2026-VIL-1906-CESTAT-CHD-CE

CENTRAL EXCISE CESTAT Cases

Central Excise - Marketability of captively consumed intermediate product - Sugar syrup prepared in the factory by mixing sugar with water and a meagre quantity of citric acid was consumed captively in the manufacture of biscuits which had become exempt - Department demanded duty on the syrup by SCNs on the ground that it is marketable, relying on an invoice of another manufacturer, a Board Circular and a test report - Whether the sugar syrup manufactured and consumed captively by the Appellant is marketable and liable to Central Excise duty - HELD - The Revenue is of the opinion that similar products are available and sold in the open market but has failed to produce any evidence comparing the chemical composition of those market products with the intermediate product manufactured by the Appellant. In absence of such comparative analysis the marketability of the specific intermediate product cannot be presumed or held to be established. Marketability of goods produced by a particular manufacturer cannot be presumed on the basis of marketability of similar goods produced by another manufacturer unless the two products are shown to be identical - The demand of duty on the captively consumed sugar syrup is not sustainable.rnrnIssue 2: Classification of sugar syrup under Tariff Item 1702 90 90 - Revenue classified the sugar syrup under Tariff Item 1702 90 90 on the basis of the report of the Chemical Examiner of CRCL, which showed the sample to be composed mainly of inverted sugar, sucrose and water - Appellant relied on a test certificate showing fructose content below the prescribed threshold - Whether the sugar syrup is classifiable under Tariff Item 1702 90 90 - HELD - Invert sugar consists of equal proportions by weight of glucose and fructose as per the Explanatory Notes to the HSN. Since the total invert sugar content in the CRCL report is less than the figure needed for fructose to reach 50 per cent by weight, the fructose component can in no way exceed that limit. The CRCL report fails to specify the exact percentage of fructose, which is the determinative factor for classification, and the Revenue has not produced any evidence of the fructose content of the product. The contention of the Revenue based on the CRCL report therefore fails - The classification under Tariff Item 1702 90 90 is not sustainable.rnrnIssue 3: Exemption to captively consumed intermediate product - Notification No. 67/95-CE dated 16.03.1995 - Rule 6 of CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004 - Appellant contended that it had either not availed CENVAT credit on inputs used in the sugar syrup or had reversed it under Rule 6, and that the syrup remains exempt although the final product biscuits is exempt - Whether the exemption under Notification No. 67/95-CE is available to the captively consumed sugar syrup - HELD - The Revenue has not contradicted the specific submission of the Appellant that it has not availed any CENVAT credit or has duly reversed the credit, if any, in terms of Rule 6 of the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004. The intermediate product manufactured and captively consumed is therefore fully eligible for the exemption under Notification No. 67/95-CE. This Tribunal has consistently held that sugar syrup manufactured as an intermediate product and captively consumed in the manufacture of biscuits is eligible for the benefit of the said notification - The Appellant is eligible for the exemption.rnrnIssue 4: Estoppel on earlier payment of duty - Revenue contended that the Appellant had paid duty on the sugar syrup for an earlier period, filed a classification declaration and had thus accepted its dutiability - Whether payment of duty and filing of classification declaration earlier bar the Appellant from contesting the demand - HELD - The principle of estoppel does not operate against the statute in taxation matters. The Appellant, as a taxpayer, is within its rights to discontinue an incorrect practice followed earlier and cannot be expected to perpetuate an error, if any. Past compliance cannot form a valid legal ground for confirming a duty liability that is otherwise not sustainable under the law. Filing of a classification declaration mistakenly does not mean that the party has to pay duty if in law it is not bound to pay - The earlier payment of duty does not bar the Appellant, the impugned orders are set aside and the appeals are allowed.

Create Account



Log In



Forgot Password


Please Note: This facility is only for Subscribing Members.

Email this page



Feedback this page