice and breach of natural justice - HELD - The Petitioner was aware of the notice under Section 73(1), the demand figures were identical to those in the intimation in Form ASMT-10 to which the Petitioner had filed a reply, and the date of hearing was known. There was failure on the part of the Petitioner to make an appearance, and no reply was filed - The procedure adopted by the Respondents being in substantial compliance and within its jurisdiction, it cannot be held that there was lack of inherent jurisdiction. The Petitioner not having participated in the proceedings in spite of adequate notice, no violation of the principles of natural justice can be said to have been occasioned - The Petitioner has not made out a case of lack of jurisdiction or violation of natural justice - As the proceedings were within jurisdiction and no violation of natural justice was made out, the writ petition fails on the ground of maintainability - The writ petition is not maintainable. The writ petition is disposed of [Read less]
Customs - Vires of Section 9A(1) of Customs Tariff Act, 1975 - Rules 4(1)(d), 17 and 18(1) of Customs Tariff (Identification, Assessment and Collection of Anti-Dumping Duty on Dumped Articles and for Determination of Injury) Rules, 1995 - Petitioner challenged the provisions of Section 9A (1) of the Customs Tariff Act, 1975 as ultra vires Article 14 of the Constitution on the ground of unfettered and unguided discretion of the Central Government, after the Central Government decided not to impose anti-dumping duty despite the positive final findings and recommendation of the Designated Authority - Whether the provisions of... [Read more]
Customs - Vires of Section 9A(1) of Customs Tariff Act, 1975 - Rules 4(1)(d), 17 and 18(1) of Customs Tariff (Identification, Assessment and Collection of Anti-Dumping Duty on Dumped Articles and for Determination of Injury) Rules, 1995 - Petitioner challenged the provisions of Section 9A (1) of the Customs Tariff Act, 1975 as ultra vires Article 14 of the Constitution on the ground of unfettered and unguided discretion of the Central Government, after the Central Government decided not to impose anti-dumping duty despite the positive final findings and recommendation of the Designated Authority - Whether the provisions of Section 9A(1) of CTA, 1975 are ultra vires Article 9.1 of the Agreement of 1994 and Article 14 of the Constitution - HELD - Article 9.1 of Agreement on implementation of Article VI of the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade, 1994 does not mandate a single, undivided exercise culminating automatically in imposition of anti-dumping duty. It expressly provides discretion to the authorities of the importing Member even where all requirements for imposition are fulfilled, and the term ‘desirable’ shows that imposition is not obligatory - The Article refers to the authorities of the importing Members and does not prescribe any institutional arrangement, so a Member cannot be refrained from creating a two-tier domestic structure - Section 9A(1) uses the phrase may to vest discretionary power in the Central Govt, while Rule 17 describes the conclusion of the Designated Authority as recommendatory. This deliberate distinction gives the final decision-making power to the Central Government, while the Designated Authority undertakes the specialised technical examination. The discretion is not unguided since it is conditioned by the findings of the Designated Authority, the standard of public interest and the purpose of the anti-dumping regime, which is to remedy unfair trade and maintain a level playing field without descending into protectionism - The impugned provisions are not ultra vires Article 9.1 of the Agreement of 1994 or Article 14 of the Constitution – The writ petition is dismissedrnrnIssue 2: Natural Justice - Decision of Central Government not to impose anti-dumping duty - Section 9A(1) of Customs Tariff Act, 1975 - Petitioner contended that the principle that the person who hears must decide and the grant of an effective opportunity of hearing were violated since the Central Government departed from the recommendation of the Designated Authority - Whether the action of the Central Government has led to violation of natural justice - HELD - Neither the Act of 1975 nor the Rules of 1995 prescribe any procedure to be followed by the Central Government where it rejects a positive recommendation of the Designated Authority. The first stage of investigation and final findings under Rule 17 is quasi-judicial, and the Petitioner had a full hearing at that stage - The second stage of discretion vested in the Central Government does not reopen the adjudication, and the findings of the Designated Authority on dumping, injury and causal link are not revisited. The observation on the quasi-judicial character of the notification relied upon by the Petitioner was rendered incidentally without examination of the text, scheme or object of Section 9A and Rule 18 and does not constitute the ratio decidendi. The discretion under Section 9A is closer to policy formulation than to adjudication, as it necessitates consideration of the interests of the public at large, and is therefore legislative or quasi-legislative in character - The principle that the person who hears must decide is not attracted since neither Section 9A(1) nor Rule 18(1) prescribes a further oral hearing, and a requirement of a second hearing cannot be read into the Act and the Rules. The question whether the amended Section 9C is in force remains sub judice, and the Petition is decided on merits without resting the outcome on the alternate statutory remedy - The second stage exercise by the Central Government is legislative or quasi-legislative in character and does not require a further oral hearing.rnrnIssue 3: Scope of Discretion of Central Government to Depart from Recommendation - Section 9A(1) of Customs Tariff Act, 1975 - Central Government declined to impose anti-dumping duty citing public interest, as one of the three domestic producers had ceased operations following a fire and the assessment obtained regarding the demand-supply impact of the duty - Whether the decision of the Central Government to depart from the positive recommendation of the Designated Authority is sustainable - HELD - The silence of the Act and Rules on procedure does not place the discretion beyond judicial review and only dictates the character of the review. The decision is tested on the scrutiny applicable to legislation and economic regulatory measures, namely whether it falls within the competence conferred by the parent statute, is consistent with fundamental rights, is founded on relevant material bearing a rational nexus to the conclusion reached, and is free from extraneous considerations and mala fides. The mandate of the Designated Authority is limited to examining dumping, injury and causal link - The interests of downstream users, availability of alternative sources of supply at competitive prices and the possibility of the domestic industry becoming a duopoly are different matters examined by the Central Government. The supervening development of one of the three domestic producers ceasing operations, read with the assessment obtained from NITI Aayog and other Government agencies on the demand-supply impact, furnished material bearing a rational and direct nexus to the decision - The finding of the Designated Authority on the historical decline of the domestic industry is analytically distinct from the forward-looking assessment of the Central Government on adequacy of supply. Non-disclosure of the assessment to the Petitioner is not the applicable standard, and no mala fide or abdication of statutory function has been demonstrated. In declining to impose duty despite a positive recommendation, the Central Government acts as custodian of the public interest and balances the interests of the domestic industry against those of the downstream user industry and the consuming public - The challenge to the Office Memorandum fails on merits and the Petition is dismissed. [Read less]
Meghalaya VAT Act, 2003 - Best judgment assessment, Denial of opportunity of being heard - Section 45 of the MVAT Act, 2003 read with Section 9 of the Central Sales Tax Act, 1956 - Assessments by best judgment holding that the returns were not complete and correct - Whether the assessment orders passed under Section 45 without fulfilling the statutory pre-conditions and without a show cause granting an opportunity of being heard are illegal and without jurisdiction - HELD - Section 45(1) permits best judgment assessment only if no returns are furnished by the prescribed date or if the Commissioner is not satisfied that the... [Read more]
Meghalaya VAT Act, 2003 - Best judgment assessment, Denial of opportunity of being heard - Section 45 of the MVAT Act, 2003 read with Section 9 of the Central Sales Tax Act, 1956 - Assessments by best judgment holding that the returns were not complete and correct - Whether the assessment orders passed under Section 45 without fulfilling the statutory pre-conditions and without a show cause granting an opportunity of being heard are illegal and without jurisdiction - HELD - Section 45(1) permits best judgment assessment only if no returns are furnished by the prescribed date or if the Commissioner is not satisfied that the returns furnished are correct and complete, and requires a reasonable opportunity of being heard. The Petitioner had filed returns by the prescribed date, so the first pre-condition was not satisfied. The notice for production of books of accounts was only for completion of audit assessment, failing which assessment would be completed by the best judgment method, and was not issued for failure to file returns - The second pre-condition was therefore not met. Such a notice amounts to a notice under Section 55, whose power to make best judgment assessment under Section 55(5) is circumscribed by the five-year limitation under Section 57, and Sections 45 and 55 operate in separate fields. There was no valid notice affording a reasonable opportunity of being heard - Best judgment assessment has to be completed in the manner strictly prescribed in the rules. When a statute prescribes a particular manner for doing an act, it must be done in that manner alone, and an authority cannot assume jurisdiction in a manner not authorised by the statute - The assessment orders passed under Section 45 are set aside and quashed - The writ petition is allowed [Read less]
Meghalaya VAT Act, 2003 - Best judgment assessment, Denial of opportunity of being heard - Section 45 of the MVAT Act, 2003 read with Section 9 of the Central Sales Tax Act, 1956 - Assessments by best judgment holding that the returns were not complete and correct - Whether the assessment orders passed under Section 45 without fulfilling the statutory pre-conditions and without a show cause granting an opportunity of being heard are illegal and without jurisdiction - HELD - Section 45(1) permits best judgment assessment only if no returns are furnished by the prescribed date or if the Commissioner is not satisfied that the... [Read more]
Meghalaya VAT Act, 2003 - Best judgment assessment, Denial of opportunity of being heard - Section 45 of the MVAT Act, 2003 read with Section 9 of the Central Sales Tax Act, 1956 - Assessments by best judgment holding that the returns were not complete and correct - Whether the assessment orders passed under Section 45 without fulfilling the statutory pre-conditions and without a show cause granting an opportunity of being heard are illegal and without jurisdiction - HELD - Section 45(1) permits best judgment assessment only if no returns are furnished by the prescribed date or if the Commissioner is not satisfied that the returns furnished are correct and complete, and requires a reasonable opportunity of being heard. The Petitioner had filed returns by the prescribed date, so the first pre-condition was not satisfied. The notice for production of books of accounts was only for completion of audit assessment, failing which assessment would be completed by the best judgment method, and was not issued for failure to file returns - The second pre-condition was therefore not met. Such a notice amounts to a notice under Section 55, whose power to make best judgment assessment under Section 55(5) is circumscribed by the five-year limitation under Section 57, and Sections 45 and 55 operate in separate fields. There was no valid notice affording a reasonable opportunity of being heard - Best judgment assessment has to be completed in the manner strictly prescribed in the rules. When a statute prescribes a particular manner for doing an act, it must be done in that manner alone, and an authority cannot assume jurisdiction in a manner not authorised by the statute - The assessment orders passed under Section 45 are set aside and quashed - The writ petition is allowed [Read less]
GST - Taxability of Corporate Guarantee - Section 7(1)(c) read with Entry 2 of Schedule I - Petitioners, being holding or group companies, furnished corporate guarantees to banking companies or financial institutions for the borrowings of their subsidiaries and charged no consideration. The Respondents sought to tax the guarantees as supply of services, and the Petitioners challenged the levy. Whether a corporate guarantee furnished without consideration for the borrowings of a related person constitutes a supply of services under Section 7(1)(c) read with Entry 2 of Schedule I of the Act of 2017, and who is its recipient ... [Read more]
GST - Taxability of Corporate Guarantee - Section 7(1)(c) read with Entry 2 of Schedule I - Petitioners, being holding or group companies, furnished corporate guarantees to banking companies or financial institutions for the borrowings of their subsidiaries and charged no consideration. The Respondents sought to tax the guarantees as supply of services, and the Petitioners challenged the levy. Whether a corporate guarantee furnished without consideration for the borrowings of a related person constitutes a supply of services under Section 7(1)(c) read with Entry 2 of Schedule I of the Act of 2017, and who is its recipient - HELD - Entry 2 of Schedule I presupposes a supply and dispenses only with the requirement of consideration. The guarantor places its balance sheet behind the borrowings of the subsidiary and assumes the risk of default from the moment the guarantee is executed. Something of value therefore passes to the subsidiary, which is neither goods, money nor securities, and is a service under Section 2(102). The assumption of another's credit risk is a recognised commercial service, as shown by the taxation of bank guarantees. The motive of protecting the investment does not alter the character of the transaction, since the definition of business under Section 2(17) is transaction-centric. The guarantee is incidental or ancillary to the trade of the guarantor under Section 2(17)(b), and the phrase "in the course or furtherance of business" does not require ordinariness. Under Section 2(93)(c), the recipient is the person to whom the service is rendered, which is the subsidiary and not the lender. The supply by the guarantor is distinct from the loan by the lender and cannot be a single composite supply under Section 8. The levy under the Act of 2017 does not depend on consideration, so the earlier service tax decisions based on a consideration-linked definition of service do not apply - A corporate guarantee furnished by a holding or group company for the borrowings of a related person is a supply of services even where no consideration is charged, and the Petitioners' challenge to taxability is rejected - The impugned show cause notices, orders and demands are set aside to the extent contrary to the findings herein, the proper officers are to determine liability afresh after hearing the Petitioners - The writ petitions are partly allowed.rnrn rnrnIssue 2: Exclusion as Actionable Claim or Security - Section 7(2)(a) read with Entry 6 of Schedule III and Section 2(102) - Petitioners contended that the guarantee is an actionable claim or a security and is therefore outside the levy. Whether a corporate guarantee furnished for a related person stands excluded from the levy as an actionable claim or as a security - HELD - The exclusion applies to the subject matter of the supply, that is, where the thing supplied is itself an actionable claim. What the subsidiary receives is credit support and not a claim, since the subsidiary acquires no right against the guarantor. Any claim arises in favour of the lender, who is not the recipient of the supply. If the exclusion were applied as urged, it would cover every bank guarantee, although the commission on such guarantees has consistently been treated as consideration for a taxable service. The definition of securities under Section 2(h) of the Act of 1956 is confined to marketable instruments and to rights or interests in securities. A guarantee is a security only in the sense of collateral for a debt, and the two meanings cannot be treated as the same - The corporate guarantee is not excluded from the levy either as an actionable claim or as a security, and the plea is rejected.rnrn rnrnIssue 3: Valuation of Corporate Guarantee - Rule 28(2) of the Rules of 2017 - The Petitioners challenged Rule 28(2), inserted by Notification No.52/2023-Central Tax dated 26.10.2023 and amended by Notification No.12/2024 dated 10.07.2024, which prescribes a deemed value for corporate guarantees given to a related person, as ultra vires the Act and violative of Articles 14, 19(1)(g), 246A and 265 of the Constitution. Whether the deemed valuation under Rule 28(2) is intra vires the Act of 2017 and consistent with the Constitution - HELD - The taxable event, the person liable, the rate and the measure are all found in Sections 7, 9 and 15, and leaving the method of valuation to delegated legislation within the policy of Section 15 is a permissible delegation of detail. A presumptive measure of value is not objectionable by itself, and the amount guaranteed is only the yardstick by which the value of the service is measured - The recommendation of the GST Council deserves deference but does not exclude judicial review on the ground of vires or arbitrariness. However, the figure was taken from the Safe Harbour Rules, where it is an option for the taxpayer, and the Council was aware that the true value of a guarantee could be lower. Rule 28(2) is a non obstante provision and operates even where the supplier shows a lower open market value. A presumptive valuation made mandatory, even where the actual value is ascertainable, is arbitrary and violative of Article 14 - Rule 28(2) is accordingly read down so that the deemed value is a rebuttable presumption which yields to a lower open market value established by the supplier on cogent and verifiable material. The consideration agreed between related persons, or the absence of any consideration, cannot by itself displace the deemed value. The proviso to Rule 28(2), which accepts the invoice value where the recipient is eligible for full input tax credit, is valid as the classification rests on the design of GST. Eligibility of the recipient to full credit is a question of fact and cannot be presumed merely because the parties are related - Rule 28(2) is intra vires but is read down as a rebuttable presumption, and the proviso is upheld.rnrn rnrnIssue 4: Time of Supply and Period of Levy - Sections 13(2) and 2(33) - Respondents contended that the taxable event recurs every year and that the levy extends to guarantees executed earlier and continuing thereafter. Whether a corporate guarantee is a continuous supply of services, when the supply takes place, and the levy on guarantees executed before 01.07.2017 and before 26.10.2023 - HELD - The service, being the assumption of risk, is supplied when the guarantee is executed and delivered. The continuing obligation is only a consequence of the supply already made, and invocation of the guarantee is not a new supply. Each renewal, extension of tenure or enhancement of the guaranteed amount is a fresh supply, valued with reference to the period of renewal or the amount of enhancement. Section 2(33) requires periodic payment obligations, which are absent in a gratuitous guarantee - A fiction under a Rule relates only to value and cannot alter a definition in the Act, so the guarantee is not a continuous supply of services. The time of supply is governed by Section 13(2)(a) or (b) and not by Section 13(2)(c), and disclosure as a related-party commitment does not amount to showing receipt in the books of the recipient. The tax is to be computed on execution for the entire tenure, and where the guarantee is released early the supplier may issue a credit note under Section 34 - The Respondents may consider permitting collection in annual instalments under Section 148, without altering the single supply. Guarantees executed before 01.07.2017 are not taxable unless renewed, extended or enhanced thereafter. Guarantees executed between 01.07.2017 and 25.10.2023 are taxable, but Rule 28(2) does not apply to them as the Government has not exercised its power under Section 164(3) to give it earlier effect. Their value must be determined under the Rules then in force on material specific to the guarantee, and Rule 31 cannot be used to apply the deemed figure indirectly. The words 'located in India' and 'per annum' [Read less]
GST - Transparency of Common Portal - Issuance and service of notices and orders through electronic mode - Proposed upgrade of Common Portal to disclose the date of the signed order being uploaded and served through electronic mode. Additional columns were proposed on the dashboard of the registered person, showing the notice or order number and date as per the signed copy, the date of issuance, and the email and SMS details with timestamps - Whether the proposed upgrade of the Common Portal is adequate for transparency in issuance and service of notices and orders - HELD - The proposed steps are in the right direction and... [Read more]
GST - Transparency of Common Portal - Issuance and service of notices and orders through electronic mode - Proposed upgrade of Common Portal to disclose the date of the signed order being uploaded and served through electronic mode. Additional columns were proposed on the dashboard of the registered person, showing the notice or order number and date as per the signed copy, the date of issuance, and the email and SMS details with timestamps - Whether the proposed upgrade of the Common Portal is adequate for transparency in issuance and service of notices and orders - HELD - The proposed steps are in the right direction and may give greater transparency. Once implemented, they may go a long way in enhancing the transparency and credibility of the GSTN portal and of the procedures adopted by the GST authorities for issuing notices and orders. Two suggestions are made. First, the placement of the column for the date of issuance and the column for the notice or order date as per the signed copy may be interchanged, as the date as per the signed copy would always be prior to the date of issuance. Second, the heading "Date of Issuance" may be changed to "Date of Upload", as it is a more accurate description of the date when the notice or order is uploaded on the Common Portal. The reformative measures are expected to be completed and implemented at the earliest. GSTN is to obtain further instructions on the status of implementation, and the matter is listed as fresh on 21.12.2026 - The interim order is extended until the next date of listing – Ordered accordingly [Read less]
Customs - Denial of refund on the ground of unjust enrichment - Appellants' refund claims were denied on the ground of unjust enrichment, and the appeals against the orders of the First Appellate Authority involve an identical issue. Chartered Accountant's certificates containing supporting worksheets, sale invoices and bills of entry are on record, certifying that the incidence of duty has not been passed on to any other person - Whether refund can be denied on the ground of unjust enrichment where the incidence of duty has not been passed on to the buyers and the fact stands certified by a Chartered Accountant - HELD - R... [Read more]
Customs - Denial of refund on the ground of unjust enrichment - Appellants' refund claims were denied on the ground of unjust enrichment, and the appeals against the orders of the First Appellate Authority involve an identical issue. Chartered Accountant's certificates containing supporting worksheets, sale invoices and bills of entry are on record, certifying that the incidence of duty has not been passed on to any other person - Whether refund can be denied on the ground of unjust enrichment where the incidence of duty has not been passed on to the buyers and the fact stands certified by a Chartered Accountant - HELD - Refund cannot be denied on the ground of unjust enrichment where the incidence of duty has not been passed on to the buyers and such fact stands certified by a Chartered Accountant. Where the sale price of the goods is lower than the assessable value or cost on which duty was paid, the presumption of passing on of duty stands effectively rebutted. Once the Chartered Accountant's certificate and supporting records establish that the incidence of duty has not been passed on and the goods have been sold at a price lower than the import cost, the bar of unjust enrichment is not attracted. Merely because the duty amount is reflected as expenditure in the Profit and Loss Account, it cannot be concluded that the incidence of duty has been passed on to the buyers. The issue is no more res integra, having been decided in favour of other parties on identical evidence and affirmed by the High Court, and the ratio deserves to be followed - The appeals are allowed [Read less]
Service Tax - Recovery of Cenvat credit - Limitation under Rule 14 of Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004 - Respondent, a developer, constructed the entire project at its own cost under a development agreement and availed full Cenvat credit on input services, whereas it paid service tax only on its share of the constructed area while the other party paid service tax on its own share without availing credit - SCN was issued on audit objection to recover the credit availed in excess of the Respondent's share - Adjudicating Authority dropped the demand on merits - Appellant (Revenue) challenged the order but not the findings on suppres... [Read more]
Service Tax - Recovery of Cenvat credit - Limitation under Rule 14 of Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004 - Respondent, a developer, constructed the entire project at its own cost under a development agreement and availed full Cenvat credit on input services, whereas it paid service tax only on its share of the constructed area while the other party paid service tax on its own share without availing credit - SCN was issued on audit objection to recover the credit availed in excess of the Respondent's share - Adjudicating Authority dropped the demand on merits - Appellant (Revenue) challenged the order but not the findings on suppression and revenue neutrality - Whether the SCN is barred by limitation and whether the unchallenged findings have attained finality - HELD - Unchallenged findings attain finality inter se between the parties, so the finding of no suppression of facts is final. At the material time the normal period for issuing an SCN for recovery of inadmissible Cenvat credit under Rule 14 was one year from the relevant date. The SCN could therefore demand recovery only for the credit availed in the one year preceding its issue, and the proposal to recover credit for the earlier period is time barred in absence of suppression of facts - Appeal of the Revenue fails on limitation.rnrnIssue 2: Revenue neutrality - Recovery of proportionate Cenvat credit - Whether the demand can be sustained when the finding on revenue neutrality has not been challenged - HELD - The finding of the Adjudicating Authority on revenue neutrality was not challenged by the Revenue and has attained finality. There is no challenge to the admissibility of Cenvat credit of input services used in construction of the project. If the Respondent were held not entitled to credit on the share of the other party and the credit were recovered from it, the other output service provider, which paid service tax on that share, would be entitled to the balance credit, so the entire exercise is revenue neutral. The Revenue has also not quoted any specific provision of the Cenvat Credit Rules under which proportionate credit could be allowed and the balance recovered - Without going into the merits, the appeal of the Revenue fails on revenue neutrality, the impugned order is upheld, the appeal is rejected. [Read less]
GST - Invocation of Section 74(1) of CGST Act, 2017 - Appellant was subjected to a survey and an ex parte order confirmed tax, interest and penalty on an SCN which inferred, from non-issue of invoice for a sale on the survey day, non-verification of stock, use of a bill book bearing the old VAT TIN and non-attendance on a summons, that sales were made outside the books - Whether Section 74(1) could be invoked in absence of foundational facts of fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression of facts to evade tax - HELD - Section 74(1) is a stringent provision and the words "by reason of fraud, or any wilful-misstatement or supp... [Read more]
GST - Invocation of Section 74(1) of CGST Act, 2017 - Appellant was subjected to a survey and an ex parte order confirmed tax, interest and penalty on an SCN which inferred, from non-issue of invoice for a sale on the survey day, non-verification of stock, use of a bill book bearing the old VAT TIN and non-attendance on a summons, that sales were made outside the books - Whether Section 74(1) could be invoked in absence of foundational facts of fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression of facts to evade tax - HELD - Section 74(1) is a stringent provision and the words "by reason of fraud, or any wilful-misstatement or suppression of facts to evade tax" are conditions for its application, the burden of establishing which lies on the Revenue. The foundational facts must be evident from the notice itself and mere employment of such words does not indicate application of mind - The SCN contained only inferences drawn from the survey and its summary stated only "Suppression of fact, Misstatement", without identifying any fact which the Appellant was required to declare in its returns and did not, or alleging unaccounted purchases, shortage or excess of stock or suppressed receipts - Non-attendance on a summons is a default with its own consequences and the inference that purchases and sales were made outside the books is a conjecture. Failure to reply to the notices occurred after the SCN and cannot supply the foundational facts, as no demand may be confirmed on grounds other than those in the notice under Section 75(7) - The turnover was disclosed in the returns on the Revenue's own portal and facts known to the department cannot be said to have been suppressed. The format of a bill book is a matter of compliance with Section 31 and is not by itself evidence of suppression of turnover with intent to evade tax - Invocation of Section 74(1) is unsustainable. The appeal is allowed [Read less]
Gujarat VAT Act, 2003 - Cancellation of composition permission - Section 14D of Gujarat VAT Act, 2003 and Rule 28C(6) and (7) of Gujarat VAT Rules, 2006 - Appellant, a restaurant, was permitted to pay lump sum tax under the composition scheme. Authorities cancelled the permission on finding invoices for purchase of sugar sachets from outside the State, one in the name of the Appellant and others in the name of a concern run by the Appellant's husband - Appellant's books showed that the amounts were received in cash from that concern and paid to the supplier on its behalf, and no purchase was debited in the books - Tribunal... [Read more]
Gujarat VAT Act, 2003 - Cancellation of composition permission - Section 14D of Gujarat VAT Act, 2003 and Rule 28C(6) and (7) of Gujarat VAT Rules, 2006 - Appellant, a restaurant, was permitted to pay lump sum tax under the composition scheme. Authorities cancelled the permission on finding invoices for purchase of sugar sachets from outside the State, one in the name of the Appellant and others in the name of a concern run by the Appellant's husband - Appellant's books showed that the amounts were received in cash from that concern and paid to the supplier on its behalf, and no purchase was debited in the books - Tribunal drew a presumption that the entries were made to come out of the breach of conditions and confirmed the cancellation for the period up to the end of the financial year - Whether the Tribunal was justified in confirming the cancellation of the composition permission - HELD - The authorities used the bulldozer to crush a fly by cancelling the permission. The ledger account shows that before payment to the supplier through the bank the amount was received in cash from the husband and was shown in the ledger account of his concern. Such entries were not doubted by the respondent-authority nor proven to be sham or bogus, so the presumption drawn by the Tribunal that they were made with a view to come out of the breach has no basis or corroborative evidence on record - Rule 28C(6) is attracted only where purchases are made from outside the State, and there is nothing on record to show that the Appellant debited any amount towards purchase of goods or raw materials in the books of account - Where the payment through the Appellant's bank account was merely reimbursement of the amount received from the husband, it cannot be said that the Appellant made purchases from outside the State. Except the invoices in question, the authorities could not find any other purchase in contravention of Rule 28C(6). The second question, whether purchase of tax-free goods from outside the State warrants cancellation, is not answered since the Appellant never purchased such goods - The Tribunal was not justified in confirming the cancellation of the composition permission. The question is answered in favour of the appellant and the appeal is allowed [Read less]
GST - Effect of omission of Rule 96(10) of CGST Rules without any saving clause on pending refund claims - Rejection of application for refund of IGST paid on export of finished goods under Rule 96 read with Section 54 of the CGST Act - The learned Single Judge directed grant of refund. The Revenue-Appellant, contended that the notification is prospective and does not affect refunds claimed for the earlier period - Whether proceedings under Rule 96(10) of the CGST Rules can be continued and the refund claim for the earlier period can be denied after the omission of the said Rule - HELD - The issue stands authoritatively se... [Read more]
GST - Effect of omission of Rule 96(10) of CGST Rules without any saving clause on pending refund claims - Rejection of application for refund of IGST paid on export of finished goods under Rule 96 read with Section 54 of the CGST Act - The learned Single Judge directed grant of refund. The Revenue-Appellant, contended that the notification is prospective and does not affect refunds claimed for the earlier period - Whether proceedings under Rule 96(10) of the CGST Rules can be continued and the refund claim for the earlier period can be denied after the omission of the said Rule - HELD - The issue stands authoritatively settled by the Supreme Court has held that proceedings under an omitted rule could not be continued. Since there was no savings clause or a sunset clause when Rule 96(10) was omitted, the said rule could not be kept alive - The intention to omit the rule without any saving clause was to bring to an end the unnecessary complications once and for all, and the intention cannot be to keep alive such complications insofar as the pending proceedings are concerned. The Respondent also pointed out that the CBIC has issued a Circular clarifying that the omission of Rule 96(10) would be effective retrospectively from 23.10.2017 - No ground to interfere with the order of the ld. Single Judge directing grant of refund - The appeal filed by Revenue is dismissed [Read less]
GST - Tax and penalty on loose order slips recovered in survey - Section 74 of CGST Act, 2017 - Revenue officers surveyed the Appellant's premises and seized loose handwritten order slips. The FAA dropped the demand on stock discrepancies as speculative. It sustained tax at 5% and an equal penalty on the value of three loose slips. The Appellant contended that the slips were temporary notes of customer orders, that they included exempt goods and that the supplies were billed and reported in returns. Whether tax and penalty can be sustained on the value appearing in loose slips when the transactions stand reconciled with ex... [Read more]
GST - Tax and penalty on loose order slips recovered in survey - Section 74 of CGST Act, 2017 - Revenue officers surveyed the Appellant's premises and seized loose handwritten order slips. The FAA dropped the demand on stock discrepancies as speculative. It sustained tax at 5% and an equal penalty on the value of three loose slips. The Appellant contended that the slips were temporary notes of customer orders, that they included exempt goods and that the supplies were billed and reported in returns. Whether tax and penalty can be sustained on the value appearing in loose slips when the transactions stand reconciled with exempted supplies and accounted taxable sales - HELD - The entries in the slips matched the corresponding invoices raised by the Appellant. Atta, maida and choker are wholly exempt from GST, so imposing tax at 5% on exempt goods is bad in law. The taxable sales on the slips were recorded in the Sales Register and the tax was reported and paid in GSTR-3B for the month. The Respondent could not verify the sales register data since it was B2C data with no further trail. The slips were temporary order notes. The demand sustained by the FAA is devoid of legal merit - The Order-in-Appeal is set aside to the extent of tax, penalty and interest. The appeal is allowed [Read less]
Central Excise - Rebate of duty - Rule 18 of the Central Excise Rules, 2002 - Respondent exported goods after payment of excise duty and claimed rebate under Rule 18 with ARE-1 forms certified by the Excise and Customs Authorities - Appellant- Revenue contended that the Revenue Authorities were justified in seeking additional documents for verification despite filing of ARE-1 forms with supporting documents - Whether the claim for rebate could be withheld on the ground of non-submission of further documents when ARE-1 forms with supporting documents were filed - HELD - There is a distinction between the pre-conditions for ... [Read more]
Central Excise - Rebate of duty - Rule 18 of the Central Excise Rules, 2002 - Respondent exported goods after payment of excise duty and claimed rebate under Rule 18 with ARE-1 forms certified by the Excise and Customs Authorities - Appellant- Revenue contended that the Revenue Authorities were justified in seeking additional documents for verification despite filing of ARE-1 forms with supporting documents - Whether the claim for rebate could be withheld on the ground of non-submission of further documents when ARE-1 forms with supporting documents were filed - HELD - There is a distinction between the pre-conditions for seeking rebate and the procedure to be followed in claiming it. The proof required under Rule 18 is that excise duty has been paid on the goods and that the goods have been exported. The certifications provided by the Excise and Customs Authorities indicate both payment and export, which satisfy the pre-requisites to claim rebate - A claimant can substantiate its claim on the basis of any of the documents mentioned in Paragraph 8 of the Supplementary Instructions, 2005 or on the basis of secondary evidence. The ARE-1 forms were complete, duly certified, accompanied by supporting documents, bank certificates and original shipping bills, and their genuineness was never questioned. As the ARE-1 forms were issued by the Revenue Authorities themselves, there was no material to suspect their own documents. The Appellant cannot travel beyond the SCN and reject the claim on the vague ground of non-furnishing of relevant documents - The zeal in collecting taxes must equally be reflected when disbursing lawful entitlements, whether in the form of rebate or refund - The impugned order allowing the assessee’s petition is not interfered with – Revenue appeal is dismissed [Read less]
Central Excise - Marketability of captively consumed intermediate product - Sugar syrup prepared in the factory by mixing sugar with water and a meagre quantity of citric acid was consumed captively in the manufacture of biscuits which had become exempt - Department demanded duty on the syrup by SCNs on the ground that it is marketable, relying on an invoice of another manufacturer, a Board Circular and a test report - Whether the sugar syrup manufactured and consumed captively by the Appellant is marketable and liable to Central Excise duty - HELD - The Revenue is of the opinion that similar products are available and sol... [Read more]
Central Excise - Marketability of captively consumed intermediate product - Sugar syrup prepared in the factory by mixing sugar with water and a meagre quantity of citric acid was consumed captively in the manufacture of biscuits which had become exempt - Department demanded duty on the syrup by SCNs on the ground that it is marketable, relying on an invoice of another manufacturer, a Board Circular and a test report - Whether the sugar syrup manufactured and consumed captively by the Appellant is marketable and liable to Central Excise duty - HELD - The Revenue is of the opinion that similar products are available and sold in the open market but has failed to produce any evidence comparing the chemical composition of those market products with the intermediate product manufactured by the Appellant. In absence of such comparative analysis the marketability of the specific intermediate product cannot be presumed or held to be established. Marketability of goods produced by a particular manufacturer cannot be presumed on the basis of marketability of similar goods produced by another manufacturer unless the two products are shown to be identical - The demand of duty on the captively consumed sugar syrup is not sustainable.rnrnIssue 2: Classification of sugar syrup under Tariff Item 1702 90 90 - Revenue classified the sugar syrup under Tariff Item 1702 90 90 on the basis of the report of the Chemical Examiner of CRCL, which showed the sample to be composed mainly of inverted sugar, sucrose and water - Appellant relied on a test certificate showing fructose content below the prescribed threshold - Whether the sugar syrup is classifiable under Tariff Item 1702 90 90 - HELD - Invert sugar consists of equal proportions by weight of glucose and fructose as per the Explanatory Notes to the HSN. Since the total invert sugar content in the CRCL report is less than the figure needed for fructose to reach 50 per cent by weight, the fructose component can in no way exceed that limit. The CRCL report fails to specify the exact percentage of fructose, which is the determinative factor for classification, and the Revenue has not produced any evidence of the fructose content of the product. The contention of the Revenue based on the CRCL report therefore fails - The classification under Tariff Item 1702 90 90 is not sustainable.rnrnIssue 3: Exemption to captively consumed intermediate product - Notification No. 67/95-CE dated 16.03.1995 - Rule 6 of CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004 - Appellant contended that it had either not availed CENVAT credit on inputs used in the sugar syrup or had reversed it under Rule 6, and that the syrup remains exempt although the final product biscuits is exempt - Whether the exemption under Notification No. 67/95-CE is available to the captively consumed sugar syrup - HELD - The Revenue has not contradicted the specific submission of the Appellant that it has not availed any CENVAT credit or has duly reversed the credit, if any, in terms of Rule 6 of the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004. The intermediate product manufactured and captively consumed is therefore fully eligible for the exemption under Notification No. 67/95-CE. This Tribunal has consistently held that sugar syrup manufactured as an intermediate product and captively consumed in the manufacture of biscuits is eligible for the benefit of the said notification - The Appellant is eligible for the exemption.rnrnIssue 4: Estoppel on earlier payment of duty - Revenue contended that the Appellant had paid duty on the sugar syrup for an earlier period, filed a classification declaration and had thus accepted its dutiability - Whether payment of duty and filing of classification declaration earlier bar the Appellant from contesting the demand - HELD - The principle of estoppel does not operate against the statute in taxation matters. The Appellant, as a taxpayer, is within its rights to discontinue an incorrect practice followed earlier and cannot be expected to perpetuate an error, if any. Past compliance cannot form a valid legal ground for confirming a duty liability that is otherwise not sustainable under the law. Filing of a classification declaration mistakenly does not mean that the party has to pay duty if in law it is not bound to pay - The earlier payment of duty does not bar the Appellant, the impugned orders are set aside and the appeals are allowed. [Read less]
GST - Dismissal of appeal on limitation against ex parte adjudication order - Recovery by attachment of bank account and debit of electronic credit ledger without opportunity to reply to SCN - Petitioner challenged the adjudication order passed ex parte without effective service of SCN, the dismissal of the appeal at the threshold on the sole ground of limitation without adjudication on merits, and the coercive recovery by garnishee notices - Petitioner, a senior citizen lacking technical expertise to operate the GST Portal, was dependent on a tax consultant whose prolonged illness resulted in non-receipt and non-knowledge... [Read more]
GST - Dismissal of appeal on limitation against ex parte adjudication order - Recovery by attachment of bank account and debit of electronic credit ledger without opportunity to reply to SCN - Petitioner challenged the adjudication order passed ex parte without effective service of SCN, the dismissal of the appeal at the threshold on the sole ground of limitation without adjudication on merits, and the coercive recovery by garnishee notices - Petitioner, a senior citizen lacking technical expertise to operate the GST Portal, was dependent on a tax consultant whose prolonged illness resulted in non-receipt and non-knowledge of the notices - HELD - The Petitioner was unaware of the notices due to the prolonged illness of the tax consultant who managed the affairs of the business and, being a senior citizen lacking technical knowledge to operate the system electronically, cannot be left remediless on account of unforeseen circumstances. For balancing the equities and for the end of justice, the appellate authority is directed to revisit the issue and dispose of the appeal on merits by a reasoned and speaking order after affording personal hearing to the Petitioner - The appellate authority shall independently consider the issue of bank attachment and the amount recovered from the electronic credit ledger - The impugned order is quashed and set aside and the writ petition is disposed of [Read less]
GST - Detention of goods in transit - Section 129(3) of CGST/UPGST Act, 2017 - The conveyance was intercepted and the goods were detained under Form GST MOV-06. Two tax invoices for the same consignment to the same purchaser were covered by a single e-way bill. Tax and penalty were imposed under Section 129(3) on the ground that a separate e-way bill was required for each invoice under Rule 138 of CGST Rules, 2017. The FAA set aside the order and the Department filed a second appeal - Whether transportation of goods covered by two invoices against a single e-way bill is a contravention warranting detention and imposition o... [Read more]
GST - Detention of goods in transit - Section 129(3) of CGST/UPGST Act, 2017 - The conveyance was intercepted and the goods were detained under Form GST MOV-06. Two tax invoices for the same consignment to the same purchaser were covered by a single e-way bill. Tax and penalty were imposed under Section 129(3) on the ground that a separate e-way bill was required for each invoice under Rule 138 of CGST Rules, 2017. The FAA set aside the order and the Department filed a second appeal - Whether transportation of goods covered by two invoices against a single e-way bill is a contravention warranting detention and imposition of tax and penalty under Section 129(3) - HELD - Both invoices, the e-way bill and the bilty accompanied the goods. The identity of the consignor and consignee, the destination and the vehicle number were not disputed. The transaction was accounted for in GSTR-1 and GSTR-3B and the IGST charged was deposited. The goods conformed to the invoices in description, weight and quantity. The transaction was neither concealed nor intended to evade tax, and the discrepancy was only a technical lapse. The Appellant brought no cogent evidence of intention to evade tax, which is necessary for imposing penalty under Section 129. Under CBIC Circular No. 64/38/2018-GST, proceedings under Section 129 should not ordinarily be initiated for minor discrepancies where the goods are covered by genuine tax invoices and there is no material indicating an attempt to evade tax. The benefit of the Circular is available to the Respondent. A procedural lapse without evidence of tax evasion cannot by itself justify penalty under Section 129(3) - The Order-in-Appeal is upheld and the Order-in-Original is set aside - The appeal of the Department is dismissed [Read less]
GST - Bench allocation of Revenue appeal before GSTAT - Office Order on classification of Bench - The FAA partly allowed the taxpayer's appeal by dropping and reducing penalties. The Revenue filed an appeal before the Tribunal against this. The Respondent objected that disputes involving determination of tax or ITC under Sections 73 and 74 are assigned to another Bench under the Office Order. Whether the appeal lies before this Bench - HELD - The principal tax demands stand discharged and appropriated. The sole surviving controversy is the imposition and quantum of penalties dropped or reduced by the FAA. Matters relating ... [Read more]
GST - Bench allocation of Revenue appeal before GSTAT - Office Order on classification of Bench - The FAA partly allowed the taxpayer's appeal by dropping and reducing penalties. The Revenue filed an appeal before the Tribunal against this. The Respondent objected that disputes involving determination of tax or ITC under Sections 73 and 74 are assigned to another Bench under the Office Order. Whether the appeal lies before this Bench - HELD - The principal tax demands stand discharged and appropriated. The sole surviving controversy is the imposition and quantum of penalties dropped or reduced by the FAA. Matters relating to an order imposing penalty are expressly assigned to this Bench under the Office Order. The objection is devoid of merit - The objection on Bench jurisdiction is rejected.rnrnIssue 2: Requirement of DIN on review authorization - Section 112(3) of CGST Act, 2017 - The Respondent contended that the authorization issued by the Principal Commissioner for filing the appeal did not bear a Document Identification Number as mandated by the CBIC Circular. Whether the absence of DIN on an authorization under Section 112(3) invalidates the Revenue's appeal - HELD - The mandate to generate and quote a DIN applies to communications issued by departmental officers to taxpayers and other external persons, so that recipients can verify their authenticity. An authorization under Section 112(3) is purely an internal inter-departmental administrative direction issued by the Principal Commissioner to the Review Section or Assistant Commissioner authorizing the filing of an appeal. It is not a notice, order or communication issued to an outside party. Non-quoting of a DIN on such an authorization does not vitiate its validity or the maintainability of the appeal - The objection is rejected.rnrnIssue 3: Bar of proceedings by amnesty waiver - Section 128A of CGST Act, 2017 - The Respondent filed Form GST SPL-02 and obtained an order in Form GST SPL-05 waiving penalty. It contended that all proceedings stood terminated by operation of law. Whether the order in Form GST SPL-05 bars the Revenue's appeal - HELD - Section 128A(1) applies exclusively to demands raised or determined under Section 73 and has no application to proceedings under Section 74. The order in Form GST SPL-05 covered only the residual penalty under Section 73(9) on part of the demand. For the demand upheld under Section 74, the Respondent itself paid the full tax, interest and penalty. The present appeal concerns the penalty dropped on one demand and the downgrading of another demand from Section 74 to Section 73. Neither was covered by the waiver order. Under Rule 164(15) and the scheme of Section 128A, an order in Form GST SPL-05 cannot extinguish the right of appeal already exercised by the Revenue under Section 112(3) - The contention is rejected.rnrnIssue 4: Violation of natural justice - Section 75(4) of CGST Act, 2017 - The Respondent alleged that the Order-in-Original was passed without granting a personal hearing. Whether Section 75(4) was violated - HELD - The Order-in-Original records that a personal hearing notice was issued fixing the date of hearing. The authorized representative of the Respondent appeared and made detailed oral submissions on both issues. A further hearing was also extended and attended. The allegation that no personal hearing was granted is contrary to the record. The principles of natural justice and Section 75(4) were complied with - The contention is rejected.rnrnIssue 5: Invocation of Section 74 on taxable receipts omitted from returns - Explanation 2 to Section 74 of CGST Act, 2017 - Commission write-off accounted in the Profit and Loss Account and receipts reflected in Form 26AS were not reported in GSTR-1 and GSTR-3B. The Respondent declared the additional liability in GSTR-9 only after the audit team commenced verification and confronted it with the financial statements and Form 26AS. The FAA converted the proceedings from Section 74 to Section 73 under Section 75(2). Whether the ingredients of suppression under Section 74 are made out and the FAA erred in converting the demand to Section 73 - HELD - Every non-payment of tax cannot be treated as evasion by fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression of facts. Each case must be examined to see whether evidence of wilful suppression for the purpose of evading tax is available on record. Explanation 2 to Section 74 defines suppression as non-declaration of facts or information required to be declared in the return, statement or report. Under the self-assessment regime of Sections 39 and 59, a registered person is bound to report all taxable supplies, considerations, commissions and write-offs in GSTR-1 and GSTR-3B. Concealing taxable receipts in private accounts while omitting them from statutory returns is wilful suppression. The mere existence of entries in books of account is no defence when those figures were withheld from the returns. The SCN set out the foundational facts and was not based on unsubstantiated mismatches. A disclosure forced by audit intervention cannot be treated as a voluntary pre-SCN disclosure. The ingredients of suppression are fully met and the FAA erred in converting the demand to Section 73 - The conversion to Section 73 is set aside and the 100% penalty under Section 74(1) is restored.rnrnIssue 6: Penalty on self-assessed tax declared in GSTR-1 but not paid in GSTR-3B - Section 73 read with Section 75(2) of CGST Act, 2017 - The Respondent declared the outward supplies in GSTR-1 but did not discharge the tax in GSTR-3B for over three years. It paid the principal tax only after audit intervention and did not pay interest under Section 50. The FAA held that Section 74 was not invocable and dropped the penalty. Whether the FAA erred in dropping the penalty - HELD - Declaration of the outward supplies in GSTR-1, which was already on the portal, negates suppression. The FAA therefore rightly held that Section 74 was not invocable. However, waiver of penalty under Section 73(6) or Section 73(8) read with Section 75(2) requires payment of both tax and interest. The Respondent paid the tax only after audit intervention and did not pay the mandatory interest. The FAA erred in dropping the penalty altogether - The dropping of penalty is set aside and penalty is confirmed under Section 73 read with Section 75(2). The Revenue's appeal is allowed. [Read less]
GST - Writ jurisdiction, Denial of input tax credit for the purchase of the SUV - The Petitioner, engaged in digital mapping and surveying services, purchased a vehicle used to transport survey equipment and technicians and claimed input tax credit on it. The credit was denied under Section 17(5) - Whether the writ petition against the order denying input tax credit on the vehicle can be entertained without the Petitioner availing the statutory appeal remedy - HELD - According to the petitioner, the vehicle is used only for the purpose of transporting both digital equipments and the surveying technicians who operate the sa... [Read more]
GST - Writ jurisdiction, Denial of input tax credit for the purchase of the SUV - The Petitioner, engaged in digital mapping and surveying services, purchased a vehicle used to transport survey equipment and technicians and claimed input tax credit on it. The credit was denied under Section 17(5) - Whether the writ petition against the order denying input tax credit on the vehicle can be entertained without the Petitioner availing the statutory appeal remedy - HELD - According to the petitioner, the vehicle is used only for the purpose of transporting both digital equipments and the surveying technicians who operate the same during the survey and mapping - The order is a considered order and the Petitioner has no case that it was not given an opportunity of hearing or that there was violation of principles of natural justice. Factual aspects have to be verified in deciding whether the Petitioner has wrongly availed the input tax credit. There is an effective statutory remedy available to the Petitioner by way of appeal under Section 107 - The writ petition is disposed of with liberty to the Petitioner to file an appeal and the order and demand notice are kept in abeyance until then – Ordered accordingly [Read less]
GST - Power of FAA to remand the matter - Section 107(11) of the CGST Act, 2017 - Refund claim under Section 54(3), on zero-rated supplies made under Letter of Undertaking without payment of integrated tax - The First Appellate Authority recorded that it was not in a position to verify the admissibility of the refund in the absence of portal access and directed the proper officer to decide the case afresh - Department contended that the statute does not vest jurisdiction in the Appellate Authority to remand - Whether the Appellate Authority could remand the matter to the adjudicating authority - HELD - Section 107(11) cont... [Read more]
GST - Power of FAA to remand the matter - Section 107(11) of the CGST Act, 2017 - Refund claim under Section 54(3), on zero-rated supplies made under Letter of Undertaking without payment of integrated tax - The First Appellate Authority recorded that it was not in a position to verify the admissibility of the refund in the absence of portal access and directed the proper officer to decide the case afresh - Department contended that the statute does not vest jurisdiction in the Appellate Authority to remand - Whether the Appellate Authority could remand the matter to the adjudicating authority - HELD - Section 107(11) contains a specific embargo on remand as the Appellate Authority shall pass an order confirming, modifying or annulling the decision appealed against but shall not refer the case back to the adjudicating authority. Once the statute does not vest jurisdiction to remand, it was not open to the Appellate Authority to pass such an order and it was expected to adjudicate the appeal within the four corners of law – The want of portal access is no ground for remand, since Section 107(11) itself empowers the Appellate Authority to make such further inquiry as may be necessary. The Appellate Authority failed to decide the appeal itself and passed an order of remand which the law does not permit, and the order is illegal, without jurisdiction and a nullity - The order of the Appellate Authority is set aside, with a direction to revisit the issue in accordance with the law - The appeal is allowed [Read less]
Customs - Confiscation under Section 111(m) and redemption fine for goods lying in SEZ unit and permitted for re-export - Appellant imported goods declared as cotton fabrics through warehouse bills of entry for clearance through an SEZ, which on testing were found to be dyed woven fabrics made of polyester filament yarns with lycra, and the goods were intercepted at the SEZ warehouse stage before home consumption with no foreign remittance. The adjudicating authority held the goods liable to confiscation under Section 111(m), permitted re-export and imposed redemption fine for the purpose of re-export. The Appellant stated... [Read more]
Customs - Confiscation under Section 111(m) and redemption fine for goods lying in SEZ unit and permitted for re-export - Appellant imported goods declared as cotton fabrics through warehouse bills of entry for clearance through an SEZ, which on testing were found to be dyed woven fabrics made of polyester filament yarns with lycra, and the goods were intercepted at the SEZ warehouse stage before home consumption with no foreign remittance. The adjudicating authority held the goods liable to confiscation under Section 111(m), permitted re-export and imposed redemption fine for the purpose of re-export. The Appellant stated that the supplier had dispatched incorrect goods due to a packing or loading error - Whether goods lying in the warehouse of an authorised SEZ unit and permitted to be re-exported are liable to confiscation and redemption fine - HELD - Since the goods were lying in the warehouse of a duly authorised SEZ unit, they are not liable to confiscation or redemption fine as no Customs duty is leviable thereon. Reliance is placed on the Tribunal decision in Morgan Tectronics holding that where goods are imported by an SEZ unit there is no question of levy of customs duty and no justification for confiscation, redemption fine and penalty. Once re-export of the goods has been permitted, there is no case for imposition of redemption fine - The order imposing redemption fine is set aside – The appeal is partly allowedrnrn rnrnCustoms - Penalty under Section 114AA of Customs Act, 1962 on import transaction - Adjudicating authority imposed penalty under Section 114AA on the Appellant for the import of goods which were mis-declared in the bills of entry, and the Appellant contended that the provision applies only to export transactions - Whether penalty under Section 114AA can be imposed in a case of import - HELD - The provision of Section 114AA applies only when export benefits are claimed without actual export or where forged documents are used. Reliance is placed on the decision of the Tribunal in Interglobe Aviation holding that as the case is not of export, no penalty under Section 114AA is imposable. The penalty under Section 114AA imposed on the Appellant is therefore liable to be reduced - The penalty under Section 114AA is reduced to a nominal amountrnrn rnrnCustoms - Penalty under Section 112(a) of Customs Act, 1962 where goods are allowed to be re-exported - Adjudicating authority imposed penalty under Section 112(a) on the Appellant after permitting re-export of the mis-declared goods, and the Appellant contended that no penalty is imposable once re-export is allowed - Whether penalty under Section 112(a) is sustainable in the amount imposed where re-export of the goods has been permitted - HELD - Relying on the decision of the Tribunal in Siemens Public Communication Networks, when goods are allowed to be re-exported neither redemption fine nor duty is required to be paid, and penalty is also not to be imposed on the importers. The same view was followed by the Tribunal in Global Enterprise, Goyal Trading Company and Perfect Trading Company. In view of the present legal position, the amount of penalty imposed on the Appellant under Section 112(a) is excessive and unreasonable - The penalty under Section 112(a) is reduced to a nominal amount and the appeal is partly allowed. [Read less]
GST – Validity of show cause notice fixing same date for submission of reply and for personal hearing - Petitioner purchased goods from a registered supplier whose registration was later cancelled, and input tax credit was proposed to be disallowed under Section 16(2)(c) - The show cause notice under Section 73 mentioned the same date for submission of reply and for personal hearing, and the order was passed under Section 73 - Petitioner contended that the procedure adopted was contrary to the Circular issued by the Commissioner - Whether a show cause notice can fix the same date for submission of reply and for personal ... [Read more]
GST – Validity of show cause notice fixing same date for submission of reply and for personal hearing - Petitioner purchased goods from a registered supplier whose registration was later cancelled, and input tax credit was proposed to be disallowed under Section 16(2)(c) - The show cause notice under Section 73 mentioned the same date for submission of reply and for personal hearing, and the order was passed under Section 73 - Petitioner contended that the procedure adopted was contrary to the Circular issued by the Commissioner - Whether a show cause notice can fix the same date for submission of reply and for personal hearing - HELD - The date of personal hearing being the same as the date of reply to the show cause notice is non-est and the practice has to be discontinued. The date of reply to the show cause notice has to be prior to the date of personal hearing. The irregularity therefore crept in from the stage of the show cause notice itself. The Standing Counsel could not dispute that the date of the show cause notice and the date of hearing cannot be the same - The order under Section 73 and the appellate order under Section 107 rejecting the appeal on delay are set aside - The matter is remitted to the proper officer to pass a fresh order – The petition is disposed of [Read less]
Service Tax - Summons and SCN under Section 70 of CGST Act, 2017 - Petitioner challenged the summons issued under Section 70 and the SCN proposing a service tax demand for 2016-17 and the first quarter of 2017-18 on construction work for the Western Dedicated Freight Corridor. The summons followed a search under the CGST Act and called for service tax documents - Petitioner contended that powers under the CGST Act could not be used to inquire into liability under the Finance Act, 1994, and that the SCN relied on Section 65(97a), which was omitted from 01.07.2012 - Whether the summons and SCN are without jurisdiction becaus... [Read more]
Service Tax - Summons and SCN under Section 70 of CGST Act, 2017 - Petitioner challenged the summons issued under Section 70 and the SCN proposing a service tax demand for 2016-17 and the first quarter of 2017-18 on construction work for the Western Dedicated Freight Corridor. The summons followed a search under the CGST Act and called for service tax documents - Petitioner contended that powers under the CGST Act could not be used to inquire into liability under the Finance Act, 1994, and that the SCN relied on Section 65(97a), which was omitted from 01.07.2012 - Whether the summons and SCN are without jurisdiction because of the wrong provision cited and the reference to an omitted definition, so that a writ petition can be entertained at the SCN stage - HELD - A SCN decides nothing and ordinarily does not give rise to a cause of action. A writ should be entertained only where the notice is wholly non est for absolute want of jurisdiction. Section 174(2)(e) of the CGST Act saves any investigation, inquiry, adjudication or other proceeding in respect of the earlier tax and permits it to be instituted afresh as if the Finance Act, 1994 had not been amended - Section 83 of the Finance Act, 1994 applies Section 14 of the CEA, 1944, the power to summon, which also survives. Mention of a wrong provision does not vitiate the action where the power exists and is traceable to a valid source - The grievance about the route and the label is at most an irregularity in the exercise of an existing jurisdiction. Officers are not expected to shut their eyes to material found in a search that discloses evasion of another tax which they also administer, and its admissibility and weight are for the adjudicating authority. Under the negative list regime, taxability does not depend on a service fitting a named category, so reliance on the omitted definition is at best a flaw in the reasoning of the notice that may be pointed out in reply - The authority had jurisdiction to investigate and to issue the notice, and the plea is a plea on merits dressed in jurisdictional clothing - The writ petition is dismissedrnrnIssue 2: Exemption, suppression and limitation - Section 73 of Finance Act, 1994 - Petitioner contended that its work was an exempt works contract under the Mega Exemption Notification, that all transactions were disclosed in its returns and books so there was no suppression, and that the SCN was time barred. Respondents alleged that the true nature of the work came to light only during the search, that the exemption was claimed by misrepresentation and that no document showed transfer of property in goods - Whether the pleas on classification, exemption, suppression and limitation can be decided by the writ Court at the SCN stage - HELD - Works contract requires a transfer of property in goods leviable to tax as a sale, and the word leviable does not require actual payment of VAT. Whether property in the materials passed, whether earth moved within the site is a supply of goods, and whether the contract is composite or a set of separate earthwork jobs depend on the work orders, the tender, the measurement records and the invoices. The exemption for a subcontractor requires the Petitioner's own contract to be a works contract and the main contract to be exempt, which raises the meaning of railways, and the authority must first decide it with full reasons - Suppression means failure to disclose full information with intent to evade duty, and a mere omission or non-payment of tax is not enough as there must be a conscious and deliberate act, the burden of showing which lies on the Department. Whether the test is met is a matter of evidence. The material shows that the activity surfaced during the search, that different exemption entries were put forward at different points, that a self assessed return merely naming an exemption entry does not by itself disclose the facts behind it, that there is an admitted difference between Form 26AS and the books, and that compliance with summonses is disputed - The allegation of suppression is not a bald assertion, and there is material both for and against it. The extended period applies only upon a finding of suppression with intent to evade, so the plea of limitation is tied to suppression and cannot be decided in isolation. The Explanation to Section 74 of the CGST Act applies to that Act and is referred to only as an aid. These questions turn on disputed facts and cannot be decided on affidavits in writ jurisdiction - The pleas are left open before the adjudicating authority.rnrnIssue 3: Pre-show cause notice consultation - Master Circular No. 1053/02/2017-CX - Petitioner contended that pre show cause consultation by the Principal Commissioner or Commissioner is mandatory where the demand exceeds the monetary limit in the Master Circular - Whether the SCN is vitiated for want of pre show cause consultation - HELD - The same Circular excludes preventive and offence related SCNs from its scope. Consultation before notice is meant for cases arising from scrutiny or audit, where the department and the taxpayer can often resolve a difference of view. A case built on a search and the seizure of documents stands on a different footing, as prior consultation may defeat the investigation itself. The notice arose from an investigation by the Anti Evasion Wing after search and seizure and falls within the excluded class. The Finance Act, 1994, as saved by Section 174, provides a complete mechanism of reply, personal hearing, a reasoned order and appeal under Sections 85 and 86 - The plea fails at the threshold and the writ petition is dismissed. [Read less]
GST - Order under Section 74 without personal hearing - Principles of natural justice - Petitioner was issued an SCN in Form GST DRC-01 and a reminder, in which the date, time and venue of personal hearing were shown as NA. An ex parte order was passed under Section 74, and the appeal was rejected by the FAA as time-barred under Section 107 - Whether an order under Section 74 can be sustained when no date, time and venue of personal hearing was fixed - HELD - The Courts normally do not interfere with a decision, but they exercise jurisdiction where there is infirmity or irregularity in the decision making process. The prin... [Read more]
GST - Order under Section 74 without personal hearing - Principles of natural justice - Petitioner was issued an SCN in Form GST DRC-01 and a reminder, in which the date, time and venue of personal hearing were shown as NA. An ex parte order was passed under Section 74, and the appeal was rejected by the FAA as time-barred under Section 107 - Whether an order under Section 74 can be sustained when no date, time and venue of personal hearing was fixed - HELD - The Courts normally do not interfere with a decision, but they exercise jurisdiction where there is infirmity or irregularity in the decision making process. The principles of natural justice were violated since no date, time and venue were fixed for personal hearing. The Respondent could not dispute that personal hearing was not accorded to the Petitioner - The order under Section 74 and the appellate order are set aside. The Respondent is at liberty to issue a fresh SCN and proceed in accordance with law – The petition is disposed ofrnrnIssue 2: Order confirming demand in excess of the SCN - Section 75(7) of CGST Act, 2017 - The amount of tax and penalty confirmed in the order under Section 74 was higher than the amount specified in the SCN. Whether the demand confirmed in the order can exceed the amount specified in the SCN - HELD - Under Section 75(7), the amount of tax, interest and penalty demanded in the order shall not be in excess of the amount specified in the notice. No demand can be confirmed on grounds other than those specified in the notice. The liability confirmed was excessive over the SCN, which is clearly forbidden by Section 75(7). The Revenue also did not dispute that the amount was altered to the detriment of the Petitioner - The Respondent is at liberty to issue a fresh SCN and proceed in accordance with law. The orders are set aside. [Read less]
GST - Transitional credit under Section 140(1) and Section 140(5) of CGST Act, 2017 - Petitioner, a manufacturer with two units under a common registration, filed Form TRAN-1 within time and carried forward CENVAT credit on inputs under Section 140(5). An SCN alleged that the credit was wrongly transitioned under Section 140(5) and proposed to disallow it. The demand was confirmed, and the appeal was dismissed by the FAA - The Revenue's case was that the credit ought to have been taken under Section 140(1). Whether transitional credit can be denied only because it was transitioned under a wrong provision or column of Form ... [Read more]
GST - Transitional credit under Section 140(1) and Section 140(5) of CGST Act, 2017 - Petitioner, a manufacturer with two units under a common registration, filed Form TRAN-1 within time and carried forward CENVAT credit on inputs under Section 140(5). An SCN alleged that the credit was wrongly transitioned under Section 140(5) and proposed to disallow it. The demand was confirmed, and the appeal was dismissed by the FAA - The Revenue's case was that the credit ought to have been taken under Section 140(1). Whether transitional credit can be denied only because it was transitioned under a wrong provision or column of Form TRAN-1 when its eligibility and quantum are not disputed - HELD - The eligibility of the credit was never in dispute, and the quantum was not disputed by the Respondents. The impugned order itself notes that the Petitioner was entitled to transitional credit under Section 140(1). Form TRAN-1 is a declaration subject to verification and scrutiny by the Revenue. Transitioning the credit under a wrong category or column is not a ground to disallow it. Unutilised credit arising from duty or tax paid is a vested right that cannot be taken away on technical grounds. The right to input credit is an indefeasible right. Admitted credit cannot be denied on technical grounds, and the impugned order is totally without jurisdiction - The order of the FAA is quashed and the Writ Petition is allowed [Read less]
GST - Writ Petition against ex parte order - Alternative remedy under Section 107 of CGST Act, 2017 - Petitioner was audited under Section 65. An SCN was issued under Section 74, and an order was passed confirming the demand with interest and penalty - Petitioner contended that the hearing notices were sent to an incorrect email address and were not served in accordance with Section 169 - Whether the High Court should entertain a Writ Petition against an order under Section 74 on the ground of non-service of hearing notices when an appeal lies under Section 107 - HELD - Where the legislature has provided an efficacious app... [Read more]
GST - Writ Petition against ex parte order - Alternative remedy under Section 107 of CGST Act, 2017 - Petitioner was audited under Section 65. An SCN was issued under Section 74, and an order was passed confirming the demand with interest and penalty - Petitioner contended that the hearing notices were sent to an incorrect email address and were not served in accordance with Section 169 - Whether the High Court should entertain a Writ Petition against an order under Section 74 on the ground of non-service of hearing notices when an appeal lies under Section 107 - HELD - Where the legislature has provided an efficacious appellate mechanism, the High Court ordinarily exercises restraint under Article 226 of the Constitution. This restraint rests on the discretionary exercise of jurisdiction and not on its absence. An alternative remedy is not an absolute bar, and exceptions such as breach of natural justice have to be examined on the facts of each case. The mere invocation of natural justice does not dispense with the requirement of availing the statutory remedy. The parties took competing positions on whether the notices were sent to the email address attributable to the Petitioner at the material time. This has to be decided with reference to the registration particulars and contemporaneous communications, and the Court should not undertake a detailed factual inquiry in writ jurisdiction - The contentions on the consideration of explanations and the merits of the demand are also matters for the appellate authority - The Petitioner is relegated to the appeal under Section 107 and all contentions are left open. The appellate authority shall consider any application under Section 14 of the Limitation Act, 1963 in accordance with law. The Writ Petition is disposed of [Read less]
GST - Time limit for availing ITC - Section 16(4) and Section 16(5) of CGST Act, 2017 - Petitioner availed ITC pertaining to a financial year in three spells in March 2020, after the due date under Section 16(4). Form GST DRC-01A was issued, and the Petitioner neither replied nor availed the personal hearing. An order was passed directing the Petitioner to pay or reverse the ITC. The Petitioner contended that Section 16(5) permits ITC in a return under Section 39 filed up to 30.11.2021. The Respondent relied on Notification No. 22/2024-Central Tax, which required an application for rectification within six months. Whether ... [Read more]
GST - Time limit for availing ITC - Section 16(4) and Section 16(5) of CGST Act, 2017 - Petitioner availed ITC pertaining to a financial year in three spells in March 2020, after the due date under Section 16(4). Form GST DRC-01A was issued, and the Petitioner neither replied nor availed the personal hearing. An order was passed directing the Petitioner to pay or reverse the ITC. The Petitioner contended that Section 16(5) permits ITC in a return under Section 39 filed up to 30.11.2021. The Respondent relied on Notification No. 22/2024-Central Tax, which required an application for rectification within six months. Whether ITC availed after the due date under Section 16(4) but before 30.11.2021 is allowable in view of Section 16(5) - HELD - Under Section 16(4), the ITC had to be availed by the due date, and it was availed beyond that date. By the introduction of Section 16(5), registered persons are allowed to avail ITC in any return under Section 39 filed on or before 30.11.2021. The Respondent's reliance on the Notification merits no acceptance. Section 16(5) is clear and no time limit is stipulated therein. The ITC availed in March 2020 therefore falls within the extended time limit - The order is set aside and the writ petition is allowed [Read less]
GST - Vague show-cause notice - Rule 21(b) of CGST Rules, 2017 - Petitioner's registration was cancelled on a show-cause notice that referred only to Rule 21(b) of the CGST Rules, alleging issue of invoice without supply of goods or services - Petitioner's reply was not considered as the acknowledgment number was not available, and no copy of the reply was retained. The reason for cancellation was disclosed only in the notice issued on the Petitioner's application for revocation - Whether the show-cause notice can be considered as vague - HELD - The show-cause notice only refers to Rule 21(b) of the CGST Rules. If the noti... [Read more]
GST - Vague show-cause notice - Rule 21(b) of CGST Rules, 2017 - Petitioner's registration was cancelled on a show-cause notice that referred only to Rule 21(b) of the CGST Rules, alleging issue of invoice without supply of goods or services - Petitioner's reply was not considered as the acknowledgment number was not available, and no copy of the reply was retained. The reason for cancellation was disclosed only in the notice issued on the Petitioner's application for revocation - Whether the show-cause notice can be considered as vague - HELD - The show-cause notice only refers to Rule 21(b) of the CGST Rules. If the notice was vague and the Petitioner was handicapped, it should have been diligent in raising this concern at the very first instance and ensured that material is placed on record to demonstrate the same. There is failure in this regard, and the Petitioner's response to a vague notice remains vague without a copy being placed on record - The Appellate Authority, being the authority which could have gone into the factual matrix, should have considered all circumstances. The reason for cancellation is specific, being availment of input tax credit based on a non-existent entity, and the Petitioner is categorical that it can produce documents to show genuineness of the transaction. The Petitioner had also not responded to the show-cause notice issued on the application for revocation of cancellation - If the Petitioner produces documents demonstrating genuineness of the transaction, the registration must be restored - The order of the Appellate Authority is set aside and the proceedings are restored to the Respondent with liberty to the Petitioner to file the response and documents - The writ petition is partly allowed [Read less]
GST – Maharashtra AAR - Classification of second-hand goods dealt with by an auctioneer under the Customs Tariff based rate notification - Applicant, an auctioneer, facilitated auction, private and exhibition sale of second-hand or used goods such as prints, sculptures, jewellery, books, furniture, carpets, watches, bags, cameras, pens, instruments, cars, collectibles and memorabilia - Whether the goods dealt with by the Applicant can be classified and the applicable rate determined in a generalised manner for all such categories - HELD - Classification under GST is determined with reference to the Customs Tariff Act rea... [Read more]
GST – Maharashtra AAR - Classification of second-hand goods dealt with by an auctioneer under the Customs Tariff based rate notification - Applicant, an auctioneer, facilitated auction, private and exhibition sale of second-hand or used goods such as prints, sculptures, jewellery, books, furniture, carpets, watches, bags, cameras, pens, instruments, cars, collectibles and memorabilia - Whether the goods dealt with by the Applicant can be classified and the applicable rate determined in a generalised manner for all such categories - HELD - Classification under GST is determined with reference to the Customs Tariff Act read with the rate notification. Explanation (iv) makes the General Rules for Interpretation applicable, under which the heading providing the most specific description is preferred to a general one. Old prints, engravings and lithographs fall under Heading 9702, old sculptures and statuary under Heading 9703, and used cameras under Heading 9007. Antiques of an age exceeding one hundred years, including jewellery, books, watches, furniture and carpets, fall under Heading 9706 irrespective of material composition - Goods which are merely old or second-hand but not exceeding one hundred years continue under their respective tariff headings. Old and used cars remain under Heading 8703 and the concessional taxation under the specific notification is available if conditions, including non-availment of input tax credit, are fulfilled. Collectibles and memorabilia are classified on essential character, commercial identity and tariff description - Where no specific entry exists and the goods derive predominant value from historical, commemorative or collectible significance, they may merit the residuary entry. For old jewellery, books, furniture, carpets, watches, bags, pens, writing instruments and other instruments, the Applicant did not furnish complete description, composition or specifications. Classification of such goods is fact specific and depends on the exact nature of goods in each transaction, so it cannot be answered in a generalised manner - The classification is ruled for goods whose description matches the specific headings. No specific ruling on classification and rate is issued where complete details are not available – Ordered accordinglyrnrnIssue 2: Applicability of margin scheme under Rule 32(5) of CGST Rules, 2017 to an auctioneer dealing in second-hand goods - Applicant procured goods on approval basis from sellers and sold them to the highest bidder. Title passed directly from seller to buyer at the close of bidding. Applicant issued one invoice to the buyer for the hammer price and buyer's premium and another invoice to the seller for commission - Whether the Applicant is eligible to adopt valuation under Rule 32(5) for second-hand goods procured from unregistered persons - HELD - Rule 32(5) is a special valuation mechanism intended to prevent cascading effect and applies only to a person dealing in buying and selling second-hand goods. The Applicant's own submissions show that the goods are owned by the sellers, that title passes directly from seller to buyer, and that the Applicant issues an invoice to the seller for commission. The Applicant is therefore acting as an auctioneer or intermediary and cannot be treated as the supplier of goods in pure agency transactions. The rule presupposes a purchase price, a selling price and a subsequent resale by the dealer - Margin cannot be computed in consignment or agency transactions where the Applicant does not purchase the goods. The margin scheme is available only where the Applicant acts as principal, actually purchases and resells the goods, sells them as such or after minor processing, avails no input tax credit and maintains proper records. Where the Applicant merely facilitates sale of goods belonging to third parties, the services are classifiable under SAC 9962 and tax is payable on commission and buyer's premium - The Applicant is eligible for Rule 32(5) only in principal-to-principal transactions satisfying the prescribed conditions. The rule does not apply to auctioneering or facilitation transactions.rnrnIssue 3: Adoption of margin scheme and normal valuation depending upon the nature of procurement - Applicant procured second-hand goods from both unregistered persons and registered suppliers charging tax. Applicant undertook that it would not claim the margin scheme where input tax credit is availed - Whether the Applicant can simultaneously adopt valuation under Rule 32(5) for goods procured without input tax credit and normal valuation under Section 15 for goods procured from registered suppliers with input tax credit - HELD - Rule 32(5) itself contains a clear condition that the margin scheme applies only where no input tax credit has been availed on purchase, so the statute contemplates two distinct situations. Where goods are purchased from registered suppliers on payment of tax and credit is availed, valuation is under Section 15 on the transaction value. Where goods are purchased from unregistered persons and no credit is available, the Applicant may opt for Rule 32(5) subject to its conditions - The Applicant's undertaking not to claim the margin scheme where credit is availed is in consonance with statutory provisions. No provision of the GST law prohibits selective application of Rule 32(5) transaction-wise depending upon the nature of procurement - The Applicant can adopt both methods simultaneously depending on the nature of the transaction, provided proper segregation and documentary records are maintained for both categories. [Read less]
GST – Tamil Nadu AAR – Advance Ruling on availability of ITC to the recipient on debit notes - Applicant, a supplier of renting of immovable property service, did not pay GST on rent for earlier years. He later issued debit notes on the recipient tenant in a subsequent financial year, declared them in GSTR-1 and paid the tax. The recipient disputed the debit notes and did not avail input tax credit - Applicant sought advance ruling on the admissibility of input tax credit on the debit notes for the recipient tenant - Whether a supplier can seek an advance ruling under Section 97(2)(d) on the admissibility of input tax ... [Read more]
GST – Tamil Nadu AAR – Advance Ruling on availability of ITC to the recipient on debit notes - Applicant, a supplier of renting of immovable property service, did not pay GST on rent for earlier years. He later issued debit notes on the recipient tenant in a subsequent financial year, declared them in GSTR-1 and paid the tax. The recipient disputed the debit notes and did not avail input tax credit - Applicant sought advance ruling on the admissibility of input tax credit on the debit notes for the recipient tenant - Whether a supplier can seek an advance ruling under Section 97(2)(d) on the admissibility of input tax credit available to the recipient of his supply - HELD - Advance ruling is a decision provided to an applicant on questions in relation to the supply of goods or services or both being undertaken or proposed to be undertaken by the applicant, as defined in Section 95(a). A supplier can seek a ruling only on his own liabilities and obligations and cannot seek an advance ruling for his tenant. The eligibility of input tax credit rests solely with the receiver of the supply and not the supplier. Section 97(2)(d) applies to input tax credit claimed by the applicant on his own inward supplies and not on outward supplies made to customers - As per Section 103, the advance ruling is binding only on the applicant and the concerned officer or the jurisdictional officer, so a ruling issued to a supplier regarding a customer's tax treatment holds no legal binding value for the customer - Section 98(7) provides for a copy of the ruling to be sent to the applicant, the concerned officer and the jurisdictional officer, so it cannot be sent to the tenant - The advance ruling sought on the admissibility of input tax credit on the debit notes issued by the Applicant to his tenant is not maintainable under Sections 95(a), 97(2)(d) and 103 of CGST Act, 2017 – Ordered accordingly [Read less]
Service Tax – Majority Order - Taxability of commitment charges collected by a bank - Section 65(105)(zm), Section 65(12) and Section 67 of Finance Act, 1994 - Appellant, a bank providing banking and other financial services, collected commitment charges from customers who did not avail the sanctioned loan facility and did not pay service tax on them - SCN demanded service tax which was confirmed by the Adjudicating Authority with interest and penalties and the FAA upheld the demand except the penalty under Section 77 - Appellant contended that the charges are in the nature of interest on undisbursed loan amounts exclude... [Read more]
Service Tax – Majority Order - Taxability of commitment charges collected by a bank - Section 65(105)(zm), Section 65(12) and Section 67 of Finance Act, 1994 - Appellant, a bank providing banking and other financial services, collected commitment charges from customers who did not avail the sanctioned loan facility and did not pay service tax on them - SCN demanded service tax which was confirmed by the Adjudicating Authority with interest and penalties and the FAA upheld the demand except the penalty under Section 77 - Appellant contended that the charges are in the nature of interest on undisbursed loan amounts excluded under Rule 6(2)(iv) of the Service Tax (Determination of Value) Rules, 2006 - Whether commitment charges are consideration for a service includible in the gross amount charged or are interest excluded from taxable value - HELD - Provisions of one Act cannot be blindly applied with reference to decisions dealing with other Acts which are not in pari materia, so the definitions of interest under the Interest Act and the Income-tax Act are not examined - Commitment charges involve a clear quid pro quo, namely payment in lieu of the bank's contractual commitment to lend the sanctioned amount at a future date. A payment towards the assured performance of a service cannot be considered as interest and is at best a charge to assure future service. Rule 6(2)(iv) excludes only interest on delayed payment of consideration for provision of services and not interest on loans, and being an exclusion it requires strict construction. The charge is not on the money lent but on the money that sits idle in the bank and entitles the borrower to a separate and additional period of time beyond the date of sanction - Liability for interest is based on compensation for use of the bank's money, whereas commitment charge is for the bank's contractual commitment to lend. The charges are also not liquidated damages as there is no specific contract whose performance is vitiated - Commitment charges form part of the gross amount charged and the demand is upheld on merits for the normal period – The appeal is partly allowedrnrnIssue 2: Extended period of limitation and penalty - Section 73 and Section 78 of Finance Act, 1994 - Whether the extended period can be invoked and penalty imposed where the issue involves interpretation - HELD - The dispute involves an interpretational issue as is clear from the clarification issued by TRU through the CBEC Circular. A case of misdeclaration or suppression of fact is not made out and the duty and interest have to be confined to the normal period. In the circumstances a case for imposition of penalty is also not made out - The demand for the extended period and the penalties are set aside.rnrnIssue 3: Cum-tax benefit - Section 67(2) of Finance Act, 1994 - Whether the Appellant is entitled to cum-tax benefit in determining the taxable value - HELD - Where consideration is received for services rendered, the amount so received is deemed inclusive of service tax and the Appellant is entitled to the cum-duty benefit while determining the taxable value, unless service tax has been separately paid by the customer. Section 67(2) provides that where the gross amount charged is inclusive of service tax, the value of the taxable service is the amount which, when service tax is added, equals the gross amount charged - The duty shall be re-calculated by giving the cum-tax benefit and interest calculated accordingly.rnrnIssue 4: Difference of opinion and conflicting coordinate Bench decisions - Whether the Member (Technical) could decide the merits or the matter should be referred to a larger Bench in view of two conflicting decisions of coordinate Benches on the issue - HELD - The Member (Judicial) refrained from expressing any opinion on merits and held that judicial discipline requires a reference to a larger Bench, while the Member (Technical) decided the merits. On reference, the Third Member found the decision of one coordinate Bench holding commitment charges liable to service tax to be just and reasonable and required to be followed, and noted that the contrary decision was not placed before that Bench. The order of the Member (T) is in line with that ruling although for different reasons - By majority, the Order-in-Appeal is upheld in terms of the findings and directions of the Member (Technical). [Read less]
This is Member Area - Please Login to view this page.
Schedule a demo to know the features and advantages of VILGST portal. Get to know the tips to find the desired results in faster way.
Didn’t find what you are searching for? No worries, please give us the following details and VIL will email you the desired Caselaws at the earliest:

