2026-VIL-362-GSTAT-CTT

SGST Tribunal

GST - Maintainability of Departmental appeals - Monetary limit under Circular No. 207/1/2024-GST dated 26.06.2024 issued under Section 120 - Two appeals filed by the Appellant-State arose from a composite order of the Appellate Authority disposing of two appeals relating to two financial years. The Respondent contended that the demand for each financial year was below the monetary limit prescribed by the Circular and the appeals were therefore barred. Whether the appeals are maintainable in view of the Circular - HELD - Paragraph 3(viii) of the Circular provides that in a composite order which disposes more than one appeal or demand notice, the monetary limit shall be applicable on the total amount and not on the amount involved in an individual appeal or demand notice. The impugned order is a composite order disposing of two separate appeals arising from two orders pertaining to two financial years, so the aggregate tax demand in the composite order is the relevant consideration. The contention that the demand for each period falls below the limit is not sustainable in view of the express language of the clause - The appeals are held to be maintainable.rnrnIssue 2: Short payment of tax - Section 73 or Section 74 - Wilful suppression - The Respondent was engaged in composite supply of works contract services. An enquiry initiated on information from WAMIS detected short payment of tax for two financial years and the SCN proposed recovery under Section 74 read with Section 50. The Respondent did not participate before the Adjudicating Authority -e Appellate Authority re-computed the tax liability and held that there was no intention to evade tax or wilful suppression, so that penalty was leviable under Section 73 - Appellant-State contended that the failure to disclose the correct taxable turnover indicated deliberate suppression within Explanation 2 to Section 74. Whether the Appellate Authority was justified in concluding that the dispute does not fall within Section 74 in the absence of fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression of facts with intent to evade payment of tax - HELD - Section 73 applies where the default is without fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression of facts, whereas Section 74 applies where it is due to such conduct with intent to evade tax. Department must establish by clear and cogent evidence that the omission was deliberate, as mere non-payment or short payment does not by itself show intent to evade tax. In the absence of direct evidence, wilfulness has to be inferred from the surrounding facts and the conduct of the person - Respondent failed to respond to the communications and the SCN and did not appear before the Adjudicating Authority. It offered no cogent explanation even before the Tribunal - Being engaged in works contract services, it was expected to understand its statutory obligations, yet it did not correctly disclose its taxable transactions in Form GSTR-1 and its taxable turnover and tax liability in Form GSTR-3B for two financial years - Respondent deliberately and persistently misstated and suppressed its actual taxable turnover, which would have remained undetected but for the intervention of the Department. The finding of the Appellate Authority that the case should be dealt with under Section 73 is not tenable - The order of the Appellate Authority holding the invocation of Section 74 illegal is set aside, the invocation of Section 74 is restored. Tax liability determined by the Appellate Authority is sustained and the penalty and interest are to be recomputed.

Create Account



Log In



Forgot Password


Please Note: This facility is only for Subscribing Members.

Email this page



Feedback this page