2026-VIL-363-GSTAT-TVP

SGST Tribunal

GST - Jurisdiction of State officers over a person registered in another State - Proceedings under Section 129 - The Enforcement Squad of the State intercepted a vehicle carrying gold jewellery from Maharashtra to Kerala. Forms MOV-01 to MOV-07 and the order in Form MOV-09 under Section 129(3) were issued to the Appellant, who is registered in Maharashtra, and a temporary identification number was issued to the Appellant only later - Whether State officers could exercise jurisdiction over the Appellant before the issue of the temporary identification number - HELD - The State officers could exercise jurisdiction over the Appellant only from the date of issue of the temporary identification number and all proceedings from the date of detention up to that date are non est and void ab initio. On the territorial jurisdiction issue alone, the case is hit by the principle of coram non judice. A defect of jurisdiction goes to the root of the matter and an order passed by an authority having no jurisdiction is a nullity - The entire proceedings are quashed and declared non est and void ab initio.rnrnIssue 2: Time limit for passing order for payment of penalty under Section 129(3) - Goods were detained but the order in Form MOV-09 was not issued within the period prescribed. The Appellant contended that the notice and the order were required to be issued within the timelines in Section 129(3) - Respondent contended that the timelines are directory and not mandatory - Whether an order for payment of penalty passed beyond the timelines in Section 129(3) is valid - HELD - Section 129(3) requires the proper officer to issue the notice within seven days of detention and to pass the order within seven days from the date of service of the notice. The use of the expression shall signifies that adherence to the timeline is mandatory and the Act, being a fiscal statute, is to be construed strictly - Once Constitutional courts have held a provision to be mandatory, the Tribunal cannot read it down as directory. The contents of the order, which refer to a reply filed by the recipient several months after detention, show that it was not passed within the stipulated time. The Respondent produced no record of the dates. Violation of the timeline vitiates the entire proceedings - The order is void ab initio and a nullity in law and is set aside.rnrnIssue 3: Invocation of Section 129 - Tax invoice under Section 31 read with Rule 46 - The consignment was accompanied by a delivery note describing the goods as gold jewellery for job work, while the goods were finished ornaments, and no tax invoice accompanied them - Respondent alleged absence of nexus between the goods and the documents. The Appellant contended that the description was a clerical error for gold jewellery after job work and that the goods were returned after job work - Whether Section 129 could be invoked against the Appellant for absence of a tax invoice - HELD - Section 31 applies only to supply of goods and the onus is on the Respondent to prove that the transaction is a supply. The SCN proceeded on the premise of supply without any basis and no argument was articulated that the transaction is a supply. Once it is not established to be a supply, Section 31 and Rule 46 have no application. The fact that the goods are finished ornaments does not automatically require a tax invoice. The fact that the recipient does not do job work is irrelevant as the Appellant contended that it provided job work to the recipient. The particulars in the delivery note were not refuted and the only discrepancy was in the description. Invocation of Section 129 requires contravention of the provisions of the Act or Rules to be established, which is not done here - The invocation of Section 129 is not sustainable and the case fails on merits.rnrnIssue 4: Reliance on Rule 45(1) at the appellate stage - Contravention not alleged in SCN or order - The FAA and the Respondent relied on Rule 45(1) to support the case against the Appellant. Whether contravention of Rule 45(1) can be invoked at the appellate stage - HELD - The allegation of contravention of Rule 45(1) was neither part of the SCN nor of the order-in-original. The requirements to make a notice or order valid must be contained in such notice or order and cannot be supplanted later. The attempt to invoke the Rule at the appellate stage is not sustainable - The appeal is allowed and the order in appeal is set aside.

Create Account



Log In



Forgot Password


Please Note: This facility is only for Subscribing Members.

Email this page



Feedback this page