2026-VIL-1266-GUJ-CE

CENTRAL EXCISE High Court Cases

Central Excise - CENVAT credit on furnace oil used in captive power plant - Electricity supplied to Grinding Unit and Jetty - Respondent manufactures clinker and cement through a Clinker Unit and a Grinding Unit, with a captive power plant about 14 kilometers from the Clinker Unit and a captive jetty at the Grinding Unit. Respondent availed CENVAT credit on furnace oil used for generating electricity supplied to the Clinker Unit, the Grinding Unit, the jetty and the residential colony. The adjudicating authority allowed credit for the electricity supplied to the Clinker Unit but denied it for the Grinding Unit, the jetty and the colony, and imposed penalties under Rule 15(1). The CESTAT allowed credit for the Grinding Unit and the jetty - Revenue contended that the Grinding Unit has a separate registration, is not part of the factory and was claimed as a separate entity for area-based exemption - Whether CENVAT credit on furnace oil used as input in the power plant is available to the extent the electricity is supplied to the Grinding Unit and the jetty - HELD - The CESTAT recorded findings of fact that the Clinker Unit, the Grinding Unit and the jetty are part of the manufacture of final products of the Respondent and are treated as the same factory, as all linking roads are in the possession and control of the Respondent. In such circumstances, it makes no difference to the eligibility of credit that the power plant is 14 kilometers away or that there is a distance between the units - The electricity was wheeled out only to the Clinker Unit, the Grinding Unit and the jetty, with no sale or diversion to an outsider, unlike a case where excess electricity is sold. The only irregularity was non-compliance with the prescribed procedure applicable on the principle of a job worker, and the substantial benefit of credit cannot be denied for that reason - The Respondent is entitled to CENVAT credit on the furnace oil to the extent the electricity is supplied to the Grinding Unit and the jetty - Since the Respondent was entitled to the CENVAT credit on the furnace oil to the extent the electricity was supplied to the Grinding Unit and the jetty, the very basis of the levy of penalty does not survive - The question is answered in favour of the Respondent. The Revenue appeals are dismissed

Create Account



Log In



Forgot Password


Please Note: This facility is only for Subscribing Members.

Email this page



Feedback this page