2026-VIL-361-GSTAT-AGR

SGST Tribunal

GST - Penalty on undeclared goods in transit, Documents produced after interception - Mobile Squad Officer intercepted a vehicle and the driver produced some bilties, the corresponding invoices and one e-way bill - On physical verification, a substantial quantity of hosiery, readymade apparels and other goods was found for which no invoice, bilty or e-way bill was produced - Penalty was imposed and the FAA upheld it. Appellant contended that the driver inadvertently produced only one of two bundles of documents - Whether the additional invoices and bilties produced long after interception were sufficient to establish the genuineness of transportation - HELD - The mere assertion that documents were available in a separate bundle does not establish that the goods found were covered by them. The driver had stated at the time of verification that he possessed no other document. The additional documents were produced much after initiation of the proceedings - The absence of buyers and sellers by itself may not invariably be sufficient to reject a transaction. However, when it is considered together with non-production of documents at interception, delayed submission, failure to establish identity and business credentials of the parties and absence of any person claiming ownership, the circumstances cast serious doubt on the explanation - Three trucks of the same transporter were intercepted on the same date and the same explanation was given in each, which does not appear natural and suggests that the goods were transported without declaration with intent to evade tax and that the documents were created as an afterthought. The Appellant failed to establish a reliable documentary link between the additional documents and the undeclared goods - The appeal is dismissed and the order of the FAA affirming the penalty is affirmedrnrnIssue 2: Jurisdiction of transit State Mobile Squad Officer - Appellant contended that mere passage of the vehicle through Uttar Pradesh did not confer jurisdiction on the Mobile Squad Officer to detain or seize the goods moving from Delhi to Madhya Pradesh - Whether the legal principles laid down by the High Court in the decision relied upon by the Appellant are applicable to the facts of the present case - HELD - Where the origin State and destination State are different and goods are moved from a third State, the officers of the transit State are empowered only to intercept and verify and to intimate the concerned authorities. The applicability of a judicial precedent must be determined by examining its material facts and comparing them with the facts of the case under consideration - In the precedent, the documents of buyers and sellers were produced contemporaneously, the parties were registered and genuine dealers, the transactions were acknowledged and reflected in their books and the destination was identifiable outside the State. In the present case, the goods were totally undeclared and transportation of undeclared goods via a transit State might cause a tax effect in the transit State. The Appellant failed to establish that the goods were genuinely destined for a place outside Uttar Pradesh, so the factual foundation for invoking the decision is not established - The decision is distinguishable and does not assist the Appellant. The appeal is dismissed

Create Account



Log In



Forgot Password


Please Note: This facility is only for Subscribing Members.

Email this page



Feedback this page