2026-VIL-359-GSTAT-DHR

SGST Tribunal

GST - Composition scheme - Cum-tax value of supplies - Section 15 of CGST Act, 2017 read with Rule 35 - The Appellant registered under the composition scheme, continued to pay tax at the composition rate in FY 2019-20 although its turnover in the preceding year exceeded the threshold limit - SCN under Section 73 demanded tax at the normal rate on the declared turnover. The FAA re-determined the liability by treating the invoice value as inclusive of tax under Rule 35 - The Revenue filed a cross-objection against the re-determination - Whether re-determination of tax liability by treating the value as cum-tax is legally permissible - HELD - Under Section 10, eligibility for the Composition scheme depends on the aggregate turnover of the preceding financial year. As the turnover of the preceding year exceeded the threshold limit, the Appellant became a regular taxpayer from 01.04.2019. Applying the normal rate directly on the declared turnover is flawed because a composition dealer is prohibited under Section 10(4) from collecting tax from customers - The gross consideration received must therefore be treated as inclusive of tax, and the cum-tax benefit is available under Section 15(1) read with Rule 35. Where the status of a composition dealer is retrospectively changed, the values of supplies already realised cannot be altered to add tax on top - The FAA correctly applied the formula under Rule 35 and deducted the tax already paid under the composition scheme. There is no fallacy in this approach and the cross-objection of the Revenue is dismissedrnrnIssue 2: Input Tax Credit on inward supplies - Section 16(4) and Section 16(5) of CGST Act, 2017 - The Appellant claimed ITC on inward supplies received in FY 2019-20 in its reply to the SCN, as it had become a regular taxpayer retrospectively - Both authorities rejected the claim - Whether the Appellant can claim ITC on inward supplies of FY 2019-20 - HELD - A regular taxpayer cannot claim ITC after the due date for filing the return for September of the succeeding financial year. The time limit under Section 16(4) is not merely procedural or directory, and late fee or a delayed GSTR-3B does not cure the time bar. Section 16(5) protects ITC for FY 2017-18 to FY 2020-21 only if the return in Form GSTR-3B was furnished by 30.11.2021 - The Appellant filed only composition returns and no such return claiming the credit up to that date. It cannot register a fresh claim through its reply to the SCN. The law does not revive a lapsed timeline for claiming ITC upon retrospective conversion to a regular taxpayer. The Appellant did not plead that it was impossible to claim ITC, so its request to adjust the ITC against the liability as a computational relief cannot be accepted. The denial of ITC is upheld.rnrnIssue 3: Input Tax Credit on stock - Section 18(1)(c) and Section 18(2) of CGST Act, 2017 - The Appellant claimed ITC on stock held on 31.03.2019 on becoming a regular taxpayer - Whether ITC on stock held can be claimed - HELD - Section 18(1)(c) entitles a person who ceases to pay tax under the composition scheme to take credit of input tax on inputs held in stock on the day immediately preceding the date of becoming liable to pay normal tax. As the switch over date shifts retrospectively to 01.04.2019, the Appellant was eligible on stock held on 31.03.2019. However, Section 18(2) bars ITC after the expiry of one year from the date of issue of the tax invoice - The invoices for stock held on 31.03.2019 would be dated March 2019 or earlier, so the one-year window closed by March 2020. The issue of the SCN in 2024 cannot serve to claim ITC after the window had closed. The denial of ITC on stock is upheld.rnrnIssue 4: Interest on delayed payment - Section 50 of CGST Act, 2017 - The Appellant pleaded bona fide belief that the composition scheme applied and sought to avoid interest - Whether interest is payable - HELD - Interest under Section 50 is inevitably payable on account of delayed payment to the exchequer. The plea of bona fide belief does not waive the interest. The department has correctly worked out the interest on the revised net differential tax. The order of the FAA is affirmed to this extent.rnrnIssue 5: Penalty - Section 73 and Section 125 of CGST Act, 2017 - Penalty under Section 73 and a general penalty under Section 125 were imposed. The Appellant pleaded that the mistake was bona fide and inadvertent - Whether the penalties are sustainable - HELD - The Appellant was aware that its turnover of the preceding year had exceeded the threshold limit. It continued as a composition dealer in disregard of law and did not disclose its true status. It is therefore liable to be penalised, and the penalty under Section 73 was rightly imposed by the FAA. A general penalty under Section 125 is not warranted in view of Section 125 itself and Section 75(13), and it is set aside. The order of the FAA is upheld with this modification and the appeal of the Appellant is dismissed.

Create Account



Log In



Forgot Password


Please Note: This facility is only for Subscribing Members.

Email this page



Feedback this page