2026-VIL-211-AAR

SGST Advance Ruling Authority

GST – Maharashtra AAR - Classification of second-hand goods dealt with by an auctioneer under the Customs Tariff based rate notification - Applicant, an auctioneer, facilitated auction, private and exhibition sale of second-hand or used goods such as prints, sculptures, jewellery, books, furniture, carpets, watches, bags, cameras, pens, instruments, cars, collectibles and memorabilia - Whether the goods dealt with by the Applicant can be classified and the applicable rate determined in a generalised manner for all such categories - HELD - Classification under GST is determined with reference to the Customs Tariff Act read with the rate notification. Explanation (iv) makes the General Rules for Interpretation applicable, under which the heading providing the most specific description is preferred to a general one. Old prints, engravings and lithographs fall under Heading 9702, old sculptures and statuary under Heading 9703, and used cameras under Heading 9007. Antiques of an age exceeding one hundred years, including jewellery, books, watches, furniture and carpets, fall under Heading 9706 irrespective of material composition - Goods which are merely old or second-hand but not exceeding one hundred years continue under their respective tariff headings. Old and used cars remain under Heading 8703 and the concessional taxation under the specific notification is available if conditions, including non-availment of input tax credit, are fulfilled. Collectibles and memorabilia are classified on essential character, commercial identity and tariff description - Where no specific entry exists and the goods derive predominant value from historical, commemorative or collectible significance, they may merit the residuary entry. For old jewellery, books, furniture, carpets, watches, bags, pens, writing instruments and other instruments, the Applicant did not furnish complete description, composition or specifications. Classification of such goods is fact specific and depends on the exact nature of goods in each transaction, so it cannot be answered in a generalised manner - The classification is ruled for goods whose description matches the specific headings. No specific ruling on classification and rate is issued where complete details are not available – Ordered accordinglyrnrnIssue 2: Applicability of margin scheme under Rule 32(5) of CGST Rules, 2017 to an auctioneer dealing in second-hand goods - Applicant procured goods on approval basis from sellers and sold them to the highest bidder. Title passed directly from seller to buyer at the close of bidding. Applicant issued one invoice to the buyer for the hammer price and buyer's premium and another invoice to the seller for commission - Whether the Applicant is eligible to adopt valuation under Rule 32(5) for second-hand goods procured from unregistered persons - HELD - Rule 32(5) is a special valuation mechanism intended to prevent cascading effect and applies only to a person dealing in buying and selling second-hand goods. The Applicant's own submissions show that the goods are owned by the sellers, that title passes directly from seller to buyer, and that the Applicant issues an invoice to the seller for commission. The Applicant is therefore acting as an auctioneer or intermediary and cannot be treated as the supplier of goods in pure agency transactions. The rule presupposes a purchase price, a selling price and a subsequent resale by the dealer - Margin cannot be computed in consignment or agency transactions where the Applicant does not purchase the goods. The margin scheme is available only where the Applicant acts as principal, actually purchases and resells the goods, sells them as such or after minor processing, avails no input tax credit and maintains proper records. Where the Applicant merely facilitates sale of goods belonging to third parties, the services are classifiable under SAC 9962 and tax is payable on commission and buyer's premium - The Applicant is eligible for Rule 32(5) only in principal-to-principal transactions satisfying the prescribed conditions. The rule does not apply to auctioneering or facilitation transactions.rnrnIssue 3: Adoption of margin scheme and normal valuation depending upon the nature of procurement - Applicant procured second-hand goods from both unregistered persons and registered suppliers charging tax. Applicant undertook that it would not claim the margin scheme where input tax credit is availed - Whether the Applicant can simultaneously adopt valuation under Rule 32(5) for goods procured without input tax credit and normal valuation under Section 15 for goods procured from registered suppliers with input tax credit - HELD - Rule 32(5) itself contains a clear condition that the margin scheme applies only where no input tax credit has been availed on purchase, so the statute contemplates two distinct situations. Where goods are purchased from registered suppliers on payment of tax and credit is availed, valuation is under Section 15 on the transaction value. Where goods are purchased from unregistered persons and no credit is available, the Applicant may opt for Rule 32(5) subject to its conditions - The Applicant's undertaking not to claim the margin scheme where credit is availed is in consonance with statutory provisions. No provision of the GST law prohibits selective application of Rule 32(5) transaction-wise depending upon the nature of procurement - The Applicant can adopt both methods simultaneously depending on the nature of the transaction, provided proper segregation and documentary records are maintained for both categories.

Create Account



Log In



Forgot Password


Please Note: This facility is only for Subscribing Members.

Email this page



Feedback this page