2026-VIL-1276-DEL

SGST High Court Cases

GST - Taxability of Corporate Guarantee - Section 7(1)(c) read with Entry 2 of Schedule I - Petitioners, being holding or group companies, furnished corporate guarantees to banking companies or financial institutions for the borrowings of their subsidiaries and charged no consideration. The Respondents sought to tax the guarantees as supply of services, and the Petitioners challenged the levy. Whether a corporate guarantee furnished without consideration for the borrowings of a related person constitutes a supply of services under Section 7(1)(c) read with Entry 2 of Schedule I of the Act of 2017, and who is its recipient - HELD - Entry 2 of Schedule I presupposes a supply and dispenses only with the requirement of consideration. The guarantor places its balance sheet behind the borrowings of the subsidiary and assumes the risk of default from the moment the guarantee is executed. Something of value therefore passes to the subsidiary, which is neither goods, money nor securities, and is a service under Section 2(102). The assumption of another's credit risk is a recognised commercial service, as shown by the taxation of bank guarantees. The motive of protecting the investment does not alter the character of the transaction, since the definition of business under Section 2(17) is transaction-centric. The guarantee is incidental or ancillary to the trade of the guarantor under Section 2(17)(b), and the phrase "in the course or furtherance of business" does not require ordinariness. Under Section 2(93)(c), the recipient is the person to whom the service is rendered, which is the subsidiary and not the lender. The supply by the guarantor is distinct from the loan by the lender and cannot be a single composite supply under Section 8. The levy under the Act of 2017 does not depend on consideration, so the earlier service tax decisions based on a consideration-linked definition of service do not apply - A corporate guarantee furnished by a holding or group company for the borrowings of a related person is a supply of services even where no consideration is charged, and the Petitioners' challenge to taxability is rejected - The impugned show cause notices, orders and demands are set aside to the extent contrary to the findings herein, the proper officers are to determine liability afresh after hearing the Petitioners - The writ petitions are partly allowed.rnrn rnrnIssue 2: Exclusion as Actionable Claim or Security - Section 7(2)(a) read with Entry 6 of Schedule III and Section 2(102) - Petitioners contended that the guarantee is an actionable claim or a security and is therefore outside the levy. Whether a corporate guarantee furnished for a related person stands excluded from the levy as an actionable claim or as a security - HELD - The exclusion applies to the subject matter of the supply, that is, where the thing supplied is itself an actionable claim. What the subsidiary receives is credit support and not a claim, since the subsidiary acquires no right against the guarantor. Any claim arises in favour of the lender, who is not the recipient of the supply. If the exclusion were applied as urged, it would cover every bank guarantee, although the commission on such guarantees has consistently been treated as consideration for a taxable service. The definition of securities under Section 2(h) of the Act of 1956 is confined to marketable instruments and to rights or interests in securities. A guarantee is a security only in the sense of collateral for a debt, and the two meanings cannot be treated as the same - The corporate guarantee is not excluded from the levy either as an actionable claim or as a security, and the plea is rejected.rnrn rnrnIssue 3: Valuation of Corporate Guarantee - Rule 28(2) of the Rules of 2017 - The Petitioners challenged Rule 28(2), inserted by Notification No.52/2023-Central Tax dated 26.10.2023 and amended by Notification No.12/2024 dated 10.07.2024, which prescribes a deemed value for corporate guarantees given to a related person, as ultra vires the Act and violative of Articles 14, 19(1)(g), 246A and 265 of the Constitution. Whether the deemed valuation under Rule 28(2) is intra vires the Act of 2017 and consistent with the Constitution - HELD - The taxable event, the person liable, the rate and the measure are all found in Sections 7, 9 and 15, and leaving the method of valuation to delegated legislation within the policy of Section 15 is a permissible delegation of detail. A presumptive measure of value is not objectionable by itself, and the amount guaranteed is only the yardstick by which the value of the service is measured - The recommendation of the GST Council deserves deference but does not exclude judicial review on the ground of vires or arbitrariness. However, the figure was taken from the Safe Harbour Rules, where it is an option for the taxpayer, and the Council was aware that the true value of a guarantee could be lower. Rule 28(2) is a non obstante provision and operates even where the supplier shows a lower open market value. A presumptive valuation made mandatory, even where the actual value is ascertainable, is arbitrary and violative of Article 14 - Rule 28(2) is accordingly read down so that the deemed value is a rebuttable presumption which yields to a lower open market value established by the supplier on cogent and verifiable material. The consideration agreed between related persons, or the absence of any consideration, cannot by itself displace the deemed value. The proviso to Rule 28(2), which accepts the invoice value where the recipient is eligible for full input tax credit, is valid as the classification rests on the design of GST. Eligibility of the recipient to full credit is a question of fact and cannot be presumed merely because the parties are related - Rule 28(2) is intra vires but is read down as a rebuttable presumption, and the proviso is upheld.rnrn rnrnIssue 4: Time of Supply and Period of Levy - Sections 13(2) and 2(33) - Respondents contended that the taxable event recurs every year and that the levy extends to guarantees executed earlier and continuing thereafter. Whether a corporate guarantee is a continuous supply of services, when the supply takes place, and the levy on guarantees executed before 01.07.2017 and before 26.10.2023 - HELD - The service, being the assumption of risk, is supplied when the guarantee is executed and delivered. The continuing obligation is only a consequence of the supply already made, and invocation of the guarantee is not a new supply. Each renewal, extension of tenure or enhancement of the guaranteed amount is a fresh supply, valued with reference to the period of renewal or the amount of enhancement. Section 2(33) requires periodic payment obligations, which are absent in a gratuitous guarantee - A fiction under a Rule relates only to value and cannot alter a definition in the Act, so the guarantee is not a continuous supply of services. The time of supply is governed by Section 13(2)(a) or (b) and not by Section 13(2)(c), and disclosure as a related-party commitment does not amount to showing receipt in the books of the recipient. The tax is to be computed on execution for the entire tenure, and where the guarantee is released early the supplier may issue a credit note under Section 34 - The Respondents may consider permitting collection in annual instalments under Section 148, without altering the single supply. Guarantees executed before 01.07.2017 are not taxable unless renewed, extended or enhanced thereafter. Guarantees executed between 01.07.2017 and 25.10.2023 are taxable, but Rule 28(2) does not apply to them as the Government has not exercised its power under Section 164(3) to give it earlier effect. Their value must be determined under the Rules then in force on material specific to the guarantee, and Rule 31 cannot be used to apply the deemed figure indirectly. The words 'located in India' and 'per annum'

Create Account



Log In



Forgot Password


Please Note: This facility is only for Subscribing Members.

Email this page



Feedback this page