2026-VIL-1274-RAJ-ST

SERVICE TAX High Court Cases

Service Tax - Summons and SCN under Section 70 of CGST Act, 2017 - Petitioner challenged the summons issued under Section 70 and the SCN proposing a service tax demand for 2016-17 and the first quarter of 2017-18 on construction work for the Western Dedicated Freight Corridor. The summons followed a search under the CGST Act and called for service tax documents - Petitioner contended that powers under the CGST Act could not be used to inquire into liability under the Finance Act, 1994, and that the SCN relied on Section 65(97a), which was omitted from 01.07.2012 - Whether the summons and SCN are without jurisdiction because of the wrong provision cited and the reference to an omitted definition, so that a writ petition can be entertained at the SCN stage - HELD - A SCN decides nothing and ordinarily does not give rise to a cause of action. A writ should be entertained only where the notice is wholly non est for absolute want of jurisdiction. Section 174(2)(e) of the CGST Act saves any investigation, inquiry, adjudication or other proceeding in respect of the earlier tax and permits it to be instituted afresh as if the Finance Act, 1994 had not been amended - Section 83 of the Finance Act, 1994 applies Section 14 of the CEA, 1944, the power to summon, which also survives. Mention of a wrong provision does not vitiate the action where the power exists and is traceable to a valid source - The grievance about the route and the label is at most an irregularity in the exercise of an existing jurisdiction. Officers are not expected to shut their eyes to material found in a search that discloses evasion of another tax which they also administer, and its admissibility and weight are for the adjudicating authority. Under the negative list regime, taxability does not depend on a service fitting a named category, so reliance on the omitted definition is at best a flaw in the reasoning of the notice that may be pointed out in reply - The authority had jurisdiction to investigate and to issue the notice, and the plea is a plea on merits dressed in jurisdictional clothing - The writ petition is dismissedrnrnIssue 2: Exemption, suppression and limitation - Section 73 of Finance Act, 1994 - Petitioner contended that its work was an exempt works contract under the Mega Exemption Notification, that all transactions were disclosed in its returns and books so there was no suppression, and that the SCN was time barred. Respondents alleged that the true nature of the work came to light only during the search, that the exemption was claimed by misrepresentation and that no document showed transfer of property in goods - Whether the pleas on classification, exemption, suppression and limitation can be decided by the writ Court at the SCN stage - HELD - Works contract requires a transfer of property in goods leviable to tax as a sale, and the word leviable does not require actual payment of VAT. Whether property in the materials passed, whether earth moved within the site is a supply of goods, and whether the contract is composite or a set of separate earthwork jobs depend on the work orders, the tender, the measurement records and the invoices. The exemption for a subcontractor requires the Petitioner's own contract to be a works contract and the main contract to be exempt, which raises the meaning of railways, and the authority must first decide it with full reasons - Suppression means failure to disclose full information with intent to evade duty, and a mere omission or non-payment of tax is not enough as there must be a conscious and deliberate act, the burden of showing which lies on the Department. Whether the test is met is a matter of evidence. The material shows that the activity surfaced during the search, that different exemption entries were put forward at different points, that a self assessed return merely naming an exemption entry does not by itself disclose the facts behind it, that there is an admitted difference between Form 26AS and the books, and that compliance with summonses is disputed - The allegation of suppression is not a bald assertion, and there is material both for and against it. The extended period applies only upon a finding of suppression with intent to evade, so the plea of limitation is tied to suppression and cannot be decided in isolation. The Explanation to Section 74 of the CGST Act applies to that Act and is referred to only as an aid. These questions turn on disputed facts and cannot be decided on affidavits in writ jurisdiction - The pleas are left open before the adjudicating authority.rnrnIssue 3: Pre-show cause notice consultation - Master Circular No. 1053/02/2017-CX - Petitioner contended that pre show cause consultation by the Principal Commissioner or Commissioner is mandatory where the demand exceeds the monetary limit in the Master Circular - Whether the SCN is vitiated for want of pre show cause consultation - HELD - The same Circular excludes preventive and offence related SCNs from its scope. Consultation before notice is meant for cases arising from scrutiny or audit, where the department and the taxpayer can often resolve a difference of view. A case built on a search and the seizure of documents stands on a different footing, as prior consultation may defeat the investigation itself. The notice arose from an investigation by the Anti Evasion Wing after search and seizure and falls within the excluded class. The Finance Act, 1994, as saved by Section 174, provides a complete mechanism of reply, personal hearing, a reasoned order and appeal under Sections 85 and 86 - The plea fails at the threshold and the writ petition is dismissed.

Create Account



Log In



Forgot Password


Please Note: This facility is only for Subscribing Members.

Email this page



Feedback this page