2026-VIL-360-GSTAT-AGR

SGST Tribunal

GST - Appeal against FAA order dismissing time barred first appeal under amnesty scheme - Pre-deposit through electronic credit ledger - Appellant filed the first appeal under the amnesty scheme against an order of the proper officer. The FAA registered the appeal as defective and dismissed it as barred by limitation - Appellant had paid the pre-deposit by debit of the electronic credit ledger as the GST portal did not allow deposit of the requisite percentage through the electronic cash ledger - Respondent contended that the conditions of the scheme were not complied with - Whether the rejection of the first appeal as time barred under the amnesty scheme under notification no. 53/2023 solely due to the debit of pre-deposit from the electronic credit ledger instead of the electronic cash ledger is legally sustainable - HELD - Under the scheme, a time barred first appeal was admissible subject to deposit of the prescribed percentage of the disputed tax, partly through the electronic cash ledger and partly through the electronic credit ledger. Where the pre-deposit is paid through the electronic credit ledger instead of the electronic cash ledger, the appellate authority should not reject the appeal outright on hyper technical grounds - A shortfall or misallocation in the cash component of the pre-deposit is a curable defect. The FAA erred in summarily dismissing the appeal as time barred without giving the Appellant a reasonable opportunity of being heard on merit and to make good the differential cash payment or rebalance the ledger debits. The rejection solely due to the debit from the electronic credit ledger is not legally sustainable - The Appellant is granted time to pay the shortfall cash component through the electronic cash ledger and the corresponding excess in the electronic credit ledger shall be recredited. The FAA is directed to admit the first appeal and decide it afresh after hearing both sides - The appeal is allowed and the order of the FAA is set aside.rnrnIssue 2: Technical glitches on GST portal - Prejudice to statutory remedy of appeal - The Appellant could not deposit the requisite percentage of pre-deposit through the electronic cash ledger on account of a technical problem on the GST portal and debited the entire amount through the electronic credit ledger. Whether technical glitches on the GST portal impeding a taxpayer from complying strictly with ledger selection can prejudice the statutory remedy of appeal - HELD - It is a well settled principle of law that a taxpayer cannot be made to suffer due to technical glitches or system error on the official portal. Technical glitches on the GST common portal impeding a taxpayer from complying strictly with ledger selection cannot prejudice the statutory remedy of appeal - The appeal is allowed and the matter is remanded to the FAA for deciding afresh.

Create Account



Log In



Forgot Password


Please Note: This facility is only for Subscribing Members.

Email this page



Feedback this page