2026-VIL-337-GSTAT-SHM

SGST Tribunal

GST - Non-speaking order and pre-judged SCN - Sections 75(6) and 107(12) of the CGST Act, 2017 - Respondent issued an SCN proposing to reclassify PP non-woven fabric bags from Tariff Heading 6305 to Tariff Heading 3923, and the adjudicating authority confirmed the demand with interest and penalty. The FAA upheld the order - Appellant contended that both orders are non-speaking and unreasoned, and that the SCN was issued with a pre-determined conclusion without any inquiry into the manufacturing process - Whether the orders of the adjudicating authority and the FAA are sustainable - HELD - The adjudicating authority passed a mechanical order without an independent evaluation of facts or setting out the grounds of its decision, in defiance of Section 75(6). The FAA was under a mandatory obligation under Section 107(12) to set out the points for determination, the decision thereon and the reasons. The FAA merely recorded a few submissions in one paragraph and dismissed them in the next, with no independent analysis and total silence on the technical reports and precedents cited. Recording reasons is not a mere procedural formality, as it ensures transparency, prevents arbitrariness and enables the higher forum to understand the path of reasoning. A mechanical affirmation reduces the right of appeal to an empty formality and is a fatal blow to the principles of natural justice. The concluding paragraphs of the SCN reflect a pre-judged conclusion and closed mind, and a notice reading like a decision rather than a proposal denies natural justice and vitiates the subsequent adjudication - The orders of both authorities are non-speaking, unreasoned and bad in law and are quashed.rnrnIssue 2: Classification of PP non-woven fabric bags - Tariff Heading 6305 or Tariff Heading 3923 - The Appellant manufactures PP non-woven fabric from PP granules by a spunbond extrusion process and makes bags by cutting and ultrasonic sealing of that fabric. The Respondent classified the bags as articles of plastic on the ground that the primary raw material is PP granules - Whether PP non-woven fabric bags are classifiable as made-up textile articles under Tariff Heading 6305 or as articles of plastics under Tariff Heading 3923 - HELD - The Revenue cannot adopt a double standard by taxing one taxpayer at a higher rate while allowing a direct competitor in the same jurisdiction the lower rate. The immediate raw material of the bags is PP non-woven fabric, a distinct intermediate product with its own commercial identity classified under Tariff Heading 5603, which the Revenue itself accepts - The PP granules lose their original identity through the spunbond process, so classification cannot rest on the starting raw material. Note 1 and Note 2(p) to Chapter 39 exclude textiles and textile articles of Section XI, so a made-up article of such fabric cannot be dragged back into the plastic chapter. The decisions relied on by the Revenue concerned woven sacks and bags from slit plastic tapes and are distinguishable - CBIC Circular No. 80/54 dated 31.12.2018 addresses conventional laminated plastic bags, and a circular cannot override Chapter Notes or enhance the rate of tax without authority of law. Even if both headings apply, the specific description under Tariff Heading 6305 must be preferred over the general description under Tariff Heading 3923 - Non-woven fabric bags are classifiable under Tariff Heading 6305. The order of the FAA is set aside and the appeal is allowed

Create Account



Log In



Forgot Password


Please Note: This facility is only for Subscribing Members.

Email this page



Feedback this page