2026-VIL-1285-P&H

SGST High Court Cases

GST - Invocation of extended period under Section 74 of the CGST Act, 2017 for non-payment of IGST on the secondment of employees arrangement – Adjudicating authority confirmed demand of tax under Section 74(1) with interest and equal penalty, treating the secondment as import of manpower supply services from a related person taxable on reverse charge for July 2017 to March 2023 - Revenue view that it amounted to wilful misstatement and suppression, and that the tax was payable since the advent of GST. The same arrangement had earlier been examined in audit under the Finance Act, 1994, and by an adjudication order the expatriates were held to be employees of the Petitioner - Whether the proceedings could validly be initiated and concluded under Section 74 - HELD - Section 74 is an exception, with a longer limitation and penalty equal to the tax, and is available only where its distinct pre-conditions exist. The words to evade tax in Section 74(1) govern all three expressions of fraud, wilful misstatement and suppression - The foundational facts leading to the inference of fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression must emerge from the notice itself, the words cannot be mechanically recited and what the notice lacks cannot be supplied by an affidavit - Section 74(1) cannot be invoked merely on account of non-payment of tax without a specific element of fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression to evade tax. The SCN equated non-payment of tax in the return with wilful misstatement and suppression and treated the declaratory nature of judgment of Northern Operating Systems as showing intent to evade tax, which says nothing about the intent of an assessee who did not pay - The arrangement was within the knowledge of the Department, which had adjudicated the same agreements and held that no service was received. Suppression presupposes that something was kept back, and here nothing was. An assessee who bona fide believes that a transaction is not a supply and does not report it as one is not making a suppression to evade tax, since otherwise every case of non-payment would fall under Section 74 and Section 73 would be rendered otiose - The pre-conditions for Section 74 did not exist. The SCN did not disclose the foundational facts, and the confirmation of demand and penalty under that provision cannot be sustained - The Order-in-Original, the summaries in Form GST DRC-07 and the SCN with its summary in Form GST DRC-01 are quashed. The writ petition is allowedrnrn rnrnIssue 2: Valuation of import of service from related person, Binding nature of Board Circular - Second proviso to Rule 28(1) of the CGST Rules, 2017 read with Section 168(1) of the CGST Act - The Petitioner and the foreign parent company are related persons, and the Petitioner is eligible for full input tax credit. The Petitioner issued no invoice for the alleged import of service. The Petitioner relied on the Board's Circular No. 210/4/2024-GST clarifying that in such a case the value of services may be deemed to be Nil. The adjudicating authority held the Circular inapplicable on the ground that consideration was involved - Whether the demand could have been confirmed notwithstanding the Circular - HELD - Section 168(1) obliges all officers to observe and follow the orders, instructions or directions of the Board and it is not open to them to contend that a Circular beneficial to the assessee is not to be followed - The clarification applies where the recipient is eligible for full input tax credit and no invoice is issued by it for the service, and both conditions were satisfied, as the failure to issue invoices was itself the Respondents' case and the eligibility was not disputed - The Circular does not make the absence of consideration a condition, since its operative paragraphs apply in all cases of supply between related persons where full input tax credit is available. The second proviso to Rule 28(1) likewise draws no distinction between supplies made with and without consideration, and an officer bound by a Circular cannot read into its operative part a limitation which the Board has not placed there - The reasoning of the adjudicating authority defeats itself, as it held that the value is to be determined under Rule 28 and extracted the second proviso, but then fixed the value at the remuneration paid without applying the proviso. Even on the assumption that the arrangement is an import of service from the foreign parent company, the value of the supply is Nil and no tax is payable. Interest, which is compensatory and levied on tax not paid, and penalty, which is computed with reference to the tax evaded, fall with the demand - The demand of tax, interest and penalty is contrary to Section 168(1) and cannot be sustained for any part of the period from July 2017 to March 2023.rnrn rnrnIssue 3: Reasoned order - Section 75(6) of the CGST Act, 2017 - The Petitioner filed a detailed reply and additional submissions relying clause by clause on the dispatch agreement and employment contracts, the earlier adjudication order on the same agreements and the Board's instruction on secondment. The order reproduced the SCN as findings - Whether the impugned order satisfies the requirement of a reasoned order - HELD - Section 75(6) requires the proper officer to set out in the order the relevant facts and the basis of the decision. Recording of reasons is an indispensable component of the decision-making process, and a pretence of reasons or rubber-stamp reasons is not equivalent to a valid decision-making process. The order reproduced the SCN with its tentative language and made no reference to the clauses of the agreements relied upon by the Petitioner. Its observations on the agreements could not be reconciled with the documents on record, as features of another case were attributed to the Petitioner without examining whether its documents bore them out. The order did not deal with the earlier adjudication order of a senior officer of the same Department on the same agreements, which had been pressed by the Petitioner and was a relevant consideration, nor with the instruction on secondment. It also did not correctly state the period for which the liability was fastened in its operative part. Remand for a fresh order is not warranted, since on the findings on the earlier issues no demand can lawfully result from the SCN - The order does not satisfy Section 75(6) and is passed in breach of principles of natural justice.rnrn rnrnIssue 4: Writ jurisdiction - Whether the petition ought not to be entertained on account of the remedy of appeal under Section 107 - HELD - The alternative remedy does not operate as a bar where there is a violation of principles of natural justice, where the order is wholly without jurisdiction, or where the challenge turns on a pure question of law on admitted facts. The challenge to invocation of Section 74 goes to the very foundation of the proceedings. The refusal of a statutory authority to follow a Circular issued by the Board under Section 168(1) is a pure question of law on undisputed facts - The grievance that the order does not deal with the Petitioner's defence is one of breach of natural justice. No disputed question of fact requires to be resolved, the petition had been pending since April 2025 and the pleadings were complete, so relegating the Petitioner to appeal would serve no purpose - The preliminary objection of Revenue is overruled.

Create Account



Log In



Forgot Password


Please Note: This facility is only for Subscribing Members.

Email this page



Feedback this page