2026-VIL-364-GSTAT-TVP

SGST Tribunal

GST - Jurisdiction of State officers over inter-State movement of goods - Proceedings under Section 130 of the CGST Act, 2017 - Appellant is registered only in Andhra Pradesh and is engaged in manufacture and sale of gold jewellery. Its sales representatives carrying sample gold ornaments were intercepted by the Mobile Squad in Kerala. The SCN under Section 130 alleged that the goods were transported without prescribed documents and with intent to evade tax, and confiscation was confirmed - FAA dismissed the appeal holding that, in the absence of statutory documents, the officer ascertained the transaction to be intra-State - Appellant contended that the transaction was an inter-State supply under Section 10(1)(a) of the IGST Act and the State officers lacked jurisdiction - Whether State officers of one State can exercise jurisdiction over an assessee registered in a different State in respect of transactions undertaken in their State without issuing a temporary identification number - HELD - Where the goods originated from Andhra Pradesh and the allegation is of attempted sale in Kerala, the transaction is inter-State and is governed by the IGST Act and not the CGST or SGST Act. The officer had no clue about the nature of the transaction and by default assumed it to be intra-State without any legal basis - The SCN, the order and the order in appeal were all issued to a person registered in another State over whom the State officers had no jurisdiction, and the temporary registration was issued only later to enable filing of the appeal. No credible explanation was offered by the Respondent for the authority under which the proceedings were conducted. The Tribunal may decide an appeal on grounds not set forth in the form of appeal, provided the affected party has had a sufficient opportunity of being heard, which was given. The case is hit by the principle of coram non judice - The entire proceedings are quashed and declared non est and void ab initio - The appeal is allowedrnrnIssue 2: Section 130(1) - Failure to specify the clause in the SCN - The SCN invoked Section 130(1) without specifying the clause alleged to be contravened. Respondent contended that the notice tracks clauses (i), (ii) and (iv), that failure to cite the sub-clause does not vitiate the exercise of power and that no prejudice was alleged. Whether proceedings under Section 130(1) can be launched against a person without specifying the particular clause alleged to be contravened - HELD - Section 130(1) deals with five distinct offences which cannot be clubbed together, and natural justice demands that the taxpayer is put to notice of the specific offence charged. Failure to cite the source of power does not vitiate its exercise only where there is no ambiguity about the source of power and the purpose for which it is exercised - Where multiple interpretations are possible, the authority cannot avoid citing the provision which clarifies the scope of action. The tracking of clauses without citing them is not based on any legal principle. The Appellant addressing intent to evade in its reply or framing a ground on an assumption does not amount to waiver of its right to be informed of the specific charge. An SCN must stand on its own and cannot be improved by submissions made by the Respondent at the second appellate stage. In the absence of specific charges, the proceedings violate the principles of natural justice and are void ab initio - The appeal is allowed.

Create Account



Log In



Forgot Password


Please Note: This facility is only for Subscribing Members.

Email this page



Feedback this page