2026-VIL-1269-GUJ

VAT High Court Cases

Gujarat VAT Act, 2003 - Cancellation of composition permission - Section 14D of Gujarat VAT Act, 2003 and Rule 28C(6) and (7) of Gujarat VAT Rules, 2006 - Appellant, a restaurant, was permitted to pay lump sum tax under the composition scheme. Authorities cancelled the permission on finding invoices for purchase of sugar sachets from outside the State, one in the name of the Appellant and others in the name of a concern run by the Appellant's husband - Appellant's books showed that the amounts were received in cash from that concern and paid to the supplier on its behalf, and no purchase was debited in the books - Tribunal drew a presumption that the entries were made to come out of the breach of conditions and confirmed the cancellation for the period up to the end of the financial year - Whether the Tribunal was justified in confirming the cancellation of the composition permission - HELD - The authorities used the bulldozer to crush a fly by cancelling the permission. The ledger account shows that before payment to the supplier through the bank the amount was received in cash from the husband and was shown in the ledger account of his concern. Such entries were not doubted by the respondent-authority nor proven to be sham or bogus, so the presumption drawn by the Tribunal that they were made with a view to come out of the breach has no basis or corroborative evidence on record - Rule 28C(6) is attracted only where purchases are made from outside the State, and there is nothing on record to show that the Appellant debited any amount towards purchase of goods or raw materials in the books of account - Where the payment through the Appellant's bank account was merely reimbursement of the amount received from the husband, it cannot be said that the Appellant made purchases from outside the State. Except the invoices in question, the authorities could not find any other purchase in contravention of Rule 28C(6). The second question, whether purchase of tax-free goods from outside the State warrants cancellation, is not answered since the Appellant never purchased such goods - The Tribunal was not justified in confirming the cancellation of the composition permission. The question is answered in favour of the appellant and the appeal is allowed

Create Account



Log In



Forgot Password


Please Note: This facility is only for Subscribing Members.

Email this page



Feedback this page