2026-VIL-1907-CESTAT-CHE-ST

SERVICE TAX CESTAT Cases

Service Tax – Majority Order - Taxability of commitment charges collected by a bank - Section 65(105)(zm), Section 65(12) and Section 67 of Finance Act, 1994 - Appellant, a bank providing banking and other financial services, collected commitment charges from customers who did not avail the sanctioned loan facility and did not pay service tax on them - SCN demanded service tax which was confirmed by the Adjudicating Authority with interest and penalties and the FAA upheld the demand except the penalty under Section 77 - Appellant contended that the charges are in the nature of interest on undisbursed loan amounts excluded under Rule 6(2)(iv) of the Service Tax (Determination of Value) Rules, 2006 - Whether commitment charges are consideration for a service includible in the gross amount charged or are interest excluded from taxable value - HELD - Provisions of one Act cannot be blindly applied with reference to decisions dealing with other Acts which are not in pari materia, so the definitions of interest under the Interest Act and the Income-tax Act are not examined - Commitment charges involve a clear quid pro quo, namely payment in lieu of the bank's contractual commitment to lend the sanctioned amount at a future date. A payment towards the assured performance of a service cannot be considered as interest and is at best a charge to assure future service. Rule 6(2)(iv) excludes only interest on delayed payment of consideration for provision of services and not interest on loans, and being an exclusion it requires strict construction. The charge is not on the money lent but on the money that sits idle in the bank and entitles the borrower to a separate and additional period of time beyond the date of sanction - Liability for interest is based on compensation for use of the bank's money, whereas commitment charge is for the bank's contractual commitment to lend. The charges are also not liquidated damages as there is no specific contract whose performance is vitiated - Commitment charges form part of the gross amount charged and the demand is upheld on merits for the normal period – The appeal is partly allowedrnrnIssue 2: Extended period of limitation and penalty - Section 73 and Section 78 of Finance Act, 1994 - Whether the extended period can be invoked and penalty imposed where the issue involves interpretation - HELD - The dispute involves an interpretational issue as is clear from the clarification issued by TRU through the CBEC Circular. A case of misdeclaration or suppression of fact is not made out and the duty and interest have to be confined to the normal period. In the circumstances a case for imposition of penalty is also not made out - The demand for the extended period and the penalties are set aside.rnrnIssue 3: Cum-tax benefit - Section 67(2) of Finance Act, 1994 - Whether the Appellant is entitled to cum-tax benefit in determining the taxable value - HELD - Where consideration is received for services rendered, the amount so received is deemed inclusive of service tax and the Appellant is entitled to the cum-duty benefit while determining the taxable value, unless service tax has been separately paid by the customer. Section 67(2) provides that where the gross amount charged is inclusive of service tax, the value of the taxable service is the amount which, when service tax is added, equals the gross amount charged - The duty shall be re-calculated by giving the cum-tax benefit and interest calculated accordingly.rnrnIssue 4: Difference of opinion and conflicting coordinate Bench decisions - Whether the Member (Technical) could decide the merits or the matter should be referred to a larger Bench in view of two conflicting decisions of coordinate Benches on the issue - HELD - The Member (Judicial) refrained from expressing any opinion on merits and held that judicial discipline requires a reference to a larger Bench, while the Member (Technical) decided the merits. On reference, the Third Member found the decision of one coordinate Bench holding commitment charges liable to service tax to be just and reasonable and required to be followed, and noted that the contrary decision was not placed before that Bench. The order of the Member (T) is in line with that ruling although for different reasons - By majority, the Order-in-Appeal is upheld in terms of the findings and directions of the Member (Technical).

Create Account



Log In



Forgot Password


Please Note: This facility is only for Subscribing Members.

Email this page



Feedback this page