2026-VIL-343-GSTAT-BLR

SGST Tribunal

GST - Bench allocation of Revenue appeal before GSTAT - Office Order on classification of Bench - The FAA partly allowed the taxpayer's appeal by dropping and reducing penalties. The Revenue filed an appeal before the Tribunal against this. The Respondent objected that disputes involving determination of tax or ITC under Sections 73 and 74 are assigned to another Bench under the Office Order. Whether the appeal lies before this Bench - HELD - The principal tax demands stand discharged and appropriated. The sole surviving controversy is the imposition and quantum of penalties dropped or reduced by the FAA. Matters relating to an order imposing penalty are expressly assigned to this Bench under the Office Order. The objection is devoid of merit - The objection on Bench jurisdiction is rejected.rnrnIssue 2: Requirement of DIN on review authorization - Section 112(3) of CGST Act, 2017 - The Respondent contended that the authorization issued by the Principal Commissioner for filing the appeal did not bear a Document Identification Number as mandated by the CBIC Circular. Whether the absence of DIN on an authorization under Section 112(3) invalidates the Revenue's appeal - HELD - The mandate to generate and quote a DIN applies to communications issued by departmental officers to taxpayers and other external persons, so that recipients can verify their authenticity. An authorization under Section 112(3) is purely an internal inter-departmental administrative direction issued by the Principal Commissioner to the Review Section or Assistant Commissioner authorizing the filing of an appeal. It is not a notice, order or communication issued to an outside party. Non-quoting of a DIN on such an authorization does not vitiate its validity or the maintainability of the appeal - The objection is rejected.rnrnIssue 3: Bar of proceedings by amnesty waiver - Section 128A of CGST Act, 2017 - The Respondent filed Form GST SPL-02 and obtained an order in Form GST SPL-05 waiving penalty. It contended that all proceedings stood terminated by operation of law. Whether the order in Form GST SPL-05 bars the Revenue's appeal - HELD - Section 128A(1) applies exclusively to demands raised or determined under Section 73 and has no application to proceedings under Section 74. The order in Form GST SPL-05 covered only the residual penalty under Section 73(9) on part of the demand. For the demand upheld under Section 74, the Respondent itself paid the full tax, interest and penalty. The present appeal concerns the penalty dropped on one demand and the downgrading of another demand from Section 74 to Section 73. Neither was covered by the waiver order. Under Rule 164(15) and the scheme of Section 128A, an order in Form GST SPL-05 cannot extinguish the right of appeal already exercised by the Revenue under Section 112(3) - The contention is rejected.rnrnIssue 4: Violation of natural justice - Section 75(4) of CGST Act, 2017 - The Respondent alleged that the Order-in-Original was passed without granting a personal hearing. Whether Section 75(4) was violated - HELD - The Order-in-Original records that a personal hearing notice was issued fixing the date of hearing. The authorized representative of the Respondent appeared and made detailed oral submissions on both issues. A further hearing was also extended and attended. The allegation that no personal hearing was granted is contrary to the record. The principles of natural justice and Section 75(4) were complied with - The contention is rejected.rnrnIssue 5: Invocation of Section 74 on taxable receipts omitted from returns - Explanation 2 to Section 74 of CGST Act, 2017 - Commission write-off accounted in the Profit and Loss Account and receipts reflected in Form 26AS were not reported in GSTR-1 and GSTR-3B. The Respondent declared the additional liability in GSTR-9 only after the audit team commenced verification and confronted it with the financial statements and Form 26AS. The FAA converted the proceedings from Section 74 to Section 73 under Section 75(2). Whether the ingredients of suppression under Section 74 are made out and the FAA erred in converting the demand to Section 73 - HELD - Every non-payment of tax cannot be treated as evasion by fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression of facts. Each case must be examined to see whether evidence of wilful suppression for the purpose of evading tax is available on record. Explanation 2 to Section 74 defines suppression as non-declaration of facts or information required to be declared in the return, statement or report. Under the self-assessment regime of Sections 39 and 59, a registered person is bound to report all taxable supplies, considerations, commissions and write-offs in GSTR-1 and GSTR-3B. Concealing taxable receipts in private accounts while omitting them from statutory returns is wilful suppression. The mere existence of entries in books of account is no defence when those figures were withheld from the returns. The SCN set out the foundational facts and was not based on unsubstantiated mismatches. A disclosure forced by audit intervention cannot be treated as a voluntary pre-SCN disclosure. The ingredients of suppression are fully met and the FAA erred in converting the demand to Section 73 - The conversion to Section 73 is set aside and the 100% penalty under Section 74(1) is restored.rnrnIssue 6: Penalty on self-assessed tax declared in GSTR-1 but not paid in GSTR-3B - Section 73 read with Section 75(2) of CGST Act, 2017 - The Respondent declared the outward supplies in GSTR-1 but did not discharge the tax in GSTR-3B for over three years. It paid the principal tax only after audit intervention and did not pay interest under Section 50. The FAA held that Section 74 was not invocable and dropped the penalty. Whether the FAA erred in dropping the penalty - HELD - Declaration of the outward supplies in GSTR-1, which was already on the portal, negates suppression. The FAA therefore rightly held that Section 74 was not invocable. However, waiver of penalty under Section 73(6) or Section 73(8) read with Section 75(2) requires payment of both tax and interest. The Respondent paid the tax only after audit intervention and did not pay the mandatory interest. The FAA erred in dropping the penalty altogether - The dropping of penalty is set aside and penalty is confirmed under Section 73 read with Section 75(2). The Revenue's appeal is allowed.

Create Account



Log In



Forgot Password


Please Note: This facility is only for Subscribing Members.

Email this page



Feedback this page