2026-VIL-367-GSTAT-PB

SGST Tribunal

GST - Intermediary services or Export of services under Section 2(6) of the IGST Act – Rendering of freight forwarding, clearing and forwarding and related services to an overseas entity under a Service Agreement. Under the agreement, the Respondent handles the routing of the overseas entity's shipments in India and the expenses paid on its behalf are charged to it. The Respondent claimed refund of unutilised Input Tax Credit on export of services without payment of tax. The refund was proposed to be rejected on the ground that the Respondent is an intermediary - The FAA held in favour of the Respondent. Revenue contended that the Respondent acted as an agent and that the place of supply is in India under Section 13(8)(b) - Whether the services rendered by the Respondent to its overseas recipient qualify as export of services under Section 2(6) of the IGST Act or fall within the definition of intermediary services under Section 2(13), and whether the Respondent is eligible for refund of unutilised ITC on account of zero-rated supplies - HELD - An intermediary merely arranges or facilitates the supply between two other parties without himself supplying the main service, and the definition expressly excludes a person who supplies on his own account. The phrase ‘on behalf of’ in the agreement does not alter the character of the transaction, as the substance, the conduct of the parties and the flow of consideration establish a principal-to-principal relationship - The Respondent is not a party to any arrangement between the overseas entity and its clients, orders and payments of the clients go to the overseas entity, the Respondent negotiates no transaction, has no authority to conclude contracts and renders services using its own resources and personnel. There are only two parties and no second supply of facilitation, so the requirements of three parties and two distinct supplies under the CBIC Circular are not satisfied - The Respondent supplies the main service on its own account and the exclusionary clause in Section 2(13) applies. The place of supply is outside India under Section 13(2) and all conditions of Section 2(6) are satisfied, so the services qualify as export of services and the Respondent is entitled to the refund - The findings of the FAA are upheld and the refund is to be granted with applicable interest under Section 56 - The appeals of the Revenue are dismissed

Create Account



Log In



Forgot Password


Please Note: This facility is only for Subscribing Members.

Email this page



Feedback this page