2026-VIL-366-GSTAT-DEL

SGST Tribunal

GST - Maintainability of departmental appeal - Monetary limit under Circular issued under Section 120 - Appellant filed an appeal under Section 112(3) against the order of the FAA which set aside a demand of tax under RCM on OIDAR services alleged to have been received from a foreign entity on the basis of an intelligence alert - Respondent contended that the disputed tax was below the monetary limit prescribed by the Circular. Appellant contended that the appeal fell within the exclusion in paragraph 4 relating to place of supply and recurring issues involving interpretation - Whether the appeal filed by the Revenue is not maintainable in view of the monetary limits prescribed under the Circular - HELD - The scheme of Section 120 is regulatory and the Circular issued under it binds the departmental authorities, who cannot selectively apply its provisions. The power under Section 112(3) must be exercised in conformity with the Circular. Where the dispute pertains to demand of tax, only the aggregate disputed tax is considered for the monetary limit. Clause 4(iv)(e) cannot be read in isolation. All matters in clause 4(iv), namely valuation, classification, refunds, place of supply or any other issue, stand on the same footing and must be recurring in nature or involve interpretation. Mere statement that SCNs were issued for other years, without placing any document on record, does not establish that the issue is recurring. No interpretation of a notification is involved, as the issue is limited to the factual question whether the Respondent actually received the services. The review order ignored the Circular and failed to disclose how the case was covered by any exclusion, which wasted judicial resources. As the disputed tax is significantly below the prescribed threshold, the appeal is barred by the monetary limit. The merits of liability under RCM were not examined - The appeal is dismissed as not maintainable.

Create Account



Log In



Forgot Password


Please Note: This facility is only for Subscribing Members.

Email this page



Feedback this page