2026-VIL-352-GSTAT-HYD

SGST Tribunal

GST - Condonation of delay - Section 107(4) of the CGST Act, 2017 - Respondent defaulted in furnishing returns for a continuous period of six months, and its registration was cancelled with retrospective effect under Section 29(2)(c) without any application for revocation being filed - Respondent filed an appeal before the FAA after the period prescribed by Section 107(1) and beyond the further period condonable under Section 107(4). The FAA condoned the delay on condition of payment of all outstanding tax, interest, penalties and late fees – Revenue-Appellant contended that the FAA had no jurisdiction to condone delay beyond the maximum period prescribed - Whether the FAA was justified in condoning the delay in preferring the appeal beyond the maximum condonable period prescribed under Section 107(4) - HELD - The FAA is a creature of the statute and must act within the four corners of the enactment, and the limits prescribed under Section 107 are mandatory in nature. The judgments of the High Court were rendered in exercise of Constitutional jurisdiction under Article 226 on the facts peculiar to those proceedings, and cannot be construed as laying down any general proposition enlarging the jurisdiction of the FAA under Section 107(4) - Equity follows the law and cannot be invoked by a statutory authority to override an express legislative prescription, so the delay cannot be extended on considerations of hardship, equity or substantial justice - The FAA exceeded the bounds of its statutory jurisdiction and exercised a power ultra vires Section 107 - The FAA was not justified in condoning the delay beyond the period permissible under Section 107(4) - However, the Department, by giving effect to the impugned order and facilitating the restoration of the respondent’s GST registration, has itself acted on the relief it now seeks to challenge - No effective relief can be granted to the Department even if its objections on limitation are accepted in principle - The appeal has become infructuous and is disposed of as not maintainablernrnIssue 2: Maintainability of Department's appeal - Implementation of impugned order of the FAA - The Department had acted upon the order of the FAA by restoring the registration of the Respondent, who has since continued to carry on business and file returns. The Department challenged the same order on the ground of limitation - Whether the appeal preferred by the Department is maintainable when it has already acted upon and implemented the impugned order by revoking the cancellation of registration - HELD - Having implemented the order and altered the legal and commercial position of the Respondent, the Department cannot seek to invalidate the same order without addressing the consequences of its own action - Allowing the appeal would make the restored registration liable to cancellation again, including with retrospective effect, and imperil the genuine transactions undertaken by the Respondent in the intervening period. Allowing the Department to attack an order it implemented would be unfair and run counter to established principles of estoppel and orderly administration. No effective relief can be granted to the Department even if its objections on limitation are accepted in principle - The appeal has become infructuous and is disposed of as not maintainable.

Create Account



Log In



Forgot Password


Please Note: This facility is only for Subscribing Members.

Email this page



Feedback this page