2026-VIL-1286-DEL-CU

CUSTOMS High Court Cases

Customs - Vires of Section 9A(1) of Customs Tariff Act, 1975 - Rules 4(1)(d), 17 and 18(1) of Customs Tariff (Identification, Assessment and Collection of Anti-Dumping Duty on Dumped Articles and for Determination of Injury) Rules, 1995 - Petitioner challenged the provisions of Section 9A (1) of the Customs Tariff Act, 1975 as ultra vires Article 14 of the Constitution on the ground of unfettered and unguided discretion of the Central Government, after the Central Government decided not to impose anti-dumping duty despite the positive final findings and recommendation of the Designated Authority - Whether the provisions of Section 9A(1) of CTA, 1975 are ultra vires Article 9.1 of the Agreement of 1994 and Article 14 of the Constitution - HELD - Article 9.1 of Agreement on implementation of Article VI of the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade, 1994 does not mandate a single, undivided exercise culminating automatically in imposition of anti-dumping duty. It expressly provides discretion to the authorities of the importing Member even where all requirements for imposition are fulfilled, and the term ‘desirable’ shows that imposition is not obligatory - The Article refers to the authorities of the importing Members and does not prescribe any institutional arrangement, so a Member cannot be refrained from creating a two-tier domestic structure - Section 9A(1) uses the phrase may to vest discretionary power in the Central Govt, while Rule 17 describes the conclusion of the Designated Authority as recommendatory. This deliberate distinction gives the final decision-making power to the Central Government, while the Designated Authority undertakes the specialised technical examination. The discretion is not unguided since it is conditioned by the findings of the Designated Authority, the standard of public interest and the purpose of the anti-dumping regime, which is to remedy unfair trade and maintain a level playing field without descending into protectionism - The impugned provisions are not ultra vires Article 9.1 of the Agreement of 1994 or Article 14 of the Constitution – The writ petition is dismissedrnrnIssue 2: Natural Justice - Decision of Central Government not to impose anti-dumping duty - Section 9A(1) of Customs Tariff Act, 1975 - Petitioner contended that the principle that the person who hears must decide and the grant of an effective opportunity of hearing were violated since the Central Government departed from the recommendation of the Designated Authority - Whether the action of the Central Government has led to violation of natural justice - HELD - Neither the Act of 1975 nor the Rules of 1995 prescribe any procedure to be followed by the Central Government where it rejects a positive recommendation of the Designated Authority. The first stage of investigation and final findings under Rule 17 is quasi-judicial, and the Petitioner had a full hearing at that stage - The second stage of discretion vested in the Central Government does not reopen the adjudication, and the findings of the Designated Authority on dumping, injury and causal link are not revisited. The observation on the quasi-judicial character of the notification relied upon by the Petitioner was rendered incidentally without examination of the text, scheme or object of Section 9A and Rule 18 and does not constitute the ratio decidendi. The discretion under Section 9A is closer to policy formulation than to adjudication, as it necessitates consideration of the interests of the public at large, and is therefore legislative or quasi-legislative in character - The principle that the person who hears must decide is not attracted since neither Section 9A(1) nor Rule 18(1) prescribes a further oral hearing, and a requirement of a second hearing cannot be read into the Act and the Rules. The question whether the amended Section 9C is in force remains sub judice, and the Petition is decided on merits without resting the outcome on the alternate statutory remedy - The second stage exercise by the Central Government is legislative or quasi-legislative in character and does not require a further oral hearing.rnrnIssue 3: Scope of Discretion of Central Government to Depart from Recommendation - Section 9A(1) of Customs Tariff Act, 1975 - Central Government declined to impose anti-dumping duty citing public interest, as one of the three domestic producers had ceased operations following a fire and the assessment obtained regarding the demand-supply impact of the duty - Whether the decision of the Central Government to depart from the positive recommendation of the Designated Authority is sustainable - HELD - The silence of the Act and Rules on procedure does not place the discretion beyond judicial review and only dictates the character of the review. The decision is tested on the scrutiny applicable to legislation and economic regulatory measures, namely whether it falls within the competence conferred by the parent statute, is consistent with fundamental rights, is founded on relevant material bearing a rational nexus to the conclusion reached, and is free from extraneous considerations and mala fides. The mandate of the Designated Authority is limited to examining dumping, injury and causal link - The interests of downstream users, availability of alternative sources of supply at competitive prices and the possibility of the domestic industry becoming a duopoly are different matters examined by the Central Government. The supervening development of one of the three domestic producers ceasing operations, read with the assessment obtained from NITI Aayog and other Government agencies on the demand-supply impact, furnished material bearing a rational and direct nexus to the decision - The finding of the Designated Authority on the historical decline of the domestic industry is analytically distinct from the forward-looking assessment of the Central Government on adequacy of supply. Non-disclosure of the assessment to the Petitioner is not the applicable standard, and no mala fide or abdication of statutory function has been demonstrated. In declining to impose duty despite a positive recommendation, the Central Government acts as custodian of the public interest and balances the interests of the domestic industry against those of the downstream user industry and the consuming public - The challenge to the Office Memorandum fails on merits and the Petition is dismissed.

Create Account



Log In



Forgot Password


Please Note: This facility is only for Subscribing Members.

Email this page



Feedback this page