2026-VIL-339-GSTAT-CTT

SGST Tribunal

GST - Denial of ITC on invoices of non-existent supplier - Section 16(2)(b) of the CGST Act, 2017 - Appellant availed ITC on purchases from a supplier which investigation found to be non-existent, as the registered proprietor disowned the business and registration and the owner of the premises denied letting it out. The rent agreement used for registration was forged, as its signatories had died long before its date - The Appellant produced invoices, e-way bills, weighment slips and bank statement but did not produce stock register, purchase and sale registers or transport challans. The demand under Section 74 was confirmed by the adjudicating authority and the FAA - Whether ITC availed against invoices issued by a non-existent supplier is admissible when the supplier was registered on the date of the transaction - HELD - The essential ingredient of input tax under Section 2(62) is a transaction of supply, and a supply can happen only if both the supplier and the recipient exist and carry on business. In the absence of any business at the registered place of business, the invoices are reduced to mere paper invoices without any underlying supply of goods - Registration obtained by a forged rent agreement is void ab initio. Validity of registration on the date of transaction, filing of returns by the supplier and appearance of the invoices in GSTR-2B are irrelevant. Invoices, e-way bills, weighment slips and bank payment do not counter the allegation and cannot be taken as evidence of receipt of goods, so the condition in Section 16(2)(b) is not fulfilled - Payment by bearer cheques without proof of credit to the supplier's account weakens reliance on the bank statement. The stock register and affidavit were not admitted as additional evidence, as no formal application explaining reasonable cause was made. The principle that a purchasing dealer cannot be denied credit for the default of a genuine selling dealer does not apply where the supply transaction itself is a paper transaction - ITC is held inadmissible, the demand is confirmed and the appeal is dismissed.rnrnIssue 2: Invocation of Section 74 - Commission of fraud - The Appellant contended that Section 74 had no application as there was no fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression of facts on its part - Whether Section 74 was rightly invoked for recovery of the ITC - HELD - Once non-existence of any business at the registered place of business and obtaining of registration by fraudulent means is established, the complicity of the recipient availing ITC against invoices of such a registrant is established as a natural corollary. Commission of fraud is one of the grounds for invoking Section 74 for recovery of inadmissible ITC. Taking ITC without receipt of goods is an offence under Section 122(1)(vi), liable to penalty equivalent to the ITC so availed - The invocation of Section 74 is sustained.c

Create Account



Log In



Forgot Password


Please Note: This facility is only for Subscribing Members.

Email this page



Feedback this page