2026-VIL-1913-CESTAT-KOL-ST

SERVICE TAX CESTAT Cases

Service Tax - Reversal of Cenvat Credit - Notification No. 39/2009-ST - The Appellant provided job-work service for alcoholic beverages and availed exemption under the notification, which requires that no Cenvat credit is taken - Demand was confirmed on the ground that the Appellant had taken Cenvat credit, and a lump sum amount based on a percentage of the value of exempted services was demanded. During the appeal, the Appellant reversed the entire credit taken on capital goods along with interest - Whether reversal of Cenvat credit with interest after the SCN, even at the Tribunal stage, satisfies the condition of the exemption notification - HELD - The notification requires that no Cenvat credit is taken, even in respect of capital goods. Reversal of the credit with interest amounts to non-availment of credit at the initial stage. The Appellant is therefore eligible for the exemption even where the reversal is made after clearance, including at the Tribunal stage – Further, a demand at a percentage of the value of exempted services cannot be sustained even if the assessee failed to opt for proportionate reversal. Rule 6(3AA) of the Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004 is a beneficial provision and has retrospective effect. The Appellant has reversed the entire credit with interest, as evidenced by challans, and no other liability arises. The impugned order is set aside and the appeal is allowed on merits - The Revenue brought no evidence that the Appellant suppressed facts with intent to evade service tax. The quantification of demand is highly disproportionate to the actual credit taken. Reversal of the entire credit with interest shows the bona fides of the Appellant. The demand for the extended period is not sustainable. The demand is also set aside as time-barred – The appeal is allowed

Create Account



Log In



Forgot Password


Please Note: This facility is only for Subscribing Members.

Email this page



Feedback this page