2026-VIL-1268-GUJ-CU

CUSTOMS High Court Cases

Customs - Export benefit under the DFIA Scheme - Classification of import item under SION Entry E22 or E76 - The Respondent exported liquid glucose concentrate and obtained DFIA Authorisations by declaring the import item as Maize (Corn) Starch under SION Entry E22. The Authorisations were transferred to third parties and remain valid and subsisting, as DGFT did not cancel or suspend them. The investigation found that starch slurry was directly used to manufacture liquid glucose and powdered starch was never used as an input - Appellant contended that the correct input was Maize under SION Entry E76 - SCN issued under Section 28AAA with confiscation under Section 113(i) and penalty under Section 114(iii), which the CESTAT set aside - Whether the Respondent was justified in claiming import of inputs under SION Entry E22 and not SION Entry E76 - HELD - Liquid glucose is a common export item under both entries, and Entry E22 specifies glucose in both liquid concentrate and powder forms while Entry E76 covers only liquid glucose. Starch slurry, essentially starch in slurry form, was used as the immediate input in manufacturing the export item, so it cannot be said that starch was not an input. The immediate parent material for the export goods was starch falling under SION Entry E22, and denial of the benefit on the ground that maize is the original input is not sustainable. The deletion of Entry E22 by DGFT on the premise that it was being misused by exporters supports the finding that the export item remained the same under both entries - The Respondent was justified in claiming the benefit under SION Entry E22. The Revenue appeals is dismissedrnrnIssue 2: Recovery under Section 28AAA, confiscation under Section 113(i) and penalty under Section 114(iii) of the Customs Act, 1962 - The DFIA Authorisations were issued by DGFT and the Appellant invoked Section 28AAA on the ground of wilful mis-statement and suppression of facts in obtaining them - Whether the Revenue could invoke Section 28AAA and sustain confiscation and penalty when DGFT has accepted the classification of the import item - HELD - DGFT is the proper authority to determine classification of goods under the DFIA claims. The Authorisations issued by DGFT are valid and subsisting, no proceedings for cancellation or suspension have been initiated and DGFT has accepted the classification of the import item under SION Entry E22. The Appellant could not have invoked Section 28AAA in these circumstances. In view of the findings of fact that there was no wilful mis-statement or suppression of facts for obtaining the Authorisations, the Revenue authorities were not justified in invoking Section 113(i) read with Section 114(iii) - The appeal is dismissed

Create Account



Log In



Forgot Password


Please Note: This facility is only for Subscribing Members.

Email this page



Feedback this page